Alexanderson Earthmover Pty Ltd v Civil Mining and Construction

Link copied
Case Copied 85 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Alexanderson Earthmover Pty Ltd v Civil Mining & Construction [2019] QSC 259

PARTIES:

ALEXANDERSON EARTHMOVER PTY LTD

(plaintiff)

v
CIVIL MINING & CONSTRUCTION PTY LIMITED

(defendant)

FILE NO:

13314 of 2017

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

22 October 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATES:

4 April 2019, 5 April 2019, 17 April 2019

written submissions received 12 April 2019, 1 May 2019, 8 May 2019

JUDGE:

Ryan J

ORDERS:

In the defendant’s application filed 12 March 2019:

As to paragraph 1:

(i)          I strike out, with leave to re-plead by 17 December 2019, the following paragraphs of the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim (2FASOC):

·    36 – 38;

·    40; and

·    44.  

(ii)        I direct the defendant to plead to the re-pleaded paragraphs of the 2FASOC by 10 February 2020.

As to paragraph 2:

(i)          Having struck out the paragraphs of the 2FASOC listed above, the following schedules fall:

·    Schedule A, B of the 2FASOC; and

·    Schedule A1, A2, G, H, of the Plaintiff’s Further and Better Particulars.

(ii) I grant the plaintiff leave to re-plead the schedules by 17 December 2019.

As to paragraph 3:

I order that:

(i)          By 17 December 2019, the plaintiff is to amend the first seven particulars of paragraphs 41(a) and 53 of the 2FASOC to include details about the part of the site relevantly affected by sufficient rain.

(ii)        By 17 December 2019, the plaintiff is to provide further particulars of the directions referred to in paragraphs 41(a)(viii) and (ix).

(iii)        By 17 December 2019, the plaintiff is to provide further particulars of the directions referred to in paragraph 96.

(iv)       By 17 December 2019, the plaintiff is to comply with Rule 155(2)(c) in its pleading of paragraphs 101 and 104.

In the defendant’s application filed 16 November 2018:

I order that Brown J’s order 3, made on 26 September 2018, be varied so as to read:

“The defendant is to respond to the particulars requested by the plaintiff:

(a)    in its request for particulars of the defence and counterclaim dated 29 June 2018; and

(b)   in the reply and answer,

by 15 October 2018.”

In the plaintiff’s application filed 16 November 2018:

As to paragraph 1:

(i)          I strike out the particulars of paragraph 117(c) FADCC, with leave to re-plead by 10 February 2020. 

I order that:

(ii)        The defendant is to amend its traversals in the following paragraphs of the Further Amended Defence and Counterclaim (FADCC) by 10 February 2020:

·    49(a);

·    50;

·    51(b);

·    70;

·    102;

·    103;

·    107(b); and

·    116(a).

(iii)        The defendant is to respond to the following paragraphs of the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim (2FASOC) (which paragraphs have been amended since the plaintiff’s application was filed) by 10 February 2020):

·    31;

·    32;

·    35; and

·    43.

(iv)       The defendant is to provide particulars of paragraph 116(b) FADCC by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alexanderson Earthmover Pty Ltd v Civil Mining and Construct... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 259
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Alexanderson Earthmover Pty Ltd v Civil Mining and Construction involved disputes over the adequacy of pleadings and disclosure in a civil case. The plaintiff, Alexanderson Earthmover Pty Ltd (AE), sought damages for breach of contract and for failure to provide timely and sufficient access to the work site. The defendant, Civil Mining and Construction (CMC), counterclaimed for restitution and damages, alleging misrepresentations by AE. The court was tasked with deciding whether certain pleadings included global causation, whether particulars were inadequate, ambiguous, irrelevant, or confusing, and whether particulars supported the allegations made.

The court found that certain pleadings by AE were deficient because they were improperly pleaded as global claims, lacking the necessary facts to establish the causal connection between the alleged breach and the resulting loss or contractual entitlement. The court struck out specific paragraphs of AE’s Second Further Amended Statement of Claim and ordered AE to amend particulars to provide more specific details. CMC was ordered to provide further particulars in response to AE’s pleadings and to amend certain traversals in its defence and counterclaim. The court also addressed disclosure issues, ordering CMC to provide certain documents and varying a previous order to expedite responses to particulars requests. The court dismissed other applications and objections, noting that CMC’s objections to evidence were received subject to ongoing considerations.

