Body Corporate 325261 v McDonough

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2011-404-8000 [2014] NZHC 1821

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 325261

Plaintiff

R W COOKE AND OTHERS Second Plaintiffs

AND

JAMES MCDONOUGH First Defendant

Continued…

Hearing: 28 and 29 July 2014

Counsel

G J Kohler QC and C Baker for Plaintiffs
J R J Knight and D J Barr for Third Defendant
D S McGill for Fifth Defendant (attendance excused)
S Mills QC, B O'Callahan and A C Poole for Sixth and Seventh
Defendants

Judgment:

29 July 2014

ORAL JUDGMENT OF KATZ J

Solicitors:        Price Baker Berridge, Auckland

Simpson Grierson, Auckland

Carter Kirkland Morrison, Auckland

Duncan Cotterill, Auckland

Counsel:          G J Kohler QC, Shortland Chambers, Auckland

S Mills QC, Shortland Chambers, Auckland

Copy to:           James McDonough

BODY CORPORATE 325261 v MCDONOUGH & ORS  [2014] NZHC 1821 [29 July 2014]

MAUNGA REI NZ LIMITED

Second Defendant AUCKLAND COUNCIL Third Defendant

GARY BICKERTON Fourth Defendant RACHEL VENABLES Fifth Defendant

STEPHEN         MITCHELL         ENGINEERS LIMITED

Sixth Defendant

STEPHEN ROBERT MITCHELL

Seventh Defendant

MACDONALD       BARNETT       PARTNERS LIMITED

Eighth Defendant MICHAEL SIMPSON Ninth Defendant

FRAMERITE INSTALLATIONS LIMITED

Third Third Party

Introduction

[1]      These proceedings concern a 130 unit residential apartment building, known as the C-Vu apartments, on the corner of Hopetoun and Day Streets in Auckland. The first plaintiff is the body corporate of the unit title development and the second plaintiffs are the various individual apartment owners.

[2]      The proceeding was initially commenced as a leaky building claim, although claims relating to structural and seismic issues were subsequently added.  There are currently nine defendants and five third parties.  Recently, shortly before a 10 week trial of the proceedings was due to commence, the plaintiffs settled with all of the defendants save for the structural engineers, Stephen Mitchell Engineers Limited and Mr Stephen Robert Mitchell (together referred to as “SML”).  The plaintiffs claim that SML’s failings contributed to weathertightness defects in the building and, in addition, that SML are primarily liable for certain structural seismic defects.

[3]      The trial between the remaining parties is now scheduled to commence on

4 August 2014, with an estimated hearing time of eight weeks. This judgment relates to an application by the plaintiffs for leave:

(a)       to discontinue their claims against those defendants they have reached settlement agreements with;

(b)      to file an amended statement of claim; and

(c)       to call certain supplementary evidence. [4]      I will consider each issue in turn.

Discontinuance

[5]      The plaintiffs seek leave to discontinue their claims against the defendants they have settled with (the first, second, third, fourth, fifth, eighth and ninth defendants).  The matter is complicated somewhat by the fact that SML has cross claims against the first to fifth defendants.

[6]      SML does not oppose the plaintiffs discontinuing their claims against the various defendants they have settled with, provided that the first to fifth defendants remain parties to the proceedings and the claims as pleaded against them in the ninth amended statement of claim (“9AMSOC”) remain on foot to the extent necessary for the purposes of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 325261 v McDonough and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 1821
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The proceedings in Body Corporate 325261 v McDonough and Others concern a residential apartment building in Auckland. The plaintiffs, the body corporate and individual apartment owners, initially sought compensation for leaky building issues, structural, and seismic defects. The defendants include the structural engineers, Stephen Mitchell Engineers Limited and Mr Stephen Robert Mitchell (SML). The plaintiffs now seek leave to discontinue claims against some defendants, amend their statement of claim, and adduce supplementary evidence. The court considered the application for discontinuance, amendment, and supplementary evidence in turn. Regarding discontinuance, the plaintiffs sought to discontinue claims against seven defendants with whom they had settled. SML did not oppose discontinuance provided the first to fifth defendants remained parties for the purpose of SML's cross claims. The court granted leave for discontinuance, noting the plaintiffs' claims against the first to fifth defendants would remain for the purpose of SML's cross claims. As for the amendment, the plaintiffs sought leave to file a 10th amended statement of claim after the pleadings had closed. The court considered factors such as whether the amendment was in the interests of justice, would not significantly prejudice the other party, and would not cause significant delay. The court declined leave for certain amendments, such as those relating to general damages, as it found the risk of prejudice to SML was too high. However, the court granted leave for other amendments, such as those relating to the estimated costs of remedial work for floor diaphragm issues, as it found the potential for prejudice to SML would only arise if the plaintiffs' reply evidence was not strictly in reply. As for the supplementary evidence, the court declined leave for evidence on stigma issues from Matthew Taylor but granted leave for supplementary evidence from Peter Gillingham, subject to further review at trial. The court also granted leave for supplementary evidence from Kristian Roussow. The court reserved costs for determination at the conclusion of the trial.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.