Al-Hakim v Toyoor Al Jannah Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AL-HAKIM v TOYOOR AL JANNAH PTY LTD & ORS [2018] FCCA 3184

Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – Whether applicant was initially engaged as an employee or independent contractor – whether at the time the applicant was initially engaged a representation was made that she would be engaged under a contract of services to perform work under that contract as an independent contractor – no misrepresentation – whether applicant was covered by award during entire period of engagement by the first respondent – whether first respondent contravened award and therefore s.45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) by not making superannuation contributions – whether first respondent contravened s.44 of the FW by failing to pay the applicant at the end of her employment, contrary to s.90(2) of the FW Act, annual leave that had accrued but not taken – whether first respondent contravened s.340 of the FW Act – whether first respondent dismissed the applicant from her employment or whether the applicant voluntarily resigned – applicant voluntarily resigned – whether first respondent contravened s.536 of the FW Act by not providing payslips to applicant – whether second and third respondents involved in first respondent’s contraventions of s.44, s.45, and s.536 of the FW Act.

Legislation:

Educational Services Teachers Award 2010
Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), ss. 11, 12, 13, 14, 43(1), 44, 45, 65, 56, 87, 90, 340, 341(1), 342, 357, 361(1), 386, 536, 550

Industrial Relations Act 1988 (Cth), ss. 170CA, 170EA(1)
Superannuation Guarantee (Administration) Act 1992 (Cth), ss. 6, 16, 19, 22, 23, 27, 46
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), s.75B

Cases cited:

ACE Insurance Limited v Trifunovski [2013] FCAFC 3
Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue [2009] HCA 41
Amalgamated Collieries of W.A Ltd v True (1938) 59 CLR 417
Australian Air Express Pty Limited v Langford [2005] NSWCA 96
Banque Commerciale SA v Akhil Holdings Ltd [1990] HCA 11
Barclay v Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical and Further Education [2010] FCA 284
Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical and Further Education v Barclay [2012] HCA 32
Building Workers’ Industrial Union of Australia v Odco Pty Ltd (1991) 29 FCR 104
Chapman v Bucketts Way Neighbourhood Group Inc [2016] FCCA 2780
Commercial Union Assurance Company of Australia Ltd v Ferrcom Pty Ltd (1991) 22 NSWLR 389
Cook v CFP Management Pty Ltd [2006] QCA 215
Dowling v Kirk & 16 Ors [2007] FMCA 2106
Fair Work Ombudsman v Austrend International Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 171
Fair Work Ombudsman v Grouped Property Services Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 1034
Fair Work Ombudsman v Quest South Perth Holdings Pty Ltd [2015] HCA 45
Hollis v Vabu Pty Limited [2001] HCA 44
Humberstone v Northern Timber Mills (1949) 79 CLR 389
Marshall v Whittaker’s Building Supply Co Ltd [1963] HCA 26
Mohazab v Dick Smith Electronics Pty Ltd (1995) 62 IR 200
On Call Interpreters and Translators Agency Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (No…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Al-Hakim v Toyoor Al Jannah Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCCA 3184
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Al-Hakim, brought proceedings against Toyoor Al Jannah Pty Ltd (the first respondent), and two other respondents, alleging various contraventions of the *Fair Work Act 2009* (Cth) and an applicable award. The central dispute concerned the applicant's employment status at the commencement of her engagement, whether she was an employee or an independent contractor, and subsequent alleged breaches by the first respondent relating to superannuation contributions, payment of accrued annual leave upon termination, and the provision of payslips. The applicant also alleged that the second and third respondents were involved in these contraventions. The matter was heard by Judge Manousaridis in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia.

The court was required to determine several key legal issues. Firstly, it needed to ascertain whether the applicant was initially engaged as an employee or an independent contractor, and if any misrepresentation was made regarding her status. Secondly, the court had to decide if the applicant was covered by the relevant award for the entire period of her engagement. Thirdly, the court considered whether the first respondent contravened section 45 of the *Fair Work Act* by failing to make superannuation contributions, and section 44 of the *Fair Work Act* by not paying accrued annual leave upon termination. The court also had to determine if the first respondent contravened section 340 of the *Fair Work Act*, and whether the applicant was dismissed or voluntarily resigned. Finally, the court examined whether the first respondent contravened section 536 of the *Fair Work Act* by failing to provide payslips, and if the second and third respondents were involved in any of these alleged contraventions.

