EBB19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

EBB19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FedCFamC2G 469

File number(s): ADG 379 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE LUCEV
Date of judgment: 3 April 2025
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Judicial review – application for Safe Haven Enterprise Visa – citizen of Pakistan – whether material error in law in considering or applying legislative provisions to new information provided by the applicant – whether material error in law in applying the real chance and real risk tests – whether failure to respond to claim to fear serious and significant harm in the applicant’s work – whether failure to consider an integer of the applicant’s claim that he was at risk of harm upon return to Pakistan – whether failure to consider country information in support of applicant’s claim that he was at risk of harm upon return to Pakistan – whether error material – whether jurisdictional error – writs issued.
Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 5J, 36, 473DC, 473DD, 474, 476

Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No 1) Rules 2024 (Cth) rr 11 and 12

Cases cited:

APH17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCA 23

Applicant VEAL of 2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2005] HCA 72; (2005) 225 CLR 88; (2005) 80 ALJR 228; (2005) 222 ALR 411; (2005) 87 ALD 512

Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 184; (2003) 236 FCR 593; (2003) 75 ALD 630

ARO17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCA 847

AUS17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2020] HCA 37; (2020) 269 CLR 494; (2020) 94 ALJR 1007; (2020) 384 ALR 196

AZT22 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCAFC 90

BYX17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCAFC 41

Carrascalao v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCAFC 107; (2017) 252 FCR 352; (2017) 347 ALR 173

CSR16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 474

CXS18 v Minister for Home Affairs [2020] FCAFC 18

Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] HCA 26; (2003) 77 ALJR 1088; (2003) 197 ALR 389; (2003) 73 ALD 321

Hossain v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] HCA 34; (2018) 264 CLR 123; (2018) 92 ALJR 780; (2018) 75 AAR 551; (2018) 359 ALR 1

Htun v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 1802; (2001) 233 FCR 136; (2001) 194 ALR 244

Kumar v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCA 1114

Lafu v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] FCAFC 140; (2009) 112 ALD 1

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v MZYTS [2013] FCAFC 114; (2013) 230 FCR 431; (2013) 136 ALD 547

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read EBB19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 469
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

EBB19, a national of Pakistan, applied for a Safe Haven Enterprise Visa (SHE Visa) in Australia, which was subsequently refused by the Authority. EBB19 sought judicial review of the Authority’s decision on various grounds, including whether there was a material error in law in considering or applying legislative provisions to new information provided by the applicant, and whether there was a failure to respond to claims of fear of serious and significant harm upon return to Pakistan. The court had to determine if the Authority’s decision was flawed in its application of the relevant legislative provisions and if it failed to appropriately consider the risk of harm EBB19 faced in Pakistan.

The court found that the Authority did not breach the legislative provisions in considering the new information provided by EBB19. The Authority was not required to make specific references to each provision of the relevant legislation but rather needed to address the prescribed matters in substance. The Authority assessed the new information, including the claim about the deaths of EBB19’s cousins, and found it to be inherently unbelievable due to concerns about the authenticity of the provided documents. The court held that even if there was a breach, it was not material as the outcome would not have been different. The decision was essentially based on the weight of the country information, which indicated improvements in the security situation in Pakistan and a declining trend in sectarian violence.

