FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Herron v HarperCollins Publishers Australia Pty Ltd (No 3) [2020] FCA 1687
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Herron v HarperCollins Publishers Australia Pty Ltd (No 3) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] FCA 1687
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court was required to determine whether the book contained defamatory imputations about the applicants and, if so, whether the defences of justification, qualified privilege, contextual truth, and fair report or fair summary applied. The Court considered the evidence of lay witnesses, including the applicants, Chelmsford nurses, former patients and their relatives, and reputation witnesses for the applicants. The Court also considered expert evidence on the use of deep sleep therapy and electroconvulsive therapy at Chelmsford, and the history and use of deep sleep therapy more generally. The Court found that the book contained defamatory imputations about the applicants' conduct in administering deep sleep therapy at Chelmsford. However, the Court found that the defences of justification, qualified privilege, contextual truth, and fair report or fair summary applied to the conveyed imputations.
The Court found that the book contained defamatory imputations about the applicants' conduct in administering deep sleep therapy at Chelmsford. However, the Court found that the defences of justification, qualified privilege, contextual truth, and fair report or fair summary applied to the conveyed imputations. The Court found that the book was justified because the findings of the Royal Commission provided a factual basis for the imputations. The Court found that the book was made under a qualified privilege because it was published in response to a public interest in the findings of the Royal Commission. The Court found that the book was contextually true because the defamatory imputations were true in the context of the Royal Commission's findings. The Court found that the book was a fair report or fair summary of the Royal Commission's findings because it accurately reported the findings and did not contain any misleading or unfair statements.
The Court dismissed the applicants' application and ordered that the applicants pay the respondents' costs as agreed or taxed. The Court found that the respondents had established that the defences of justification, qualified privilege, contextual truth, and fair report or fair summary applied to the conveyed imputations. The Court found that the applicants had not established that the book contained defamatory imputations that were not justified or privileged, or that the book was not a fair report or fair summary of the Royal Commission's findings. The Court found that the applicants had not established that the book contained any defamatory imputations that were not true in substance or in the context of the Royal Commission's findings. The Court found that the applicants had not established that the book contained any misleading or unfair statements.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The originating application be dismissed.
2. The applicant pay the respondents’ costs as agreed or taxed.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1 INTRODUCTION
[1]
2 THE BOOK
[7]
3 THE IMPUTATIONS AND DEFENCES
[16]
4 THE LAY WITNESSES
[21]
4.1 The applicants
[21]
4.1.1 Dr Gill
[24]
4.1.2 Mr Herron
[28]
4.2 Chelmsford nurses
[43]
4.2.1 Jan Reid
[44]
4.2.2 Julie Bothman
[59]
4.2.3 Noelene Brasche
[89]
4.2.4 Marcia Fawdry
[99]
4.3 Former patients and their relatives
[109]
4.3.1 CO
[109]
4.3.2 John Finn
[114]
4.3.3 GW
[121]
4.3.4 CW
[130]
4.3.5 Ernest Nam
[139]
4.3.6 General
[144]
4.4 Reputation witnesses for Dr Gill and Mr Herron
[146]
4.4.1 Virginia Gill
[146]
4.4.2 Margaret North
[150]
4.4.3 Roger Wilkinson
[152]
4.4.4 Richelle Herron
[155]
4.4.5 Brendon Herron
[158]
4.5 Stephen Cannane
[161]
4.5.1 Background
[161]
4.5.2 Writing the Book
[164]
4.5.3 Other evidence
[167]
4.5.4 The imputations
[174]
4.5.5 Discussion
[204]
5 DST AND ECT AT CHELMSFORD
[208]
5.1 The doctors
[210]
5.2 The standard procedure
[212]
6 EXPERT EVIDENCE
[222]
6.1 Dr Richard Clark
[222]
6.2 Professor Ian Whyte
[227]
6.3 Dr John Sydney Smith
[246]
6.4 Professor Gordon Parker
[277]
6.5 Dr Jonathan Phillips
[300]
6.6 Professor Ian Hickie
[340]
6.7 Professor Patrick McGorry
[390]
7 SLEEP THERAPY AND DST
[410]
7.1 Applicants’ submissions
[410]
7.2 Psychiatry
[411]
7.3 History and use of deep sleep therapy
[421]
7.4 Dr Gill
[482]
7.5 Deaths at Chelmsford
[490]
7.5.1 Audrey Francis
[503]
7.5.2 John Adams
[514]
7.5.3 Peter Clarke
[523]
7.5.4 Miriam Podio
[531]
7.5.5 Janice Nam
[545]
7.5.6 Other patients
[547]
7.6 Barry Hart
[548]
8 DEFAMATORY MEANING
[586]
8.1 Principles
[586]
8.2 Discussion
[594]
9 JUSTIFICATION
[633]
9.1 Imputation A
[642]
9.2 Imputation B
[647]
9.3 Imputation C
[652]
9.4 Imputation D
[657]
9.5 Imputation I
[662]
9.6 Imputation N
[668]
9.7 Imputation E
[676]
9.8 Imputation F
[683]
9.9 Imputation G
[690]
9.10 Imputation H
[714]
9.11 Imputation J
[729]
9.12 Imputation K
[733]
9.13 Imputation L
[738]
9.14 Imputation M
[750]
9.15 Conclusion
[757]
10 QUALIFIED PRIVILEGE
[758]
10.1 Principles
[758]
10.2 Discussion
[773]
10.2.1 General
[773]
10.2.2 Section 30(3) factors
[776]
10.2.3 Respondents’ response to criticisms of Mr Cannane
[790]
10.2.4 Applicants’ submission about Mr Cannane
[805]
11 CONTEXTUAL TRUTH
[849]
11.1 Mr Herron
[850]
11.2 Dr Gill
[858]
12 FAIR REPORT/FAIR SUMMARY
[860]
12.1 Principles
[860]
12.2 Competing submissions
[874]
12.3 Discussion
[892]
13 DAMAGES
[898]
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi