Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Lux Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Lux Pty Ltd
[2004] FCA 926

TRADE PRACTICES – sale of vacuum cleaner to consumer – sale conducted by agent of corporation - consumer alleged to be illiterate and intellectually disabled – circumstances of sale said to involve unconscionable conduct, undue harassment and coercion – whether intellectual disability established – unconscionability established – undue harassment and coercion not established – form of relief – need for further submissions on relief

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 21
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 4(2), 51AB, 51AB(1), 51AB(2), 51AB(2)(a), 51AB(2)(c), 51AB(2)(d), 51AB(2)(e), 51AB(5), 60, 80, 80(1)(e), 80(4), 80(5), 83, 84(2), 87(1A)(b)

New Shorter Oxford English Dictionary  (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1993)

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v 4WD Systems Pty Ltd (2003) 200 ALR 491 cited
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Maritime Union of Australia (2001) 114 FCR 472 considered
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v McCaskey (2000) 104 FCR 8 considered
Australian Competition & Consumer Commissionv Real Estate Institute of Western Australia Inc (1999) 95 FCR 114 cited
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Samton Holdings Pty Ltd (2002) 117 FCR 301 considered
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Simply No-Knead (Franchising) Pty Ltd (2000) 104 FCR 253 considered
Commercial Bank of Australia Ltd v Amadio (1983) 151 CLR 447 considered
Hospitals Contribution Fund of Australia Ltd v Switzerland Australia Health Fund Pty Ltd (1987) 78 ALR 483 cited
Hurley v McDonald’s Australia Ltd (2000) ATPR 41-741 considered, applied
Our Town FM Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal (1987) 16 FCR 465 considered
Qantas Airways Ltd v Cameron (1996) 66 FCR 246 considered

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v LUX PTY LTD and DENNIS PODGER
W124 of 2000

RD NICHOLSON J
16 JULY 2004
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W124 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
APPLICANT

AND:

LUX PTY LTD
(ACN 054 882 852)
FIRST RESPONDENT

DENNIS PODGER
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

RD NICHOLSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

16 JULY 2004

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1. The first respondent, in connection with the supply of a vacuum cleaner to Janice Standing on 26 August 1999, engaged in unconscionable conduct in contravention of s 51AB of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)(‘the Act’).

2. The second respondent in engaging in the conduct found by the Court in these reasons has been directly knowingly concerned in and a party to the contravention of s 51AB of the Act, namely the engagement in unconscionable conduct.

AND THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

3.     In relation to the application for injunctive relief, the giving of a public notice and the implementation of a compliance program:

a.       Relief in the form sought in the application is refused.

b.       Within 21 days the applicant file and serve any alternative formulation for relief in relation to those matters together with written submissions.

c.       Within 21 days from the date of service upon the respondents…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Lux Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 926
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) filed a case against Lux Pty Ltd, seeking relief on the grounds of unconscionability and undue harassment in the sale of a vacuum cleaner to Mrs Standing, who is illiterate. The matter was heard and determined by a court in Australia. The primary legal issues revolved around whether the conduct of Mr Podger, an employee of Lux, was unconscionable under section 51AB of the Australian Consumer Law and whether Lux used undue harassment in connection with the supply of the vacuum cleaner, in contravention of section 60 of the same law.

The court meticulously evaluated the credibility of the witnesses, considering the inconsistencies in their testimonies. It found that neither a general adverse credibility finding against any witness was appropriate, nor was it necessary to prefer one witness’s evidence over another on all matters. Instead, the inconsistencies were addressed within the context of the specific issues they arose. The court concluded that Mr Podger's conduct was unconscionable as he failed to recognize Mrs Standing's inability to comprehend commercial matters and did not offer her the opportunity to seek independent advice. This conduct was held to be irreconcilable with what is right or reasonable. However, the claims for undue harassment and coercion were dismissed.

In summary, the court found Lux Pty Ltd liable for the unconscionable conduct of Mr Podger. It refused to grant the injunctive relief, public notice, and compliance program sought by the ACCC. The court also dismissed the claims for undue harassment, coercion, and a further order of findings of fact. Both parties were directed to address the issue of costs in written submissions within specified timelines.

Orders

Orders of the court

3. In relation to the application for injunctive relief, the giving of a public notice and the implementation of a compliance program:

a. Relief in the form sought in the application is refused.

b. Within 21 days the applicant file and serve any alternative formulation for relief in relation to those matters together with written submissions.

c. Within 21 days from the date of service upon the respondents of any submission in accordance with paragraph ‘a’ the respondents file and serve any written submissions in response.

d. Within a further 10 days the applicant file and serve any written submissions in reply.

e. The issue of further relief in any of the above terms then stand reserved.