In conclusion, the court dismissed EBB19’s application for judicial review. The Authority’s decision was found to be legally sound, and there was no material error in law that would warrant overturning the refusal of the SHE Visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The history of EBB19’s SHE Visa application, including the relevant background, is as follows:(a)at the time of his arrival in Australia on 21 August 2013 EBB19, a national of Pakistan, was 29 years old: CB 64 and 71;(b)an entry interview was conducted with EBB19 on 3 December 2014: CB 28;(c)on 22 September 2016 the Minister invited EBB19 to apply for a temporary protection visa or a SHE Visa: CB 46;(d)EBB19 made a valid application for a SHE Visa on 9 December 2016 indicating therein that he had previously worked as a driver in a town (“Town”) in the Kurram District (formerly the Kurram Agency, and which is in north-west Pakistan): CB 79, and said that he left Pakistan because, at CB 89:9.…I was working as a driver. Given the very poor security situation, I was only able to drive within a very small area. Many attacks occurred and I felt it was only a matter of time until I was killed. Accordingly, I felt I had no option except to flee Pakistan. (e)EBB19 was interviewed by the Delegate on 27 June 2019: CB 145, and in summary, relevant to his claim, told the Delegate:(i)he was born and raised in a village (“Village”) near the Town in the Kurram District: CB 160; (ii)he is readily identifiable as a Shia Turi and practising Muslim: CB 161; and(iii)his home area borders Afghanistan where sectarian violence is rife: CB 162;(f)on 22 August 2019 the Delegate’s Decision was to refuse to grant EBB19 a SHE Visa: CB 183;(g)the Delegate’s Decision was referred to the Authority for review on 27 August 2019: CB 200; and(h)on 18 September 2019 EBB19 provided new information to the Authority in support of his claims: CB 215, and in particular he provided:(i)an account of the recent deaths of his two cousins aged 15 and 20 who were travelling together on the roads between the Village and another village, when they were stopped, kidnapped and poisoned: CB 215;(ii)documents signed by senior medical officers at a hospital in the Town certifying the deaths of his cousins: CB 221-222; and(iii)an explanation that he could not have provided the new information to the Delegate because he was unaware of it prior to the Delegate’s Decision.AUTHORITY DECISION On 1 October 2019 the Authority Decision was to affirm the Delegate’s Decision. In the Authority Decision the Authority:(a)relevantly commenced its reasons by referring to a submission dated 17 September 2019 (“EBB19’s Authority Submission”) received on behalf of EBB19: CB 215-220. EBB19’s Authority Submission attached two certificates, which were styled as death certificates (“Death Certificates”): CB 221-222. In relation to the Death Certificates the Authority:(i)explained at CB 232 at [4] the claim underlying the Death Certificates as relating to EBB19's two cousins who were involved in an incident on 19 November 2018. The two cousins were said to be travelling from one village to another when they were stopped on the road, kidnapped, poisoned and died. Sunni militants were thought to be the perpetrators. This was said to be relevant to EBB19's claim of ongoing attacks on the roads between villages. The Authority recorded the claim that EBB19 had not been told earlier of this incident because his family “knew he had been feeling depressed”;(ii)expressed itself as not being “satisfied” that there were exceptional circumstances to consider the new “claim” and the Death Certificates: CB 232-233 at [5], for the following reasons:(A)it had concerns with the explanation for the delay (that is, because the family were concerned EBB19 was “depressed”). In this specific context, it said that “[i]t is obvious on the face of it that this information is highly relevant to his application for protection and I find it difficult to believe that they did not provide him with this information because he was feeling depressed”;(B)relatedly, it referred to EBB19's suspicion of the involvement of Sunni militants being “based on their previous history of attacking [EBB19's] community and [EBB19 had] not provided any other supporting evidence of who allegedly committed the attack or why”; and(C)it had “significant concerns” about the authenticity of the Death Certificates (being the “evidence ... provided in support of the new claim”). It offered a number of reasons for effectively saying that the Death Certificates were not capable of being believed. First, they were typed on a blank piece of paper, which made it difficult to verify them as official documents. Second, one was issued nine months after the event, without there being any explanation for this. Third, the other bore no date. Fourth, apart from the reference to “poisoning”, there was no other information about the causes of death. Fifth, there was no other supporting evidence that the deceased persons were EBB19’s cousins;(b)set out EBB19’s protection claims as follows:(i)he was born and resided in the Village, near the Town, in the Kurram District and is a citizen of Pakistan;(ii)he is of Pashtun race and is a Shia Muslim belonging to the Turi Tribe;(iii)his life was difficult in Pakistan due to his race, religion, tribal affiliation and his area of origin;(iv)since 2007 there has been a high level of tension between the Sunni Muslims, Shia Muslims and extremist groups in his home area (the Kurram District). The Taliban wish to have power in his area to allow them access to Afghanistan and ongoing attacks were perpetrated against his religious community;(v)he was scared to obtain supplies as attacks were perpetrated against marketplaces. He was also scared to practise his faith given many Shia places of worship were attacked;(vi)in late 2009 he witnessed an explosion in the Town and two of his good friends were killed in the attack. This made him very scared and he travelled to the United Arab Emirates (“UAE”) but the authorities in that country started mistreating Shia Muslims and he had no choice but to return to Pakistan. On his return to Pakistan he was working as a driver but due to the poor security situation he was only able to drive within a very small area and felt it was only a matter of time until he will be killed so he felt he had no option but to flee