Bruce v IAG New Zealand Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV 2016-409-1223

[2020] NZHC 661

BETWEEN

J T BRUCE, S L BRUCE and L G

WILLETTS as Trustees of the Jo and Stephen Family Trust

Plaintiffs

AND

IAG NEW ZEALAND LTD

Defendant

AND

ORANGE H MANAGEMENT LTD (FORMERLY HAWKINS MANAGEMENT

LTD) (in receivership and liquidation) First Third Party

ORANGE H GROUP LTD (FORMERLY HAWKINS MANAGEMENT LTD) (in

receivership and liquidation) Second Third Party

QBE INSURANCE (AUSTRALIA) LTD

Third Third Party

On the papers

Judgment:

31 March 2020


JUDGMENT OF MALLON J


Introduction

[1]                 Mr and Mrs Bruce, through their family trust, have brought a claim against the defendant (IAG). The trial of their claim was divided into two stages. The first stage has been determined.1 The second stage is to be heard later this year.


1      Bruce v IAG New Zealand Ltd [2018] NZHC 3444.

BRUCE v IAG NEW ZEALAND LTD [2020] NZHC 661 [31 March 2020]

[2]                 The Bruces seek an order for costs for the first stage. They say they succeeded at the first stage and are therefore entitled to costs. IAG disagrees that the Bruces succeeded. It considers costs should remain reserved until the second stage has been determined.

Background

[3]                 Mr and Mrs Bruce’s home, owned through their family trust, was damaged in the Christchurch earthquake. The house was insured with the IAG. IAG elected to repair the house. The repairs were extensive. The Bruces considered the builder engaged by IAG did not meet the “as when new” standard required under the policy. They brought this claim against IAG seeking remediation costs of $2,056,221 for 135 alleged defects as well as general damages of $50,000, temporary accommodation costs, interest and costs.

[4]                 Pursuant to a pre-trial direction the claim was divided into two stages. The first stage was whether the alleged repair defects existed and what was required to remedy them. The second stage was to determine the cost of remediation and the appropriate remedy or damages.

[5]                 The trial on the first stage took place in November 2019. Prior to the trial, IAG accepted that a large number of the pleaded defects existed and that it was responsible to remediate them. The trial was confined to five remaining alleged defects: (1) the interior finish; (2) the wall verticalities; (3) the floor levels; (4) the downstairs fire place; and (5) the garage. At trial the Bruces contended the award of damages should be the estimated cost to rebuild the whole house or, alternatively, to lift the house and rebuild the foundation.

[6]I determined these matters as follows:

(a)I found in favour of the Bruces as to the level of interior finish that was required for an “as when new” repair. I accepted IAG’s expert evidence as to what remediation would be required to achieve this finish.

(b)I found that the wall verticalities were affected by the repairs but to a minor extent. I accepted IAG’s expert evidence that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bruce v IAG New Zealand Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 661
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, Mr and Mrs Bruce through their family trust, sought a costs order against the defendant IAG New Zealand Ltd following the first stage of a two-stage trial concerning repair defects to their Christchurch home, damaged in the Christchurch earthquake. The trial of the claim was divided into two stages, the first being whether the alleged repair defects existed and what was required to remedy them, and the second being to determine the cost of remediation and the appropriate remedy or damages. The trial on the first stage took place in November 2019, with IAG accepting that a large number of the pleaded defects existed and that it was responsible to remediate them. The trial was confined to five remaining alleged defects. The plaintiffs sought an order for costs for the first stage, contending that they succeeded and were therefore entitled to costs. IAG disagreed that the plaintiffs succeeded and considered costs should remain reserved until the second stage had been determined.

The court was required to determine whether the plaintiffs were entitled to an order for costs for the first stage of the trial, or whether costs should remain reserved until the second stage had been determined. The court considered the principles set out in the High Court Rules 2016 and relevant case law, including Cousins & Associates v FM Custodians Ltd and Well v Mean Fiddler Holdings Limited. The court found that it was not appropriate to order costs until the outcome of the second stage was determined, as there was a prospect that the plaintiffs would not succeed in establishing anything beyond their success at the first hearing. The court declined the application for costs, reserving costs to be determined when the second stage had been determined if the parties did not reach an agreement.

In light of the above, the court declined the application for costs. Costs remained reserved to be determined when the second stage had been determined if the parties did not reach an agreement. The court encouraged the parties to see if a settlement could be reached, as it was likely that a negotiated settlement of the outstanding matters remained the best way forward for both parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.