Swindle v Withers

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-001237 [2014] NZHC 578

BETWEEN  BURVIE EDWARD SWINDLE, CAROLIE ANN TERPENING SWINDLE as trustees of the SWINDLE FAMILY TRUST

First Plaintiffs

AORANGI FORESTS LIMITED Second Plaintiff

ANDM D WITHERS Defendant

ZURICH AUSTRALIAN INSURANCE LIMITED trading as ZURICH NEW ZEALAND

Third Party

Hearing:                   25 February 2014

Appearances:           P Robertson and A Ayton for Plaintiffs

S Maloney for Defendant
I J Law for Third Party

Judgment:                26 March 2014

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE J P DOOGUE

This judgment was delivered by me on

26.03.14 at 4 pm, pursuant to

Rule 11.5  of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

SWINDLE & Ors v WITHERS & ANOR [2014] NZHC 578 [26 March 2014]

Background

[1]      The third party (“Zurich”) has applied to strike out the third to tenth causes of action of the plaintiffs’ third amended statement of claim.  The third party is the insurer of the defendant.

[2]      For a number of years the first plaintiffs (“the Swindles”) advanced funds to a wine producer called Goldridge Estate which carried on business in the Matakana area.  The advances were in the form of term loans for periods of two years.  The purpose of the loans was to provide funding for the processing of grape juice and the manufacture of wine.

[3]      The arrangements seems to have worked well for a number of years and in

2008 and 2009 the parties decided to repeat the funding operation.  I understand that the nature of the funding took the form of the Swindles advancing money which would be repaid and then be lent again.

[4]      In 2008 and 2009 the parties agreed terms for the provision of finance.  The amount of $1,500,000  was to be made available for each of those  years.   The structure of the loans for those two years took a familiar form which I shall now describe, first in relation to 2008 and then 2009.

[5]      The 2008 arrangements were first contained in Investor Facility Agreements between the Swindles and an intermediary company, the third plaintiff (“Orakei”), which  was  later  struck  off.    It  will  shortly  be  reinstated.    The  third  amended statement of claim filed on 19 February 2014 anticipates the last step being taken. However, no significance attaches to that aspect of the matter.

[6]      The structure of the loans involved the third plaintiff entering into “Investor Facility Agreements” in respect of the advances which were to be made to two separate companies, Vintage 2008 (A) Limited and Vintage 2008 (B) Ltd, which I shall collectively refer to as the 2008 Vintage Companies.  As the statement of claim recites:

Each company was dedicated to the production of varieties of wine discreet from the other.

Orakei in turn entered into borrower facility agreements which were the borrowing side of the structure with the 2008 Vintage Companies.  Orakei used funds provided by the first plaintiffs to advance to the 2008 Vintage Companies.

[7]      The two agreements were respectively entered into 7 April 2008 and 8…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Swindle v Withers and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 578
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved an application by Zurich Australian Insurance Limited (trading as Zurich New Zealand) to strike out certain causes of action in the third amended statement of claim filed by the plaintiffs in the High Court of New Zealand. The plaintiffs, Burvie Edward Swindle and Carolie Ann Terpening Swindle, trustees of the Swindle Family Trust, sought damages for losses they suffered due to the alleged negligent misstatements and breaches of the Fair Trading Act 1986 by the defendant, Mr. Mark Withers, a chartered accountant. The plaintiffs had previously advanced funds to Goldridge Estate, a wine producer, through intermediary companies Vintage 2008 (A) Limited, Vintage 2008 (B) Limited, Vintage 2009 (A) Limited, and Vintage 2009 (B) Limited. The intermediary companies, Vintage 2008 (A) Limited and Vintage 2008 (B) Limited, were placed in liquidation on 10 August 2011, and Goldridge Estate was placed in liquidation on 21 November 2011. The court dismissed the application to strike out the third cause of action, which was the Swindles' claim under the Fair Trading Act 1986. The court found that the claim was pleaded in the alternative and that the parties' awareness of the loss was a disputed fact, which was not appropriate to resolve on a strike out application. However, the court struck out the fourth and fifth causes of action, which were the Swindles' and Orakei's claims as assignees of the cause of action under the Fair Trading Act 1986. The court found that a cause of action under the Fair Trading Act 1986 was not assignable, and the claims were therefore not reasonably arguable. The court dismissed the application to strike out the sixth, seventh, and eighth causes of action, which were the claims in negligent misstatement by the Swindles, Aorangi, and Orakei, respectively. The court found that while there could be some improvement in the particularisation of the pleading of the causes of action, the radical step of striking them out at this stage would not be justified. The court declined to strike out the ninth cause of action, which was the Swindles' claim as assignees of Orakei's cause of action in negligent misstatement. The court found that the issues raised by the application were not straightforward and could not be satisfactorily resolved in the context of a strike out application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.