Dzaff v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

DZAFF v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 569

Citation: DZAFF v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 569
Appeal from: DZAFF v Minister for Immigration [2015] FCCA 544
Parties: DZAFF v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION and WENDY BODDISON IN HER CAPACITY AS INDEPENDENT MERITS REVIEWER
File number: NTD 4 of 2015
Judge: MANSFIELD J
Date of judgment: 11 June 2015
Catchwords: MIGRATION – appeal from Federal Circuit Court and Independent Merits Reviewer decision – whether notification of adverse information and invitation to comment given to agent was sufficient notification – procedural fairness – decision made in absence of response – in circumstances, notification insufficient
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth)
Cases cited: Plaintiff M61/2010E (2010) 243 CLR 319
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Bhardwaj (2002) 209 CLR 597
NAFF v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2004) 221 CLR 1
Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Lam (2003) 214 CLR 1
SZFDE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2007) 232 CLR 189,
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v SZFDE (2006) 154 FCR 365
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v George (2004) 139 FCR 127
Osborne v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2002) 124 FCR 416
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v SZFNL (2006) 154 FCR 572
SZSXT v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2014) 222 FCR 73
Guo v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 134
Date of hearing: 14 May 2015
Place: Adelaide (heard in Darwin)
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 40
Counsel for the Appellant: J Burnside QC
Solicitor for the Appellant: Ward Keller Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: T Anderson
Solicitor for the Respondents: Australian Government Solicitors

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NORTHERN TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NTD 4 of 2015

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

DZAFF
Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION
First Respondent

WENDY BODDISON IN HER CAPACITY AS INDEPENDENT MERITS REVIEWER
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

MANSFIELD J

DATE OF ORDER:

11 JUNE 2015

WHERE MADE:

ADELAIDE (HEARD IN DARWIN)

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.The recommendation of the Independent Merits Reviewer made on 23 August 2012 that the appellant does not meet the criteria for a Protection (Class XA) visa set out in s 36(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) and that the appellant not be recognised as a person to whom Australia has protection obligations was made by error of law, in that the Independent Merits Reviewer failed to accord the appellant with the opportunity to comment on adverse information which she regarded as credible, relevant and significant to the review.

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

2.The appeal be allowed.

3.The first respondent pay to the appellant costs of the appeal in this Court and of the application in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia.

4.The orders of the Federal Circuit…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dzaff v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 569
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Dzaff v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, the appellant, Dzaff, sought a protection visa due to a well-founded fear of persecution if he returned to Iran. The appellant alleged that he had intercourse with a young woman before they were married and faced serious threats from her family, as well as potential charges from Iranian authorities. However, the Independent Merits Reviewer (IMR) did not accept his claims, finding that the appellant's evidence was inconsistent and did not substantiate his fear of persecution. The case was appealed to the Federal Circuit Court and subsequently to the High Court, focusing on whether the IMR provided Dzaff with adequate notification of adverse information and an opportunity to respond, which is a matter of procedural fairness.

The central legal issue was whether the IMR had provided Dzaff with sufficient procedural fairness by notifying him and his agent about the adverse information and inviting him to comment. This involved examining whether the communication with Dzaff's legal representative, Vrachnas Lawyers, constituted a reasonable opportunity for Dzaff to respond to the adverse information. The court needed to determine if the notification was adequate given the circumstances, including the use of different interpreters and potential linguistic subtleties that might explain inconsistencies in Dzaff's statements.

The court found that the IMR's notification and invitation to comment were not sufficient to meet the requirements of procedural fairness. The reasoning was that the communication was directed to Dzaff's legal representatives, and there was no evidence that Dzaff was personally made aware of the contents of the letter, which was critical for him to respond effectively. Furthermore, the court noted that the communication to the legal representatives did not ensure that Dzaff had a reasonable opportunity to respond, particularly since the IMR did not follow up on a telephone call to Vrachnas Lawyers. Consequently, the court concluded that the procedural fairness was not adequately upheld, leading to the appeal being allowed. The court ordered that the appeal be allowed, the costs of the appeal and the application in the Federal Circuit Court be paid by the first respondent, and the orders of the Federal Circuit Court be set aside.

Orders

Orders of the court

2. The appeal be allowed.

3. The first respondent pay to the appellant costs of the appeal in this Court and of the application in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia.

4. The orders of the Federal Circuit Court, including as to costs, of 13 March 2015 be set aside.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant, a citizen of Iran, applied for a protection visa in Australia, claiming that he had a well-founded fear of persecution if he were to return to Iran. He alleged that he had intercourse with a young woman before they were married and had to flee Iran due to a serious threat of retribution from the members of that young woman's family. The Independent Merits Reviewer (IMR) did not accept the appellant's claims, concluding that the appellant's fear of being charged with adultery or rape if he returned to Iran was not well-founded. The IMR based this conclusion, in part, on apparent inconsistencies in the appellant's evidence, which were not explained by the appellant. The inconsistencies, according to the appellant's counsel, might have been due to the use of different interpreters during various interviews and the interpretation of colloquial Iranian words into English. The appellant's counsel suggested that if the appellant had been given the opportunity to explain these inconsistencies, they would not have appeared as contradictions.

