FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WZARH v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] FCAFC 137
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read WZARH v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] FCAFC 137
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the Appellant's claim that the IMR's decision-making process was procedurally unfair because it did not include an oral hearing. The court clarified that the Appellant was not seeking a second oral hearing but rather an initial one. The IMR's January 2012 interview did not necessitate an oral hearing for the subsequent reviewer. Regarding the visible scarring, the court found that the IMR had indeed considered the Appellant's account of the events that led to his injuries, and thus, the argument that this consideration was omitted was unconvincing. The court ultimately concluded that the IMR's failure to take into account the visible scarring in the final recommendation did not constitute a breach of procedural fairness.
The appeal was allowed, and the Federal Circuit Court's orders were set aside. The court declared that the IMR's decision was made in breach of procedural fairness. The Minister was ordered to pay the Appellant's costs, and the Appellant was awarded his own costs as well.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal is allowed.
2. Orders 1 and 2 of the Federal Circuit Court made on 14 October 2013 in PEG 218/2012 are set aside and in lieu thereof:
(i) It is declared that the decision of the Independent Merits Reviewer made on 25 July 2012 in review case number NEC053 was arrived at in breach of the rules of procedural fairness.
(ii) The First Respondent is to pay the Applicant’s costs as taxed or agreed.
3. The First Respondent is to pay the costs of the Appellant.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Expressly rejected is the Respondent Minister’s contention that the Appellant was seeking “a second oral hearing”. The interview conducted by the Independent Merits Reviewer in January 2012 did not satisfy any requirement on the part of the second Independent Merits Reviewer to conduct an oral hearing or interview. The failure to have regard to a relevant consideration – no procedural unfairness? The second of the two ways in which the Appellant advances his claim as to a denial of procedural fairness focusses attention upon “visible scarring” on his arm not being taken into account in the findings made that he would not have a sufficient “profile to come to the attention of the authorities in Sri Lanka, as per paragraphs 104 and 105 of the IMR Recommendation”. Paragraphs [104] and [105] of the recommendation to which this argument is directed provide as follows:104.Having examined the claimant’s case including his previous experiences with the authorities and other groups in Sri Lanka, I find that the claimant is a Tamil from Jaffna who has left Sri Lanka twice using a genuine passport issued in his own name and who has travelled back to Jaffna on the same passport. I found that there has been no change in his risk profile during the period he has held his passport. I acknowledge that persons returned to Sri Lanka, whether failed asylum seekers, including persons of Tamil ethnicity, or other deportees, are likely to be subjected to closer scrutiny than other travellers on return. I accept that there is a greater interest in these arrivals on the part of the authorities.105.In view of the profile of the claimant, however, I find that there are not substantial grounds for believing that there is a real risk of significant harm for this claimant as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of his being removed from Australia to Sri Lanka. This part of the Appellant’s argument expressed as either a failure to take into account a relevant consideration or as a denial of procedural fairness is, with respect, far less persuasive than his former argument. The argument lacks persuasive force by reason of the fact that the Independent Merits Reviewer who made the July 2012 recommendation accepted the claims made by the Appellant. He was given “the benefit of the doubt” by that Reviewer. With respect to the “visible scarring”, the reasons for the recommendation provided by the Independent Merits Reviewer referred on a number of occasions to the account of events given by the Appellant in April 2004 when the injuries were said to have been inflicted. Paragraph [39] of those reasons, for example, thus states as follows:39.He stated that he was abducted at about 7pm and taken to a house behind the EPDP camp and he was kept there until about 4.30am the following morning at which time he was released. During his detention he was continuously assaulted and cuts were inflicted on his left arm and his head was bashed. He was asked whether anyone else was held and he replied that he was singled out but he remembers that one of the others involved in setting the fire was also assaulted and he has not seen him again.The Appellant was a supporter of the United National Party. The Reviewer returned to the claims being made in respect to the events in April 2004 when his reasons later record the following:82.I am prepared to give the claimant the benefit of the doubt and accept that he was detained by the SL Navy when he was a youth for not complying with a curfew as I am prepared to accord the claimant the benefit of the doubt regarding the incident of April 2004 in relation to the EPDP and accept that he was detained by them and may have been mistreated during the period of detention which lasted a few hours. I accept this, since it is not inconsistent with the behaviour of this paramilitary group especially at that time and towards the general population in the Jaffna area. I do not accept that the reason for his detention was his support for Maheswaran.