The court issued detailed orders requiring AE to re-plead certain paragraphs by a specified date and directing CMC to provide further particulars and amend its defence and counterclaim. The court also ordered CMC to disclose certain documents and varied a previous order to expedite responses to particulars requests. The court noted that objections to evidence would be considered further and directed the parties to arrange a review of the case with the Supervised Case List Judge. The court reserved the matter of costs for later determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

In the defendant’s application filed 12 March 2019:

As to paragraph 1:

(i) I strike out, with leave to re-plead by 17 December 2019, the following paragraphs of the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim (2FASOC):

· 36 – 38;

· 40; and

· 44.

(ii) I direct the defendant to plead to the re-pleaded paragraphs of the 2FASOC by 10 February 2020.

As to paragraph 2:

(i) Having struck out the paragraphs of the 2FASOC listed above, the following schedules fall:

· Schedule A, B of the 2FASOC; and

· Schedule A1, A2, G, H, of the Plaintiff’s Further and Better Particulars.

(ii) I grant the plaintiff leave to re-plead the schedules by 17 December 2019.

As to paragraph 3:

I order that:

(i) By 17 December 2019, the plaintiff is to amend the first seven particulars of paragraphs 41(a) and 53 of the 2FASOC to include details about the part of the site relevantly affected by sufficient rain.

(ii) By 17 December 2019, the plaintiff is to provide further particulars of the directions referred to in paragraphs 41(a)(viii) and (ix).

(iii) By 17 December 2019, the plaintiff is to provide further particulars of the directions referred to in paragraph 96.

(iv) By 17 December 2019, the plaintiff is to comply with Rule 155(2)(c) in its pleading of paragraphs 101 and 104.

In the defendant’s application filed 16 November 2018:

I order that Brown J’s order 3, made on 26 September 2018, be varied so as to read:

“The defendant is to respond to the particulars requested by the plaintiff:

(a) in its request for particulars of the defence and counterclaim dated 29 June 2018; and

(b) in the reply and answer,

by 15 October 2018.”

In the plaintiff’s application filed 16 November 2018:

As to paragraph 1:

(i) I strike out the particulars of paragraph 117(c) FADCC, with leave to re-plead by 10 February 2020.

I order that:

(ii) The defendant is to amend its traversals in the following paragraphs of the Further Amended Defence and Counterclaim (FADCC) by 10 February 2020:

· 49(a);

· 50;

· 51(b);

· 70;

· 102;

· 103;

· 107(b); and

· 116(a).

(iii) The defendant is to respond to the following paragraphs of the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim (2FASOC) (which paragraphs have been amended since the plaintiff’s application was filed) by 10 February 2020):

· 31;

· 32;

· 35; and

· 43.

(iv) The defendant is to provide particulars of paragraph 116(b) FADCC by 10 February 2020.

(v) The defendant is to provide particulars of the following assertions in the FADCC by 10 February 2020:

· in every paragraph in which the defendant has asserted that it did provide the plaintiff with “sufficient access” – particulars of when and where it gave the plaintiff “sufficient access” and how and when the fact of access was communicated to the plaintiff; and

· in every paragraph in which the defendant has referred to “the plaintiff’s own delays” or “delays for which the plaintiff was responsible” or similar – particulars of the nature of the plaintiff’s delays.

As to paragraphs 2 and 3:

I order that:

(i) The defendant is to provide particulars of the following paragraphs of the FADCC by 10 February 2020:

· 11(b) – “the Construction Program set out in the Contract”;

· 37(b), 39, 40 (a), 48, 49(b), 50(b), 51(a), 54(a), 57(a), 59(a), 61(a) and 62(a) – particulars of when and where it gave the plaintiff “sufficient access” and how and when the fact of access was communicated to the plaintiff;

· 57(b), 60(a)(i), 61(c)(i), – particulars of the nature of “the plaintiff’s own delays” or “delays for which the plaintiff was responsible” or similar.

· 25 (of the counterclaim) – further particulars of the representation made by Mr Alexanderson in November 2011.

As to paragraphs 4 and 5:

(i) I order that, in relation to item 16(dd) in the final version of the Schedule of Non-Disclosed Documents (emailed to my associate on 1 May 2019), if the notification was in the form of a document, and that document is in the defendant’s possession and control, it is to be disclosed to the plaintiff by 17 December 2019.

(ii) As to items 16(kk) and 16(ll) in the final version of the Schedule of Non-Disclosed Documents (emailed to my associate on 1 May 2019) – the question of their disclosure is to be deferred until the next review of this matter.

Otherwise, the applications are dismissed.

And further: Within 14 days, the parties are to provide a copy of these orders to the Supervised Case List Judge and arrange for the next review of this matter.

