New Zealand Fire Service Commission v Legg

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2014-409-000681 [2017] NZHC 29

BETWEEN

NEW ZEALAND FIRE SERVICE

COMMISSION Plaintiff

AND

SELWYN DISTRICT COUNCIL Second Plaintiff

AND

ROSS JOHN LEGG AND ANNETTE JILL LEGG

First Defendants

AND

EVOLVING LANDSCAPES LIMITED Second Defendant

AND

AMI INSURANCE LIMITED First Third Party

AND

LUMLEY GENERAL INSURANCE (NZ) LIMITED

Second Third Party

Hearing: On the papers

Counsel:

G K Rippingale & R M Dixon for the Plaintiffs
A Riches & J Taylor for the First & Second Defendants
I Thain & V Cress for the First Third Party
J Parker & J Herd for the Second Third Party

Judgment:

20 January 2017

JUDGMENT OF NATION J

[1]      In  a  judgment  of  1  July  2016,  the  first  and  second  plaintiffs  obtained judgment against the first and second defendants for costs which the plaintiffs had incurred fighting a fire originating from the first defendants’ property on 10 January

2013.  I held that the first defendants (the Leggs) were entitled to indemnity from the

NZ FIRE SERVICE COMMISSION v LEGG & EVOLVING LANDSCAPES [2017] NZHC 29 [20 January

2017]

first third party (AMI).  The second defendant, Evolving Landscapes Limited (ELL) was entitled to indemnity from the second third party (Lumley).   AMI have subsequently appealed that judgment to the Court of Appeal.

[2]      In my judgment, I gave the parties leave to file memoranda as to costs if there was any dispute over those.   Memoranda were subsequently filed on behalf of all parties.

The plaintiffs’ position

[3]      The first  and  second  plaintiffs  seek  indemnity  or increased  costs  on  the grounds that the defendants’ failure to admit substantiated claims against them until just prior to (the Leggs) or at trial (ELL), was improper conduct under r 14.6(4)(a) of the High Court Rules.   The plaintiffs characterise the defendants’ liability as “objectively obvious from the start”.

[4]      The   amount   sought   is   $141,204   for   legal   fees   and   $13,511.61   for disbursements.   By comparison, the quantum of 2B scale costs is $47,724.   The plaintiffs also seek 2B scale costs in respect of the two costs memoranda filed on this application.

The defendants’ position

[5]      The Leggs and ELL were both represented in the proceedings by Saunders & Co.  They do not oppose an award of costs against them on a 2B basis but oppose an order for increased or indemnity costs as sought by the plaintiffs.

[6]      ELL seeks indemnity or increased costs against Lumley on the basis their defence to the third party claim lacked merit in that it was based primarily on an alleged failure of ELL to take reasonable precautions to avoid the fire which had occurred, a defence which had a high threshold and which could not reasonably be made out on the evidence.

[7]      The Leggs submitted that costs on the third party claim should be payable by

AMI on a 2B basis.

[8]      Both the Leggs and ELL seek an order that any costs which they should have to pay to the plaintiffs for the period after 10…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read New Zealand Fire Service Commission v Legg and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court was a dispute over the costs incurred by the New Zealand Fire Service Commission (the plaintiffs) in fighting a fire that originated from the property of the first and second defendants, Ross John Legg and Annette Jill Legg, and Evolving Landscapes Limited (ELL). The Leggs were insured by AMI Insurance Limited, while ELL was insured by Lumley General Insurance (NZ) Limited. The plaintiffs sought indemnity or increased costs against the defendants for their failure to admit liability until late in the proceedings. The defendants, in turn, sought indemnity or increased costs against their respective insurers for the costs they were required to pay to the plaintiffs. The court found that the defendants were not entitled to indemnity or increased costs as they had not acted vexatiously, frivolously, improperly, or unnecessarily. The Leggs and ELL were, however, entitled to costs from their respective insurers on a 2B basis for the third party claims against them. The insurers, AMI and Lumley, were to jointly and severally indemnify the defendants for the costs they were liable to pay to the plaintiffs after 10 March 2015.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established