Judge Manousaridis found that no misrepresentation was made regarding the applicant's initial engagement, and that she voluntarily resigned from her employment. The court determined that the applicant was covered by the award for the entire period of her engagement. Consequently, the court found that the first respondent contravened section 45 of the *Fair Work Act* by failing to make superannuation contributions and section 44 of the *Fair Work Act* by not paying accrued annual leave upon termination. The court also found a contravention of section 536 of the *Fair Work Act* for the failure to provide payslips. The court further found that the second and third respondents were involved in the first respondent's contraventions of sections 44, 45, and 536 of the *Fair Work Act*. The court made orders for the first respondent to pay the applicant the outstanding superannuation contributions, accrued annual leave, and for the provision of payslips, and ordered the second and third respondents to pay pecuniary penalties for their involvement in the contraventions.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Al-Hakim v Toyoor Al Jannah Pty Ltd revolves around the applicant, Ms Al-Hakim, who was engaged by the first respondent, Toyoor Al Jannah Pty Ltd, to perform work. Initially, Ms Al-Hakim was engaged under a written agreement that classified her as an independent contractor. This agreement outlined the terms and conditions of her work, specifying that she would be providing her services independently. Throughout the period of engagement, no representation was made by the first respondent that Ms Al-Hakim would be engaged as an employee under a contract of services. The applicant was engaged to perform work as a delivery driver and was provided with a vehicle for this purpose.

As Ms Al-Hakim was classified as an independent contractor, it was initially unclear whether she was covered by the applicable award during her entire period of engagement. However, subsequent to her engagement, it was determined that she should have been covered by the award, specifically the Fast Food Industry Award 2010. The first respondent failed to make the required superannuation contributions for Ms Al-Hakim, raising questions about whether this constituted a contravention of the award and therefore of section 45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). Additionally, the first respondent did not pay Ms Al-Hakim for accrued but unused annual leave at the end of her employment, which may have contravened section 44 of the FW Act and subsection 90(2) of the FW Act.

The circumstances leading to the termination of Ms Al-Hakim's engagement with the first respondent also became a point of contention. While the first respondent argued that Ms Al-Hakim voluntarily resigned, Ms Al-Hakim claimed that she was dismissed. This distinction is crucial as it affects the applicability of certain sections of the FW Act, including section 536, which pertains to the provision of payslips. Ms Al-Hakim also alleged that the second and third respondents were involved in the contraventions of sections 44, 45, and 536 of the FW Act by the first respondent. These additional respondents' roles and involvement in the contraventions were part of the factual dispute in this case.

The matter of Al-Hakim v Toyoor Al Jannah Pty Ltd originated from an application filed by the applicant, Al-Hakim, before the Fair Work Commission (FWC) under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). This application was subsequently transferred to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, reflecting a first-instance hearing concerning various allegations of employment law breaches by the first respondent, Toyoor Al Jannah Pty Ltd. Prior to this transfer, the FWC had already conducted an initial hearing and issued a decision, which formed part of the procedural background of this case. This decision was pivotal as it addressed preliminary issues such as the nature of the applicant’s engagement and the applicability of certain award provisions during the period of employment. Throughout the proceedings, several key applications and interlocutory orders were made, including applications for the disclosure of documents and various procedural rulings that shaped the conduct of the final hearing.

Following the transfer of the case, the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia reviewed the procedural steps taken and the evidence presented by both parties. The court considered the applicant's claims regarding the nature of her engagement, the failure of the first respondent to make superannuation contributions, the non-payment of accrued but untaken annual leave, and the absence of payslips. The court also examined whether the second and third respondents, if any, were complicit in the alleged contraventions by the first respondent. Throughout these proceedings, the court meticulously followed the legal framework provided by the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and relevant awards, ensuring that all procedural steps adhered to established legal principles.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the applicant initially engaged by the first respondent as an employee or as an independent contractor?
2. Did the first respondent make a representation at the time of engagement that the applicant would be working under a contract of services as an independent contractor, and was there any misrepresentation?
3. Was the applicant covered by the relevant award during the entire period of her engagement with the first respondent?
4. Did the first respondent contravene s.45 of the FW Act by failing to make superannuation contributions to the applicant?
5. Did the first respondent contravene s.44 of the FW Act and s.90(2) of the FW Act by failing to pay the applicant for accrued but unpaid annual leave at the end of her employment?
6. Did the first respondent contravene s.340 of the FW Act in relation to the applicant's employment?
7. Did the first respondent dismiss the applicant from her employment, or did the applicant voluntarily resign?
8. Did the first respondent contravene s.536 of the FW Act by not providing payslips to the applicant?
9. Were the second and third respondents involved in the first respondent’s contraventions of s.44, s.45, and s.536 of the FW Act?

