Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v SZFDE

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs v SZFDE

[2006] FCAFC 142

MIGRATION – judicial review – procedural fairness – fraud – protection visa – application to Refugee Review Tribunal – invitation to attend oral hearing – fraudulent advice from migration agent that Tribunal would refuse application – advice that applicant should not attend hearing – applicant dissuaded by agent’s fraud from attending – whether procedural unfairness – effect of statutory provisions relating to invitation to appear and codification of natural justice hearing rule – whether apparent consent to non-appearance vitiated by fraud – whether Tribunal decision induced or affected by fraud
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – judicial review – jurisdictional error – procedural fairness – fraud – circumstances analogous to fraud – decision induced or affected by fraud – decision-maker blameless – party induced by fraudulent advice of representative not to appear at hearing – whether certiorari would lie

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 36(2), 65(1), 411(1)(c), 417, 420, 422B, 425, 425A, 426, 426A, 441A, 441C, 441G, and 474
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) s 5(1)(g)

Taylor v Taylor (1979) 143 CLR 1 discussed
R v Secretary of State for the Home Department; Ex parte Al-Mehdawi [1990] 1 AC 876
discussed
Cameron v Cole (1944) 68 CLR 571 cited
Grimshaw v Dunbar [1953] 1 QB 408 cited
Re Anasis; Ex parte Total Australia Ltd (1985) 11 FCR 127 cited
R v Leyland Justices, Ex parte Hawthorn [1979] QB 283 cited
R v Blundeston Prison Board of Visitors; Ex parte Fox-Taylor [1982] 1 All ER 646 cited
R v West Sussex Quarter Sessions; Ex parte Albert and Maud Johnson Trust Ltd [1974] QB 24 cited
R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board; Ex parte A [1992] 2 AC 330 discussed
Barrett v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1989) 18 ALR 129 cited
Transport Accident Commission v Bausch (1998) 4 VR 249 cited
Kuswardana v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1981) 35 ALR 186 cited
SBA Foods Pty Ltd v Victorian WorkCover Authority [2001] VSC 276 cited
Hot Holdings Pty Ltd v Creasy (2002) 210 CLR 438 cited
R v Gillyard [1848] 12 QB 527 cited
R v Recorder of Leicester, Ex parte Wood [1947] KB 726 cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs; Ex parte Applicant S134/2002 (2003) 211 CLR 441 cited
O’Sullivan v Repatriation Commission (2003) 128 FCR 590 cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v SCAR (2003) 128 FCR 553 discussed
Anisminic Limited v Foreign Compensation Commission [1969] 2 AC 147 cited
Applicant S296/2003 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2006] FCA 1166 cited
Appellant P119/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 230 cited
NALQ v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 121 cited
Chamberlain v The Queen (No 2) (1983) 72 FLR 1 cited
Nguyen v Nguyen (1990) 169 CLR 245 cited
Transurban City Rail v Allan (1999) 95 FCR 553 cited
SZEEU v Minister for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v SZFDE and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCAFC 142
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter involves an appeal by the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs against a decision of the Federal Magistrates Court that quashed a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal and mandated a review of the Minister's decision to refuse protection visas to the respondents, a Lebanese family. The family, represented by SZFDE, had applied for protection visas based on SZFDE's claim of a well-founded fear of persecution due to her political opinions and membership in a particular social group. The Tribunal decided to proceed without a hearing, apparently based on the family's consent, but this decision was influenced by fraudulent actions of their agent, who misrepresented the likelihood of success and pressured the family into waiving their right to a hearing.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Tribunal's decision to proceed without a hearing, based on the family's apparent consent, was valid given the fraudulent misrepresentations by their agent. The court had to determine if the Tribunal's decision, which was influenced by the agent's fraud, could stand or if it should be quashed due to procedural unfairness. The appeal hinged on interpreting the statutory framework, particularly the obligations under the Migration Act and the principles of natural justice.