Pakistan;(vii)he fears harm from the Taliban, associated extremists, the Islamic State and the Sunni Muslim community in Pakistan. He will be harmed due to his religion, his area of origin, tribe affiliation, race, as a Shia Pashtu from the Kurram District and his imputed political opinion which emanates from these characteristics. Extremists target them given they believe their community has worked against them and prevented their access to Afghanistan. He can be easily recognised as a Shia Muslim given his name, facial features, area of origin, identity documents and religious practice. He will be harmed in all areas of Pakistan; and(viii)he claims the Pakistani authorities are corrupt and unable to uphold the rule of law in Pakistan and do not have the ability to prevent terrorist groups from committing atrocities and the authorities aid extremist groups to commit acts of violence. The Taliban and the other extremist groups are very powerful and cannot be stopped by the authorities;(c)accepted: (i)EBB19 is of the Shia faith, a member of the Turi Tribe, of the Pashtun race, and that he previously resided in the Village, near the Town, in the Kurram District: CB 235 at [12]; (ii)based on supporting country information, that there have been tensions between Sunni and Shia Muslims in EBB19's home area in the past and that various militant groups have targeted Turi Shias in the Kurram District: CB 235-236 at [14]-[15]; (iii)as plausible that EBB19 may have witnessed an explosion that killed his friends in 2008 or 2009: CB 236 at [18]. This finding must be read against the earlier findings where it noted EBB19's evidence that none of his family had been physically harmed as a result of conflict around his home area: CB 236 at [16], alongside an evaluation of EBB19's evidence before the Delegate. As to the latter point, the Authority found that nothing of significance happened in EBB19's village, but that residents lived in fear of militant activity: CB 236 at [17];(d)essentially found that EBB19 did not satisfy the criteria for the grant of the SHE Visa on the basis of country information, which indicated that there have been significant improvements to the security situation in the Kurram District due to improved infrastructure and counter-terrorism operations by the Pakistani authorities: CB 237 at [22] and CB 239 at [32]; (e)considered that the country information indicated that there had been a declining trend in sectarian violence in Pakistan since 2014: CB 237 at [23] and there had been no attacks in the Town since early 2017: CB 239 at [32], and noted the following:(i)in 2017 the Pakistani authorities announced nationwide military operations which included counter-terrorism operations, the installation of closed circuit television throughout the Town, and the construction of new forts and border posts to improve surveillance: CB 237 at [24];(ii)in a report by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (“DFAT”) in 2019 (“2019 DFAT Report”) DFAT acknowledged a trend of decreased reports of attacks against Turis in 2018. Although DFAT assessed that Turis in the Kurram District still faced a moderate risk of sectarian violence, the Authority apportioned weight to the country information that government operations and associated counter-terrorism activities have significantly decreased the number and severity of attacks on Turis: CB 237-238 at [25]-[26]; and(iii)country information indicated that the security situation in the area of the Village is located had improved substantially in 2018, arising from legislative changes introduced by the Pakistani government, the construction of military fencing, and the establishment of roads, bridges and telecommunication networks, schools, health facilities and markets: CB 237-238 at [26];(f)noted that EBB19's family continue to reside in the Village and that nothing had happened to them. Consequently, the Authority did not accept that EBB19's family cannot move freely due to fear of militant attacks, since the security situation has improved in the Town since 2017: CB 238 at [28]. The Authority had regard to EBB19's request for it to consider findings of the then Administrative Appeals Tribunal (“AAT”) in two decisions in September 2018 which found that it would be unreasonable for Turi Shias to relocate in Pakistan. The Authority gave little weight to the two AAT decisions, noting that it was not bound by them: CB 239 at [31];(g)considered the practice of EBB19's religion in Pakistan and found that he would not be prevented from practising his Shia Muslim faith, bearing in mind that EBB19 comes from a majority Shia area, and that, contrary to his claim that Shias have been targeted by the Pakistani authorities, he had not claimed to have received adverse attention from the Pakistani authorities on the basis of his religion, or that he would be of adverse interest to the authorities: CB 239-240 at [33];(h)considered EBB19's journey back to the Town, accepting that he would have to travel through the Sunni dominated lower Kurram District, along the main road to the Town (“Main Road”). In that regard, the Authority noted country information relating to the decrease in road attacks reported in the 2019 DFAT Report which had instilled confidence within the community to travel on the Main Road. Against that backdrop, it said that it was not satisfied on the basis of country information before it that the roads can only be used during daylight: CB 240-241 at [36];(i)within that framework of findings, the Authority then said at CB 240-241 at [36] (emphasis added):…I also find that if the applicant were to continue to work as a taxi driver in Pakistan the country information above does not indicate that this will exacerbate his risk of harm. (j)noted that the Delegate considered a claim of harm in Pakistan due to EBB19 being a failed asylum seeker, but that the Delegate had not appeared to accept this claim on the basis of country information indicating that returnees are able to integrate into the community: CB 241 at [37]-[38];(k)in the result, said that it was not satisfied, on the basis of EBB19's claims and profile, that he will face a real chance of any harm in Pakistan in the reasonably foreseeable future: CB 241 at [39]; and(l)for similar reasons, the Authority found that the complementary protection criteria were not made out: CB 242 at [43].AMENDED JUDICIAL REVIEW APPLICATION