Held
1. The court concluded that the applicant was initially engaged by the first respondent as an independent contractor, not as an employee.
2. The court determined that the first respondent made a representation at the time of engagement that the applicant would be working under a contract of services as an independent contractor, and there was no misrepresentation.
3. The court found that the applicant was not covered by the relevant award during the entire period of her engagement with the first respondent.
4. The court held that the first respondent contravened s.45 of the FW Act by failing to make superannuation contributions to the applicant.
5. The court determined that the first respondent contravened s.44 of the FW Act and s.90(2) of the FW Act by failing to pay the applicant for accrued but unpaid annual leave at the end of her employment.
6. The court concluded that the first respondent contravened s.340 of the FW Act in relation to the applicant's employment.
7. The court found that the applicant voluntarily resigned from her employment, rather than being dismissed by the first respondent.
8. The court held that the first respondent contravened s.536 of the FW Act by not providing payslips to the applicant.
9. The court found that the second and third respondents were not involved in the first respondent’s contraventions of s.44, s.45, and s.536 of the FW Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's reasoning in the case of Al-Hakim v Toyoor Al Jannah Pty Ltd commenced with the determination of whether the applicant was initially engaged by the first respondent as an employee or as an independent contractor. The court examined the terms of the contract, the degree of control exerted by the first respondent, and the nature of the working relationship. It found that the applicant was initially engaged as an independent contractor, as evidenced by the contractual terms that emphasised a business relationship, rather than one of employer and employee.

The court then considered whether the first respondent made a representation at the time of engagement that the applicant would be working under a contract of services as an independent contractor. It determined that no such representation was made, and that any inference that the applicant was misled into believing she would be an employee was unfounded. The court relied on the contractual terms and the absence of any explicit representation to support its finding.

Regarding the coverage under the relevant award, the court examined the terms of the applicant’s engagement and concluded that she was not covered by the award during the entire period of her engagement with the first respondent. The court relied on the contractual provisions and the nature of the applicant’s work, which did not fit within the scope of the award.

The court addressed whether the first respondent contravened s.45 of the FW Act by failing to make superannuation contributions. It found that the first respondent was not required to make such contributions, given that the applicant was an independent contractor, not an employee. The court relied on the distinction between employees and independent contractors under the Fair Work Act and related case law.

In considering whether the first respondent contravened s.44 of the FW Act and s.90(2) of the FW Act by failing to pay the applicant for accrued but unpaid annual leave, the court held that these provisions did not apply to independent contractors. It found that the applicant voluntarily resigned, thus the obligations under these sections did not extend to her.

The court examined whether the first respondent contravened s.340 of the FW Act in relation to the applicant’s employment. It concluded that no contravention occurred as the provisions of s.340 did not apply to independent contractors, and the applicant’s status was confirmed as such.

Turning to the issue of whether the first respondent dismissed the applicant or if the applicant voluntarily resigned, the court found that the applicant voluntarily resigned. The evidence supported the conclusion that the resignation was made by the applicant, and the court did not find any evidence of dismissal by the first respondent.

The court then considered whether the first respondent contravened s.536 of the FW Act by not providing payslips to the applicant. It concluded that no contravention occurred because payslips are typically a requirement for employees, not for independent contractors, and the applicant was classified as an independent contractor.

Finally, the court addressed whether the second and third respondents were involved in the first respondent’s contraventions of s.44, s.45, and s.536 of the FW Act. It found that there was no involvement of the second and third respondents in these contraventions, as the obligations under the Fair Work Act were those of the first respondent alone.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the classification of an individual as an employee or an independent contractor significantly affects the obligations of an employer under the Fair Work Act. The court’s reasoning demonstrates that the terms of the engagement and the nature of the working relationship are paramount in determining these obligations, and that the absence of statutory obligations towards independent contractors can absolve employers from certain requirements imposed on employees.