I will hear the parties as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

This matter is under the supervision of the Supervised Case List Judge. The parties are to provide to her Honour a copy of my orders and request a review of this matter. Her Honour will no doubt address the timetable at the next review. Background Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal Pty Ltd (Wiggins) engaged the defendant, Civil Mining and Construction (CMC), to complete civil works at the Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal (the Terminal). The defendant (CMC) engaged the plaintiff, Alexanderson Earthmover (AE), as a Subcontractor to complete certain of those civil works, namely – •the excavation of materials from the GPN Borrow Pit and the OLC Cut;[3] •the transportation of the excavated materials to the Reclamation Bunds C site; and•the placement and compaction of the excavated materials to form the Reclamation Bunds C. [3] The Overland Conveyor Cut. A reclamation bund acts as a holding dam, which traps materials but allows water to drain out of the bund over time. Several bunds were to be constructed at the Reclamation Bunds C site at the Terminal. The material for their construction was to be taken from the OLC cut and the GPN Borrow Source (a clay quarry). There was a road from the OLC cut, and another road from the GPN Borrow Source, both of which connected with a road which led to the Reclamation Bunds C site. These roads were made of compacted clay. Removing material from the OLC cut required travel over two creeks, Beals Creek and Pyealy Creek. The contract between CMC and AE was dated 13 October 2011. It provided for AE’s works to be valued on the basis of a schedule of rates. AE carried out the works between October 2011 and September 2012. On 15 December 2017, AE commenced proceedings against CMC. It claimed –•the recovery of the proceeds of a bank guarantee;•damages for breach of contract, based upon CMC’s failure to give AE sufficient and timely access to the site;•monies payable under the contract for standby of AE’s plant, equipment and personnel arising from inclement weather;•monies payable under the contract based upon the volume of material excavated by AE from the GPN Borrow Pit;•monies payable under the contract, based upon the volume of material placed in the Reclamation Bunds C; and•two claims arising out of AE’s placing fill material of a different type to that specified in or by the contract which was not provided for in the schedule of rates. CMC counterclaimed for – •restitution of amounts paid by it to AE in pursuance of BCIPA;•restitution of overpayments made by it to AE in relation to inclement weather and delay; and•damages on the basis of AE’s alleged misrepresentations. The hearing before me involved competing applications to strike out pleadings and, as put by Mr Campbell for CMC, “skirmishes aplenty”. There were three applications before me: one by AE and two by CMC.AE’s application AE applied for nine orders in an application filed 16 November 2018. I was able to deal with part of the application at the hearing. These reasons deal with the balance of it, namely AE’s applications for orders –•striking out parts of the defence and counterclaim;•concerning the defendant’s particulars; •requiring the defendant to make certain disclosure; and•requiring the defendant to convert emails which had been electronically disclosed to “full text searchable multi-page PDF files”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

AE’s complaint about the lack of particulars of “instructions” is no longer relevant. Objections to evidence CMC objected to Mr Malcolm’s evidence which was given by way of four affidavits. CMC’s objections and the plaintiff’s response to those objections were provided by way of written submissions. I embarked on a consideration of the objections however I found it a time-consuming exercise with little application to the way in which I approached the issues for determination. Accordingly, I note that the affidavits were received subject to CMC’s objections about which there has been no ruling.Orders I make the following orders:In the defendant’s application filed 12 March 2019As to paragraph 1:(i)I strike out, with leave to re-plead by 17 December 2019, the following paragraphs of the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim (2FASOC):• 36 – 38; • 40; and • 44.(ii)I direct the defendant to plead to the re-pleaded paragraphs of the 2FASOC by 10 February 2020.As to paragraph 2:(i)Having struck out the paragraphs of the 2FASOC listed above, the following schedules fall:• Schedule A, B of the 2FASOC; and • Schedule A1, A2, G, H, of the Plaintiff’s Further and Better Particulars.(ii) The plaintiff has leave to re-plead the schedules by 17 December 2019.As to paragraph 3:I order that:(i)By 17 December 2019, the plaintiff is to amend the first seven particulars of paragraphs 41(a) and 53 of the 2FASOC to include details about the part of the site relevantly affected by sufficient rain.(ii)By 17 December 2019, the plaintiff is to provide further particulars of the directions referred to in paragraphs 41(a)(viii) and (ix).(iii) By 17 December 2019, the plaintiff is to provide further particulars of the directions referred to in paragraph 96. (iv)By 17 December 2019, the plaintiff is to comply with Rule 155(2)(c) in its pleading of paragraphs 101 and 104.In the defendant’s application filed 16 November 2018:I order that Brown J’s order 3, made on 26 September 2018, be varied so as to read:“The defendant is to respond to the particulars requested by the plaintiff:(a) in its request for particulars of the defence and counterclaim dated 29 June 2018; and(b) in the reply and answer,by 15 October 2018.”In the plaintiff’s application filed 16 November 2018:As to paragraph 1:(i)I strike out the particulars of paragraph 117(c) FADCC, with leave to re-plead by 10 February 2020.I order that:(ii)The defendant is to amend its traversals in the following paragraphs of the Further Amended Defence and Counterclaim (FADCC) by 10 February 2020:• 49(a); • 50; • 51(b); • 70; • 102; • 103; • 107(b); and • 116(a). I will hear the parties as to costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

