Body Corporate 326421 v Auckland Council

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV2009-404-008136 [2015] NZHC 862

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 326421

First Plaintiff

WILLIAM MILLER AND RAEWYN MILLER & ORS

Second Plaintiffs

AND

AUCKLAND COUNCIL First Defendant

BROOKFIELD MULTIPLEX CONSTRUCTIONS (NZ) LIMITED (in liquidation)

Second Defendant

WALKER ARCHITECTS LIMITED (in liquidation)

Third Defendant

cont:…/2

Hearing: 4 August - 12 September 2014

Appearances:

C M Meechan QC, T J Rainey, G R Grant and J Heatlie for the
Plaintiffs
S A Thodey, L J Douglas, S B Mitchell and K M Parker for the
First Defendant
D T Broadmore for the Second Defendant
No appearance for the Third to Sixth Defendants
S C Price, D M Cross and N J Brazendale for the First Third
Party
M G Ring QC, A S McIntyre, M J Francis, M Cusak and
A C Cupples for the Second Third Party

Judgment:

29 April 2015

JUDGMENT OF GILBERT J

This judgment is delivered by me on 29 April 2015 at 3.30 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

..................................................... Registrar / Deputy Registrar

BODY CORPORATE 326421 v AUCKLAND COUNCIL [2015] NZHC 862 [29 April 2015]

DOWNER EDI WORKS LIMITED Fourth Defendant (Discontinued)

FAÇADE TECHNOLOGIES LIMITED (in liquidation)

Fifth Defendant

CHARLES NORAGER & SONS LIMITED

Sixth Defendant

ANDBOSTIK NEW ZEALAND LIMITED First Third Party

ZURICH INSURANCE PLC AS LEAD UNDERWRITER AND ON BEHALF OF ALL UNDERWRITERS SEVERALLY SUBSCRIBED TO POLICY

B 0901LB0810824

Second Third Party

Table of Contents

Introduction ..........................................................................................................[1] The issues ............................................................................................................[16] Roof

What are the defects? ...................................................................................[18]

Who is liable for the defects? .......................................................................[20]
What is required to repair the defects? ........................................................[36]

Roof edge

What are the defects? ...................................................................................[43]

Cladding

What are the defects? ...................................................................................[57]

Who is liable for these defects? ...................................................................[76] Council ..................................................................................................[76] Brookfield Multiplex...........................................................................[128] Walker Architects ................................................................................[132] What is required to repair the defects? ......................................................[139]

Decks

What are the defects? .................................................................................[141]

Insufficient step-down at the threshold ...............................................[142] Failure of Membrane to cure ...............................................................[146] Membrane not dressed into outlets......................................................[149] Discontinuity of membrane at the nib .................................................[152] Corner overflows not adequately formed ............................................[155] Waterproof membrane under grout fill at the threshold ......................[160]

Who is liable for these defects?

Insufficient step-down .........................................................................[165] Failure of membrane to cure ...............................................................[173] Membrane not dressed into outlets......................................................[186] Membrane not continuous at the nib ...................................................[190] Corner overflows not adequately formed ............................................[202] Waterproof membrane under grout fill at threshold ............................[208] What is required to repair these defects? ...................................................[210]

Balustrades

What are the defects? ................................................................................. [211]

Who is responsible for these defects?.........................................................[222]
What is required to repair these defects? ...................................................[229]

Podium

What are the defects? .................................................................................[233]

Who is responsible for these defects?.........................................................[235] What is required to repair these defects? ...................................................[245] What will it cost to repair the defects? ..........................................................[246] Storage allowance ………………………………………………………..[250] Allowance for wall straightening and reinstatement .................................[251] Allowance to remediate corrosion to structural steel ...............................[254]

Wall cladding .............................................................................................[256] Timber soffit framing ..................................................................................[258] Overcladding of planter walls ....................................................................[261] Contingency sum ........................................................................................[264] Design and contract administration fees .………………………………..[266]

Proportional deductions .............................................................................[267] Has an appropriate allowance been made for betterment?

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 326421 v Auckland Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 862
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Body Corporate 326421 and other unit owners in the Nautilus building brought an action against Auckland Council, Brookfield Multiplex Constructions (NZ) Limited, Walker Architects Limited, Charles Norager & Sons Limited, and others, for damages for design and construction defects in the building. The plaintiffs claimed that the building was not watertight and suffered from a number of fundamental defects that would cost over $23 million to repair. The plaintiffs sought compensation for their proportionate share of the remediation costs, the costs of temporary repairs, loss of use of the units while they were remediated and general damages for inconvenience. The issues before the court were: (a) what are the defects; (b) who is liable for the defects; (c) what is required to repair the defects; (d) what will it cost to repair the defects; (e) has an appropriate allowance been made for betterment; (f) are plaintiffs with assigned claims entitled to recover; (g) are the plaintiffs entitled to the cost of temporary repairs; (h) are the plaintiffs entitled to consequential losses; (i) are the plaintiffs entitled to general damages; (j) did any of the plaintiffs fail to mitigate their loss; (k) did any of the plaintiffs contribute to their own losses; (l) what damages are the plaintiffs entitled to against each of the defendants; (m) what contribution is each defendant entitled to from other defendants; and (n) is Brookfield Multiplex entitled to indemnity for part or all of its liability under the professional indemnity insurance policy. The court found that the plaintiffs were entitled to judgment against each of the defendants for the amounts calculated in accordance with the judgment. Council and Charles Norager were liable for the same damage in relation to the decks. Liability for this damage was apportioned 80 per cent to Charles Norager and 20 per cent to Council. Brookfield Multiplex’s claim for a declaration that it is entitled to be indemnified in respect of the judgment entered against it in this proceeding was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established