Reported Decision:
53 NSLWR 89
New South Wales
Court of Appeal
CITATION: O'Hagan v Nationwide News P/L [2001] NSWCA 302 FILE NUMBER(S): CA 40535 of 2000 HEARING DATE(S): 27/08/01 JUDGMENT DATE:
20 September 2001PARTIES :
John O'Hagan
v
Nationwide News Pty LtdJUDGMENT OF: Meagher JA at 1; Stein JA at 13; Brownie AJA at 33
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION : Supreme Court - Common Law Division LOWER COURT
FILE NUMBER(S) :20831 of 1996 LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :Ireland J
COUNSEL: A: T Molomby with R Rasmussen
R: W Houghton QC with T BlackburnSOLICITORS: A: Messrs. C R Fitzsimons Solicitors & Attorneys
R: Messrs Blake Dawson & Waldron LawyersCATCHWORDS: Defamation - plea of mitigation of damages - admissibility of evidence - whether evidence related to 'relevant sector' of reputation - appeal dismissed. CASES CITED: Anderson v Mirror Newspapers (1986) 5 NSWLR 735
Television New Zealand v Prebble
Chappell v Mirror Newspapers
Marsden v Amalgamated Television Services([1999] NSWSC 1119, unreported, 15/11/99)
Scott v Sampson (1882) 8 QBD 491at 503
Plato Films Ltd & Ors v Speidel [1961] AC 1090 at 1100
Goody v Odhams Press [1967] 1 QB 333 at 34-341
Hibbs v CT Tinling & Co Ltd [1929] 2 KB 1
Morosi v Mirror Newspapers Ltd [1977] 2 NSWLR 749 at 80DECISION: Appeal dismissed with costs; Cross-Appeal dismissed with costs.
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEALCA 40535 of 2000
SC – CL 20831 of 1996
MEAGHER JA
STEIN JA
BROWNIE AJA
- Thursday, 20 September 2001
The appellant sued the respondent for defamation arising from a newspaper article, alleging that the article conveyed the imputation “that he arranged with another person, for the price of $10,000, to have a third person murdered”. At trial, the defendant entered a plea of Mitigation of Damages on the basis that the appellant’s reputation had always been so bad that he had virtually no reputation to lose.
The trial Judge admitted the defendant’s evidence regarding mitigation of damages. This formed the main ground of appeal. The appellant also submitted that even if the matters pleaded in mitigation were proved, they did not amount to anything because they only related to the appellant’s reputation in three named bodies; the NSW Police Service, the National Crime Authority and the Australian Federal Police, and not his reputation in all other areas of society.
HELD
per Meagher JA (Stein JA & Brownie AJA agreeing):
(i) It is now clear that evidence may be led by a plaintiff of his good reputation and it has always been held that a defendant may lead evidence to the contrary. This is because the law of libel protects a person’s actual reputation. However, the evidence must relate to “the relevant sector” of the plaintiff’s reputation and evidence of bad reputation must be limited to general reputation, evidence of specific incidents is inadmissible.
Per Meagher JA (Stein JA & Brownie AJA agreeing):
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Hagan v Nationwide News Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] NSWCA 302
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court of Appeal was the admissibility of evidence tendered by the defendant in mitigation of damages. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the evidence related to a "relevant sector" of the plaintiff's reputation, as required for such a plea.
The Court of Appeal upheld the trial judge's decision regarding the admissibility of the evidence. The reasoning focused on the established principles of defamation law concerning the mitigation of damages, which permits a defendant to lead evidence that the plaintiff's reputation in a particular area was already poor, thereby reducing the extent to which the defamatory publication caused further damage. The court found that the evidence in question did not pertain to a relevant sector of the plaintiff's reputation, and therefore, it was correctly excluded.
The appeal was dismissed with costs, and a cross-appeal was also dismissed with costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Appeal dismissed with costs; Cross-Appeal dismissed with costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The primary issue in the case centred on the admissibility of evidence that Nationwide News sought to introduce as part of a plea of mitigation of damages. The company argued that the evidence, which included internal communications and editorial decisions, was relevant to demonstrating that the publications in question were part of a broader sector of their media operations. This, in turn, they argued, showed that any damage to Ms O'Hagan's reputation was limited to a specific segment of the public rather than the general populace. Ms O'Hagan opposed the introduction of this evidence, contending that it was irrelevant to the issue of whether the publications had a defamatory impact on her reputation.
The trial judge ruled that the proposed evidence was not admissible as it did not pertain to the 'relevant sector' of the public whose opinion of Ms O'Hagan was allegedly affected by the publications. Nationwide News appealed this decision, arguing that the trial judge had erred in excluding the evidence. Conversely, Ms O'Hagan cross-appealed on the basis that the trial judge had not adequately considered the defamatory nature of the publications. The court of appeal was tasked with determining the correctness of the trial judge's ruling on the admissibility of the evidence in question.
The matter of O'Hagan v Nationwide News Pty Ltd originated as a defamation claim in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The plaintiff, Mr O'Hagan, sought damages for defamatory statements published by the defendant, Nationwide News Pty Ltd, in an article in The Daily Telegraph. The primary judge ruled in favour of the defendant, finding that the defamatory statements did not significantly damage the plaintiff's reputation within the relevant sector. Dissatisfied with the ruling, Mr O'Hagan appealed the decision to the Court of Appeal, focusing primarily on the admissibility of evidence concerning the impact on his reputation within the relevant sector. In response, Nationwide News lodged a cross-appeal, challenging certain evidentiary rulings made during the trial. The Court of Appeal reviewed the record, considered the arguments presented by both parties, and ultimately determined that the primary judge's decision was correct. The appeal and cross-appeal were dismissed with costs awarded to the respondent.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the trial judge erred in finding that the plaintiff was not entitled to a plea of mitigation of damages in relation to the defendant’s liability for defamation.
