O'Hagan v Body Corporate 189855

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA506/2008
[2010] NZCA 65

BETWEENPATRICK JAMES O'HAGAN
Appellant

ANDBODY CORPORATE 189855
First Respondent

ANDPAULINE LOUISE HOUGH & ORS
Second Respondents

ANDNORTH SHORE CITY COUNCIL
Third Respondent

ANDSTEPHEN FRANCIS SMYTHE
Fourth Respondent

ANDCENTRE OF ATTRACTION LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)
Fifth Respondent

ANDJOSEPH WALDEN & STACK NZ LTD
Sixth Respondent

ANDSTACK NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Seventh Respondent

ANDANDREW PLASTERING CO (1994) LTD
Eighth Respondents

CA507/2008

AND BETWEEN             NORTH SHORE CITY COUNCIL
Appellant

ANDBODY CORPORATE 189855
First Respondent

ANDPAULINE LOUISE HOUGH & ORS
Second Respondents

ANDPATRICK JAMES O'HAGAN
Third Respondent

ANDSTEPHEN FRANCIS SMYTHE
Fourth Respondent

ANDCENTRE OF ATTRACTION LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)
Fifth Respondent

ANDJOSEPH WALDEN & STACK NZ LIMITED
Sixth Respondent

ANDSTACK NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Seventh Respondent

ANDANDREW PLASTERING CO (1994) LIMITED
Eighth Respondent

Hearing:7-11 September 2009

Court:William Young  P, Arnold and Baragwanath JJ

Counsel:M E Casey QC for Appellant in CA506/2008
G B Lewis and M C Josephson for First Respondent in CA506/2008
D J Goddard QC, S A Thodey and S B Mitchell for Third Respondent in CA506/2008
M A Gilbert SC for Fourth Respondent in CA506/2008
H M Macfarlane for Sixth Respondent in CA506/2008
G Andrew for Seventh Respondent in CA506/2008
D J Goddard QC, S A Thodey and S B Mitchell for Appellant in CA507/2008
G B Lewis and M C Josephson for First Respondent in CA507/2008
M A Gilbert SC for Fourth Respondent in CA507/2008
H M Macfarlane for Sixth Respondent in CA507/2008
G Andrew for Eighth Respondent in CA507/2008

Judgment:22 March 2010 at 10am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

This judgment may be cited as Byron Avenue [2010] NZCA 65.

CA506/2008

The judgments against Mr O’Hagan are set aside and the appeal by him and cross-appeal against him are dismissed by consent.

CA507/2008

AThe Council’s appeal is dismissed.

BThe cross-appeals by the second respondents against the trial Judge’s finding of contributory negligence are dismissed.

CThe awards to the second respondents of general damages are varied as set out in the reasons for judgment at [127] – [129].

DLeave to apply to this Court for further directions or clarifications is reserved in terms of [130] of the reasons for judgment.

ECosts are reserved.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

Baragwanath J  [1]
William Young P  [131]
Arnold J  [183]

BARAGWANATH J

Table of Contents

Para No

CONTEXT OF APPEAL   [4]
FACTUAL SETTING   [7]
THE INDIVIDUAL CLAIMS  [13]
MR AND MRS MCCONVILLE UNIT 11  [14]
MR BLACKMORE AND MS SHEEHY – UNITS 13 AND 14  [16]
MR JUPP – UNIT 4  [17]
GYDICK INVESTMENTS LTD – UNIT 9  [18]

Mr Kennett and Ms Blakie – unit 3  [20]
Ms Hough – unit 1  [23]
Mr Wilson and Ms Stewart – unit 7  [26]
RCA Investments – unit 5  [36]

SUE BRADLEY PROPERTIES LTD – UNIT 12  [40]
MS CLARK AND THE TRUSTEES OF THE CLARK FAMILY TRUST – UNIT 8  [44]

Ms Kim – unit 10  [53]

Discussion  

(f) May a council which has not issued a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Hagan v Body Corporate 189855 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZCA 65
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal of New Zealand delivered a judgment on two appeals, CA506/2008 and CA507/2008, concerning leaky apartments in the Byron development at 45 Byron Avenue Takapuna. The principal appeal, CA507/2008 by the North Shore City Council, challenged a judgment against it in favour of the Body Corporate and the purchasers of the apartments. The Court rejected the Council's primary argument that it could not be held liable for careless inspection prior to the issue of a code compliance certificate. The Court held that the Council owed a duty of care to the purchasers to ensure that the inspections were performed properly, even before the code compliance certificate stage. The Court also addressed the issue of contributory negligence when there was fault on the part of the purchasers. It found that failure to seek a land information memorandum (LIM) or make other enquiries of the Council went to contributory negligence rather than barring the claim. The Court further examined the effect of transactions between related parties and concluded that such transactions should not be ignored in assessing contributory negligence. The Court upheld the judgment against the Council, with a 25% reduction for contributory negligence in certain cases.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.