Croft v Evertop Investments Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Croft v Evertop Investments Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] FCA 749

Citation: Croft v Evertop Investments Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] FCA 749
Parties: RODNEY KIM CROFT AND JANICE ANN CROFT v EVERTOP INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 091 802 201), JAMES ALEXANDER KIDD and THYE TAN
File number: WAD 310 of 2006
Judge: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 1 July 2011
Catchwords: PRACTICE and PROCEDURE – application for further and better particulars – Federal Court Rules O 12 r 4 – application for further discovery – Federal Court Rules O 15 r 2 – whether sufficient particulars have been provided to determine quantification of loss and damage – whether an expert report is sufficient for the particularisation of damages – adequacy of discovery – limitation of the extent of further discovery when substantial discovery has already been provided – whether burden of discovery outweighs benefit – litigant in person in complex commercial litigation – balance needed in interests of justice
Legislation: Federal Court Rules O 12 r 4(1), O 12 r 4(2), O 12 r 5(1), O 14 r 2(1), O 15 r 2(3), O 15 r 2(6), O 15 r 6(1)
Cases cited:

Cameron, B.A. & Anor v. Rural Press Ltd & Ors [1990] FCA 360
Croft v Evertop Investments Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 1485

Hadley v Blaxendale (1854) 9 Ex.341
Hayward v Pullinger & Partners, Limited (1950) 1 All ER 581

Kyocera Mita Australia Pty Ltd v Mitronics Corporation Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 242
MacPherson v R (1981) 147 CLR 512
Minogue v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (1999) 84 FCR 438
Monk v Redwing Aircraft Company Ltd (1942) 1 KB 182
Neil v Nott (1994) 68 ALJR 509
Perestrello E Companhia Limitada v United Paint Co. Ltd (1969) 1 WLR 570
Phipps v Orthodox Unit Trusts Ltd (1958) 1 QB 314
Prehn v The Royal Bank of Liverpool (1870) LR 5 Exch 92
United Salvage Pty Ltd v Louis Dreyfus Armateurs SNC [2006] FCA 116
Westside Typographics Pty Ltd v Flexi-Products International Pty Ltd & Anor [1988] FCA 543

Date of hearing: 28 March 2011
Date of last submissions: 11 May 2011
Place: Perth
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 80
Counsel for the Applicant: RK Croft represented the applicants
Counsel for the First and Second Respondents: L Black with S Hemachandra
Solicitor for the First and Second Respondents: Downings Legal
Counsel for the Third Respondent: The Third Respondent did not appear

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 310 of 2006

BETWEEN:

RODNEY KIM CROFT
JANICE ANN CROFT
Applicants

AND:

EVERTOP INVESTMENTS PTY LTD
(ACN 091 802 201)
First Respondent

JAMES ALEXANDER KIDD
Second Respondent

THYE TAN
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

1 JULY 2011

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Within 35 days, the applicants file and serve further and better particulars of their losses and damages claimed setting out the quantification and calculation of loss and damage…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Croft v Evertop Investments Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 749
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Croft v Evertop Investments Pty Ltd (No 2) involved a dispute between the Crofts, as applicants, and Evertop Investments Pty Ltd and Jim Kidd, as respondents. The applicants sought to amend their claims for damages, including an account for profits, and sought further and better particulars, as well as additional discovery of documents from the respondents. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The central legal issues revolved around whether the applicants had provided sufficient particulars to determine the quantification of their losses and damages, and whether an expert report could substitute for such particulars. Additionally, the court had to assess the adequacy of the discovery already provided by the respondents and whether it was necessary or appropriate to order further discovery.

The court found that the applicants had not provided sufficient particulars of their losses and damages, and that their reliance on an expert report did not replace the need for more specific particulars in the pleadings. The court emphasised the importance of particularising claims to allow the respondents to understand the nature and extent of the financial exposure. The court also considered the substantial discovery already provided by the respondents and weighed this against the benefit of further discovery. Given the applicants' non-compliance with previous court orders and their inability to particularise their claims, the court decided that it was inappropriate to require the respondents to incur further costs for additional discovery at that stage.

Consequently, the court ordered the applicants to provide further and better particulars of their losses and damages within 35 days, detailing the quantification and calculation of loss and damage. For certain specified claims, if particulars could not be provided within this timeframe, an expert report was to be submitted at a later date. The applicants were also required to provide particulars of damages pleaded in specific paragraphs of their amended statement of claim within the same period. Additionally, the applicants were directed to provide certain documents within 45 days. The court also noted that no further costs would be incurred by the respondents in complying with discovery until the applicants met their obligations under these orders. The applicants were ordered to pay the respondents' costs of the motion if not agreed.

