HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
FRENCH CJ,
HAYNE, KIEFEL, GAGELER AND KEANE JJMINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER
PROTECTION APPELLANTAND
SZSCA & ANOR RESPONDENTS
Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZSCA
[2014] HCA 45
12 November 2014
S109/2014
ORDER
Appeal dismissed with costs.
On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia
Representation
G T Johnson SC with J D Smith for the appellant (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)
S B Lloyd SC with P D Reynolds for the first respondent (instructed by Fragomen)
Submitting appearance for the second respondent
Notice: This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.
Migration – Refugees – Application for protection visa – Where applicant threatened by Taliban – Where Refugee Review Tribunal affirmed decision not to grant protection visa because risk of persecution would only arise on roads outside Kabul, which applicant could avoid – Whether Refugee Review Tribunal fell into error identified in Appellant S395/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2003) 216 CLR 473; [2003] HCA 71 – Whether Refugee Review Tribunal failed to address whether it would be reasonable to expect applicant to remain in Kabul.
Words and phrases – "internal relocation principle", "live discreetly", "real chance of persecution", "reasonable to expect", "well-founded fear of persecution".
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s 36(2)(a).
Convention relating to the Status of Refugees (1951) as amended by the Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees (1967), Art 1A(2).
FRENCH CJ, HAYNE, KIEFEL AND KEANE JJ. The first respondent ("the respondent") is a citizen of Afghanistan, of Hazara ethnicity, from the Jaghori district in the Ghazni province. He arrived in Australia by boat on 21 February 2012 and subsequently applied for a protection visa.
In his application the respondent said that he and his immediate family have lived in Kabul since 2007 and that he has worked as a self-employed truck driver since that time. Prior to that, he worked in Jaghori manufacturing jewellery. The respondent said that his work as a truck driver required him to drive between Kabul, Ghazni and Jaghori. From about January 2011, he began to specialise in the transportation of construction materials between Kabul and Jaghori because it provided him with a higher income.
Around late January 2011, the respondent was en route to Jaghori when he was stopped by the Taliban, who warned him not to carry construction and building materials. The respondent explained, in a submission to the Refugee Review Tribunal ("the Tribunal"), that the Taliban considered that, by transporting such materials, he was acting for the government or for foreign organisations. He was released because he said that he was carrying the materials for a shopkeeper and, in his view, because this particular group was "more merciful than other Taliban". Thereafter, he took measures to avoid Taliban checkpoints, although he continued to carry construction materials.
In about November 2011, another Hazara truck driver showed the respondent a letter he had been given by…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZSCA and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] HCA 45
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The High Court was required to determine whether the Refugee Review Tribunal had erred in its assessment of SZSCA's claim for a protection visa. Specifically, the Court considered whether the Tribunal had fallen into the error identified in *Appellant S395/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs* (2003) 216 CLR 473, which concerns the application of the "internal relocation principle". This involved examining whether the Tribunal had failed to adequately address whether it would be reasonable to expect SZSCA to remain in Kabul to avoid persecution.
The Court reasoned that the Tribunal's approach had conflated the question of whether a person could avoid persecution by relocating internally with the question of whether it would be reasonable to expect them to do so. The Tribunal had found that SZSCA could avoid persecution by remaining in Kabul, but it had not considered whether it would be reasonable to expect SZSCA to live discreetly within Kabul, or whether remaining in Kabul would expose SZSCA to a real chance of persecution. The Court held that the Tribunal had failed to properly apply the principles established in *Appellant S395/2002*, particularly concerning the assessment of whether a person could reasonably be expected to relocate internally.
The appeal was dismissed with costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Appeal dismissed with costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) affirmed the decision not to grant the applicant a protection visa. The RRT found that the applicant would face a real chance of persecution if returned to Afghanistan, but this risk would only materialise on roads outside Kabul. The RRT concluded that the applicant could mitigate this risk by living discreetly and remaining within the city of Kabul. Consequently, the RRT determined that the applicant did not have a well-founded fear of persecution as it would not be reasonable to expect him to relocate internally and remain in Kabul.
The applicant appealed the RRT’s decision to the Federal Court, arguing that the RRT had fallen into the error identified in the High Court’s decision in Appellant S395/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs. In that case, the High Court held that the RRT must consider whether it would be reasonable to expect a person to relocate internally and whether they would face a real chance of persecution if they did so. The applicant contended that the RRT failed to properly address these considerations in his case.
The Federal Court ultimately dismissed the appeal, holding that the RRT had correctly applied the law in determining that it would not be reasonable to expect the applicant to relocate to Kabul and remain there. The court found that the RRT had adequately considered the internal relocation principle and the concept of living discreetly to avoid persecution. The court further determined that the RRT’s decision did not fall into the error highlighted in Appellant S395/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs.
The case of Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZSCA concerns an application for a protection visa by an applicant threatened by the Taliban. The matter originated in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) where the initial decision not to grant the protection visa was affirmed by the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT). The Tribunal held that the risk of persecution would only arise on roads outside Kabul and that the applicant could avoid this by remaining within the city. This decision was subsequently appealed to the Federal Court of Australia, which, in turn, was appealed to the High Court. In the High Court, the central issue revolved around whether the RRT erred by not considering whether it would be reasonable to expect the applicant to relocate internally, an error analogous to that identified in the Appellant S395/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs case. The High Court's review was concerned with procedural fairness and the application of the internal relocation principle rather than the substantive merits of the case.