4. The claims for undue harassment and for coercion be dismissed.

5. The application for a further order of findings of fact be dismissed.

6. At the same time as each of the parties complies with order 3, each of them also address the issue of costs in written submissions.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It is not in dispute that the credit sale contract for the vacuum cleaner (‘the Lux Contract’) was entered into on 26 August 1999. It was concluded in Port Pirie, South Australia where Mr and Mrs Standing (‘the Standings’) were then living. In April 2000 they moved to a suburb of Perth, Western Australia where they have continued to live. EVIDENCE The witnesses called for the applicant were Mr and Mrs Standing; her mother Mrs Stella Boyce; Ms Tamala Jeffery-Cooper, Local Area Coordinator for the Disability Services Commission in Western Australia; Ms Joan Rudd, a financial counsellor at the Armadale Information & Referral Service (Inc). Ms Nada Murphy, clinical psychologist who was called as an expert witness. The respondent’s witnesses were Ms Maria Piteo, Ms Bronwyn Kitson, Ms Mary Hutchison, Ms Joanne Connelly, Mr Anthony Ween, Ms Sharon Nicolle, Mr Jason Jamieson, Mr Vasco Drallini, Mr Trevor McBride and Mr Dennis Podger. Associate Professor Susan Hayes was called as an expert witness for the respondents. The case for the applicant accepts that the findings which it invites the Court to make are dependent upon the Court preferring the evidence of Mrs Standing and her husband (‘Mr Standing’) to that of Mr Podger. There are consequently issues of credibility which require resolution. The applicant seeks the making of a general adverse credibility finding in respect of Mr Podger. It contends that the evidence of Mr and Mrs Standing should be seen as having remained consistent on key issues despite their obvious distress at times concerning the process of giving evidence. On the other hand it contends that the evidence of Mr Podger should be seen as inconsistent, self-serving and unreliable. Reference is made to three written statements provided by Mr Podger prior to trial which failed to take the opportunity to set out in a detailed, meaningful or adequate way his account of what took place at the Standings’ home. Reliance is also placed on a table in which alleged inconsistencies are set out. The respondents submit that Mr Standing was an entirely unreliable witness due to his lack of memory of events and his apparent nervousness in the witness box. They further submit that Mrs Standing’s evidence showed that her memory was affected by the lapse of time since the events in question and the number of times she had been asked to recall events. It is the case that Mr Podger’s evidence contained inconsistencies on a number of issues between his initial written statement and his oral evidence. These were in large measure the difference between general statements and particularised statements. I did not form the impression that these were as the consequence of the witness being self-serving or that they were so fundamental as to be viewed that way. Furthermore it is apparent that the evidence of both Mr and Mrs Standing was in some respects affected by the factors raised by the respondents. In those circumstances I do not consider the evidence here can be dealt with on the basis of a general adverse credibility finding against any of these persons. Such a general finding would require the Court to prefer the evidence of witnesses other than the witness against whom the finding had been made. That would not be appropriate in this case. The alleged inconsistencies are more appropriately dealt with in the context of the particular issues concerning which they arise.FINDINGS OF FACT

