Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Samton Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Samton Holdings Pty Ltd
[2000] FCA 1725

TRADE PRACTICES – EQUITY – unconscionability – statutory prohibition of engaging in unconscionable conduct – tenant of business premises took possession four days before expiry of option to obtain grant of new lease for term of seven years – tenant paid substantial amount for goodwill of business – goodwill depended largely on location of business – business unable to be relocated – tenant aware that option had to be exercised by particular date – tenant failed to exercise option by that date – purported to exercise option sixteen days later – landlords initially resolved to resume possession on expiry of then current term and so informed tenant – tenant threatened legal action – agreement reached whereby tenant paid $70,000 to obtain assignment of new lease from company associated with landlords – arrangement so structured to avoid “key money” prohibition in State statute – whether tenant in position of special disadvantage – whether landlords unconscionably took advantage of that position – whether Equity would grant relief to tenant and the landlords would thus have contravened s 51AA of the Trade Practices Act – whether s 51AA Constitutionally valid.

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), s 51AA
Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreement Act 1985 (W.A.)

Blomley v Ryan (1956) 99 CLR 362 applied
Commercial Bank of Australia Ltd v Amadio (1983) 151 CLR 447 applied
Earl of Chesterfield v Janssen (1751) 2 Ves Sen 125 [28 ER 82] referred to
Earl of Aylesford v Morris (1873) LR 8 Ch App 484 referred to
Antonovic v Walker (1986) 7 NSWLR 151 referred to
The Commonwealth v Verwayen (1990) 170 CLR 394 referred to
Harry v Kreutziger (1978) 95 DLR (3d) 231 referred to
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v C G Berbatis Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) (1999) 96 FCR 491 referred to
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Berbatis Holdings Pty Ltd [2000] FCA 1376 referred to
Burt v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (1994) ATPR (Digest) 46-123 referred to

ACCC v SAMTON HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ORS
W 20 of 1999

CARR J
29 NOVEMBER 2000
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W 20 of 1999

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

SAMTON HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 062 688 359)
First Respondent

FRANCESCO PARASILITI
Second Respondent

GAETANINA PARASILITI
Third Respondent

SALVATORE PARASILITI
Fourth Respondent

MARIA PARASILITI
Fifth Respondent

FELICE ANTONIO SCIARRETTA
Sixth Respondent

SILVANA SCIARRETTA
Seventh Respondent

NEIL PHILIP GENTILLI
Eighth Respondent

SAMTON HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 062 688 359)
First Cross Claimant

FRANCESCO PARASILITI
Second Cross Claimant

GAETANINA PARASILITI
Third Cross Claimant

SALVATORE PARASILITI
Fourth Cross Claimant

MARIA PARASILITI
Fifth Cross Claimant

FELICE ANTONIO SCIARRETTA
Sixth Cross Claimant

SILVANA SCIARRETTA
Seventh Cross Claimant

FRANK MARK RANALDI
First Cross Respondent

EXECUTIVE BLOODSTOCK SERVICES PTY LTD
Second Cross Respondent

NEIL PHILIP GENTILLI
Third Cross Respondent

JUDGE:

CARR J

DATE OF ORDER:

29 NOVEMBER 2000

WHERE…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Samton Holdin... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 1725
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission brought an action against Samton Holdings Pty Ltd and several other respondents, seeking declaratory relief and other remedial orders due to alleged unconscionable conduct under section 51AA of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The dispute arose when the first respondent, Samton Holdings, required a lessee who had failed to exercise an option to extend the lease term, to pay $70,000 for the assignment of a lease for the same extended term. The action was taken to structure the receipt of the money in such a manner that it did not constitute "key money" within the meaning of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreement Act 1985 (W.A.). The court had to determine whether the conduct of the first respondent amounted to unconscionable conduct, and whether the other respondents were directly or indirectly involved in the contravention of the Act.

The court examined the nature of the conduct and concluded that although it might be considered avaricious and opportunistic, it did not reach the level of unconscionable conduct that equity would regard as unacceptable. The court noted that the failure to exercise the option within the stipulated time resulted in the dissolution of the option as a valuable asset, which is analogous to a forfeiture situation. However, the court held that the principles of relief against forfeiture had not been extended to circumstances such as the one in this case. The court suggested that a legislative adjustment might be appropriate to prevent such grave consequences for the lessee and unearned windfalls for the lessor.

The application against the first to seventh respondents was dismissed. The cross-claim of the first to seventh cross-claimants against the first and second cross-respondents was also dismissed with no order as to costs. The applicant was ordered to pay the first to seventh respondents' costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application against the first to seventh respondents be dismissed.

