[2022] TASSC 39
COURT: SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
CITATION: Bullard v Tasmanian Industrial Commission [2022] TASSC 39
PARTIES: BULLARD, Tim
v
TASMANIAN INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION
FILE NO: 1013/2021
DELIVERED ON: 16 June 2022
DELIVERED AT: Hobart
HEARING DATE: 17 September 2021
JUDGMENT OF: Blow CJ
CATCHWORDS:
Industrial Law – Tasmania – Industrial Commission – Jurisdiction and Powers – Tasmanian State Service – Power to direct Head of Agency to take such action as the Commission considers appropriate – Whether power to direct retrospective reinstatement of teacher's suspension on full pay.
State Service Act 2000 (Tas), s 51(6)(c).
Aust Dig Industrial Law [3380]
Industrial Law – Tasmania – Conditions of Employment – Remuneration – Generally – Teacher without current registration – Salary not to be paid except in circumstances beyond employee's control.
Teaching Service (Tasmanian Public Sector) Award, Part II, cl 7.
Aust Dig Industrial Law [3392]
REPRESENTATION:
Counsel:
Applicant: P Turner SC, M Jehne
Respondent: No appearance
M P Crocker: A Cohen, Z Lieutier
Solicitors:
Applicant: Solicitor-General
Respondent: Crown Solicitor
M P Crocker: Rae & Partners
Judgment Number: [2022] TASSC 39
Number of paragraphs: 48
Serial No 39/2022
File No 1013/2021
TIM BULLARD v TASMANIAN INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT BLOW CJ
16 June 2022
This is an application under the Judicial Review Act 2000. The applicant, Tim Bullard, is the Secretary of the Department of Education ("the Secretary"). He has applied for judicial review of a decision of Deputy President N M Ellis of the Tasmanian Industrial Commission relating to the remuneration of a teacher named Mark Philip Crocker.
In September 2020 the teacher was notified that a complaint had been made to the Department of Education alleging that in 1989 he had commenced a sexual relationship with a student. For a short time he was suspended from teaching on full pay. On 28 September 2020, the Teachers Registration Board suspended his registration as a teacher pursuant to s 24B of the Teachers Registration Act 2000 on the ground that he posed a risk of harm to students. On 2 October 2020, the Secretary advised the teacher that, because his registration as a teacher was suspended and he was therefore unable to teach, he would no longer be paid a salary as a teacher. The teacher applied to the Commission under s 50(1)(b) of the State Service Act 2000 seeking a review of that decision. On 29 April 2021, Deputy President Ellis made a decision directing the Secretary to reinstate the teacher on suspension with full pay as from 2 October 2020. The Secretary has sought judicial review of her decision.
The sequence of events
It is necessary to go into more detail as to the events leading up to the decision of the Deputy President.
The Teachers Registration Act provides for a system for the registration of teachers. By virtue of s 11(1) of that Act, it is an offence for a person to teach at a school unless the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bullard v Tasmanian Industrial Commission and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] TASSC 39
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with interpreting the specific wording of the award, particularly the phrase "Except in circumstances beyond the employee's control" found in clause 7. The legal question centred on whether this exception could apply to situations where the teacher was not registered at the time of the salary determination, despite the circumstances being beyond the teacher's control. The court examined the ordinary meaning of the words and the context in which they were used, concluding that the exception applied only to circumstances existing at the time of salary determination.
The court found that the exception could cover a wide range of scenarios beyond the teacher's control, such as administrative errors or delays. The court rejected the narrower interpretation proposed by the Secretary, which limited the exception to specific administrative oversights. Instead, it held that the phrase should be interpreted broadly, covering any circumstance outside the teacher's control at the time the issue of salary arises.
In light of the interpretation, the court determined that the Commission did not have the power to direct retrospective reinstatement on full pay. The decision hinged on the understanding that the exception in clause 7 only applied to the specific situation when the teacher was not registered, not to any past circumstances.
Background
Background to the litigation
The sequence of events leading to the current legal dispute includes the initial allegations of misconduct against Mr. Bullard, the subsequent suspension by the Head of Agency, and the eventual lapse of his registration with the Teachers Registration Board. Despite the suspension, Mr. Bullard took steps to address the situation, including applying for a review of the decision by the Teachers Registration Board and considering judicial review. However, these efforts did not yield immediate results, leaving him unregistered and without pay. The Secretary's decision on 2 October 2020, which upheld the non-payment of Mr. Bullard's salary, became the focal point of the dispute. The case revolves around the interpretation of the phrase "circumstances beyond the employee's control" in the relevant award provision, particularly whether it applies to the situation where a teacher is not currently registered and the issue of salary payment arises. The court's task is to determine the scope and meaning of this exception in the context of Mr. Bullard's case.