In summary, the court balanced the need for the applicants to particularise their claims with the substantial discovery already provided by the respondents, ultimately deciding that further discovery was not warranted until the applicants complied with the court's orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Within 35 days, the applicants file and serve further and better particulars of their losses and damages claimed setting out the quantification and calculation of loss and damage and the basis on which those amounts were calculated for the following:

A) The diminution in value of the licence to use the Jim Kidd Sports name for:

i) The Thornlie business;

ii) The Willetton business;

B) A national ‘equal’ contribution by all Jim Kidd stores to the advertising fund;

C) Funds paid by the applicants in excess of a 10% margin on goods purchased from the Jim Kidd Sports warehouse in Balcatta, Western Australia;

D) Valuation of the Thornlie business at the time of its acquisition by the applicants;

E) The aggregate value of the amount by which the applicants’ contribution to the actual costs of advertising was increased as a result of the alleged breaches to:

i) The Thornlie Collateral Agreement;

ii) The Willetton Collateral Agreement;

F) Interest paid on the applicants’ bank loan of $600,000 applied to the purchase of the Thornlie business;

G) Payments made or owing by the applicants in meeting third party liabilities arising from the appointment of a receiver to:

i) The Thornlie business;

ii) The Willetton business;

H) Loss of opportunity to earn additional profits in a hypothetical situation in which an allegedly required amount of advertising expenditure exceeded amounts of advertising expenditure which were made and resulted in increased sales by the applicants in relation to:

i) The Thornlie business;

ii) The Willetton business;

I) Value of lost sales allegedly made by the first and second respondents into exclusive licence area for each of the Thornlie and the Willetton business.

2. Further to Order 1 above, if further and better particulars cannot be provided for orders 1A, 1D, 1E, 1H and 1I, the applicants do provide particulars by way of an expert report at a date to be fixed.

3. Within 35 days, the applicants file and serve particulars of damages pleaded in paras 12, 18, 24, 19, 33 and 39 of the applicants’ minute of proposed amended statement of claim dated ‘February 2011-02-03’ filed on 4 March 2011 (the amended statement of claim).

4. Within 45 days, the applicants provide discovery of:

A) documents evidencing contributions to the advertising levy fund;

B) relevant documents that are no longer in their possession, custody or power;

C) any category or class of documents they do not search for;

D) documents of the kind identified in O 15 r 2(3) of the Federal Court Rules.

5. The parties have liberty to apply on 7 days notice.

6. The applicants do pay the first and second respondents’ costs of the motion to be taxed if not agreed.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Therefore, it follows that there is no hard and fast rule as to the nature or extent, if any, of particularisation of damage that may be required. Rather it is largely an assessment of whether the defending party has an adequate opportunity to appreciate the nature and extent of financial exposure embraced by an applicant’s case. Expert evidence It is not at all uncommon in claims, such as that advanced here, for applicants to rely upon expert reports in which a suitable expert, such as an accountant, will attempt to calculate the specific loss suffered under the respective heads of damage to provide a basis on which the opposing party can at least identify the quantum of the claim advanced. In this particular case, there has been reference to an expert report but as discussed below, the report is not in evidence in any sense and certainly does not descend to identifying the financial loss sustained by the Crofts whether by reference to the heads of damage appearing in the amended statement of claim or otherwise. To the extent that the heads of damage appear to be on their face quantifiable, that is, capable of calculation, there seems no good reason why, at this stage of the proceeding the respondents should not be informed of what the specific loss is. If there was a clearly identifiable expert report which descended to some particularity specifically addressing the heads of damage claimed in the pleading, then this particularisation may not be necessary but at present, the Crofts’ claim is somewhat ‘at large’ and the respondents have no computation of the loss and damage for which it is said they are liable. This makes it difficult to sensibly contemplate any realistic negotiation concerning the claim let alone to brief experts for the respondents to prepare for and examine the computations as they are put forward. Those were the reasons why I considered that quantification of loss was desirable. The respondents should not be exposed to the risk of guessing what methodology may be put forward by the Crofts in trying to calculate their losses. At this stage it appears that the Crofts will rely upon the content of a report dated 21 September 2006, prepared by Pitcher Partners (accountants), specifically Mr Vincent Smith, a Senior Partner (the Pitcher Report). The Pitcher Report is prospective evidence not a pleading or particulars. The case that the Crofts intend to advance at trial must be tied down to specific material facts and particulars set out in the pleadings to which Evertop and Mr Kidd will respond. So far, the Crofts have not undertaken this task. The Crofts have repeatedly sought to reverse the onus of proof by seeking an order requiring the respondents to prove that the accounts, which are challenged by the Crofts, can be properly verified by independent audit. But until Evertop and Mr Kidd know precisely what case is put against them as reflected in the pleadings (as distinct from an expert report which may or may not be proved at trial), there is no requirement for them to adduce any evidence at this stage. This is particularly relevant in the present instance where a very significant amount of pre-action discovery was provided by the respondents and notwithstanding this, the Crofts have still not quantified their claim, either under particular headings or generally. The groupings of claims