2. The cross-claim of the first to seventh cross-claimants against the first and second cross-respondents be dismissed with no order as to costs.

3. The applicant pay the first to seventh respondents’ costs of the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, seeks declaratory relief and other remedial orders against the first to seventh respondents on the basis that the first respondent engaged in unconscionable conduct contrary to s 51AA of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (“the Act”) and that the other respondents were directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in the first respondent’s contravention of the Act. The conduct in question was to require a lessee who had failed to exercise an option to extend the term of its lease, to pay $70,000 for the assignment of a lease for the same extended term. The new lease had been granted to the first respondent (a company owned and controlled by four of the lessors) to structure the receipt of the money in such a manner that it did not constitute “key money” within the meaning of that term in the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreement Act 1985 (W.A.) (“the State Act”). FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND The following narrative of the factual background refers mainly to matters which were not in dispute, save where express reference is made to a matter being in issue. These proceedings concern the business of a lunch bar (“the Business”) conducted at premises (“the Premises”) in Canning Vale, a Perth suburb. The Premises formed part of a larger piece of land, which I will call “the Land”. The second to seventh respondents owned the Land as tenants-in-common. The second respondent operated a service station business (“the Mobil Service Station”) on the rest of the Land. Between June 1992 and February 1997 a company controlled by a Mr and Mrs Farruggio carried on the Business. Mr and Mrs Farruggio became the lessees of the Premises by a deed of assignment dated 15 June 1992 of the leasehold interest created by a lease dated 20 March 1992 (‘the Lease”) from the then registered proprietors of the Land. On or about 29 January 1993, the second to seventh respondents, being various members respectively of the Parasiliti and Sciarretta families became registered as proprietors of the Land as tenants in common (“the Proprietors”). They thereby became the lessors of the Premises. In 1995 disputes arose between the Proprietors and Mr and Mrs Farruggio in relation to their tenancy of the Premises. The disputes became the subject of an application by Mr and Mrs Farruggio to the Commercial Tenancy Tribunal, but were resolved by settlement in October 1996. The documents recording that settlement were not prepared and executed until some months later. The term of the Lease was due to expire on 2 June 1997. However, the Lease contained an option whereby its term could be extended for seven years from 2 June 1997 upon the lessee giving written notice to the lessors to that effect at least three months prior to, but not earlier than six months prior to, 2 June 1997 (“the Option”). According to the terms of the Option, written notice was required to be given by the lessee by no later than 2 March 1997.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

CARR J
It might well be thought that the respondents adopted an avaricious, opportunistic approach and struck a very hard bargain. But, in my opinion, their conduct fell short, though not far short, of being the sort of conduct which Equity would regard as unconscionable. CONCLUSION For the foregoing reasons the application against the first to seventh respondents will be dismissed with costs. FootnoteAn option to obtain a further grant of a lease is often a very valuable asset. It certainly was in this case. Failure to exercise such an option within a stipulated time has the result in law that this asset dissolves into nothing. Where a business has been conducted on the leasehold premises, much of the goodwill of that business may pass to the lessor, even though the option may have been purportedly exercised only slightly out of time and the lessor can show no prejudice. The situation is analogous to one of forfeiture. Relief against forefeiture is granted in Equity, generally speaking, where there has been unconscionable conduct. There have been statutory modifications in that area. On the authorities to date, Equity has not extended the principles of relief against forfeiture to circumstances such as the situation in which Executive Bloodstock found itself in this matter. There seems to be a good case for either the State or Commonwealth legislature to consider a statutory adjustment of the law so that a careless omission to exercise an option to extend the term of a lease should not result in such grave circumstances for a lessee and such an unearned windfall for a lessor. The legislative adjustment need not be complicated. It might simply require a lessor to serve on the lessee a notice referring to the fact that no notice of exercise of the option has been served and that it proposes to resume possession of the premises at the expiry of the current term of the lease unless the lessee within, say, fourteen days, indicates in writing that it exercises the option which the statutory amendment would have to revive. The statutory revival of the option might be for a period commencing with its expiry under the terms of the lease and ending with the period stipulated in the lessor’s notice. Any reasonable expenses incurred by the lessor in relation to the giving of such notice might be borne by the lessee whether or not it exercises the extended option to renew. Any such amendments would fit quite neatly into Division 2 of Part VII of the Property Law Act 1969 (W.A.).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: CARR J

Full text does not contain this section.