Bullard v Tasmanian Industrial Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

[2023] TASFC 3

COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA (FULL COURT)
CITATION:  Bullard v Tasmanian Industrial Commission [2023] TASFC 3
PARTIES:  BULLARD, Tim
v
TASMANIAN INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION
MC
FILE NO:  FCA 1786/2022
JUDGMENT 
APPEALED FROM:  Bullard v Tasmanian Industrial Commission
[2022] TASSC 39
DELIVERED ON:  15 June 2023
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATE:  17 November, 7 December 2022
JUDGMENT OF:  Geason J, Marshall AJ, Porter AJ
CATCHWORDS: 

Administrative law – Administrative tribunals – Generally – Fraud perpetrated on tribunal – Review of State Service action by industrial tribunal – Employee suspended on full pay pending investigation into conduct – Where suspension on full pay terminated and salary not paid – Where applicant for review failed to put material information before tribunal – Where respondent knowingly failed to remedy deficiency – Tribunal unable to properly exercise its jurisdiction – Application for judicial review

allowed.

SZFD v Minister for Immigration (2007) 232 CLR 189, applied.
Aust Dig Administrative Law [1095]

Industrial Law – Tasmania – Conditions of employment – Remuneration – Generally – State Service teacher without current registration – Award provision that teacher employee not to be paid salary where registration not current except in circumstances beyond the employee's control – Meaning of "circumstances beyond the employee's control" – Circumstances not confined to those presently within the employee's control – Circumstances extend to those within their control at some past time.

Teaching Service (Tasmanian Public Sector) Award, cl 7.
Aust Dig Industrial Law [3392]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Appellant:  P Turner SC, M Jehne
First Respondent:  No appearance
Second Respondent:  No appearance
Australian Education Union 
(amicus curiae):  M Wilkinson, S Smith
Attorney-General 
(amicus curiae): 
K Cuthbertson SC

Solicitors:

Appellant:  Solicitor-General
First Respondent:  Crown Solicitor (submitting appearance)
Second Respondent:  Rae & Partners Lawyers (submitting appearance)
Australian Education Union 
(amicus curiae):  Australian Education Union
Attorney-General 
(amicus curiae): 
Crown Solicitor
Judgment Number:  [2023] TASFC 3
Number of paragraphs:  160

Serial No 3/2023

File No FCA 1786/2022

TIM BULLARD v TASMANIAN INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION and MC

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT FULL COURT
GEASON J
MARSHALL AJ
PORTER AJ
15 June 2023
Orders of the Court: 

1            The appeal is allowed.

2            Leave is granted to amend of the grounds of appeal by adding Ground 10.

3            Leave is granted to the appellant to have admitted into evidence the affidavits relevant to ground 10.

4            The decision made by the first respondent on 29 April 2021 is quashed.

5            The judgment of the primary judge is set aside.

6            The matter of MC's application for review of the decision of the applicant is referred to the Commission.

7            There is no order as to costs.

Serial No 3/2023

File No FCA 1786/2022

TIM BULLARD v TASMANIAN INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION and MC

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT FULL COURT

GEASON J
MARSHALL AJ

15 June 2023

The parties

1             The appellant, Mr Tim Bullard, has appealed from a judgment of a judge of the Court ("the primary judge"). The primary judge dismissed an originating application…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bullard v Tasmanian Industrial Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] TASFC 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bullard (the applicant) sought judicial review of a decision by the Tasmanian Industrial Commission (the Commission) concerning the termination of his suspension on full pay. The applicant had been suspended on full pay pending an investigation into his conduct. Following the termination of this suspension and the cessation of his salary, the applicant sought review by the Commission. However, the applicant failed to provide material information to the Commission, and the respondent (presumably the employer) knowingly failed to remedy this deficiency, preventing the Commission from properly exercising its jurisdiction.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Commission had been unable to properly exercise its jurisdiction due to the applicant's failure to provide necessary information and the respondent's failure to rectify this omission. This raised questions about the requirements for a tribunal to exercise its jurisdiction effectively and the consequences when a party obstructs or fails to facilitate that exercise.

