Sherwin Chan & Walshe Ltd (in Liq) v Jones

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA505/2011
[2012] NZCA 474

BETWEEN  SHERWIN CHAN & WALSHE LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)
First Appellant

AND  WHK (NZ) LIMITED
Second Appellant

AND  SIR ROBERT JONES AND YORGEN HOLDINGS LIMITED
Respondents

Hearing:         31 July and 1 August 2012

Court:             Ellen France, Harrison and White JJ

Counsel:         L J Taylor, O M Meech and J M Peterson for Appellants
M P Reed QC and M G Colson for Respondents

Judgment:      15 October 2012at 10 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellants must pay the respondents costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.  We certify for two counsel.

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Harrison J)

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction  [1]
Background  [5]
Issues  [31]
      Causation  [31]

(a)  SCWL’s case  [31]

(b)  Legal principles  [35]

(c)  Factual inquiry  [42]

(d)  Voluntary disclosure  [47]

(e)  Taxation liability  [65]

Costs  [71]

(a)  SCWL’s case  [71]

(b)  Legal principles  [74]

(c)  Factual analysis  [77]

Benefits  [82]

(a)  SCWL’s case  [82]

(b)  High Court  [87]

(c)  Legal principles  [88]

(d)  No benefit  [95]

Result  [101]

Introduction

  1. This appeal, on largely uncontested facts, raises issues of causation and liability for damages for negligent provision of tax advice.

  2. Sir Robert Jones and Yorgen Holdings Ltd are the trustees of the Tirohanga Family Trust (the Trust), the beneficial owner of companies within what is known as the Robert Jones Group (the Group).  Sherwin Chan & Walshe Ltd (SCWL) acted on a retainer as accountant and tax adviser for both entities for some years.  The firm does not dispute that it performed its professional services negligently in: (a) failing continually to advise the Trust about the effect of a discrete taxation regime upon annual increases in intercompany debt; and (b) advising the Trust to enter into a corporate restructuring transaction designed to eliminate that debt.  In the result, the Trust incurred a substantial and unexpected tax liability.

  3. The Trust sued SCWL for breach of contract, effectively seeking an indemnity against its tax liability.  SCWL admitted its negligence but denied liability.  Following a trial in the High Court, Whata J found for the Trust.  He entered judgment for damages of $4.285 million[1] and separately for interest and costs of $899,635.[2] 

    [1]Jones v WHK Sherwin Chan & Walshe HC Wellington CIV-2009-485-1324, 25 July 2011; in this judgment all denominations are in New Zealand dollars unless otherwise stated.

    [2]      Jones v WHK Sherwin Chan & Walshe HC Wellington CIV-2009-485-1324, 31 October 2011            and 5 December 2011.

  4. SCWL accepts that before exercising rights of set-off it is liable for $3.454 million of the Trust’s losses being its liability to tax on the corporate restructuring transaction.  However, on appeal to this Court the firm challenges the damages judgment on these three separate grounds:

    (a)First, the Trust unnecessarily incurred an extra liability to tax on the annual increases in intercompany debt of $1.667 million,[3] being…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sherwin Chan & Walshe Ltd (in Liq) v Jones and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZCA 474
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal, on largely uncontested facts, raises issues of causation and liability for damages for negligent provision of tax advice. Sherwin Chan & Walshe Ltd (SCWL) acted on a retainer as accountant and tax adviser for the Tirohanga Family Trust (the Trust), the beneficial owner of companies within the Robert Jones Group (the Group). The firm does not dispute that it performed its professional services negligently in: (a) failing continually to advise the Trust about the effect of a discrete taxation regime upon annual increases in intercompany debt; and (b) advising the Trust to enter into a corporate restructuring transaction designed to eliminate that debt. In the result, the Trust incurred a substantial and unexpected tax liability. The Trust sued SCWL for breach of contract, effectively seeking an indemnity against its tax liability. SCWL admitted its negligence but denied liability. Following a trial in the High Court, Whata J found for the Trust. He entered judgment for damages of $4.285 million and separately for interest and costs of $899,635. SCWL accepts that before exercising rights of set-off it is liable for $3.454 million of the Trust’s losses being its liability to tax on the corporate restructuring transaction. However, on appeal to this Court the firm challenges the damages judgment on three separate grounds: (a) First, the Trust unnecessarily incurred an extra liability to tax on the annual increases in intercompany debt of $1.667 million, being the balance of the damages judgment above $3.454 million, as a result of reliance upon unreasonable, negligent or wrongful advice from its new tax adviser, Ernst & Young (EY) which is attributable to the Trust. Alternatively, EY’s unreasonableness or negligence severed the chain of causation between SCWL’s negligence and the Trust’s adjusted liability to tax. (b) Second, if SCWL had given timely advice to the Trust of its potential taxation liability, the Trust would necessarily have incurred costs of $1.286 million in eliminating its taxation exposure which must be offset against that liability. (c) Third, the Trust obtained a benefit from the restructuring transaction which completely offset its total tax liability of $4.285 million. This Court rejected all three grounds of appeal. The appeal is dismissed. SCWL must pay the Trust’s costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.