Peros v Nationwide News Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Peros v Nationwide News Pty Ltd & Ors (No 3) [2024] QSC 192

PARTIES:

JOHN PEROS
(plaintiff)

v

NATIONWIDE NEWS PTY LTD
ACN 008 438 828

(first defendant)

AND
HEDLEY THOMAS
(second defendant)
AND
SHANNAH BLACKBURN

(third defendant)

FILE NO:

BS 7796 of 2023

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Hearing of separate harm issue under Defamation Act 2005 (Qld), s 10A

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

27 August 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

29 and 30 July 2024

JUDGE:

Applegarth J

ORDERS:

The proceeding is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

DEFAMATION – ACTIONS FOR DEFAMATION – OTHER PROCEEDINGS BEFORE TRIAL – SERIOUS HARM ISSUE – where the plaintiff was charged with, and later acquitted of, murder – where he was later found by a Coroner to have violently killed the deceased using a bladed instrument – where the Coroner’s finding was widely publicised – where the first and second defendants published an investigative podcast series into the killing – where Episode 13 is alleged to have imputed that the plaintiff murdered the deceased – where the plaintiff pleads that the episode “caused or is likely to cause serious harm” to his reputation so as to satisfy the serious harm element of the cause of action enacted by s 10A of Defamation Act 2005 (Qld) – where the defendants dispute the “serious harm element” of the plaintiff’s cause of action on the grounds that his reputation had been practically destroyed by the widespread reporting of the Coroner’s finding – where the Coroner’s finding was reported in the first episode of the series – where an order is made pursuant to s 10A of the Defamation Act 2005 (Qld) for the early determination of the serious harm issue – where the plaintiff objects to the admissibility of reports of the Coroner’s findings and other prior publications that are alleged to have injured his reputation prior to the publication of Episode 13 – whether the plaintiff has established the serious harm element of his cause of action against the first and second defendants over Episode 13 – whether the plaintiff has established the serious harm element of his cause of action against the third defendant over things she said in an interview that were included in Episode 13

Defamation Act 2005 (Qld), ss 10A, 38
Defamation Act 2013 (UK), s 1

Alsaifi v Trinity Mirror Plc [2017] EWHC 2873 (QB), cited
Amalgamated Television Services Pty Ltd v Marsden [2002] NSWCA 419, cited
Associated Newspapers Ltd v Dingle [1964] AC 371, discussed
Banks v Cadwalladr [2023] EWCA Civ 219, cited
Barron v Vines [2016] EWHC 1226 (QB), cited
Blake v Fox [2024] EWHC 146 (KB), cited
Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336, cited
Burstein v Times Newspapers Ltd [2001] 1 WLR 579, cited
Carson v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd (1993) 178 CLR 44, cited
Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd v Mohammed (2010) 278 ALR 232; [2010] NSWCA 335,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Peros v Nationwide News Pty Ltd (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QSC 192
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Peros v Nationwide News Pty Ltd (No 3), the plaintiff, William Daniel Peros, sought to establish that the defendants had defamed him in a podcast series. Peros had been acquitted of murdering Ms Shandee Blackburn, but a Coroner had found that he had killed her using a bladed instrument. The defendants published an investigative podcast series into the killing, and Peros claimed that Episode 13 of the series imputed that he had murdered Ms Blackburn, causing or likely to cause serious harm to his reputation. The defendants argued that Peros' reputation had already been practically destroyed by the widespread reporting of the Coroner’s finding, and thus the episode did not cause serious harm. The court was required to determine whether Peros had established the serious harm element of his cause of action against the defendants.

The court found that prior to the publication of Episode 13, numerous other publications, including the first 12 episodes of the podcast, had already seriously injured Peros' reputation. Listeners to the podcast series had concluded that Peros was the person who the Coroner had found to have violently killed Ms Blackburn. However, the court held that Episode 13 continued a theme that the jury at the murder trial did not hear a great deal of the evidence that was potentially available at the time of the trial, but was either not relied upon by the prosecution or excluded from the evidence as the result of principles governing criminal trials and rulings by the trial judge. The court found that Episode 13 was likely to cause serious harm to Peros' reputation because it reinforced the impression that Peros was the killer, despite his acquittal.

