Freeman v Health Insurance Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Freeman v Health Insurance Commission [2004] FCAFC 335

HEALTH LAW – medical practitioner – Professional Services Review Scheme under Part VAA of the Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) – investigative referral made by delegate of Health Insurance Commission to Director of Professional Services Review – adjudicative referral made by Director of Professional Services Review to Professional Services Review Committee – finding by Professional Services Review Committee that general practitioner engaged in inappropriate practice – directions made by Determining Authority including repayment of Medicare benefits received in relation to services identified – whether investigative referral to the Director of Professional Services Review was invalid – whether investigative referral sufficiently specified the conduct referred – whether referral is invalid where conduct not sufficiently specified – whether appellant ought to have been given opportunity by the Determining Authority to present submission concerning ‘exceptional circumstances’ where that case was not presented by the appellant before the Health Insurance Commission – where appellant not aware that Determining Authority might make directions which went beyond the recommendations of the Health Insurance Commission – powers of the Determining Authority – whether there is denial of procedural fairness resulting in a breach of natural justice where decision-maker not responsible for the unfairness

Statutes

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act1977 (Cth)s 5(1)(b)

Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) ss 80(1), 86(1), 81, 86(2), 86(4), 87, 88, 86(4A), 89, 89(1), 91, 93(1), 93A, 101(2), 102, 106KD(1), 106KD(3), 106L(1), 106L(4), 82(1), 106KA(3), 106KA(1), 106KA(2), 106KA(5), 106KA(7), 106T(1), 106TA, 106U, 106V(1), 106U(1)(ca), 82, 86(4)(b), 106KA, 93(6), 94(3), 106T, 106U(1)

Health Legislation (Professional Services Review) Amendment Act 1994 (Cth)

Cases

Al-Mehdawi v Secretary of State for the Home Department [1990] 1 AC 876 Cons

Health Insurance Commission v Grey (2002) 120 FCR 470 Cons

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs; Ex parte Lam (2003) 214 CLR 1 Cited

NAFF of 2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] HCA 62 Cited

National Companies and Securities Commission v News Corporation Ltd (1984) 156 CLR 296 Refd to

O’Sullivan v Repatriation Commission [2003] FCA 387 Cons

Pradhan v Holmes (2001) 125 FCR 280 Not Foll, Dist

Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355 Cited

R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board;Ex parteA [1999] 2 AC 330 Not Foll

Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs; Ex parte Applicants S134/2002 (2003) 195 ALR 1 Cons

JACK FREEMAN v HEALTH INSURANCE COMMISSION, DR ALAN JOHN HOLMES (as the Director of Professional Services Review), DR MICHAEL RICE (as Chairperson of Professional Services Review Committee No 224), DR BOB BROWN (as a Member of Professional Services Review Committee No 224), DR BRUCE INGRAM (as a Member of Professional Services Review Committee No 224), DR NICHOLAS RADFORD (as Chairperson of the Determining Authority), DR MORRIS WILLIAMS (as a Member of the Determining Authority), MS JANE PHELAN (as a Member of the Determining Authority)

V613 of 2004

KIEFEL, MARSHALL AND DOWNES JJ
22 DECEMBER 2004

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Freeman v Health Insurance Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCAFC 335
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Freeman v Health Insurance Commission, Dr Jack Freeman appealed against a decision of the Health Insurance Commission, which had disqualified him from providing Medicare services for a period of two years and nine months. The Commission had found that Dr Freeman engaged in inappropriate practice by rendering an excessive number of professional attendances per day. The primary judge dismissed the appeal, and Dr Freeman appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia. The central issue before the Full Court was whether the investigative referral was valid and if the Commission had the authority to make the final determination in the circumstances presented. The Full Court considered the statutory framework governing professional services reviews and the importance of the concluding sentence in the investigative referral, which stated that the attached material was provided for information only and was not intended to limit the conduct referred. The Full Court found that the referral was invalid as it did not comply with the statutory requirements, as established in Pradhan v Holmes. However, the Full Court held that the invalidity of the referral did not necessarily invalidate the entire review process, as the appeal was not limited to the form of the referral but also involved the legality of the final determination. Ultimately, the Full Court dismissed the appeal and ordered that Dr Freeman pay the respondents' costs of the appeal.