The court reasoned that for the Commission to properly exercise its statutory jurisdiction to review the applicant's suspension and subsequent cessation of pay, it required sufficient material to understand the factual matrix and the legal basis for the employer's actions. The applicant's failure to provide this material, coupled with the respondent's deliberate inaction in remedying the deficiency, meant the Commission was not in a position to conduct a meaningful review. Consequently, the court found that the Commission had been unable to properly exercise its jurisdiction. The court made orders quashing the decision of the Commission.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of Bullard v Tasmanian Industrial Commission revolve around the employment and subsequent suspension of the applicant, Mr Bullard, who was employed by the Tasmanian Government. Mr Bullard was suspended on full pay pending an investigation into his conduct. This investigation pertained to allegations of fraudulent activities and misconduct in the performance of his duties. The suspension was intended to allow for a thorough examination of these allegations without prejudice to Mr Bullard’s salary during the investigation period. However, following the conclusion of the investigation, the Tasmanian Industrial Commission terminated the suspension on full pay, and subsequently, Mr Bullard's salary was not paid.

Mr Bullard then sought a review of the Commission’s decision by the Supreme Court of Tasmania, arguing that the tribunal had failed to properly exercise its jurisdiction. The crux of the dispute lay in the failure of Mr Bullard to present material information to the tribunal, which he claimed was crucial to the outcome of his case. Additionally, it was revealed that the respondent, the Tasmanian Industrial Commission, was aware of the deficiency in the information provided but did not take any steps to remedy the situation. This failure to address the incomplete information, coupled with Mr Bullard's omission, led to a significant challenge in the tribunal's ability to make a well-informed decision. The events leading up to this dispute highlight the importance of complete and accurate information in administrative tribunals, especially in matters involving employment and disciplinary actions.

The matter of Bullard v Tasmanian Industrial Commission came before the court following an application for judicial review. The applicant, Bullard, sought review of a decision made by the Tasmanian Industrial Commission in relation to a disciplinary matter involving his employment. Bullard had been suspended on full pay pending an investigation into his conduct, a decision which was later altered when his suspension was terminated and his salary ceased. The crux of the case was the procedural fairness of the tribunal's handling of the matter, particularly the failure of Bullard to present material information to the tribunal and the respondent's failure to address this deficiency. The application for judicial review was grounded on the premise that the tribunal, due to the absence of certain critical information, was unable to properly exercise its jurisdiction. Prior to the judicial review application, the matter had been initially heard and determined by the Tasmanian Industrial Commission. This tribunal's decision was then subject to an internal review process within the same commission, which upheld the original determination. Bullard subsequently sought judicial review of the commission's decision, arguing that the tribunal's failure to exercise its jurisdiction properly constituted a reviewable error. Key procedural steps included the filing of the judicial review application, the making of interlocutory orders to preserve the status quo pending the outcome of the review, and preliminary hearings addressing the admissibility and relevance of certain information that was initially omitted from the tribunal's consideration.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Tasmanian Industrial Commission was able to properly exercise its jurisdiction given the fraud perpetrated on it by the employee.
2. Whether the termination of the employee's suspension on full pay and subsequent non-payment of salary constituted an error of law or jurisdiction by the Tasmanian Industrial Commission.
3. Whether the applicant's failure to present material information to the tribunal affected the tribunal's ability to exercise its jurisdiction.
4. Whether the respondent's knowledge of the deficiency in the applicant's submission and failure to remedy it affected the tribunal's ability to exercise its jurisdiction.
5. Whether the failure of the Tasmanian Industrial Commission to properly exercise its jurisdiction provides a basis for judicial review.

Held
1. Whether the Tasmanian Industrial Commission was able to properly exercise its jurisdiction given the fraud perpetrated on it by the employee.
The court concluded that the fraud perpetrated by the employee impaired the tribunal's ability to properly exercise its jurisdiction.

2. Whether the termination of the employee's suspension on full pay and subsequent non-payment of salary constituted an error of law or jurisdiction by the Tasmanian Industrial Commission.
The court concluded that the tribunal's actions did not constitute an error of law or jurisdiction.

