Amalgamated Collieries of WA Ltd v True

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read
59 CLR 417

AMALGAMATED COLLIERIES OF W.A. LTD. APPELLANT TRUE

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Industrial ArbitrationAward-Basic wage-Mining-Day wages-Tonnage rates

-Automatic adjustment of basic wage-Basic wage decreasedReduction not applicable to tonnage rates-Statutory right to wages prescribed in ward-Limita- tion of time for recovery of wages-Contract to pay wages-Limitation of time applicable to recovery of wages due under contract or under statutory right- Industrial Arbitration Act 1912-1935 (W.A.) (No. 57 of 1912-No. 6 of 1935), secs. 83, 92, 121, 123, 124, 176 (2).

The Industrial Arbitration Act 1912-1935 (W.A.) provided for a periodical ascertainment of the basic wage (sec. 121), required that awards of the Court of Arbitration should prescribe and distinguish separately (a) the basic wage, and (b) other wages or allowances and/or additional remuneration (sec. 123), and provided that the basic wage prescribed in every award of the court should, from time to time, automatically become increased or decreased SO that it conforms to and is in parity with the basic wage as last determined by the court (sec. 124).

An award applying to the coal-mining industry declared, under the heading Day Wages," that the rates of wages fixed by it were based upon the basic wage fixed by the Court of Arbitration at a date specified, being a minimum of 13s. 10d. for a shift of eight hours it then declared minimum wages by stating the `margin' for skill which was to be added to the basic wage; under the heading Tonnage Rates," it declared that miners working on tonnage rates should be paid a specified sum per ton. The plaintiff was employed by the defendant under a verbal contract to work as a miner at tonnage rates in

59 CLR 418

Held, by the whole court, that the provision of sec. 124 of the Act for the automatic readjustment of the basic wage applied only to the day wages fixed by the award, and not to the tonnage rates; accordingly, the plaintiff was entitled to be paid the full amount of the tonnage rates stated in the award, notwithstanding that there had been a decrease in day wages because of a readjustment of the basic wage.

The Act also provided that an award should be a common rule in the industry to which it applied (sec. 83), and that every worker should be entitled to be paid by his employer in accordance with any award which was applicable,

notwithstanding any contract or pretended contract to the contrary, and such worker may recover as wages the amount to which he is hereby declared entitled in any court of competent jurisdiction, but every action for the recovery of any such amount must be commenced within twelve months from the time when the cause of action arose " (sec. 176 (2) ).

Held, by Latham C.J., Starke and Dixon JJ. (Evatt and McTiernan JJ. dis- senting), that an action by the plaintiff, based on his contract, to recover an amount which the defendant, his employer, had wrongly deducted…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Amalgamated Collieries of WA Ltd v True and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1938] HCA 19
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, Amalgamated Collieries of W.A. Ltd., appealed to the High Court of Australia from a decision of the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The dispute concerned the correct calculation of wages for the respondent, Mr. True, a coal miner employed by the appellant. Mr. True was engaged to work at tonnage rates, as stipulated in an award of the Court of Arbitration of Western Australia. The appellant had deducted a sum of £8 1s. 9d. from Mr. True's earnings, claiming this was permissible due to a decrease in the basic wage, which it argued should automatically reduce tonnage rates. Mr. True contended he was entitled to the full tonnage rates as per the award.

The High Court was required to determine two primary legal issues. Firstly, whether the provisions of the *Industrial Arbitration Act 1912-1935* (W.A.), specifically section 124, mandated an automatic adjustment of tonnage rates in response to fluctuations in the basic wage. Secondly, the Court had to consider the application of section 176(2) of the Act, which imposed a twelve-month limitation period on actions for the recovery of wages due under an award, and whether this limitation applied to Mr. True's claim, which was based on a verbal contract incorporating the award's terms.

A majority of the High Court (Latham C.J., Starke and Dixon JJ.) held that the automatic adjustment provision in section 124 of the Act applied only to "day wages" prescribed in the award, not to "tonnage rates." The Court reasoned that tonnage rates were fixed per unit of coal mined, and their calculation was not directly linked to the basic wage in a manner that allowed for automatic adjustment under the statute. Therefore, Mr. True was entitled to the full tonnage rates as specified in the award, irrespective of changes in the basic wage. Regarding the limitation period, the majority found that section 176(2) applied to all actions for the recovery of wages due under an award, even if the claim was also framed as a breach of contract. Consequently, Mr. True could only recover underpayments made within the twelve months preceding the commencement of his action.

The High Court varied the decision of the Supreme Court. While agreeing that tonnage rates were not automatically reduced, the majority ruled that Mr. True's recovery was limited to the amount of underpayment within the twelve months prior to the action's commencement. This resulted in a reduced judgment for Mr. True of £3 8s. 10d., representing the portion of the claimed underpayment that fell within the statutory limitation period.

Background

Background to the litigation

Gwyn A. True sued Amalgamated Collieries of Western Australia Ltd in the Local Court at Collie, Western Australia, for unpaid wages. The facts of the case were agreed upon by both parties. True was verbally engaged by the defendant company to work as a miner at tonnage rates, not at day wages, at its Proprietary Colliery under the terms and conditions of award No. 32 of 1934 of the Court of Arbitration of Western Australia. During the period of one year preceding 26 September 1936, True's earnings in this employment, at the tonnage rates prescribed by the award, amounted to the sum of £319 8s. 10d. However, the defendant paid True sums totalling only £311 7s. 1d., claiming that owing to reductions from time to time in the basic wage it was entitled to deduct and did deduct from True's earnings sums totalling £8 1s. 9d. for the said period. True claimed the sum of £8 1s. 9d. as being the balance of the wages earned by him and payable to him by the defendant for the said period, pursuant to his contract of service. The court dismissed the claim. True then appealed to the Supreme Court of Western Australia, which ordered that judgment be entered for True for the full amount claimed. The defendant company appealed to the High Court.

