IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND GREYMOUTH REGISTRY
CIV-2011-418-000143 [2012] NZHC 1081
BETWEEN SWORDFISH CO LIMITED Plaintiff
ANDBULLER DISTRICT COUNCIL Defendant
Hearing: 10 May 2012
Appearances: A J Prebble and K M McMullen for Defendant (Applicant) G M Downing for Plaintiff (Respondent)
Judgment: 17 May 2012
JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE MATTHEWS
[1] This is an application to strike out the statement of claim dated 9 September
2011 and to dismiss this proceeding. The applicant relies on r 15.1 of the High Court Rules which provides that the Court may strike out all or part of a pleading if it does not disclose any reasonably arguable cause of action.
[2] In its statement of claim the respondent alleges that the applicant owed it a duty to take reasonable care in issuing a certificate under s 224 of the Resource Management Act 1991, and a duty to take reasonable care in issuing and ensuring registration of a consent notice. The respondent alleges breach of these duties of care in a number of ways, and that it has suffered a financial loss as a result of these breaches. The first issue on this application is whether the applicant owed a duty of care to the respondent as alleged.
[3] In the second cause of action the respondent alleges that the applicant owed it a statutory duty and has breached that duty in the same ways as it is said to have
SWORDFISH CO LIMITED V BULLER DISTRICT COUNCIL HC GRY CIV-2011-418-000143 [17 May
2012]
breached its duty of care, resulting in the same loss. The second issue on this application is whether a statutory duty was owed to the applicant.
[4] Neither of the issues in this proceeding has previously been decided in New Zealand. No case from Australia, Canada or the United Kingdom deciding either issue was cited in argument or located in subsequent research.
Principles to be applied on applications to strike out
[5] The principles to be applied are summarised in McGechan paragraph 15.1.02 by reference to Attorney-General v Prince,1 and Couch v Attorney-General.2 First, pleaded facts, whether or not admitted, are assumed to be true unless shown to be entirely speculative and without foundation. Secondly, the jurisdiction to strike out is not excluded by the need to decide difficult questions of law requiring extensive argument.
[6] Of particular relevance to the present application is the summary of principles in Couch v Attorney-General (per Elias CJ and Anderson J) at [30] to [35] inclusive. After identifying specific deficiencies in the pleadings in that case which led to a lack of focus in the argument presented to the Court on the part of the plaintiff, their Honours noted cases in which deficient pleadings had nonetheless not resulted in proceedings being struck out, and then referred to the decision of Barwick CJ in
General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways NSW,3 cited with approval
by Richmond P in Takaro Properties Ltd (in receivership) v Rowling,4 that…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Swordfish Co Limited v Buller District Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] NZHC 1081
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue was whether the Council owed a duty of care or statutory duty to the plaintiff. The court considered the principles applicable to applications to strike out, emphasising that claims should not be dismissed summarily unless the court can be certain that it cannot succeed. The court noted that determining whether a duty of care exists in novel situations is difficult and requires caution to prevent injustice and avoid skewing the law.
The court found that while there was insufficient proximity between the Council and the plaintiff for a duty of care to exist, there were points upon which more evidence would provide a firmer basis for a finding. The court also highlighted the need for a policy determination based on actual facts. Given the limitations of summary consideration of a novel duty of care, the court declined the application to strike out.
The court declined to strike out the statutory duty claim, allowing it to proceed alongside the negligence claim. The plaintiff was awarded costs on a 2B basis plus disbursements. Directions were issued for the filing of an amended statement of claim, standard discovery, and a final case management conference.