Body Corporate 346799 v KNZ International Co Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-6290 [2017] NZHC 511

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 346799

First Plaintiff

HA THI HOANG & ORS Second Plaintiffs

AND

KNZ INTERNATIONAL CO LIMITED First Defendant

BROOKFIELD MULTIPLEX CONSTRUCTIONS (NZ) LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)

Second Defendant

… continued

Hearing:

Further submissions:

12-14, 17-21 and 25 October 2016, 5 and 14 December 2016

1, 15, 19 and 21 December 2016

Counsel:

G B Lewis and L M Deane for Plaintiffs
D T Broadmore for Second Defendant
S A Thodey and L J Douglas for Fifth Defendant

Interim Judgment:

7 March 2017

Final Judgment:

22 March 2017

JUDGMENT OF THOMAS J

This judgment was delivered by me on 22 March 2017 at 3.00 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date:………………………….

BODY CORPORATE 346799 v KNZ INTERNATIONAL CO LIMITED [2017] NZHC 511 [7 March 2017]

FAÇADE DESIGN SERVICES LIMITED Third Defendant

PBS CONTRACTING LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)

Fourth Defendant (Discontinued)

AUCKLAND CITY COUNCIL Fifth Defendant

BOSTIK NEW ZEALAND LIMITED Sixth Defendant (Discontinued)

STEPHEN MITCHELL ENGINEERS LIMITED

First Third Party (Discontinued)

STEPHEN MITCHELL
Second Third Party (Discontinued)

CITY DESIGN LIMITED
Third Third Party (Discontinued)

DAVID LEE
Fourth Third Party (Discontinued)

DAVID JAMES FORSTER
Fifth Third Party (Discontinued)

TRISTAN D’ARCY HARVEY-SMITH Sixth Third Party (Discontinued)

WILLIS NEW ZEALAND LIMITED Seventh Third Party (Discontinued)

RONALD CHARLES HANLEY Eighth Third Party

Introduction ............................................................................................................. [1] Background.............................................................................................................. [7] Plaintiffs .............................................................................................................. [19] Additional assignees............................................................................................ [21] First defendant .................................................................................................... [23] Second defendant................................................................................................ [25] Evidence ................................................................................................................. [30] DEFECTS .............................................................................................................. [32] Cracked cladding sheets on Eterpanel system ................................................... [32] Balcony waterproofing defects ............................................................................. [38] Construction ........................................................................................................ [38]

Failure of membrane ........................................................................................... [41] Cause of membrane failure ................................................................................. [43] Internal damage .................................................................................................. [44] Building Code breaches ...................................................................................... [45] Podium ................................................................................................................... [48] Fire defects ............................................................................................................. [51] CLAIM AGAINST KNZ INTERNATIONAL CO LTD.................................... [54] Nature of duty of care ........................................................................................... [54] Breach..................................................................................................................... [62] Cracking to Eterpanel cladding system .............................................................. [63] Balconies ............................................................................................................. [66] Podium ................................................................................................................ [70] Fire defects .......................................................................................................... [73] Affirmative defences ............................................................................................. [75] CLAIM AGAINST MULTIPLEX ....................................................................... [77] Nature of duty of care ........................................................................................... [77] Responsibilities ................................................................................................... [83] Breach..................................................................................................................... [91] Cracking to Eterpanel cladding system .............................................................. [91] Balconies ............................................................................................................. [93] Podium ................................................................................................................ [96] Fire defects .......................................................................................................... [98] QUANTUM.......................................................................................................... [100] Claim for remedial work costs ........................................................................... [100] Consequential losses............................................................................................ [102] General damages ................................................................................................. [104] Approach ........................................................................................................... [104] Quantum ............................................................................................................ [112] GST....................................................................................................................... [128] Unit owners ....................................................................................................... [129] Body Corporate ................................................................................................. [130] Interest ................................................................................................................. [133] Award to Body Corporate .................................................................................. [134] Award to unit owners .......................................................................................... [136] Settlement............................................................................................................. [137] Costs ..................................................................................................................... [139] Legal costs......................................................................................................... [139] Disbursements ................................................................................................... [144] CROSS CLAIMS ................................................................................................ [145] Issues .................................................................................................................... [145] Liability ................................................................................................................ [147] Apportionment .................................................................................................... [155] Law .................................................................................................................... [155] Weathertight Homes Tribunal ........................................................................... [162] Application ........................................................................................................ [165] Conclusion......................................................................................................... [168] Amount................................................................................................................. [169] Reasonableness of the Settlement...................................................................... [169] Effect of the Settlement ...................................................................................... [173] Law .................................................................................................................... [179]

Analysis ............................................................................................................. [185] Orders sought ...................................................................................................... [193] Costs ..................................................................................................................... [194]

Introduction

[1]      This  claim  concerns  building  defects  at  the  Victopia  Apartments  (the Building),…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 346799 v KNZ International Co Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 511
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Body Corporate 346799 and other plaintiffs brought a claim against KNZ International Co Ltd and Brookfield Multiplex Constructions (NZ) Limited in relation to defects at the Victopia Apartments. The plaintiffs claimed that KNZ and Multiplex were responsible for building defects which included cracking to the Eterpanel cladding system, balcony waterproofing defects, podium defects and fire defects. The plaintiffs sought damages for the cost of repairing the defects and consequential losses. The plaintiffs also claimed general damages for stress and anxiety caused by the defects. The plaintiffs further claimed interest on expenditure to date and costs.

The court found that KNZ and Multiplex were both liable for the defects. KNZ, as the developer, had a non-delegable duty of care to ensure the building was constructed in accordance with the Building Code. KNZ failed to ensure the Eterpanel cladding system would comply with the Code, failed to ensure the balcony waterproofing products were in accordance with the building consent, and failed to ensure the podium waterproofing was installed properly. Multiplex, as the head contractor, had a non-delegable duty of care and was also liable for the defects. Multiplex failed to properly review the Eterpanel cladding system design, failed to ensure the balcony waterproofing products were in accordance with the building consent, failed to properly install the podium waterproofing, and failed to properly undertake the fire stopping works.

The court awarded the plaintiffs $54,393,481 in damages for the cost of repairing the defects and consequential losses. The court also awarded general damages of $3,320,000 for stress and anxiety caused by the defects. The court awarded interest on expenditure of $106,189 and costs of $283,096.

The Auckland City Council cross-claimed against KNZ and Multiplex for contribution from them to the settlement it had made with the plaintiffs. The court found KNZ and Multiplex liable for 85% of the Council's liability and awarded the Council 85% of the settlement amount together with interest.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established