The court concluded that Peros had established the serious harm element of his cause of action against the defendants over Episode 13. The proceeding was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

The proceeding is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves defamation claims against Nationwide News Pty Ltd (the first and second defendants) and a journalist (the third defendant). The plaintiff, who was charged with and acquitted of murdering Ms Blackburn, was later found by a Coroner to have violently killed her using a bladed instrument. This finding was widely publicised. The first and second defendants published an investigative podcast series into the killing, with Episode 13 alleging that the plaintiff murdered Ms Blackburn. The plaintiff contends that Episode 13 caused or is likely to cause serious harm to his reputation, satisfying the serious harm element of the cause of action under s 10A of the Defamation Act 2005 (Qld). The defendants argue that the plaintiff's reputation had already been practically destroyed by the widespread reporting of the Coroner’s finding. The Coroner’s finding was reported in the first episode of the series. The court made an order for the early determination of the serious harm issue, and the plaintiff objected to the admissibility of reports of the Coroner’s findings and other prior publications that allegedly injured his reputation prior to the publication of Episode 13.

The case came before the court following an order made pursuant to s 10A of the Defamation Act 2005 (Qld) for the early determination of the serious harm issue in the defamation action. The plaintiff's objections to the admissibility of certain prior publications and reports were considered in the context of determining whether he had established the serious harm element of his cause of action against the defendants. The court examined the impact of Episode 13 on the plaintiff's reputation, considering the state of his reputation prior to its publication and the themes of the podcast series that preceded Episode 13.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In Sivananthan v Vasikaran Collins Rice J stated:[33]“Where a libel claimant selects some publications as examples of a wider campaign of allegations by a defendant, that claimant may face a daunting problem of causation. If a defendant has undertaken a protracted course of conduct publicising allegations, a corresponding improbability arises that any member of that public later re‑encountering them in published form will be impacted as an effect of that specific publication. The serious harm test is about the impact of an individual publication by a defendant on its readership. If the readership already knows everything about the defendant’s view of the claimant contained in the publication from the defendant’s own history and course of conduct, it is correspondingly unlikely that the publication will have material impact.”[33][2022] EWHC 2938 (KB) at [56] (emphasis in original).Proof of serious harm by direct evidence or by inference The serious harm element requires proof of actual harm to reputation. Harm is not presumed. Serious harm may be proven by direct evidence of harm to reputation, by inference, or by both means of proof. By direct evidence, I include evidence from recipients of the publication or from persons who have heard others speak about the publication and its effect on their estimation of the claimant. It includes publications in the media, in readers’ comments, in social media posts, abuse, criticism, and being avoided because of the defamatory publication. Care is required in such cases that the abuse, criticism or other response (such as being avoided) is caused by the publication of the defamatory matter, and not by other publications.[34] [34]Daryanani v Ramnani [2017] EWHC 183 (QB) at [7]; Spicer v Commissioner of Police for the Metropolis [2021] EWHC 1099 (QB) at [374]-[375]. Actual or likely serious harm may be established by inference, at least when the defamation conveys a gravely serious meaning about the claimant.[35] In some cases, a claimant may rely on inference and, if the inference is strong enough, serious harm may not be in issue. As noted, it has been held that mass media publications of very serious defamatory allegations may render the need for evidence of serious harm unnecessary. All depends upon the circumstances. It may also be unnecessary to call direct evidence of serious harm in the case of grave defamation to a more limited number of recipients, if the circumstances make that inference compelling and there is no competing, reasonable inference.[35]Whittington v Newman [2024] NSWCA 27 at [42]. This is not to say that serious harm is established by the inherent tendency of the words. Lord Sumption in Lachaux stated:[36]“… if serious harm can be demonstrated only by reference to the inherent tendency of the words, it is difficult to see that any substantial change to the law of defamation has been achieved by what was evidently intended as a significant amendment.”[36][2020] AC 612 at 624 [16].