The matter before the court, Bullard v Tasmanian Industrial Commission, originated in an application made by the Tasmanian Industrial Commission to the Supreme Court of Tasmania for an order to review its decision. This application followed a decision made by the Secretary of the Tasmanian Industrial Commission on 2 October 2020, which determined that a teacher's salary should not be paid due to the teacher's failure to maintain a current registration with the Teachers Registration Board. The applicant, Mr Bullard, sought judicial review of the Secretary's decision, arguing that the relevant clause of the award, specifically Part II cl 7, allowed for exceptions in circumstances beyond the employee's control, which he believed should have applied in his case. The application for judicial review was heard in the Supreme Court, where the court considered the interpretation and application of the award's provisions concerning teacher registration and salary payments.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the phrase "circumstances beyond the employee's control" in Part II cl 7 of the award relate to the time when the question of payment of salary to an unregistered teacher arises, or to circumstances that were within the employee's control at a past time?
2. Can the exception in Part II cl 7 be interpreted to apply only to situations where a teacher is unable to secure registration due to administrative oversight or error, or should the words of the exception be construed more broadly?
3. What is the appropriate scope of the phrase "circumstances beyond a teacher's control" in Part II cl 7, and how should it be applied in the context of this case?
4. Can the teacher be held responsible for attempting to change the circumstances that led to his non-registration, and if so, to what extent?
5. Should the teacher have been paid salary while he was not registered under the Teachers Registration Act, based on the interpretation of Part II cl 7?
Held
1. The phrase "circumstances beyond the employee's control" in Part II cl 7 of the award relates to the time when the question of payment of salary to an unregistered teacher arises, not to circumstances that were within the employee's control at a past time. Result: The court concluded that the phrase refers to the circumstances existing at the time the payment of salary is being determined.
2. The exception in Part II cl 7 can be interpreted to apply to a wide range of circumstances beyond just administrative oversight or error. Result: The court rejected the narrow interpretation proposed by the Secretary and held that the words should be construed more broadly.
3. The appropriate scope of the phrase "circumstances beyond a teacher's control" in Part II cl 7 is broad and should be applied in the context of this case to include various situations where the teacher could not exert control over the outcome. Result: The court accepted the wide interpretation of the phrase.
4. The teacher cannot be held responsible for attempting to change the circumstances that led to his non-registration to the extent that he was not in a position to exert control over certain outcomes. Result: The court acknowledged that the teacher could have taken certain actions but was not in a position to control the outcomes.
5. The teacher should not have been paid salary while he was not registered under the Teachers Registration Act, based on the interpretation of Part II cl 7. Result: The court upheld the Secretary's decision that the teacher was not to be paid a salary while unregistered.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The relevant provision in the award, Part II cl 7, provided as follows:"7 TEACHER REGISTRATIONThe responsibility to maintain a current registration with the Teachers Registration Board rests with the individual teacher employee.In accordance with the Teachers Registration Act 2000, a teacher employee must have a current registration issued by the Teachers Registration Board.Except in circumstances beyond the employee's control, where a teacher employee is not currently registered as detailed above, the employee will not be paid salary until a current registration certificate is issued." As I have said, I infer from the Secretary's decision of 2 October 2020 that he took the view that the exception relating to "circumstances beyond the employee's control" did not apply, and that the teacher was therefore not to be paid a salary while he was not registered under the Teachers Registration Act. It is necessary to consider the meaning of the words "Except in circumstances beyond the employee's control" in cl 7. When interpreting the words of any written instrument, it is appropriate to take into account the text, context and purpose of the provision in question. In their ordinary literal meaning, the words in question clearly refer to the circumstances existing at the time when the question of payment of a salary to an unregistered teacher arises for determination. The words cannot reasonably be interpreted as referring to circumstances that were within the employee's control at some past time, but are no longer within the employee's control. The structure of the final sentence of cl 7 indicates that the exception in relation to circumstances beyond a teacher employee's control relates to the situation at a time when the teacher employee is not currently registered under the Teachers Registration Act, and the issue of payment of salary arises. Counsel for the Secretary argued that the exception was intended to apply only to the sort of situation where a teacher was unable to secure registration because of some sort of administrative oversight or error, such as a delay in processing a payment, resulting in a teacher being unregistered due to circumstances beyond his or her control. No doubt the exception would apply in that sort of situation. However there is no reason to give the words of the exception such a restricted interpretation. The range of possible circumstances beyond a teacher's control is no doubt very wide, and the words of the exception should be construed accordingly. I accept that the teacher could have attempted to change the relevant circumstances in various ways. He could have applied to the Magistrates Court for a review of the decision of the Teachers Registration Board. He could have sought judicial review of the decision of the Registrar. He could have tried to persuade the Board or the Registrar to reverse their decisions. However he was not in a position to exert control in relation to the outcome of an application to the Magistrates Court, the outcome of a judicial review proceeding, the possibility of any decision being reversed, the willingness of the complainant to maintain her allegations as to his conduct, or anything else.