The court found that while the Magistrate's decision could not be upheld on grounds of procedural unfairness, the process was compromised by the fraud of the family's agent. The apparent consent to proceed without a hearing was not genuine due to the agent's fraudulent conduct. However, the majority of the court, Allsop and Graham JJ, took a different view, holding that the appeal should be allowed. They reasoned that despite the fraud, the Tribunal's decision could still be considered valid as the family had not been misled to their detriment and had not suffered any prejudice as a result of proceeding without a hearing. Therefore, the appeal was allowed, and the original decision of the Federal Magistrates Court was set aside.

The final orders of the court were to allow the appeal, set aside the orders of the Federal Magistrates Court, dismiss the family's application, and direct the family to pay the Minister's costs for the appeal and the proceedings in the Federal Magistrates Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. Orders 3, 4 and 5 made on 20 December 2005 in the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia be set aside.

3. The application filed on 24 November 2004 in the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia be dismissed.

4. The First Respondents pay the Appellant’s costs of the appeal and of the proceedings in the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Minister now appeals against that decision. In my opinion, having regard to the legislative framework, the Magistrate’s orders could not be supported on the grounds of procedural unfairness. However, the process leading to the Tribunal’s decision was compromised by the fraud of the family’s agent. The apparent consent by SZFDE to have her application for review by the Tribunal decided without a hearing was not a genuine consent. It had been obtained by that fraud. The Tribunal acted upon that apparent consent. Its decision was therefore affected by the fraud of the agent. On that basis I would dismiss the appeal. In this case however, Allsop and Graham JJ take a different view, and so the appeal will be allowed by majority.Factual and procedural background leading to Tribunal decision The respondents who are designated SZFDE, SZFDF, SZFDG and SZFDH for the purpose of these proceedings, are husband and wife and their two children. They are citizens of Lebanon. The family arrived in Australia on 27 February 2002. They applied for protection visas on 23 March 2002. These were refused by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs on 29 August 2002. On 30 September 2002 the family applied to the Tribunal for a review of the delegate’s decision. The original application for protection visas for the family members was based upon a claim by the wife, SZFDE, that she had a well-founded fear of persecution on account of political opinions which she had expressed in Lebanon and because she was a member of a particular social group comprising ‘Islamic women who have transgressed the social mores of Islamic society’. SZFDE’s claims, as set out in an attachment to her application, may be summarised as follows. When she turned 17 she began to rebel against Islamic law and became sceptical of her parents’ beliefs. She rejected their religious customs. She wondered why she should believe in a religion which distinguished between male and female and which considered that men had rights and women had none. She considered Islam to be a male dominated religion which could not come from a God of infinite justice. Her husband held the same views and the same attitude towards Islam and human rights. One day SZFDE met a well known Christian Lebanese journalist who offered her the opportunity of employment with the Circles Newspaper as a production manager. While employed by the newspaper she wrote articles which reflected her opinion about Islamic rule. The newspaper was opposed to Islamic fundamentalists particularly those involved with the main fundamentalist party Altawheed. It published articles about the activities of Altawheed which included threatening restaurant owners to deter them from serving alcoholic drinks on their premises. Altawheed also purported to prohibit advertising showing women’s legs and destroyed signs in Tripoli with photographs of women on them. According to the first respondent the newspaper received threatening letters and telephone calls from Altawheed party members in Tripoli. Some of the letters were published. She claimed that the government could not do anything to protect them against such threats because it was unable to confront the Altawheed party.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

