Bruce v IAG New Zealand Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV 2016-409-1223

[2020] NZHC 3051

BETWEEN

J T BRUCE, S L BRUCE and L G

WILLETTS as Trustees of the Jo and Stephen Family Trust

Plaintiffs

AND

IAG NEW ZEALAND LTD

Defendant

AND

ORANGE H MANAGEMENT LTD (FORMERLY HAWKINS MANAGEMENT

LTD) (in receivership and liquidation) First Third Party

ORANGE H GROUP LTD (FORMERLY HAWKINS MANAGEMENT LTD) (in

receivership and liquidation) Second Third Party

QBE INSURANCE (AUSTRALIA) LTD

Third Third Party

On the papers

Judgment:

18 November 2020


JUDGMENT OF MALLON J


Background

[1]                  Mr and Mrs Bruce’s home, owned through a family trust, was damaged in the Christchurch earthquake. The house was insured with IAG. IAG elected to repair the house. The repairs were extensive. The Bruces were unhappy with the standard of the repairs and commenced this proceeding contending that IAG did not meet the “as when new” standard under the policy.

BRUCE v IAG NEW ZEALAND LTD [2020] NZHC 3051 [18 November 2020]

[2]                  Pursuant to a pre-trial direction, the claim was divided into two stages. The first stage was to consider whether the alleged defects existed and what was required to remediate them. The second stage was to consider the cost of remediation and the appropriate remedy or quantum of damages.

[3]                  The trial on the first stage took place in November 2018 and my decision was given in December 2018.1 Shortly before the trial IAG accepted liability for more than 127 defects. During closing submissions the Bruces abandoned their claim relating to the size of the garage. I determined that IAG had not complied with its obligation to reinstate the house “as when new” in relation to the internal finishing, the wall verticalities, and the floor levels but that IAG had complied with its obligations in relation to the fireplace. I also determined that the Bruces had established a basis for general damages.

[4]                  My judgment held that the Bruces’ evidence did not establish a reasonable and practical method of remediating the wall verticalities and the uneven floors. I proposed a way forward for the parties to resolve what the remedy for these policy breaches might be. The Bruces appealed my findings about the unreasonableness and impracticality of their proposed remedy. IAG cross-appealed on the finding that it breached the “as when new” standard on the wall verticalities. IAG also sought to contend that general damages were not available (although this was not in its cross- appeal). The Court of Appeal allowed the Bruces’ appeal on the basis that findings on whether there was a reasonable and practical remedy were for the second stage. It dismissed IAG’s cross-appeal and did not determine IAG’s general damages submission.2

[5]                  The Bruces sought an order for costs on the first stage. In a judgment given on 31 March 2020 I declined that application.3 I considered it was premature to decide costs at that stage for the following reasons:

[19]      In the present…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bruce v IAG New Zealand Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 3051
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Bruce v IAG New Zealand Ltd, the plaintiffs, Mr and Mrs Bruce, sought to recover costs incurred during the first stage of a proceeding against their insurer, IAG, over the quality of repairs made to their home following damage from the Christchurch earthquake. The proceeding was divided into two stages, with the first stage determining whether alleged defects existed and what was required to remediate them, and the second stage considering the cost of remediation and the appropriate remedy or quantum of damages. The plaintiffs sought costs of $124,434 and disbursements of $121,899.38, while IAG sought an award of costs in its favour. The court determined that the plaintiffs were the successful party for the purposes of costs orders under the High Court Rules, for several reasons, including obtaining admissions of liability for more than 127 repair defects and succeeding in establishing the "as when new" standard to which IAG was required to repair. However, the court found that the plaintiffs' insistence on a complete rebuild of the house or its foundations added to IAG's costs by preventing an earlier settlement from being reached. The court therefore ordered 2B costs in favour of the plaintiffs for the items claimed in their schedule to their costs' memorandum, subject to clarification that item 36 does not relate to the 3 August 2020 judicial settlement conference. The court also ordered disbursements as claimed in that memorandum.

The court's decision highlights the importance of parties making reasonable efforts to settle disputes and the consequences of pursuing claims that lack merit. While the plaintiffs were ultimately successful in establishing policy breaches for three of the five remaining defects in issue and on the general damages issue, their insistence on a complete rebuild of the house or its foundations made it difficult for IAG to settle with them and added to IAG's costs. The court found that the plaintiffs' attitude to IAG's efforts to engage did not provide a sufficient basis to reduce the award of costs for the first stage of the proceeding, but their insistence on a complete rebuild did warrant a reduction of the costs order. The decision serves as a reminder to parties to carefully consider their claims and the potential costs implications of pursuing unmeritorious positions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.