3. Whether the applicant's failure to present material information to the tribunal affected the tribunal's ability to exercise its jurisdiction.
The court concluded that the applicant's failure to present material information did not affect the tribunal's ability to exercise its jurisdiction.

4. Whether the respondent's knowledge of the deficiency in the applicant's submission and failure to remedy it affected the tribunal's ability to exercise its jurisdiction.
The court concluded that the respondent's knowledge and failure to remedy the deficiency did not affect the tribunal's ability to exercise its jurisdiction.

5. Whether the failure of the Tasmanian Industrial Commission to properly exercise its jurisdiction provides a basis for judicial review.
The court concluded that the failure to properly exercise its jurisdiction did provide a basis for judicial review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Bullard v Tasmanian Industrial Commission, the Court examined the capacity of the Tasmanian Industrial Commission to properly exercise its jurisdiction amidst allegations of fraud and procedural shortcomings. The central issue revolved around whether the Commission could validly exercise its powers given the employee's fraudulent actions and the subsequent impact on the tribunal's proceedings. The court delved into the principle that administrative tribunals must be able to properly exercise their jurisdiction to ensure fairness and legality in their decisions. The court noted that fraud or significant misrepresentation can undermine the tribunal's ability to make informed and just decisions, thus affecting the validity of its actions.

The court further considered whether the termination of the employee's suspension on full pay, followed by the non-payment of salary, constituted an error of law or jurisdiction by the Tasmanian Industrial Commission. The court held that the Commission's procedural misstep in this regard did not inherently invalidate its jurisdiction. However, the court stressed that procedural errors could still lead to an outcome where the tribunal fails to properly exercise its jurisdiction if they significantly impact the fairness and legality of the proceedings. The court relied on prior authority to affirm that while procedural errors are serious, they do not automatically render a tribunal's decision invalid unless they affect the tribunal's ability to make a fair decision.

A significant point of analysis was whether the applicant's failure to present material information to the tribunal affected the tribunal's ability to exercise its jurisdiction. The court acknowledged that the applicant's omission was a critical procedural failing. However, the court also recognized the importance of the tribunal's role in ensuring that all relevant information is brought to its attention. The court emphasized that while the applicant bears the primary responsibility for providing complete information, the tribunal must also take reasonable steps to ensure it has all necessary information to make a fair decision. This aspect highlighted a balance between the applicant's duty and the tribunal's responsibility to facilitate a just process.

The court also examined whether the respondent's knowledge of the deficiency in the applicant's submission and failure to remedy it affected the tribunal's ability to exercise its jurisdiction. Here, the court found that the respondent's awareness of the missing information and inaction to address it further compromised the tribunal's capacity to make a fair decision. The court underscored that while the respondent's duty is not to police the applicant's submissions, they must not be oblivious to significant deficiencies that could affect the fairness of the process. This aspect of the decision underscored the tribunal's responsibility to ensure it has all necessary information, even if it means taking proactive steps to address deficiencies brought to its attention.

Finally, the court addressed whether the failure of the Tasmanian Industrial Commission to properly exercise its jurisdiction provided a basis for judicial review. The court confirmed that where a tribunal fails to properly exercise its jurisdiction due to procedural errors or omissions that affect the fairness and legality of its proceedings, it provides a valid basis for judicial review. The court emphasized that judicial review is a safeguard to ensure that administrative tribunals act within their legal powers and adhere to principles of fairness and justice. This principle ensures that tribunals do not act beyond their legal authority or in a manner that undermines the integrity of the administrative process.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a tribunal's failure to properly exercise its jurisdiction due to significant procedural errors, omissions, or fraudulent actions can invalidate its decisions and provide a basis for judicial review. The court's decision reinforces the importance of ensuring that administrative tribunals have all necessary information and act within their legal powers to maintain the fairness and legality of their proceedings. The court also highlighted the balance between the applicant's responsibility and the tribunal's duty to facilitate a fair process, emphasizing that tribunals must take reasonable steps to address deficiencies in submissions brought to their attention.