Decision

Reasons for decision

After the first 12 episodes, William Daniel remained a suspect, but the episodes highlighted evidence, including a great deal of evidence that was not placed before the jury, that overwhelmingly pointed to the plaintiff as the person who had brutally killed Ms Blackburn. To be clear, I am not making any finding of responsibility in this regard nor am I agreeing with the Coroner’s findings. Instead, I am concerned with the impression that the first 12 episodes would have left upon listeners.Conclusion I find that listeners to the first 12 episodes were likely to conclude that the Coroner’s findings were right, and that the plaintiff had violently attacked Ms Blackburn with a bladed instrument in a fast, frenzied and personal attack at around 12.15 am on 9 February 2013. This conclusion is not based simply on the tendering of those earlier publications. It relies on the perceived authority of the persons who made those publications, and the form of the publications as being the product of investigative journalism. That distinguishes the publication from a publication of rumours and bare allegations. The state of the plaintiff’s reputation prior to the publication of Episode 13 Prior to Episode 13 being published, numerous other publications, including the first 12 episodes of the podcast, had seriously injured the plaintiff’s reputation. Listeners to the podcast series were told that the plaintiff was the person who the Coroner had found to have violently killed Ms Blackburn, and most listeners would have concluded on the strength of the first 12 episodes that the Coroner’s findings were firmly based in evidence that was not placed before the jury at the plaintiff’s criminal trial. Listeners would have regarded William Daniel as a suspect. However, by the end of Episode 12, they would have reached the view that, despite his acquittal, the plaintiff was Ms Blackburn’s killer.Episode 13 Episode 13 is titled “Unheard Evidence”. It continued a theme that ran through the podcast series and that was introduced in Episode 1, namely that the jury at the murder trial did not hear a great deal of the evidence that was potentially available at the time of the trial, but was either not relied upon by the prosecution or excluded from the evidence as the result of principles governing criminal trials and rulings by the trial judge. Another theme of the podcast series prior to Episode 13 was that the jury, the judge, the prosecutor, the police, and others were unaware, at the time of the trial, of the deep flaws in the system for DNA testing. These flaws were the subject of many episodes in the podcast series. Episode 13 did not bring these issues to light. It repeated them. Episode 13 was introduced by Mr Thomas saying:“We are a long way into this series. And up to now, you haven’t heard Shandee’s sister, Shannah, or her mother, Vicki, disclose their views about the murderer’s identity. This has been a deliberate omission. I wanted listeners to make their own judgments about this, untainted by the family’s position, but it’s now time to hear it and to understand some of the reasons which have informed their views.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the impact of Episode 13 in light of the plaintiff's reputation prior to its publication. The plaintiff, William Daniel, had been charged with, and later acquitted of, the murder of Ms Blackburn. His reputation had already been significantly harmed by the widespread reporting of the Coroner’s finding that he violently killed Ms Blackburn using a bladed instrument. The first 12 episodes of the podcast series had also contributed to the deterioration of his reputation by presenting evidence that pointed to him as the murderer. The court found that by the time Episode 13 was published, listeners would have already concluded that Daniel was Ms Blackburn’s killer. The court relied on the principle from Sivananthan v Vasikaran, which stated that if a defendant has undertaken a protracted course of conduct publicising allegations, it is unlikely that any specific publication will have a significant impact on the readership’s perception of the claimant. Given that the plaintiff's reputation had already been severely damaged by prior publications, the court held that Episode 13 did not cause or was not likely to cause serious harm to his reputation. The reasoning was based on the established legal principle that serious harm is not presumed and must be proven by direct or inferred evidence. In this case, the prior publications had already conveyed a gravely serious defamatory allegation, which rendered the need for additional evidence of serious harm from Episode 13 unnecessary. The court distinguished the impact of Episode 13 from that of the prior publications, noting that the serious harm test focused on the impact of an individual publication, which was minimal in this case due to the already damaged reputation.