Bruce v IAG New Zealand Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA45/2019
 [2019] NZCA 590

BETWEEN

JOANNE TRACEY BRUCE, STEPHEN
LESLIE BRUCE AND LESLIE GORDON
WILLETTS as Trustees of the JO AND
STEPHEN FAMILY TRUST
Appellants

AND

IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

15 October 2019

Court:

Miller, Simon France and Hinton JJ

Counsel:

M V Robinson and P H Biddle for Appellants
M G Ring QC and O V Collette-Moxon for Respondent

Judgment:

26 November 2019 at 2.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A         The appeal is allowed in part.  We set aside the finding that the Bruces have not established that there is a reasonable and practical way to remedy the wall verticalities or the uneven floor levels.  Those issues must be decided at the second trial.  The appeal is otherwise dismissed. 

BThe cross-appeal is dismissed.

CThe respondent must pay costs to the appellants for a standard appeal on a band B basis with usual disbursements.  We certify for second counsel.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Miller J)

Introduction

  1. This is a case about substandard repairs to an earthquake-damaged house. 

Narrative

  1. The house is the family home of the appellants Joanne and Stephen Bruce.  It is a modern house, completed in 2006, and it was built to a very high standard.  It won “gold” awards in the 2006 Master Builders House of the Year competition.  The evidence is that its pile-supported concrete slab floor was level and its interior framed timber walls true.

  2. The house was damaged in the Christchurch earthquakes.  IAG, the insurer, elected to repair it rather than rebuild.  Under the policy standard repairs must be completed to “the same condition and extent as when the house was new”.  If that was “not practicable”, repairs would be “as close as is reasonably possible to that condition and extent”.

  3. The necessary repairs were extensive.  The concrete slab on which the house and garage stood was no longer level.  The house was lifted so the slab could be excavated and replaced.  It was then lowered and its exterior and interior walls were fixed to the new slab.  Much consequential work was required to make it good.

  4. It is not now in dispute that the builder engaged by IAG did not meet the policy’s “as when new” standard in a number of respects.  The Bruces pleaded no fewer than 135 defects.  Shortly before trial IAG conceded almost all of them.  Four were disputed at trial:  the floor level, the verticality of interior walls, the quality of wall finishes required and achieved, and the fireplace.  The last of these is not in issue on appeal.

  5. The trial Judge, Mallon J, found that in each of the first three areas the work failed to meet the contractual standard.[1]  The Bruces’ appeal concerns the Judge’s findings about what needs to be done to repair the house.  They say that the work must be done again and the Judge wrongly excluded that option, finding rather that a combination…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bruce v IAG New Zealand Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZCA 590
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal of New Zealand heard an appeal and a cross-appeal in the matter of Bruce v IAG New Zealand Ltd. The appellants, Joanne Tracey Bruce, Stephen Leslie Bruce and Leslie Gordon Willetts as Trustees of the Jo and Stephen Family Trust, are the owners of a house that was damaged in the Christchurch earthquakes. The respondent, IAG New Zealand Limited, is the insurer who elected to repair the house rather than rebuild it. The appellants claimed that the repairs were substandard and sought remediation costs and damages. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal in part and dismissed the cross-appeal. The Court set aside the finding that the appellants had not established a reasonable and practical way to remedy the wall verticalities or the uneven floor levels, and those issues must be decided at the second trial. The Court held that it was open to the trial Judge to decide whether the respondent breached the contract by failing to meet its repair standards with respect to the slab, the interior wall verticalities, and wall finishes, but she ought not to have excluded the appellants' preferred methodologies for remediating the slab and wall verticalities as unreasonable at that stage since their cost was not known. The Court further held that the trial Judge was correct to find that the respondent breached the contract in respect of the wall verticalities, but that it was not practicable to achieve the as-when-new standard and the fallback standard applied. The Court held that the evidence sufficiently established that it was possible to meet the as-when-new standard, but the trial Judge made no such finding and it appeared she was not asked to address the de minimis principle. The Court further held that the trial Judge was not wrong to prefer the respondent's evidence about the extent and quality of the work required on a room by room basis. The Court also held that it was premature to decide whether the appellants were entitled to general damages for the adverse mental effects of a breach. The Court ordered that the respondent must pay costs to the appellants for a standard appeal on a band B basis with usual disbursements, and certified for second counsel.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.