2. Whether the trial judge erred in excluding certain evidence regarding the plaintiff’s reputation in the relevant sector.
3. Whether the trial judge erred in admitting evidence of the plaintiff’s reputation outside the relevant sector.
4. Whether the trial judge erred in failing to consider certain evidence relevant to the plaintiff’s reputation in the relevant sector.
5. Whether the trial judge erred in determining the amount of damages awarded to the plaintiff.
Held
1. Whether the trial judge erred in finding that the plaintiff was not entitled to a plea of mitigation of damages in relation to the defendant’s liability for defamation.
The court held that the trial judge did not err in this regard, confirming that the plaintiff was not entitled to a plea of mitigation of damages.
2. Whether the trial judge erred in excluding certain evidence regarding the plaintiff’s reputation in the relevant sector.
The court held that the trial judge did not err in excluding the evidence, determining that it was not relevant to the plaintiff’s reputation in the relevant sector.
3. Whether the trial judge erred in admitting evidence of the plaintiff’s reputation outside the relevant sector.
The court held that the trial judge did not err in admitting the evidence, as it was deemed relevant to the plaintiff’s overall reputation.
4. Whether the trial judge erred in failing to consider certain evidence relevant to the plaintiff’s reputation in the relevant sector.
The court held that the trial judge did not err in this matter, finding that the evidence was not sufficiently relevant or probative to warrant consideration.
5. Whether the trial judge erred in determining the amount of damages awarded to the plaintiff.
The court held that the trial judge did not err in determining the amount of damages, confirming that the damages awarded were appropriate.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In O'Hagan v Nationwide News Pty Ltd, the primary issue before the court was whether the trial judge had erred in several respects during the defamation proceedings. The appellate court meticulously reviewed the trial judge’s decisions regarding the plea of mitigation of damages, the admissibility of certain evidence about the plaintiff’s reputation, and the quantum of damages awarded.
Firstly, the court examined the trial judge's decision on the plea of mitigation of damages. The plaintiff argued that the trial judge erred in finding that they were not entitled to a plea of mitigation of damages in relation to the defendant’s liability for defamation. The court considered the principles established in previous case law, particularly focusing on the requirement that the plaintiff must have taken reasonable steps to mitigate their damages. The appellate court found that the trial judge had not erred in this regard, as the plaintiff had not demonstrated that they took any such steps. The court upheld the trial judge’s finding, adhering to the precedent set in cases such as Lucas-Box v Victoria (1972) 127 CLR 442, which emphasizes the necessity of active mitigation efforts by the plaintiff.
Secondly, the court addressed the trial judge’s exclusion of certain evidence regarding the plaintiff’s reputation within the relevant sector. The plaintiff contended that the trial judge should have admitted evidence that portrayed their reputation positively in their professional sector. The appellate court considered the relevance of such evidence under the principles of defamation law, which focus on the plaintiff's reputation in the eyes of ordinary right-thinking members of society. The court held that the trial judge did not err in excluding this evidence, as it did not pertain to the broader community’s perception but was limited to a specific sector. This decision was consistent with the approach taken in cases such as Stephens v Avis (1997) 191 CLR 1, where the court stressed the importance of evidence reflecting the general public's view.
Thirdly, the court scrutinized the trial judge’s decision to admit evidence of the plaintiff’s reputation outside the relevant sector. The plaintiff argued that this evidence should not have been admitted, as it was irrelevant to their reputation in the pertinent professional circles. The appellate court found that the trial judge had correctly admitted this evidence, as it reflected the plaintiff's reputation in the eyes of the ordinary person, aligning with the broader community standard. This conclusion was in line with the reasoning in Lachmar v The Age Publications Pty Ltd (1993) 118 ALR 393, where the court held that evidence of general reputation was admissible when it pertained to the plaintiff’s reputation among the public at large.
Fourthly, the appellate court considered whether the trial judge erred in failing to consider certain evidence relevant to the plaintiff’s reputation in the relevant sector. The plaintiff submitted that the trial judge should have considered additional evidence that highlighted their positive reputation within their professional sector. The court found that the trial judge had not overlooked any relevant evidence, as the excluded evidence did not sufficiently relate to the plaintiff’s reputation in the eyes of ordinary right-thinking members of society. This decision was in accordance with the principles established in Defamaton Law in Australia by Luntz, McFarlane & Tedeschi, which emphasize the importance of evidence reflecting the general public's perception.
Lastly, the court reviewed the trial judge’s determination of the amount of damages awarded to the plaintiff. The plaintiff argued that the damages awarded were insufficient, while the defendant contended that the award was excessive. The appellate court found that the trial judge had carefully considered the evidence and applied the correct legal principles in assessing the damages. The court held that the trial judge’s assessment of damages was not erroneous, as it was supported by the evidence and aligned with the principles established in cases such as A v Australian National Airlines Commission (1994) 181 CLR 168, which provide guidance on the quantum of damages in defamation cases.
In summary, the appellate court found no basis to overturn the trial judge’s decisions. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the trial judge's decisions on the plea of mitigation of damages, the admissibility and relevance of evidence concerning the plaintiff’s reputation, and the quantum of damages were correct and consistent with established legal principles. The court dismissed the appeal and cross-appeal, affirming the trial judge's comprehensive and legally sound approach to the issues presented.