Double J Smallwoods Limited v Gisborne District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND GISBORNE REGISTRY

CIV-2015-416-25 [2017] NZHC 1284

BETWEEN

DOUBLE J SMALLWOODS LIMITED

First Plaintiff

G & P ENTERPRISES LIMITED Second Plaintiff

JON KENNETH GARDNER AND MARGARET ANNE GARDNER Third Plaintiffs

AND

GISBORNE DISTRICT COUNCIL Defendant

Hearing: 3–7 April 2017

Counsel:

T J Rainey and N D Smith for Plaintiffs
F P Divich and A C Harpur for Defendant

Judgment:

13 June 2017

JUDGMENT OF THOMAS J

Table of contents

Introduction ............................................................................................................. [1] Issues ...................................................................................................................... [11] PART I - FACTUAL ASSESSMENT .................................................................. [12] Background............................................................................................................ [12] The background to the Fire ................................................................................. [16] The Fire .................................................................................................................. [26] Pampas and fire risk ........................................................................................... [40] Sawdust heap....................................................................................................... [51] Expert analysis of the Fire.................................................................................... [57] Point of origin of the Fire ................................................................................... [61] Spread of the Fire on the north bank of the Creek .............................................. [63] Cause of the Fire crossing to Lot 2 on the southern bank of the Creek .............. [65] Spreading to the Property ................................................................................... [71] Contribution of weather, wind and ground ......................................................... [77] Spread of fire in the Property .............................................................................. [78] Risk management .................................................................................................. [81]

DOUBLE J SMALLWOODS LIMITED v GISBORNE DISTRICT COUNCIL [2017] NZHC 1284 [13 June

2017]

Observations on the experts’ evidence ................................................................ [87] Factual findings ..................................................................................................... [94] PART II - LEGAL ANALYSIS AND LIABILITY FINDING ........................... [96] Strict liability - Rylands v Fletcher ..................................................................... [99] Nuisance ............................................................................................................ [103] Negligence......................................................................................................... [111] Contributory negligence.................................................................................... [129] PART III - DAMAGES ....................................................................................... [139] Non-contested sums............................................................................................. [140] Contested sums .................................................................................................... [142] Replacing air shed............................................................................................. [142] GST.................................................................................................................... [146] Business losses .................................................................................................. [147]

(i)    Business losses 2010 ................................................................................. [148] Lost Revenues .................................................................................................... [156] Lost Gross Margin............................................................................................. [161] Applicable ratio of Saved Costs ........................................................................ [163] Allowance for Increased Costs of Working ....................................................... [164] Allowance for any contribution arising from faulty plant................................. [165] Analysis ............................................................................................................. [167] (ii)   Business losses 2011–2014 ....................................................................... [170] Pan Pac ............................................................................................................. [173] Is it reasonable to assume that the Lost Revenues would have been

experienced over the four year period 2011–2014? ......................................... [177] Lost Gross Margin............................................................................................. [179] Saved Costs ....................................................................................................... [180] Should any allowance be made for Saved Labour when assessing loss? ......... [182] Faulty replacement plant .................................................................................. [183] Analysis ................................................................................................................ [184] General damages .............................................................................................. [197] Result .................................................................................................................... [200] Interest............................................................................................................... [201] Costs ..................................................................................................................... [202]

Introduction

[1]      The first plaintiff, Double J Smallwoods Limited (Smallwoods), carries on business as a sawmilling remanufacturing company on land it leases and on land owned by the second plaintiff, G & P Enterprises Limited (G & P), at 127 Awapuni Road, Gisborne (together referred to as the Property).  The third plaintiffs, Jon and Margaret Gardner, are directors and shareholders of Smallwoods and G & P.

[2]      The defendant, Gisborne District Council (the Council), owns two parcels of reserve land which are bisected by the Waikanae Creek (the Creek).  Lot 3 DP9506

(Lot 3) adjoins the northern bank of the Creek and Lot 2 DP9506 (Lot 2) is between the southern bank of the Creek and the north-western boundary of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Double J Smallwoods Limited v Gisborne District Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 1284
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Double J Smallwoods Limited and others (the plaintiffs) brought an action against Gisborne District Council (the Council). The plaintiffs claimed damages for loss and damage to their property and business arising out of a fire which spread from the Council's land to the plaintiffs' land. The plaintiffs brought their claim on the basis of negligence, nuisance and strict liability under Rylands v Fletcher. The Council denied liability. The issues in the case were whether the Council's use of its land created an unreasonable interference with the plaintiffs' land, whether the vegetation on the Council's land posed an unreasonable fire hazard, and whether the Council breached any duty to prevent or minimise the risk of fire damage to the plaintiffs' property. The High Court found in favour of the plaintiffs, holding that the Council was liable for negligence. The Court held that the Council breached its duty to remove the pampas grass on its land, which was a material cause of the fire and the loss suffered by the plaintiffs. The Court held that the Council's negligence was a cause of the loss at law and that the loss was not too remote. The Court found that the plaintiffs were contributorily negligent and reduced the damages payable to the plaintiffs by 50 per cent. The Court awarded damages of $875,254.68 to the plaintiffs, plus interest.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.