A hearing took place on 19 September 2005 and on 20 December 2005 the learned Federal Magistrate made an order in the nature of certiorari to quash the decision of the Tribunal. An order in the nature of mandamus was also made requiring the Tribunal to review, according to law, the delegate’s decision of 29 August 2005 refusing protection visas sought by the respondents. The Minister filed an appeal against the decision of the Federal Magistrates Court on 31 January 2006 and an amended notice of appeal on 11 April 2006.Evidence before the Federal Magistrates Court The Federal Magistrates Court had before it the Tribunal’s decision and the papers relevant to it. In addition, it received an affidavit sworn by SZFDE on 7 April 2005. In the affidavit she said that, prior to the date upon which her protection visa application was refused by the delegate, she had been telephoned by her cousin who said words to the following effect: ‘I want to introduce you to a person who can send you to a solicitor who is very good in refugee matters.’She met a Mr Fouad El-Ashwah with her husband at the home of one of her cousins on the same night. In the course of that meeting Mr El-Ashwah told her that he would introduce her to a ‘very, very good solicitor’. That solicitor, he said, would get her permanent residence ‘with great ease’. He named the solicitor as Fahmi Hussain. SZFDE said she would meet him. On the day after her meeting with Mr El-Ashwah SZFDE met Mr Hussain. That meeting took place on 27 July 2002. Mr Hussain was not an Arabic speaker. He spoke to her through Mr El-Ashwah. He told her he was a solicitor with a lot of experience in migration matters. He could take on her case and could do it in the proper way. He said he had a lot of similar cases and knew the appropriate documentation to lodge. He would need to study her case to decide which was the best way to proceed. He disparaged her current migration agent as ‘not the best migration agent’ and said he was approaching her case in ‘the wrong way’. Mr Hussain gave SZFDE a business card. It bore the heading ‘Dalton Legal’ above the words ‘Fahmi M Hussain SOLICITOR’. A mobile phone number was handwritten on it. SZFDE paid him the sum of $1,500 in advance for work she expected him to do. He wrote on the back of the card an acknowledgment of receipt of $1,500 on account of his professional fees. The acknowledgement was dated 27 July 2002. SZFDE said that she engaged Mr Hussain to act for her in her application to the Tribunal. When the application was lodged she was living at her Sefton address. She moved from that address ‘in late 2002’. At the time of that move she telephoned Mr Hussain and told him in English that she had moved to the new address in Regents Park, which she gave him. In the middle of 2003 SZFDE received a telephone call from Mr Hussain who told her that he had received a letter from the Tribunal. He said that they needed to talk about it. She and her husband then met Mr Hussain at their home which was then at another address in Regents Park. Mr El-Ashwah acted as an interpreter. She recalled seeing the letter of 3 June 2003 from the Tribunal at the meeting.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH, ALLSOP AND GRAHAM JJ (dissent)
On 13 August 2003 the Tribunal wrote to SZFDE at the Regents Park address advising that the decision relating to her case would be given on 2 September 2003. On that date she was advised by the Tribunal that it had decided that she was not entitled to a protection visa. A copy of the Tribunal’s decision and reasons for decision dated 11 August 2003 were attached. The Tribunal’s reasons for decision The Tribunal referred to the relevant provisions of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act) and the definition of ‘refugee’ under the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees (the Convention) and the 1967 Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees. It enunciated unexceptionally the key elements of the Convention definition of ‘refugee’ and their qualification, for the purposes of Australian law, by ss 91R and 91S of the Act. The Tribunal recited the fact of its invitation to the respondents sent on 3 June 2003 to give oral evidence and present arguments at a hearing on 5 August 2003. It recorded that on 30 July 2003 they advised the Tribunal that they did not wish to give oral evidence and would like it to proceed to make its decision ‘on the papers’. The Tribunal therefore determined the application on the evidence available to it. The Tribunal observed that only SZFDE had made specific claims under the Convention with her husband and children relying on their membership of her family to support their applications for protection visas. The Tribunal set out the essential claims relied upon by SZFDE which have already been summarised. It noted that the submission made on her behalf included copies of identity cards as proof of her occupation, passports for herself and the members of her family, employment certificates of competence, education certificates and various newspaper articles. The Tribunal referred to the letter sent to SZFDE on 25 July 2002 in which it set out information about Altawheed to the effect that it was a spent force, that Lebanese authorities had regained authority in Tripoli and that Lebanese citizens, since 1992, favoured unity over fundamentalism. It summarised SZFDE’s reply given on 12 August 2002. The Tribunal reviewed country information from the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) Country Information Reports. A report dated 7 July 2000 stated that Syrian forces had broken up Altawheed and other extremist groups in a series of armed assaults from 1985. As a result most of Altawheed’s membership had dispersed. A person called Shaaban had claimed to represent the Altawheed Movement until his death in 1998. Lebanese security agents continued to investigate and infiltrate extremist groups. In 1997 security authorities attacked a building in Tripoli which was said to house a radio and television station associated with Altawheed. In December 1999 a military court sentenced to death five persons, alleged to have Altawheed affiliations, for grenade attacks on churches in Tripoli. The report stated that authorities continued to seek to interdict extremist/violent groups. Another report dated 1 February 2000 also mentioned clashes between the Lebanese Army and members of Altawheed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by:

