Zurich Australian Insurance Ltd v Withers

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA317/2015
[2016] NZCA 618

BETWEEN

ZURICH AUSTRALIAN INSURANCE LIMITED
Appellant

AND

MARK DONALD WITHERS
First Respondent

AND

BURVLE EDWARD SWINDLE AND CAROLIE ANN TERPENING SWINDLE AS TRUSTEES OF THE SWINDLE FAMILY TRUST
Second Respondents

AND

AORANGI FORESTS LIMITED
Third Respondent

AND

ORAKEI SECURITIES LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)
Fourth Respondent

Hearing:

13 and 14 July 2016

Court:

Randerson, Harrison and Kós JJ

Counsel:

A C Challis and H K Harkess for Appellant
J Long and SGT Ma Ching for First Respondent
D J Heaney QC and P A Robertson for Second, Third and Fourth Respondents

Judgment:

16 December 2016 at 3 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed and the judgment entered for the first respondent against the appellant is set aside.  Judgment is entered for the appellant against the first respondent.

B        The appeal by the first respondent is allowed to the extent that:

(a)The judgment sum of $1.31 million is set aside.  Judgment is entered for the second respondent against the first respondent for the sum of $1,155,697.

(b)       The first respondent is ordered to pay interest to the second respondents on the amended judgment sum in accordance with [42] of this judgment. 

CThe cross-appeal by the second respondents is dismissed.

DThe application by the first respondent for leave to adduce further evidence is declined.

E        The first respondent is ordered to pay the appellant costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis with usual disbursements. 

F        The second respondents are ordered to pay costs to the first respondent on the cross-appeal for a standard appeal on a band A basis (plus a 50 per cent uplift to reflect the first respondents limited success on the appeal against the damages award) with usual disbursements. 

GCosts in the High Court are to be fixed by that Court.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Harrison J)

Contents

Introduction  [2]
Background facts  [6]
Damages  [18]
Fresh evidence  [47]
Contribution to loss  [53]
Indemnity  [71]

Zurich’s defence  [71]
Legal principles  [78]
Analysis  [86]

(a)       Mr Withers’ conduct  [86]
(b)       Mr Withers’ subjective knowledge  [92]
(c)       Objective standards  [103]

Result  [112]
Postscript  [119]

Introduction

  1. Burvle and Carolie Swindle are American citizens who loaned $1.5 million to the Vintage group of companies (Vintage) in each of 2008 and 2009 to a total of $3 million.  The funds were advanced as annual working capital for Vintage’s wine growing and producing business but the group used them for other purposes.  Vintage repaid the Swindles $380,000 before defaulting and was later wound up.  The Swindles have not recovered anything further from the company or various guarantors.

  2. The Swindles claimed their net loss of $2.62 million was caused by Mark Withers, Vintage’s accountant.  Following a defended trial in the High Court, Peters J found that Mr Withers had breached his duties to the Swindles under the Fair Trading Act 1986 (FTA) by making false and misleading statements in undertakings to the Swindles’ agent upon which they relied…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zurich Australian Insurance Ltd v Withers and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZCA 618
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal of New Zealand heard an appeal from Mark Withers, Vintage's accountant, against a judgment for $1.31 million entered in favour of the Swindles, the original lenders. The Swindles also cross-appealed against the reduction of their damages claim for contributory negligence, while Withers sought leave to adduce fresh evidence. The central issue was whether Withers was entitled to indemnity from Zurich, his professional liability insurer. The Court found that Withers' conduct was dishonest, and thus Zurich was not liable to indemnify him. The Court reduced the damages to $1.155 million, acknowledging the Swindles' contributory negligence. Withers' application for leave to adduce fresh evidence was declined.

The Court began by outlining the background facts of the case, which involved loans made to Vintage, a wine growing and producing business, by the Swindles through intermediaries. Withers, as Vintage's accountant, provided misleading and deceptive undertakings to the Swindles, causing them to rely on these statements and advance funds to Vintage. The Court found Withers liable for breach of the Fair Trading Act and reduced his liability by 50% due to the Swindles' contributory negligence. Zurich, Withers' insurer, was found liable to indemnify him, but the Court of Appeal disagreed.

In determining the issue of indemnity, the Court held that evidence of professional standards is directly relevant to the objective element of the dishonesty inquiry. Withers' conduct, when considered alongside his recurring conduct since 2001, showed a fundamental and repetitive pattern of false statements. The Court found that an honest person in Withers' position would have ensured their statements were correct before making them, and relied on their clients to ensure that the appropriate arrangements were in place. Withers' conduct was found to be dishonest by the objective measure, amounting to sustained and conscious impropriety. Consequently, Withers was not entitled to indemnity from Zurich.

The Court then addressed the issue of damages, reducing the damages to $1.155 million, acknowledging the Swindles' contributory negligence. The Court of Appeal found that the Swindles' delay in appointing receivers was imprudent, and that they could have taken more steps to protect their loans by monitoring Vintage's financial situation. However, the ultimate cause of the Swindles' loss was Vintage's failure, and it was wrong to visit all the financial consequences on Withers.

Finally, the Court declined Withers' application for leave to adduce fresh evidence. The evidence was not found to be fresh, credible, and cogent, and the factual contest between both deponents could only have been resolved by cross-examination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.