The matter originated as an application for review of a decision made by the IMR, which was initially heard in the Federal Circuit Court (FCC). The FCC found error in the IMR's decision and remitted the matter back to the IMR for reconsideration. Both parties appealed to the Federal Court of Australia. The Federal Court heard the appeal, taking into account additional documents submitted by the Minister and the material previously considered by the FCC. The court considered the submissions made by both parties, including the appellant's argument that he was not given a fair opportunity to respond to the adverse information.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I note that a detailed consideration of the documents relevant to the sole issue, as contained in the material before the Court and the FCC, was undertaken during the hearing of the appeal. The Minister indicated there may be further relevant documents, and was given leave to adduce them. These reasons for judgment take into account the Minister’s Amended Supplementary Submissions and the three additional documents to which they refer, and which are attached to that Submission.THE DECISION ON THE APPELLANT’S CLAIM The appellant claimed that he is entitled to a protection visa, because he has a well-founded fear of persecution if he were to return to Iran. He said that he had intercourse with a young woman before they were married, and had to flee because of a serious threat of retribution from the members of that young woman’s family. He said that he could not return to Iran because the Iranian authorities would not protect him from that threat. The Reviewer did not accept his claims. That is reflected in [103] of her reasons in the following terms:When the reviewer examines the claimant evidence as a whole, including all the interviews the claimant has participated in, the reviewer is not satisfied that the claimant had sex with his girlfriend and that her family have found out and intend to harm him for having been responsible for his girlfriend losing her virginity. Consequently, the reviewer is not satisfied that the authorities in Iran will harm the claimant (or would let others harm the claimant) or bring adultery (or rape) charges against him for having sex with his girlfriend. The reviewer does not accept that the claimant faces a real chance of being charged with rape or adultery if he returned to Iran and his fear is not well-founded. The reviewer is not satisfied that the claimant has breached Sharia law and therefore is not satisfied that he would be imputed with an anti-government political opinion as a result. Equally the reviewer is not satisfied that he would be regarded as having offended against religion. He would not be regarded as an infidel. (Emphasis added.) The significance of that paragraph, for present purposes, flows from the fact that the IMR perceived that the appellant had provided in some respects inconsistent evidence or information in interviews, including an interview with the Reviewer, about which it was appropriate to seek the appellant’s specific comments. Those apparent inconsistencies, it is said by senior counsel on his behalf, may have been explained by reference to the use of different interpreters at his various interviews and the way in which words in Iranian were interpreted into English by different interpreters. It was said that they might turn on matters of linguistic subtlety rather than contradictions, and that if the appellant had had the opportunity to explain that (perhaps supported by one interpreter having listened to and translated all of the records of interview), the inconsistencies would not be so apparent. Counsel for the Minister did not make any submission to controvert those assertions. A particular illustration was given of a use of a colloquial English word in the transcript of the interview by the Reviewer which, it was fairly said, would not be likely to be a literal translation of what the appellant had said. Because the Reviewer’s comments and conclusions are based upon the whole of the evidence, the fact that the appellant did not in fact comment upon those apparent inconsistencies is potentially significant. The reference in [103] of the IMR decision to the “whole of the evidence” suggests that the Reviewer, being aware of the inconsistencies, and having given the appellant the opportunity to explain them, and the appellant not having explained them, assumed that they were inconsistencies and therefore played a role in the conclusion which the IMR reached.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The additional documents produced by the Minister on this appeal, as well as the material before the FCC, following the first FCC decision declaring error of law on the part of the IMR in relation to its earlier review, indicates:(1)by letter of 20 April 2012 from the Independent Protection Assessment Office addressed to the appellant, and to Vrachnas Lawyers: john@vraclaw.com, the appellant was notified of the interview on 9 May 2012 (the interview conducted by the Reviewer). On the same date an email was sent to Vrachnas Lawyers by the Independent Protection Assessment Office, addressed to johns@vraclaw.com and copied to “heidi@vraclaw.com” enclosing the letter to the appellant. It added:If you could please forward this letter to your client that would be appreciated as it will assist in ensuring their attendance at the review on the designated date and time.We have included the client’s address as indicated by our records. Please cross reference your contact details in case of any changes to address since this time.(2)by email of 2 July 2012, from John Vrachnas, to the “Review Team”, a request was made for a prompt determination by the Reviewer, and by return email of the same day to “John@vraclaw.com” he was told he would be notified promptly when the recommendation of the Reviewer was available;(3)by email of 31 July 2012 and addressed to “john@vraclaw.com” and copied to “heidi@vraclaw.com”, attached the letter of 31 July 2012 referred to above at [13], pointing out the date for the response.CONSIDERATION In a cascading series of propositions, it is said on behalf of the appellant that the Reviewer did not accord the appellant procedural fairness because:(1)it was necessary for the Reviewer to be satisfied that the appellant personally had had the opportunity to respond and so personally came to know of the contents of the letter of 31 July 2012;(2)it was necessary for the Reviewer to have sent the letter to the lawyers, and in the circumstances also to have sent it to the appellant (as was indicated on the form constituting the application for IMR);(3)in the absence of any response from Vrachnas Lawyers by 14 August 2012, it was necessary for the Reviewer to have taken steps to ensure that the contents of the letter had been brought to the attention of the appellant so that he had made, or appeared to have made by communications provided from his agent and/or Vrachnas Lawyers, a conscious decision not to respond to the letter;(4)it was necessary for the Reviewer to have addressed the letter to either Ms Smidt at Vrachnas Lawyers, or to Mr Benjamin at Vrachnas Lawyers, to have ensured that a reasonable opportunity was provided to the appellant to respond to it;(5)in any event, as the letter was not sent either to the agent, or to Vrachnas Lawyers at the address given because the email address was incomplete, the necessary opportunity to be heard had not been given; and(6)further, in any event, having regard to the communications with Vrachnas Lawyers, did not amount to a reasonable opportunity to respond in the circumstances simply to speak to an unidentified person at Vrachnas Lawyers in the terms in which apparently occurred on 20 August 2012, without further following up the telephone call.