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant states that Mrs Standing may have been able to acquire credit from a person other than Lux at a significantly lower rate of interest given the interest rates current at that time. When the exhibit said to support this was tendered it was on the limited basis that it stated the Reserve Bank interest rates at the time as opposed to any concession it was relevant to any matter before the Court. Furthermore there is no evidence going to the issue that Mrs Standing might have been able to acquire credit as alleged.Conclusion on unconscionability In my opinion the features of the meeting between Mrs Standing and Mr Podger set out in the above considerations required to be addressed by the s 51AB(2) make apparent that the meeting was ‘clearly unfair or unreasonable’. It was in my view ‘irreconcilable with what is right or reasonable’. Mr Podger came close to realising this when he thought of the question whether Mrs Standing should receive independent advice. He veered away from that course because he considered she had told him that she could read (evidence I have not accepted). However, even if that was the case he was on notice that Mrs Standing was illiterate and unable to understand commercial matters in any depth. She was alone without the assistance of even her husband. While it is clear she was not deprived of an independent and voluntary will, it must have been apparent to him that she was not able to make a worthwhile judgement as to what was in her best interests in the circumstances. I consider that it is established that in all the relevant circumstances (and particularly his decision not to give Mrs Standing the opportunity to take independent advice) he acted without regard to conscience and so acted unconscionably. The consequence is that Lux is also liable for his conduct in that respect.UNDUE HARASSMENTREQUIREMENTS OF THE LAW The applicant seeks a declaration against the first respondent that it used undue harassment in connection with the supply of the new vacuum cleaner to Mrs Standing in contravention of s 60 of the Act. It also seeks a declaration against the second respondent on the basis of him having been, directly or indirectly, knowingly concerned in or a party to such contravention. Section 60 provides that a corporation shall not use physical force or undue harassment (or coercion) in connection with the supply or possible supply of goods or services to a consumer or the payment for goods or services by a consumer. The meaning of ‘harassment’ was examined by French J in Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v McCaskey (2000) 104 FCR 8 at [47]. He referred to the dictionary definition of the verb ‘harass’ as:‘1 Trouble by repeated attacks. Now Freq; subject to constant molesting or persecution. 2 Lay waste, devastate. 3 Tire out, exhaust. 4 Overwhelm with cares and misfortunes etc...’: New Shorter Oxford English Dictionary (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1993) p 1188. The noun of that verb is ‘harassment.’ His Honour considered it important to have regard to its context in considering its application in s 60. He said that it describes a range of conduct which involves applying repeated pressure to a consumer who is under no pre-existing obligation to acquire goods or services. French J considered that the word ‘undue’ added an extra layer of evaluative judgement, although more relevant to debt recovery than to sale of goods or services.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Podger attended at the home of Mr and Mrs Standing on the afternoon of 26 August 1999. Duration of attendance Mrs Standing’s evidence was that Mr Podger arrived at the home at 2.30 pm and that Mr Standing returned home around 5.30 pm. Mr Podger testified that the whole event took about an hour. He thought he had arrived about 3 pm. Mrs Standing’s evidence of the total time involved in the attendance by Mr Podger is in some degree inconsistent with her evidence that they had talked for about an hour after the initial exchanges. Furthermore the submissions for the applicant accept that Mrs Standing has only a limited ability to tell the time. I find that the attendance by Mr Podger took about an hour.Who was present Both Mr and Mrs Standing gave evidence that Mr Standing was not at home when Mr Podger arrived at the house. Mr Podger’s evidence was that it was Mr Standing who answered the door. Mr Standing’s evidence was that after lunch on 26 August 1999 he went out to get milk for Mrs Standing and to collect some cans. He said he got caught with a friend and arrived home at about 5.30 pm or 5.45 pm when he saw Mr Podger leaving the house. He said Mr Podger was with Mrs Standing and was putting things into his car. This was corroborated in Mrs Standing’s evidence. She said in cross-examination that Mr Standing did not do his can run on a Sunday. Mr Standing also testified that when he returned he was forced to park across the road from the home because the ‘Electrolux bloke…was parked in my spot.’ Mrs Standing’s evidence was that it was she who invited Mrs Podger inside. Mr Podger’s evidence was that when he arrived at the Standing’s home Mr Standing answered the door. He testified Mr Standing then went ‘over to the other side’ and that during his discussion with the Standings nobody left the room or entered it. He later described how Mr Standing had reacted to his production of the new vacuum cleaner. He also said that when he was leaving the home Mr Standing had come outside and carried the old vacuum cleaner in a box to Mr Podger’s car. His testimony was that at that time Mr Standing had pointed out his yellow van across the street. Mr Podger said that the van was already there when he arrived. I consider it is improbable that if Mr Standing was present in the room throughout the discussion of the dealings relating to the sale of the new vacuum cleaner his participation would not have been the subject of more extensive evidence by both Mr Podger and Mrs Standing. Furthermore the evidence of Mr and Mrs Standing is corroborative of each other. Therefore I accept Mrs Standing’s evidence that she was present alone in the home with Mr Podger.Examination of old vacuum cleaner On arrival at the home, Mr Podger noticed a vacuum cleaner on the front verandah but Mrs Standing told him it was not the old vacuum cleaner, which was inside the home. Mr Podger’s testified that on entering the home he examined the old vacuum cleaner. He identified it as an Electrolux 735 about 10 years old. He turned it on for a few seconds and when he turned it off it made ‘grinding noises’. On examination he discovered that liquid had entered the vacuum cleaner and all the components needed replacing. He had told Mrs Standing ‘fusion’ would occur and a service could not avoid this. He said she had not asked him to explain what fusion meant. He denied saying it would ‘blow up’ as he had always used the word ‘fusion’.