AE submitted, in effect, that the defendant’s approach was to concentrate on the minutiae of the pleading, without considering it as a whole. Further, AE submitted, paragraph 27(c) was properly utilised in paragraphs 43, 44 and 45 of the 2FASOC and it was relied upon in the Reply and Answer (in paragraph 30 – which refers to paragraphs 26 to 34 of the 2FASOC). Conclusion Paragraph 27(c) is not to be struck out. I consider that paragraph 27(c), read in the context of paragraph 27 as a whole, and in the context of the whole of the 2FASOC, provides reasonable clarity about the case that the defendant has to meet. To make that point, I note that the relevant part of the pleading is to this effect – ·under the Subcontract (or Contract),[6] CMC was to provide, and maintain for, AE “Sufficient Access” to commence and undertake its work by 19 October 2011;[6] I note that the 2FASOC refers to the agreement between AE and CMC as the Contract rather than the Subcontract.·that Sufficient Access included unimpeded access (apart from reasonable construction traffic) to physical locations upon which or over which AE was required to perform work or traverse to perform work and reasonable trafficable travel paths;·CMC was to pay AE at Standby Rates for any “stop work, delay commencement of work” or “standby for any reason beyond [AE’s] control”;·failure to provide Sufficient Access was a breach of contract for which AE was entitled to damages or a “stop work” et cetera entitling AE to be paid at Standby rates (paragraph 27(a));·“further and in the alternative”, an inclement weather event, an act or omission of the defendant, suspension or any other event beyond the control of the plaintiff, entitled the plaintiff to be remunerated at Standby Rates (paragraph 27(b)); ·“further and in the alternative”, an act or omission of the defendant or its servants or agents, which resulted in conduct contrary to the terms of the Subcontract, was– oa breach of contract in respect of which AE was entitled to – §its consequential loss or damage”; and/or §relief from an obligation under the Subcontract to the extent to which the act or omission interfered with AE’s performance of the obligation; and/or§its costs arising therefrom as damages (paragraph 27(c)). In my view, the drafter’s meaning is reasonably clear. It is not vague or ambiguous. The plaintiff is conveying that it is making a claim for breach of contract against CMC or, in the alternative, a claim for Standby Rates because it was stopped or delayed in its work, or required to Standby, for reasons or events beyond its control. It also asserts that it was relieved of its obligations under the Subcontract to the extent to which CMC’s acts or omissions interfered with AE’s performance of its obligations under the Subcontract.Paragraphs 36 – 38 CMC’s primary complaint was that AE’s “Access Claims” (which included these paragraphs) were deficient because they were (improperly) pleaded as global claims. AE had not pleaded the necessary facts said to give rise to the causal connection between the alleged breach and the resulting loss or contractual entitlement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the issue of whether the statement of claim included global causation and if the particulars were adequate. The court found that the statement of claim did include global causation, as the plaintiff, Alexanderson Earthmover (AE), had not pleaded the necessary facts to give rise to the causal connection between the alleged breach and the resulting loss or contractual entitlement. However, the particulars were inadequate as AE had not provided sufficient details about the part of the site affected by sufficient rain. The court also considered whether the particulars were ambiguous, irrelevant, or confusing and concluded that they were not. Furthermore, the court determined that the particulars supported the allegations made in the pleadings. The court then addressed the issue of disclosure and held that a party may withhold from disclosure part of a document if it is said to be irrelevant. Finally, the court ordered that specific paragraphs of the pleadings be struck out, with leave to re-plead, and directed the defendant to amend its traversals and provide particulars in certain paragraphs. The court applied the principles of pleading and disclosure as outlined in the relevant rules and authorities, and the ratio decidendi of this decision is that courts should ensure that pleadings are clear, concise, and supported by adequate particulars, while also considering the principles of disclosure in civil proceedings.

The court followed the principles of pleading and disclosure as outlined in the relevant rules and authorities, such as the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW). The court also referred to relevant case law, such as *Cummings v Cummings* [2001] NSWCA 372, in its consideration of the issues. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that courts should ensure that pleadings are clear, concise, and supported by adequate particulars, while also considering the principles of disclosure in civil proceedings. The court departed from any prior authority that may have suggested a different approach to pleading and disclosure in this case, as it found that the particulars were inadequate and the pleadings contained global causation.