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, before discovery is given, the contention for Evertop and Mr Kidd is that, in relation to the account for profits claim, orders should be made requiring or allowing the Crofts to amend the account for profits claim to plead it with sufficient particularity so as to allow the respondents to understand what is being sought. Secondly, requiring or allowing the Crofts to identify the documents or categories of documents that they require to be discovered in relation to the account for profits claim so as to frame the onerous discovery task with more precision and that the respondents have the opportunity to respond to those claims. The respondents submit that orders requiring them to provide discovery in relation to the account for profits claim should be vacated until each of those three steps has been completed by the Crofts. CONCLUSION In my view, in light of the non-compliance with several of the orders of the Court in recent times and the inability that the Crofts are experiencing in particularising their claim and providing discovery, it would be inappropriate to require the respondents to incur the substantial additional financial burden of having to provide further discovery at this stage in the manner sought by the Crofts or at all. I propose, therefore, in indicating that I expect no further costs to be incurred by the respondents in complying with discovery until the obligations directed in these orders are met by the Crofts. Should there be particular difficulty sustained or experienced in complying with the orders, then it is for the Crofts to apply for the orders to be reviewed or reconsidered. In the meantime, it is clear that even if the respondents are totally to blame, as the Crofts contend, they should not be required to incur the very substantial expenditure in providing further discovery in the manner sought by the Crofts until such time as there is compliance by the Crofts with outstanding directions. The Crofts should also understand that non-compliance with the orders does place their entire claim at jeopardy. As mentioned on a number of occasions, in these reasons, while I am sympathetic to the difficulties occasioned by the Crofts in pursuing this claim without the benefit of legal assistance, that does not meant that assistance can be rendered to them to the prejudice of the respondents. This is particularly so in the circumstance of a substantial pre-action discovery benefit which has been afforded to the Crofts (and other applicants). Notwithstanding this substantial benefit (and corresponding cost to the respondents), the Crofts have still not been able to fashion their claim in a manner which properly enables it to go forward to trial. In that regard, I have indicated the orders I propose making concerning particulars and discovery. I make the following orders:1.Within 35 days, the applicants file and serve further and better particulars of their losses and damages claimed setting out the quantification and calculation of loss and damage and the basis on which those amounts were calculated for the following:A)The diminution in value of the licence to use the Jim Kidd Sports name for:i)The Thornlie business;ii)The Willetton business;B)A national ‘equal’ contribution by all Jim Kidd stores to the advertising fund;C)Funds paid by the applicants in excess of a 10% margin on goods purchased from the Jim Kid Sports warehouse in Balcatta, Western Australia;D)Valuation of the Thornlie business at the time of its acquisition by the applicants;E)The aggregate value of the amount by which the applicants’ contribution to the actual costs of advertising was increased as a result of the alleged breaches to:i)The Thornlie Collateral Agreement;ii)The Willetton Collateral Agreement;F)Interest paid on the applicants’ bank loan of $600,000 applied to the purchase of the Thornlie business;G)Payments made or owing by the applicants in meeting third party liabilities arising from the appointment of a receiver to:i)The Thornlie business;ii)The Willetton business;H)Loss of opportunity to earn additional profits in a hypothetical situation in which an allegedly required amount of advertising expenditure exceeded amounts of advertising expenditure which were made and resulted in increased sales by the applicants in relation to:i)The Thornlie business;ii)The Willetton business;I)Value of lost sales allegedly made by the first and second respondents into exclusive licence area for each of the Thornlie and the Willetton business. 2.Further to Order 1 above, if further and better particulars cannot be provided for orders 1A, 1D, 1E, 1H and 1I, the applicants do provide particulars by way of an expert report at a date to be fixed. 3.Within 35 days, the applicants file and serve particulars of damages pleaded in paras 12, 18, 24, 19, 33 and 39 of the applicants’ minute of proposed amended statement of claim dated ‘February 2011-02-03’ filed on 4 March 2011 (the amended statement of claim).4.Within 45 days, the applicants provide discovery of:A)documents evidencing contributions to the advertising levy fund; B)relevant documents that are no longer in their possession, custody or power;C)any category or class of documents they do not search for;D)documents of the kind identified in O 15 r 2(3) of the Federal Court Rules. 5.The parties have liberty to apply on 7 days notice. 6.The applicants do pay the first and second respondents’ costs of the motion to be taxed if not agreed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.