To'o v Wellington City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2024-485-142

[2025] NZHC 216

UNDER the Contract and Commercial Law Act 2017

IN THE MATTER

of claims in negligence and for relief under the Contract and Commercial Law Act 2017

BETWEEN

JULIUS MAXWELL TO’O and JOANNA TO’O

Plaintiffs

AND

WELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL

First Defendant

BRUCE ALEXANDER WELSH

Second Defendant

CLARE MARIE BUTLER and MARIE CLARE TRUSTEE LIMITED

Third Defendants

Hearing: 4 November 2024

Appearances:

D Parker and E McLean for Plaintiffs M Freeman for Third Defendants

Judgment:

20 February 2025


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SKELTON


[1]    The third defendants in these proceedings, Ms Clare Butler and Marie Clare Trustee Ltd, apply to strike out all causes of action against them and/or seek summary judgment against the plaintiffs. They argue that none of the plaintiffs’ causes of action against them can succeed because the plaintiffs could not have been assigned any

TO’O v WELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL [2025] NZHC 216 [20 February 2025]

claims against the third defendants. In any event, they submit that the claims are time-barred by the Limitation Act 2010.

Background

[2]    The plaintiffs, Mr Julius To’o and Mrs Joanna To’o, are the registered proprietors of a property located in Melrose (the property). The property was constructed between 2002 and 2004, with a Code Compliance Certificate (CCC) being issued on 8 September 2004. Around October 2004, Ms Butler purchased the property. She remained a registered owner of the property until May 2016, when she sold the property to Anastasia To’o (Ms To’o) for $675,000. Ms To’o then sold the property to the plaintiffs (her son being Julius To’o) in August 2017 for $675,000.

[3]    The property has weathertightness issues. Ms Butler noticed the water ingress issues from the time she moved into the property in 2004. She made a number of unsuccessful attempts to resolve the weathertightness issues, which eventually led her to pursuing a claim with the Weathertight Homes Resolution Service (WHRS) in 2011. As part of her claim, she commissioned a report from Ron Thurlow Building Consultant Ltd in 2011. The report identified widespread weathertightness defects and damage to the north, west and south elevations of the property. The final WHRS assessor’s report in March 2012 identified construction defects, water entry and damage and provided a schedule of remedial work, which included work to all elevations.

[4]    The claim was eventually settled for $60,000. The settlement agreement obliged Ms Butler to carry out all repairs necessary to remedy the defects to the building and/or ensure that the repairs were carried out. If she sold the property, she warranted to include a special condition in the agreement requiring the purchaser to acknowledge the claim and the settlement.

[5]    Ms Butler says that the consensus between the experts was that the problem was the north wall and in particular the north wall patio. Remedial work was undertaken in 2014 and a CCC was issued for that work on 9 June 2014.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read To'o v Wellington City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NZHC 216
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of To'o v Wellington City Council involves claims brought by Julius Maxwell To’o and Joanna To’o against the Wellington City Council and others. The plaintiffs seek damages for weathertightness issues with a property they purchased, alleging misrepresentation and mistake under the Contract and Commercial Law Act 2017 (CCLA). The third defendants, Ms Clare Butler and Marie Clare Trustee Ltd, sought to strike out or obtain summary judgment against the plaintiffs' claims. The court addressed two main issues: the validity of the assignment of Ms To’o’s claims to the plaintiffs and whether the plaintiffs' claims were time-barred under the Limitation Act 2010.

Regarding the validity of the assignment, the court considered whether the statutory causes of action for misrepresentation and mistake under the CCLA are assignable. The court found that while traditionally, personal statutory causes of action are not assignable, the CCLA explicitly provides for the assignment of such causes of action, indicating that these claims are not strictly personal and therefore assignable. The court also found that the plaintiffs had a genuine commercial interest in enforcing the assigned claims, as they had a commercial relationship with Ms To’o and were influenced by the same alleged misstatements. Consequently, the court held that the plaintiffs had a tenable argument that the statutory causes of action were assignable and that the plaintiffs had a genuine commercial interest in the claims.

On the issue of limitation, the court examined whether the plaintiffs' claims were time-barred under the Limitation Act 2010. The court found that the plaintiffs had a tenable argument that they gained knowledge of the relevant facts, including the alleged misrepresentations and the consequential damage, around July 2022, when they first observed leaks and water ingress. The plaintiffs filed their claims within three years of this date, and the court held that it was not beyond argument that the claims were time-barred.

As a result, the court dismissed the third defendants' application for strike out and/or summary judgment against the plaintiffs. The court also indicated that the plaintiffs were likely entitled to costs on a 2B basis and reasonable disbursements. The matter was to be listed for a case management conference to address outstanding matters.