Spiteri v RCR Infrastructure (New Zealand) Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NELSON REGISTRY

CIV-2015-442-10 [2017] NZHC 438

BETWEEN

ADRIAN ALBERT SPITERI AND

VANESSA SPITERI Plaintiffs

AND

RCR INFRASTRUCTURE (NEW ZEALAND) LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 20-22 June 2016

Counsel:

L A Andersen for Plaintiffs
M J Dennett for Defendant

Judgment:

14 March 2017

JUDGMENT OF CLARK J

Table of contents

A Introduction [1]
B The defendant [3]
C Background [4]
D The terms of the contract [24]
Plaintiffs’ position [24]
Defendant’s position [26]
Analysis [27]
E Breach [36]
F Limitation Act 1950 [46]
Boiler installation [51]
Continuing attempts to perform [57]
Conclusion [58]
G Exclusion Clause in contract [61]
Analysis [71]
H Remedy [77]
Betterment [77]
The two options [86]
Comparative costings [103]
Damages [112]
General Damages [119]
Cost of investigation report [126]
Accommodation costs [135]

Result  [136]

SPITERI AND SPITERI v RCR INFRASTRUCTURE (NEW ZEALAND) LIMITED [2017] NZHC 438 [14 March 2017]

Introduction

[1]      In 2007 the plaintiffs, Mr and Ms Spiteri, commenced building what was to be their dream home in Redwood Valley, Richmond.   They had particular requirements for heating as they knew it could be very cold in winter.  As well, they had ready access to firewood and wanted to use that as a form of cheap fuel.  Mr and Ms Spiteri arranged for a design brief and then the supply and installation of an underfloor heating system.  They have experienced problems with the system ever since and sue for breach of contract.

[2]      The defendant concedes breach of contract but its case is that the breach was in  the  design  of  the  heating  system.    The  defendant  says  its  contract  with  the plaintiffs was breached when it prepared the design for the heating system which was defective but in response to the plaintiffs’ claim the defendant raises affirmative defences:

(a)       the proceeding is time-barred;

(b)      the defendant’s liability is limited by a clause in the terms of trade

which form part of the contract between the parties.

B      The defendant

[3]    The  design  and  the  installation  of  the  heating  system  was  completed  by Norfolk Electrical and Mechanical Ltd, a subsidiary of the named defendant and trading as Climatech.  The defendant accepts for the purpose of the proceeding it is one  and  the  same  as  Climatech.    It  is  to  Climatech  that  the  parties  referred throughout the hearing and accordingly to which I refer in this judgment.

C      Background

[4]    In 2007 the plaintiffs approached Climatech to design and install a heating system.  Mr Spiteri’s evidence (which was not contested by the defendant) was that he and Ms Spiteri had particular requirements of the heating system for their new home:

(a)       They did not want heat pumps or direct sources of heating which was why they were investigating underfloor heating.

(b)They  wished  to  use  the  firewood  from  the  farm  block  they  had purchased and thereby save money.

(c)       Because of the dust and smoke likely to be created by log burners, they did not want log burners in the house.

[5]    Discussions with Climatech began…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Spiteri v RCR Infrastructure (New Zealand) Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 438
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the plaintiffs, Mr and Ms Spiteri, sued the defendant, RCR Infrastructure (New Zealand) Limited, for breach of contract. The plaintiffs engaged the defendant to design and install a heating system in their new home, but they experienced problems with the system ever since. The defendant conceded that it breached the contract but argued that the breach was in the design of the heating system. The plaintiffs argued that the breach was in the defendant's failure to deliver a functioning heating system. The court found that the contract was for the design, supply, and installation of a heating system that would heat the whole house. The contract was concluded with the opening of a customer account on 8 April 2008. The court found that the breach of contract was in the defendant's failure to deliver a functioning heating system, which was complete only on 10 April 2009 when the boiler became operable. The court also found that the proceeding having been filed on 30 March 2015, it was not time-barred. The plaintiffs were entitled to the measure of damages that would place them in the position they would have occupied had the contract been performed. The damages which the court awarded were as follows: (a) $303,700.00 - being the cost of supplying and installing the Variotherm heating system but after deducting the amounts set out in the judgment; (b) $20,000.00 - general damages; (c) $13,266.91 - contribution to the cost of the Opus investigation report; (d) $9,000.00 - as the cost of alternative accommodation while works are carried out. The plaintiffs have succeeded and are entitled to costs. If costs are unable to be agreed, counsel may submit focused memoranda.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established