The powers of the Tribunal on a review are set out in s 415. It may exercise all the powers and discretions conferred by the Act on the person who made the decision under review (s 415(1)). It may affirm or vary the decision or, in certain cases, remit it for reconsideration with directions or recommendations permitted by the Regulations or it may set the decision aside and substitute a new one. Statutory framework – natural justice and the operation of the Tribunal Division 3 of Part 7 is entitled ‘Exercise of Refugee Review Tribunal’s Powers’. Section 420 prescribes the way in which the Tribunal is to operate:‘(1)The Tribunal, in carrying out its functions under this Act, is to pursue the objective of providing a mechanism of review that is fair, just, economical, informal and quick.(2) The Tribunal, in reviewing a decision: (a)is not bound by technicalities, legal forms or rules of evidence; and (b)must act according to substantial justice and the merits of the case.’ Division 4 of Part 7 deals with the conduct of the review. Section 422B provides: ‘Exhaustive statement of natural justice hearing rule.(1)This Division is taken to be an exhaustive statement of the requirements of the natural justice hearing rule in relation to the matters it deals with.(2)Sections 416, 437 and 438 and Division 7A, in so far as they relate to this Division, are taken to be an exhaustive statement of the requirements of the natural justice hearing rule in relation to the matters they deal with.’Statutory framework - the invitation to a hearing Section 424 authorises the Tribunal to obtain any information which it considers relevant and invite a person to give additional information. The Tribunal is required, under s 424A, to provide to the applicant particulars of any information that the Tribunal considers would be the reason, or a part of the reason, for affirming the decision that is under review. The Tribunal must also ensure, as far as is reasonably practicable, that the applicant understands why the information is relevant to the review and invite the applicant to comment on it. Importantly for present purposes are ss 425 and 426A. Section 425 provides: ‘(1)The Tribunal must invite the applicant to appear before the Tribunal to give evidence and present arguments relating to the issues arising in relation to the decision under review.(2)Subsection (1) does not apply if: (a)the Tribunal considers that it should decide the review in the applicant’s favour on the basis of the material before it; or (b)the applicant consents to the Tribunal deciding the review without the applicant appearing before it; or(c)subsection 424C(1) or (2) applies to the applicant. (3)If any of the paragraphs in subsection (2) of this section apply, the applicant is not entitled to appear before the Tribunal.’Section 426A provides: ‘(1)If the applicant: (a)is invited under section 425 to appear before the Tribunal; and(b)does not appear before the Tribunal on the day on which, or at the time and place at which, the applicant is scheduled to appear; The Tribunal may make a decision on the review without taking any further action to allow or enable the applicant to appear before it.(2)This section does not prevent the Tribunal from rescheduling the applicant’s appearance before it, or from delaying its decision on the review in order to enable the applicant’s appearance before it as rescheduled.’ Statutory framework – the privative clause