New Zealand Fire Service Commission v Legg

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2014-409-000681 [2016] NZHC 1492

BETWEEN

NEW ZEALAND FIRE SERVICE

COMMISSION Plaintiff

AND

SELWYN DISTRICT COUNCIL Second Plaintiff

AND

ROSS JOHN LEGG AND ANNETTE JILL LEGG

First Defendants

AND

EVOLVING LANDSCAPES LIMITED Second Defendant

AND

AMI INSURANCE LIMITED First Third Party

AND

LUMLEY GENERAL INSURANCE (NZ) LIMITED

Second Third Party

Hearing: 7 December 2015

Appearances:

G K Rippingale & R M Dixon for the Plaintiffs
A Riches & J Taylor for the First & Second Defendants
I Thain & V Cress for the First Third Party
J Parker & J Herd for the Second Third Party

Judgment:

1 July 2016

JUDGMENT OF NATION J

Introduction

[1]      On  10  January 2013,  there  was  a  serious  fire  in  the  Selwyn  District  in

Canterbury.  The fire originated from a burn heap on a lifestyle property belonging to

Mr and Mrs Legg (the Leggs).  It spread to neighbouring properties where it caused

NEW ZEALAND FIRE SERVICE COMMISSION v LEGG [2016] NZHC 1492 [1 July 2016]

significant property damage.  The claim I deal with is to recover the costs of fighting the fire.  My judgment will, however, have implications for other claims which are the subject of different proceedings.

[2]      The claim for the costs of fighting the fire is made by the New Zealand Fire Service Commission and the Selwyn District Council under the Forest and Rural Fires Act 1977.  After all evidence had been taken, their claims were admitted by both the Leggs and Evolving Landscapes Limited (Evolving Landscapes), the landscaping business run by the first defendants.

[3]      The  Leggs’  property  was  insured  with  AMI  Insurance  Limited  (AMI). Evolving Landscapes was insured with Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Limited (Lumley).

[4]      The fire heap on the Leggs’ property had been used to burn vegetation and other material from their lifestyle block but also vegetation, including some tree stumps from the Evolving Landscapes business.   The major issue before me is whether or not, in terms of their particular policies, AMI and Lumley have any obligation to indemnify the Leggs and Evolving Landscapes on the claims that have been made against them.

How the fire started

[5]      On a lifestyle block in the country, it is common to dispose of green waste or other rubbish using a fire.   The Leggs had a burn heap on their property for that purpose.  It was about 1.5 kilometres from their home at the north-western end of their property.   On the burn heap was some paper and other rubbish from their household including paper from the office and their home.  That office was also the office for Evolving  Landscapes.   There was  also vegetation  from  their lifestyle block.  This included the stumps of some olive trees that had been on the property. They also had a large planted area around their home which would have generated significant waste.  The majority of the material was green waste or slash from the

Evolving Landscapes…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read New Zealand Fire Service Commission v Legg and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 1492
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of New Zealand Fire Service Commission v Legg involved a fire that occurred in the Selwyn District, Canterbury, on 10 January 2013. The fire originated from a burn heap on the Leggs' property, which spread to neighbouring properties causing significant damage. The New Zealand Fire Service Commission and the Selwyn District Council brought a claim for the costs of fighting the fire under the Forest and Rural Fires Act 1977. The Leggs and Evolving Landscapes, the landscaping business run by the first defendants, admitted liability for the costs of the fire. The major issue before the court was whether AMI and Lumley, the insurers of the Leggs and Evolving Landscapes respectively, had any obligation to indemnify the Leggs and Evolving Landscapes for the claims made against them.

The court found that AMI and Lumley were not liable to indemnify the Leggs and Evolving Landscapes. The Leggs were not in breach of the reasonable precautions clause in their policy with Lumley. The court also held that AMI's exclusion clause did not apply to exclude their liability to indemnify the Leggs. The exclusion clause required AMI to prove that the events and circumstances of 10 January 2013 were connected with Evolving Landscapes' business in a way that was causative of the Leggs' liability. AMI had not discharged this onus. The court further held that the exclusion clause was not effective to exclude AMI's liability to indemnify the Leggs even if it had been established that the connection with Evolving Landscapes' business had increased the risk of loss. The Leggs were entitled to indemnity under s 11 of the Insurance Law Reform Act 1977.

The court granted judgment to the plaintiffs in the sum of $217,118.30, together with interest under the Judicature Act 1908 from 8 April 2013. The Leggs were entitled to judgment against AMI for all sums for which the plaintiffs had obtained judgment against the Leggs. Evolving Landscapes was entitled to judgment against Lumley for all sums for which the plaintiffs had obtained judgment against Evolving Landscapes. The court also ordered that memoranda as to costs be filed within specified time periods.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established