Lumley General Insurance (NZ) v Evolving Landscapes Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2019-409-000380

[2020] NZHC 737

BETWEEN LUMLEY GENERAL INSURANCE (N.Z.) LIMITED
Applicant

AND

EVOLVING LANDSCAPES LIMITED

First Respondent

AND

NEW ZEALAND FIRE SERVICE COMMISSION AND SELWYN DISTRICT COUNCIL

Second Respondents

AND

JOHN ERNEST CHAMBERLAIN AND KATHERINE BERNADETTE CHAMBERLAIN

Third Respondents

AND

SELWYN QUARRIES LIMITED

Fourth Respondent

AND

ROSS ALLEN CAMMELL AND MARY-ANN CAMMELL

Fifth Respondents

AND

ROBERT BRIAN WYNN-WILLIAMS, MARGARET-ELIZABETH

WYNN-WILLIAMS AND JOHN LINDSAY JOSEPH
Sixth Respondents

AND

LOUJOHN HOLDINGS LIMITED

Seventh Respondent

AND

TIMOTHY JAMES MALLETT AND HEIDI JANE BRACE

Eighth Respondents

AND

JONET CARR WARD

Ninth Respondent

LUMLEY GENERAL INSURANCE (N.Z.) LIMITED v EVOLVING LANDSCAPES LIMITED [2020] NZHC 737 [9 April 2020]

AND

RICHARD PETER DUNCAN AND

WENDY ANN RUSCOE
Tenth Respondents

AND

STEPHEN JAMES OVERTON AND LINDA KAY OVERTON

Eleventh Respondents

AND

MERVYN WILLIAM ALLAN WHITE

Twelfth Respondent

AND

JUDITH ANN SMITH

Thirteenth Respondent

AND

BRIAN DAVID COURT AND LESLIE STEPHANIE COURT

Fourteenth Respondents

AND

NEVELE R STUD LIMITED

Fifteenth Respondent

AND

CLIVE WILLIAM HARTLEY AND DEANNE MAY HARTLEY

Sixteenth Respondents

AND

KOTUKUNUI PROPERTIES (NO 2)

LIMITED AND AMBROSIA NURSERIES LIMITED
Seventeenth Respondents

AND

ALLAN PETER MARSHALL AND JUDITH ANN MARSHALL

Eighteenth Respondents

AND

ELIZABETH RUTH MITCHELL

Nineteenth Respondent

Counsel:

J N Bierre and L G Cox for the Applicant

J A Knight and G K Rippingale for the Second Respondents
V S Wethey and A R Cornwell for the Eighteenth Respondents

Judgment:

9 April 2020

(Determined on the papers)


JUDGMENT OF OSBORNE J


Introduction

[1]    Evolving Landscapes Ltd (Evolving) took out a policy with Lumley General Insurance (N.Z.) Ltd (Lumley). The policy covered liability under the Forest and Rural Fires Act 1977.

[2]    Evolving was responsible in 2013 for a fire which caused damage to other properties and involved the New Zealand Fire Service and Selwyn District Court (collectively here “the Fire Service”) in fighting the fire. One of the properties damaged by the fire was the farm of the 18th respondents (the Marshalls).

[3]The Fire Service obtained a judgment against Evolving for $217,118.30.1

[4]    Subsequently Evolving obtained an order that Lumley indemnify it in the sum of $51,107.70 for costs and disbursements incurred by Evolving in defending the Fire Service’s claim (the $51,107.70 costs).2

[5]    Under s 9(1) Law Reform Act 1936, Evolving’s liability to the Fire Service and other persons (including the Marshalls) is the subject of a charge on the insurance monies payable by Lumley (the insurance sum). The policy had a limit of $1 million in respect of its General and Products Liability cover. The policy also contained a sub-limit provision, imposing a sub-limit of $250,000 in relation to liability under the Forest and Rural Fires Act.

[6]    The Marshalls were entitled to recover against Evolving the indemnity value of what they lost. This required the application of a depreciation rate. Lumley and the Marshalls contend for different depreciation rates (65 per cent and 50 per cent respectively).

[7]Four issues arise for determination:

(a)As between Evolving…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lumley General Insurance (NZ) v Evolving Landscapes Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 737
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Evolving Landscapes Limited (Evolving) insured its liability under the Forest and Rural Fires Act 1977 with Lumley General Insurance (N.Z.) Limited (Lumley). In 2013, a fire for which Evolving was responsible caused damage to other properties. One of the properties damaged was the farm of the Marshalls. The New Zealand Fire Service and Selwyn District Council (the Fire Service) obtained a judgment against Evolving for $217,118.30. Lumley was ordered to indemnify Evolving for $51,107.70 in costs and disbursements incurred by Evolving in defending the Fire Service’s claim. Under section 9(1) of the Law Reform Act 1936, Evolving’s liability to the Fire Service and others is the subject of a charge on the insurance monies payable by Lumley. The policy had a limit of $1 million in respect of its General and Products Liability cover and a sub-limit of $250,000 in relation to liability under the Forest and Rural Fires Act. The court had to determine four issues: (a) as between Evolving and Lumley, whether the $51,107.70 costs should be included in the calculation of payments to be made by Lumley from the insurance sum, whether interest on the $217,118.30 judgment should be added to Evolving’s claim on the insurance sum, and whether the $250,000 policy sub-limit applies; and (b) as between the Marshalls and Lumley, whether the depreciation rate to be applied to the Marshalls’ property should be 65 per cent or 50 per cent. The court held that the $51,107.70 costs are not to be included in the value of the Fire Service’s quantum to be taken into account in the apportioning of the insurance sum. Interest is to be included in the Fire Service’s claim. The $250,000 sub-limit applies to the Fire Service’s claim. The appropriate figure to be utilised by Lumley in respect of the Marshalls’ claim is $908,581.29. In respect of the Fire Service’s claim, the court orders that the costs and disbursements are not to be included in its claim, interest is to be included in its claim, and the $250,000 sub-limit applies. In respect of the Marshalls’ claim, the court orders that the claim is to be based on the assessment as at the date of loss, being $908,581.29. The court reserves any order as to costs and disbursements, and any party wishing to make an application for costs is to do so by memorandum (four page limit) filed and served by 15 May 2020, with any party opposing the application to file and serve their memorandum (four page limit) within five working days thereafter. In the absence of any such application, the order of the Court will be (without further minute) that there is no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established