Goodman-Jones v Hughey

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2017-409-000839

[2023] NZHC 180

BETWEEN

PHILLIPPA ANNE GOODMAN-JONES and GARETH GOODMAN-JONES

as Trustees of the Bayview Trust Plaintiffs

AND

DAVID JOHN HUGHEY

First Defendant

AND

BUILDING CHOICES LIMITED

Second Defendant

AND

CHRISTCHURCH CITY COUNCIL

Third Party

Hearing: 10-20 October 2022

Appearances:

P J Shamy and S B Henry for the Plaintiffs

J E Bayley and F H Scrase for the First Defendant B G Walker for the Second Defendant

S H Macky for the Third Party

Judgment:

13 February 2023


JUDGMENT OF NATION J


GOODMAN-JONES v HUGHEY [2023] NZHC 180 [13 February 2023]

Introduction  1

Claimed unreasonable labour cost and failure to complete the contract

within a reasonable time, and claim for general damages  9

Background to the plaintiffs’ residual claims  21

Termination of the contract  57

Claim for damages for the cost of removal and replacement of all existing

cladding  64

The framework – spacing of the dwangs - pleadings  68

Framework - Spacing of the dwangs - Determinations  85

Spacing of the dwangs — claim against PlaceMakers  181

The cedar cladding — spacing between the vertical boards  190

The cedar cladding — Cupping  246

Nailing issues  263

Flashings  268

Holes in the cladding  273

Vermin strips  274

Nailing off bottom of cladding on north and eastern elevations  275

Installation of balustrade strapping  281

Appropriate remediation costs as estimated for Mr Hughey  287

Whether removal of the existing cladding and recladding is required to obtain a code compliance certificate from the Council for all work

associated with the home?  291

Summary  338

Costs  351

Introduction

[1]                  Phillippa and Gareth Goodman-Jones (the plaintiffs) are two of the three trustees of the Bayview Trust. The trustees are the owners of a steep hillside property near Charteris Bay on the Lyttelton Harbour. The property has views to the north over the harbour, Lyttelton and the hills beyond. From late 2014 and through 2016, the plaintiffs built an architecturally designed home on the property.

[2]                  The plaintiffs contracted the first defendant (Mr Hughey) to be their builder. He traded as David Hughey Builders and employed others on the build. When referring to Mr Hughey’s business, I refer to the first defendant as “Hughey Builders”.

[3]                  The plaintiffs’ contract with Hughey Builders was terminated by mutual agreement on 10 June 2016.

[4]                  In these proceedings, the plaintiffs made claims against Hughey Builders in both contract and tort for alleged negligence in carrying out building work on their home.

[5]                  Part of their claim related to the alleged defective ordering, acceptance and installation of external wall framing and the fixing of vertical cedar cladding to those walls. The plaintiffs claimed it is necessary to remove the existing cladding and reclad the home at a cost of $465,427, including GST. The plaintiffs also claimed Hughey Builders failed to complete the work required of them within a reasonable time and the hours and total amount they charged were excessive. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Goodman-Jones v Hughey and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 180
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, Phillippa and Gareth Goodman-Jones, owners of a steep hillside property near Charteris Bay on the Lyttelton Harbour, engaged Hughey Builders to construct an architecturally designed home. Disputes arose over the quality of the building work, leading the plaintiffs to terminate the contract. The plaintiffs sued Hughey Builders for alleged defective ordering, acceptance, and installation of external wall framing and vertical cedar cladding, and for failure to complete the work within a reasonable time. They also sought damages for the cost of removing and replacing the cladding. Hughey Builders denied liability, and the plaintiffs joined PlaceMakers, the supplier of the framing, and the Christchurch City Council, as third parties, alleging negligence and seeking contribution under the Law Reform Act 1936. The court considered the spacing of the dwangs, the cladding installation, and the compliance with Building Code requirements. The court held that the plaintiffs failed to prove that Hughey Builders were under an obligation to ensure the dwangs were spaced at 400 or 480 mm centres or that the plaintiffs were entitled to damages for the removal and replacement of the cladding. The court found that the framing and cladding, as installed, complied with the Building Code and would provide the same structural integrity and weathertightness protection as the consented plans and specifications. The plaintiffs would be able to obtain a code compliance certificate through applying for a minor variation to the building consent. The court also found that Hughey Builders were not in breach of contract or negligent in their workmanship in ways that required the removal of all existing cladding and the rigid air barrier board, alteration to external wall framework, and recladding. Hughey Builders accepted liability for certain minor rectification work. The plaintiffs’ claim for $162,043 for costs unreasonably charged by Hughey Builders and for an unreasonable delay in completing the work was abandoned during the trial. Judgment was given for Hughey Builders on that part of the plaintiffs’ claim. PlaceMakers was not in breach of contract for constructing the framing with dwangs generally at 480 mm centres, and the plaintiffs had suffered no loss through the framing as used. The Council had no liability to Hughey Builders or PlaceMakers. The court ordered the plaintiffs to pay the costs of Hughey Builders and PlaceMakers, and the Council to file a memorandum as to the costs it seeks and the parties against whom it seeks costs within 20 working days of this judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established