The Full Court found that the invalidity of the investigative referral did not necessarily render the entire review process unlawful. The Court acknowledged that the referral did not comply with the statutory requirements, as established in Pradhan v Holmes. However, the Court held that the invalidity of the referral did not automatically invalidate the final determination made by the Commission. The Court considered the arguments put forward by Dr Freeman, including the contention that the Determining Authority should not have proceeded to a final determination and that he should have been allowed to return to a differently constituted committee to reconsider the recommendations. The Full Court found that the arguments were without merit, as the invalidity of the referral did not impact the legality of the final determination. The Court held that the Commission had the authority to make the final determination, and the invalidity of the referral did not affect the outcome of the review process. As a result, the Full Court dismissed the appeal and ordered that Dr Freeman pay the respondents' costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellant pay the respondents’ costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Again, the person under review is provided with an opportunity to make submissions. The Determining Authority must, where it has made a draft determination, within one month after the end of a 14 day period, within which the person under review may make submissions, proceed to make a final determination: s 106TA. Section 106U provides that the draft or final determination must contain one or more of the directions which are then listed. They include that the person under review be reprimanded or counselled, that the practitioner be disqualified in relation to the provision of service and that any Medicare benefits for a service subject to the finding of inappropriate practice be repaid to the Commonwealth. The final determination takes effect on a particular day after a copy is given to the person the subject of the review: s 106V(1).FACTUAL BACKGROUND By an investigative referral dated 20 February 2001, a delegate of the Commission referred to the Director:‘… the conduct of Dr Jack Freeman relating to· whether he has engaged in inappropriate practice in connection with the rendering of services constituting a prescribed pattern of services within the meaning of section 106KA(1) of the Act and Part 3 of the Health Insurance (Professional Services Review) Regulations 1999 (“the Regulations”).’The referral identified the locations at which the services were rendered and the specified period, namely, on and from 1 January 2000 to and including 19 June 2000 (‘the referral period’). The last paragraph of the referral, which assumes some importance on this appeal, is in these terms:‘The attached material is provided to assist the Director of Professional Services Review, but is not intended to limit in any way the conduct referred.’ The attached material included details of the Commission’s records relating to services rendered by Dr Freeman in the referral period. It also contained the Commission’s reasons for the referral:‘In accordance with section 86(4)(b) of the Act the Commission considers Dr Freeman may have engaged in inappropriate practice because there is evidence that some of Dr Freeman’s professional attendances constitute a prescribed pattern of services as defined in s 106KA of the Act and Part 3 of the Regulations.Specifically, the Commission’s records for professional attendances rendered by Dr Freeman during the referral period show that Dr Freeman:· rendered 80 or more professional attendances per day on 92 occasions on and from 1 January 2000 to and including 19 June 2000.The Commission has documentary evidence verifying the accuracy of this information.For further information in relation to professional attendances and services rendered by Dr Freeman during the referral period refer to Book 1, Section E, Reports 1 to 5 and Book 2, Report 6.’ On 26 April 2001 the Director established a Committee and made an adjudicative referral to it. The Committee nominated a date for hearing and wrote to the solicitors for the appellant concerning the issues to be dealt with by the Committee at the hearing. It included an observation that the hearing was an important opportunity for their client to present his evidence in relation to any exceptional circumstances to explain his current situation.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

KIEFEL J
The Determining Authority also considered that a substantial period of disqualification should be imposed but accepted that the appellant had consented to the Committee’s recommendation because he thought no other direction would be made and that he did not now support the Committee’s recommendation. Nevertheless, it directed that he be disqualified for the same period, two years and nine months. THE DECISION OF THE PRIMARY JUDGE Before his Honour the primary judge it was argued that the investigative referral was invalid because of the concluding sentence ‘The attached material is provided to assist the Director of Professional Services Review, but is not intended to limit in any way the conduct referred’. This had been determined by Finn J in Pradhan v Holmes. It was further argued that the Determining Authority ought not to have proceeded to a final determination and should have considered whether to permit the applicant to return to a differently constituted committee to reconsider what recommendations to make to the Determining Authority. In Pradhan v Holmes the form of the investigative referral (at [62] of the Reasons) was held not to comply with s 86(1) of the Act. The referral was of ‘the conduct of Dr Jagjit Singh Pradhan relating to whether he has engaged in inappropriate practice within the meaning of section 82 of the Act in connection with rendering and initiation of services’. The services were not further specified although the period in which they occurred was identified. The referral concluded with a sentence which is in similar form to that contained in the referral in the present case: ‘The attached material is provided for information only and is not intended in any way to limit the conduct referred.’ Finn J noted that the attached material ran to over 170 pages and specified two particular concerns relating to Dr Pradhan’s conduct (at [80], [82] and [83]): the high volume of rendered services with high daily servicing, and that some services rendered might not have been reasonably medically necessary for the care of his patients. His Honour’s concern was with the statement that the material was provided for information and not intended to limit the conduct referred. His Honour said (at [82] -[83]): ‘82.… Full force, in my view, should be given to the statement I have quoted above. The Commission, while specifying conduct in the attachments, stated that it did not in any way intend to limit the conduct referred … the statement is an unqualified one indicating both the significance to be attributed to the attached material – it was provided for information only (notwithstanding that parts of what was provided were required by s 86(4) to be provided) – and the effect to be given it insofar as it specified conduct that might be inquired into. There is no ambiguity in what is stated. Nor is it contradicted by other parts of the document. Rather, it is consistent with the description of the “Investigative Referral” in the first paragraph of the same document which was “of the conduct of” Dr Pradhan etcetera.’83.I find, then, that while the Commission has specified two species of conduct that (a) have provided the stimulus to the referral and (b) are the subject of the s 86(4) reasons why the Commission considers Dr Pradhan may have engaged in inappropriate practice, the conduct referred is unspecified and unlimited.’

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KIEFEL J

Full text does not contain this section.