The matter came before the High Court of Australia by way of an appeal by special leave from the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The facts of the case were agreed upon by the parties and involved an action commenced on 12 April 1937 by Gwyn A. True against Amalgamated Collieries of W.A. Ltd. in the Local Court at Collie, Western Australia. True claimed the sum of £8 1s. 9d. as the balance of the wages earned by him and payable to him by the defendant company for the period of one year ending 26 September 1936, pursuant to his contract of service. The Local Court dismissed the claim, but the Supreme Court of Western Australia ordered that judgment be entered for True for the full amount claimed. The defendant company appealed to the High Court by special leave. The High Court's decision varied the decision of the Supreme Court of Western Australia, reducing the amount of the judgment to £3 8s. 10d.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does section 124 of the Industrial Arbitration Act 1912-1935 apply to the automatic adjustment of tonnage rates in the award?
2. If section 124 does not apply to tonnage rates, what is the relationship between the tonnage rates and the basic wage prescribed in the award?
3. Does section 176(2) of the Industrial Arbitration Act 1912-1935 limit the time for recovery of wages in this case?
4. If section 176(2) applies, what is the maximum amount the respondent can recover from the appellant?
5. Are there any other legal principles or precedents that should be considered in determining the respondent's right to recover the deducted wages?

Held
1. Does section 124 of the Industrial Arbitration Act 1912-1935 apply to the automatic adjustment of tonnage rates in the award?
- The court held that section 124 does not apply to the automatic adjustment of tonnage rates in the award. The tonnage rates remain fixed and unaffected by alterations of or adjustments in the declared basic wage.

2. If section 124 does not apply to tonnage rates, what is the relationship between the tonnage rates and the basic wage prescribed in the award?
- The relationship between the tonnage rates and the basic wage is not explicitly stated in the award. It is impossible to say whether any arithmetical relation exists between them.

3. Does section 176(2) of the Industrial Arbitration Act 1912-1935 limit the time for recovery of wages in this case?
- The court held that section 176(2) applies to the respondent's right to recover the deducted wages. The respondent can only recover the amount for which judgment should be entered within twelve months from the time when the cause of action arose.

4. If section 176(2) applies, what is the maximum amount the respondent can recover from the appellant?
- The maximum amount the respondent can recover from the appellant is £3 8s. 10d.

5. Are there any other legal principles or precedents that should be considered in determining the respondent's right to recover the deducted wages?
- The court considered various cases and precedents in determining the respondent's right to recover the deducted wages. The court held that the respondent is entitled to sue upon his contract of employment and is not limited by the twelve-month period mentioned in section 176(2).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined whether section 124 of the Industrial Arbitration Act 1912-1935 applied to the automatic adjustment of tonnage rates in the award. The court held that section 124, which provided for the automatic adjustment of the basic wage, did not apply to tonnage rates. The tonnage rates were fixed amounts per ton of coal mined and were not tied to the basic wage in the same manner as day wages were. The court reasoned that the tonnage rates were not adjusted by reference to the basic wage, and therefore, the decrease in the basic wage did not affect the tonnage rates.

Regarding the relationship between tonnage rates and the basic wage prescribed in the award, the court concluded that tonnage rates and the basic wage were distinct components of the award. While the basic wage was adjusted automatically to conform with the court's determination, the tonnage rates remained fixed as specified in the award. The tonnage rates were not derived from the basic wage and were not subject to automatic adjustment based on changes in the basic wage.

The court then considered whether section 176(2) of the Industrial Arbitration Act 1912-1935 limited the time for recovery of wages in this case. Section 176(2) provided that workers could recover wages prescribed in an award within twelve months from when the cause of action arose. The court found that the respondent's claim was based on his contract with the appellant, rather than solely on the award. However, the court held that the limitation period applied to the respondent's claim because he was entitled to recover wages prescribed by the award, regardless of his contract.

The court determined the maximum amount the respondent could recover from the appellant. Given that the action was filed more than twelve months after the cause of action arose, the respondent could only recover wages for the twelve months preceding the filing of the action. The court calculated the recoverable amount to be £3 8s. 10d.

In considering other legal principles and precedents, the court noted that an employee could sue for wages under a contract of employment, even where an award prescribed a specific rate of remuneration. The court distinguished between actions where the employee sought to enforce a statutory right created by the award and actions based on a contractual agreement. The court held that the respondent could recover the deducted wages under his contract, as there was no inconsistency between the contract and the award. The court's decision aligned with previous cases that recognized an employee's right to enforce a valid contract in the ordinary courts, provided the contract was not void, unlawful, or inconsistent with the terms of the award.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the automatic adjustment provisions for the basic wage do not apply to tonnage rates, which remain fixed as specified in the award. The court also held that the twelve-month limitation period for recovering wages applies to actions based on an award, even if the employee's claim is rooted in a contractual agreement. The court distinguished this case from previous authority by clarifying the distinction between statutory rights created by an award and contractual rights between employer and employee.