Marlborough District Council v Altimarloch Joint Venture Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

SC 33/2010

[2012] NZSC 11

BETWEEN  MARLBOROUGH DISTRICT COUNCIL
Appellant

AND  ALTIMARLOCH JOINT VENTURE LIMITED
First Respondent

AND  D S AND J W MOORHOUSE
Second Respondents

AND  VINING REALTY GROUP LIMITED
Third Respondent

AND  GASCOIGNE WICKS
Fourth Respondent

SC 40/2010

BETWEEN  VINING REALTY GROUP LIMITED
Appellant

AND  ALTIMARLOCH JOINT VENTURE LIMITED
First Respondent

AND  GASCOIGNE WICKS
Second Respondent

AND  D S AND J W MOORHOUSE
Third Respondents

AND  MARLBOROUGH DISTRICT COUNCIL
Fourth Respondent

SC 41/2010

BETWEEN  GASCOIGNE WICKS
Appellant

AND  ALTIMARLOCH JOINT VENTURE LIMITED
First Respondent

AND  D S AND J W MOORHOUSE
Second Respondents

AND  MARLBOROUGH DISTRICT COUNCIL
Third Respondent

AND  VINING REALTY GROUP LIMITED
Fourth Respondent

Hearing:         15-16 February 2011

Court:             Elias CJ, Blanchard, Tipping, McGrath and Anderson JJ

Counsel:         D J Goddard QC, M A Cavanaugh, and J H Morrison for Marlborough District Council
M E Casey QC and R N Dunningham for Altimarloch Joint Venture Limited
M R Ring QC and A B Darroch for Vining Realty Group Limited
F B Barton and M B Couling for Gascoigne Wicks

Judgment:      5 March 2012

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal by the Marlborough District Council from the liability judgment given against it in favour of Altimarloch Joint Venture Limited is dismissed.

BThe appeal by the Marlborough District Council from the contribution judgment given against it in favour of D S and J W Moorhouse is allowed.  That judgment is set aside and judgment in favour of the Council is entered in respect of that claim.

CThe appeals by Vining Realty Group Limited and Gascoigne Wicks against the amount of the judgment entered in favour of Altimarloch Joint Venture Limited against the Moorhouses are dismissed.

DCosts:

In the Supreme Court

(a)      The Council is to pay Altimarloch costs of $10,000. 

(b)Vining Realty and Gascoigne Wicks are to pay the Council costs of $5,000.  They are to pay in the proportions fixed in the Court of Appeal, namely 60 per cent by Vining Realty and 40 per cent by Gascoigne Wicks.

(c)Vining Realty and Gascoigne Wicks are to pay in the same proportions costs of $10,000 to Altimarloch.

(d)      In each case where costs are awarded, disbursements shall be added as agreed or fixed by the Registrar. 

In the Court of Appeal

(a)The Council is to pay Altimarloch such costs as agreed or fixed by the Court of Appeal.

(b)Vining Realty and Gascoigne Wicks are to pay in the same proportions costs to the Council as agreed or fixed by the Court of Appeal.

(c)As between Vining Realty and Gascoigne Wicks on the one hand and Altimarloch on the other, Order F made by the Court of Appeal stands.

(d)      All orders made in the Court of Appeal that are inconsistent with the foregoing orders are set aside. 

(e)In each case where costs are awarded, disbursements shall be added as agreed or fixed by the Registrar.

In the High Court

(a)All…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marlborough District Council v Altimarloch Joint Venture Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZSC 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of New Zealand heard three appeals from the Marlborough District Council, Vining Realty Group Limited, and Gascoigne Wicks against the judgments of the Court of Appeal and High Court. The appeals related to the sale of a rural property in the Awatere Valley, where the vendors and the Council provided misrepresentations regarding the quantity of water rights held by the vendors. The purchaser, Altimarloch Joint Venture Limited, sought damages for the misrepresentations. The Court of Appeal largely upheld the High Court's judgment, which found the vendors and the Council liable for damages. The Court of Appeal reduced the damages awarded against the Council to $125,000. The Court of Appeal also upheld the equal apportionment of damages between the vendors and the Council, but only in respect of the Council's liability on the tortious measure of $125,000. The Court's decision considered the measure of damages and the issue of contribution. The Court found that the proper measure of damages was the extent to which Altimarloch suffered loss in the bargain because the vendors did not hold the water rights represented and could not transfer them under the contractual obligation. The difference in the value of the property with and without the represented water rights was accepted as $400,000. The Court allowed the appeals by Vining Realty and Gascoigne Wicks, and entered judgment against the vendors for $400,000 together with costs. The Court dismissed the appeal by the Marlborough District Council against the liability judgment given against it in favour of Altimarloch Joint Venture Limited. However, the Court allowed the Council's appeal against the contribution judgment given against it in favour of D S and J W Moorhouse. The Court set aside the contribution judgment and entered judgment in favour of the Council in respect of that claim. The Court also dismissed the appeals by Vining Realty and Gascoigne Wicks against the amount of the judgment entered in favour of Altimarloch Joint Venture Limited against the Moorhouses.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established