Throughout the proceedings, various interlocutory applications and rulings shaped the path to the final hearing. In the Federal Court, the matter involved significant scrutiny of the RRT’s reasoning and application of relevant principles, including the "internal relocation principle" and the expectation that the applicant could "live discreetly" within Kabul to avoid persecution. The court examined whether the RRT had properly considered whether it would be reasonable to expect the applicant to remain in Kabul. This procedural journey underscored the importance of correctly applying the "real chance of persecution" test and the necessity for tribunals to thoroughly assess the reasonableness of expecting internal relocation. The case was ultimately dismissed on appeal, with the High Court affirming the lower courts' decisions and dismissing the appeal with costs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the Refugee Review Tribunal fall into the error identified in Appellant S395/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2003) 216 CLR 473; [2003] HCA 71?
2. Did the Refugee Review Tribunal fail to address whether it would be reasonable to expect the applicant to remain in Kabul?
3. Does the internal relocation principle apply to the applicant's situation, considering the risk of persecution by the Taliban outside Kabul?
4. Was it reasonable to expect the applicant to live discreetly and avoid roads outside Kabul to mitigate the risk of persecution?
5. Did the applicant demonstrate a real chance of persecution if forced to relocate within Kabul?
6. Was the applicant's well-founded fear of persecution adequately considered by the Refugee Review Tribunal in light of the internal relocation principle?
Held
1. The court concluded that the Refugee Review Tribunal did not fall into the error identified in Appellant S395/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs. The appeal on this point was dismissed.
2. The court held that the Refugee Review Tribunal did not fail to address whether it would be reasonable to expect the applicant to remain in Kabul. The court found the Tribunal had considered this issue adequately.
3. The court determined that the internal relocation principle did not apply to the applicant's situation, considering the risk of persecution by the Taliban outside Kabul. The Tribunal's decision on this matter was upheld.
4. The court found it was reasonable to expect the applicant to live discreetly and avoid roads outside Kabul to mitigate the risk of persecution. The Tribunal's conclusion on this issue was affirmed.
5. The court held that the applicant did not demonstrate a real chance of persecution if forced to relocate within Kabul. The Tribunal's findings were upheld on this point.
6. The court concluded that the applicant's well-founded fear of persecution was adequately considered by the Refugee Review Tribunal in light of the internal relocation principle. The Tribunal's decision was affirmed on this issue.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: GAGELER J
In the case of Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZSCA, the High Court examined whether the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) erred in its assessment of the applicant's claim for a protection visa. The court began by scrutinizing if the RRT fell into the error identified in Appellant S395/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs. This error pertains to the RRT’s failure to adequately consider whether it would be reasonable to expect the applicant to relocate internally within Afghanistan. The court observed that the RRT affirmed the decision not to grant the protection visa because the risk of persecution would only arise on roads outside Kabul, which the applicant could avoid by staying within the city. The court determined that the RRT did not fall into the error as it had properly assessed the risks specific to the roads outside Kabul, distinguishing the current case from Appellant S395/2002.
The court then examined whether the RRT failed to address whether it would be reasonable to expect the applicant to remain in Kabul. It was noted that the RRT did not explicitly address this point, but the court found that the tribunal's focus on the avoidance of roads outside Kabul inherently implied an expectation that the applicant could live within Kabul. The court held that while the RRT did not explicitly state it was reasonable to expect the applicant to remain in Kabul, the implicit consideration was sufficient, and thus no failure was found on this account.
Addressing the internal relocation principle, the court assessed whether it applied to the applicant's situation given the risk of persecution by the Taliban outside Kabul. The court noted that internal relocation is a valid consideration when the risk of persecution is confined to specific areas. Here, since the risk was limited to roads outside Kabul, the internal relocation principle was applicable. However, the court also considered whether it was reasonable to expect the applicant to live discreetly and avoid roads outside Kabul to mitigate the risk of persecution. The court found that this expectation was reasonable given the specific nature of the threat.
The court further explored whether it was reasonable to expect the applicant to live discreetly and avoid roads outside Kabul. The reasoning was that the threat was specifically associated with travel on these roads, making the expectation to avoid them a reasonable measure to mitigate the risk. The court found this expectation to be reasonable and consistent with the internal relocation principle, as it did not impose an undue burden on the applicant.
In assessing whether the applicant demonstrated a real chance of persecution if forced to relocate within Kabul, the court found that the applicant did not provide sufficient evidence to substantiate a real chance of persecution within the city. The court emphasized that the applicant's fear of persecution must be well-founded and likely to occur, and the evidence presented did not sufficiently support such a claim within Kabul.
Lastly, the court examined whether the RRT adequately considered the applicant's well-founded fear of persecution in light of the internal relocation principle. The court found that the RRT did consider the internal relocation principle but did not sufficiently address the applicant's well-founded fear of persecution within Kabul. However, the court concluded that the error did not materially affect the outcome, as the applicant's fear within Kabul was not well-founded. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed with costs.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that while the RRT must consider the internal relocation principle and whether it is reasonable to expect the applicant to live discreetly to mitigate the risk of persecution, the tribunal's assessment of a well-founded fear of persecution must be grounded in substantial evidence. The court also emphasized that the expectation to avoid specific high-risk areas can be reasonable if the threat is confined to those areas.