JCS Cost Management Ltd v QBE Insurance (International) Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA698/2014
[2015] NZCA 524

BETWEEN

JCS COST MANAGEMENT LTD
First Appellant

STEPHEN ROY JOHNSTON
Second Appellant

AND

QBE INSURANCE (INTERNATIONAL) LTD
Respondent

Hearing:

11 August 2015

Court:

Miller, Courtney and Clifford JJ

Counsel:

I J Thain for Appellants
PJ Napier for Respondent

Judgment:

25 November 2015 at 3.00 pm

Recalled and

Reissued:

9 December 2015

Effective date

of Judgment:

25 November 2015

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BThe respondent will have costs in this Court for a standard appeal on a band A basis with usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

Miller J (dissenting)      [1]
Courtney and Clifford JJ  [41]

Addendum (Miller J, for the Court)  [66]

MILLER J (dissenting)

Table of Contents

Summary judgment principles  [6]
The policy language  [8]
The Council’s claim against the insureds  [13]
The insureds’ claim against QBE  [19]
The decision below  [22]
Has QBE shown that the insureds’ claim cannot succeed?  [23]
Result  [39]

  1. QBE Insurance (International) Ltd insured JCS Cost Management Ltd and its director, Stephen Johnston, for, among other things, the legal costs of defending a claim brought in connection with their professional business as quantity surveyors and project managers. 

  2. In March 2009 Mr Johnston attended an open home at 18 O’Neills Avenue, Takapuna, with an existing client, Linda Johnson.  He says that he did so in the expectation that JCS might project-manage any upgrade to the house should Mrs Johnson and her husband buy it.  He had done similar work for them in the past.  The Johnsons did buy the property through their family trust, and in due course JCS did manage renovations on the house.

  3. However, the home proved to be a leaky building.  The Johnsons sued the Auckland Council, which joined Mr Johnston, pleading that the Johnsons bought the house in reliance upon his advice that it appeared to be watertight.  The claim failed at trial, Woodhouse J finding that Mr Johnston did not give any such advice.[1]  His legal costs, net of recovery from the Council in the High Court and the policy excess, were $52,950.50.[2] 

    [1]Johnson v Auckland Council [2013] NZHC 165. The Johnsons’ appeal to this Court was allowed in part, in relation to a quantum issue: Johnson v Auckland Council [2013] NZCA 662.

    [2]Mr Johnston successfully recovered costs from the Council:  Johnson v Auckland Council [2013] NZHC 1148.

  4. Mr Johnston claimed the defence costs from QBE, which declined cover, alleging that the costs were incurred in connection not with his quantity surveying and project management business but rather with a claim that Mr Johnston had given pre-purchase advice as a building appraiser. 

  5. JCS and Mr Johnston brought a claim for damages in the High Court.  QBE sought summary judgment and won.[3]  JCS and Mr Johnston now appeal.  The issue is whether it is arguable that the claim alleged civil liability “by any act, error, omission or conduct” that occurred in connection with quantity surveying or project management.

Summary judgment principles

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JCS Cost Management Ltd v QBE Insurance (International) Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZCA 524
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

JCS Cost Management Ltd and its director, Stephen Johnston, appeal against the decision of the Associate Judge of the High Court who dismissed their claim for indemnity of costs and expenses under an insurance policy taken out with QBE Insurance (International) Ltd. The Associate Judge granted QBE summary judgment on the basis that the claim alleged civil liability by any act, error, omission or conduct that occurred not in connection with JCS's professional business practice as a quantity surveyor and project manager. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, holding that the Associate Judge was right to grant QBE's application for summary judgment. The appeal was dismissed with QBE to have costs in this Court on a band A basis with usual disbursements.

The appeal raises two issues. The first is whether the court should accept QBE's argument that the policy only covers claims for civil liability that arise from conduct in connection with JCS's business as a quantity surveyor and project manager. The second is whether the court should accept QBE's argument that the Council's claim against Mr Johnston was a claim for pre-purchase advice given as a building appraiser and not as a quantity surveyor and project manager.

The Court of Appeal considered that the appeal was suitable for summary judgment. It held that the Associate Judge was correct to grant QBE summary judgment. The Court held that the policy only covers claims for civil liability that arise from conduct in connection with JCS's business as a quantity surveyor and project manager. It held that the Council's claim against Mr Johnston was a claim for pre-purchase advice given as a building appraiser and not as a quantity surveyor and project manager. The Court held that the claim was not a Valid Claim under the policy because there was no causal connection between Mr Johnston's notional liability and the conduct alleged by the Council. It followed that the Council's claim against Mr Johnston was not and never could have been a Valid Claim under the policy.

The Court of Appeal declined to interfere with the award of costs made in the High Court. It held that the issues were not without difficulty and were of some wider significance. The proceeding was properly heard in the High Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established