McFall v Bayley Developments Limited t/a Fabricators Builders Renovators

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA KIRIKIRIROA ROHE

CIV 2021-419-000035

[2023] NZHC 1040

UNDER the District Court Act 2016

IN THE MATTER

of an appeal against a decision of the District Court at Hamilton

BETWEEN

REGAN JAMES MCFALL AND EMMA MCFALL

Appellants

AND

BAYLEY DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED

trading as FABRICATORS BUILDERS RENOVATORS

Respondent

Hearing: 28 & 29 November 2022

Appearances:

V A Whitfield for the Appellants

P J Morgan KC for the Respondent

Judgment:

3 May 2023


JUDGMENT OF TAHANA J


This judgment was delivered by me on 3 May 2023 at 4.00pm Pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

…………………………

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors/Counsel:

Beattie Rickman Legal, Hamilton Thackeray Chambers, Hamilton

Victoria Whitfield, Barrister, Cambridge O’Sheas Barrister & Solicitors, Hamilton

MCFALL v BAYLEY DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED (trading as FABRICATORS BUILDERS RENOVATORS) [2023] NZHC 1040 [3 May 2023]

Introduction

[1]    Mr and Mrs McFall (the McFalls) engaged Bayley Developments Ltd (BDL) to build a new home. There was no written contract. The District Court held that the McFalls owed BDL $78,501.58 (including GST) for unpaid building works, and BDL owed the McFalls $69,407.00 for costs to repair building defects.1 Applying a set-off, the District Court awarded judgment for BDL of $9,094.58 (including GST). The McFalls appeal that decision.

[2]The McFalls say the Judge erred:

(a)By finding that BDL had charged a reasonable amount for labour costs.

(b)In relation to certain defects:

(i)by awarding the wrong amount to repair the defect; or

(ii)by finding that BDL was not responsible for the defect or unfinished work.

(c)By not awarding general damages for stress and anxiety.

[3]After set-off, the McFalls are seeking judgment in their favour of $152,708.61.

Approach on appeal

[4]    A general appeal requires the Court to come to its own view on the merits. The McFalls, however, bear the onus of satisfying the Court that it should differ from the decision under appeal.2 It is only if the appellate court considers that the appealed decision is wrong that it is justified in interfering with it.3


1      Bayley Developments Limited v McFall [2020] NZDC 23168 at [71].

2      Austin, Nichols & Co Inc v Stichting Lodestar [2007] NZSC 103.

3 At [4].

[5]    Mr Morgan KC submitted that this was a factual case, evidence was heard and a large volume of documents were considered over 13 hearing days, so that any factual issues were appropriately considered by the District Court Judge.

[6]    I accept that this is a general appeal which allows this Court to consider any errors of fact with due allowance for the advantage the trial judge had of hearing the witnesses over the course of the trial.

Appeal ground 1 – reasonable costs

District Court finding

[7]    The Judge found that BDL’s labour costs of $93,800.00 (plus GST) were reasonable. In reaching this decision, the Judge considered:

(a)the estimates provided by each of the quantity surveyors (Mr Brock for BDL and Mr White for the McFalls); and

(b)the time…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McFall v Bayley Developments Limited t/a Fabricators Builder... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 1040
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of McFall v Bayley Developments Limited t/a Fabricators Builders Renovators, the High Court of New Zealand assessed an appeal from the District Court decision. The McFalls, who had engaged Bayley Developments Ltd (BDL) to construct a new home, contested the District Court's ruling that BDL was owed $78,501.58 for unpaid building works, while the McFalls were owed $69,407.00 for defect repairs, resulting in a net judgment for BDL of $9,094.58 after set-off. The McFalls appealed on several grounds, including the reasonableness of BDL's labour costs, the adequacy of the repair costs for specific defects, and the refusal to award general damages for stress and anxiety.

The High Court reviewed each appeal ground, finding that the District Court did not err in considering BDL's labour costs reasonable despite discrepancies in the quantity surveyors' estimates. The Court also upheld the District Court's findings on the repair costs for certain defects, noting that the alternative repair solutions proposed were realistic and proportionate to the defects. Regarding the claim for general damages, the Court concluded that the District Court was entitled to consider the broader context of the case, including the litigation itself, in deciding not to award general damages.

However, the Court did find merit in two appeal grounds, adjusting the damages awarded for specific defects. For defect 1, the Court allowed an additional award of $8,278.70, and for defect 8, concerning the foam backing rod for doors and windows, the Court found that BDL was liable for $1,020.00 in repair costs. These adjustments increased the total damages awarded to the McFalls by $9,298.70 to $78,705.70. After set-off, the net sum of $204.12 (including GST) was payable by BDL to the McFalls. The Court also addressed the issue of costs, instructing the parties to file cost memoranda if they could not agree on costs themselves.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established