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Minister’s submissions were as follows:(a)this ground is specious. A close inspection of the Authority Decision makes it plain that the Authority’s reasons did not breach s 473DD, let alone in a way that materially affected the outcome;(b)in order to meet s 473DD(b)(i) the Authority must be satisfied that the new information given, or proposed to be given, by the referred applicant was not, and could not have been, provided to the Minister before the Delegate’s Decision was made. To meet the requirement in s 473DD(b)(ii), the Authority must be satisfied that the new information given, or proposed to be given, by the referred applicant: (i)is credible information about an identified individual, or an individual who is reasonably identifiable;(ii)was not previously known by either the Minister or the referred applicant; and(iii)had the information been known by either the Minister or the referred applicant, may have affected the consideration of the referred applicant's claims: Plaintiff M174/2016 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] HCA 16; (2018) 264 CLR 217; (2018) 92 ALJR 481; (2018) 353 ALR 600 (“Plaintiff M174”) at [34] per Gageler, Keane, Nettle JJ;(c)in embarking upon the deliberative process the notion of “credible” is to be understood as “capable of being believed”: CSR16 at [42] per Bromberg J; (d)contrary to EBB19’s argument, the Authority was not required to expressly refer to each provision in s 473DD(b) in order to comply with the holding in AUS17. It is enough that the Authority dealt with the matters prescribed by s 473DD in substance. Nor is there anything in AUS17 which detracts from the ordinary principle that the reasons must be read fairly and as a whole and without an eye keenly attuned to the perception of error: Wu Shan Liang, CLR at 272 per Brennan CJ, Toohey, McHugh and Gummow JJ;(e)formulaic consideration of the criteria is not required: APH17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCA 23 (“APH17”) at [79] per Markovic J:(f)four things can be noted about the Authority's reasons in the present matter:(i)first, and importantly, unlike the situation in BTW17, this is not a case where the Authority made some “relatively definitive findings about the credibility of the visa applicant”: BTW17 at [76] per Mortimer and Jackson JJ. Apart from expressing some concerns about whether the Death Certificates were capable of being believed, and thus whether in the absence of corroborative material the claim itself was capable of being believed, the Authority made no adverse credibility finding of any kind against EBB19 in its substantive consideration of the protection claims. True it is that it used language such as “credible” in the context of country information, but it cannot be said that this was a case which depended on an adverse credibility assessment;(ii)second, a fair reading of the Authority Decision at CB 232-233 at [5]-[6] in context reveals that the Authority in fact assessed the claim (comprised, as it was, of EBB19’s Authority Submissions and said to be buttressed by the Death Certificates) in the following order:(A)it rejected the assertion that the family declined to provide the Death Certificates earlier because of the concern that EBB19 was depressed. In that way, the Authority dealt with s 473DD(b)(i), that is, it “was not, and could not have been, provided to the Minister before the Minister made the decision under section 65”; and (B)it then offered a brief deliberation (confined to one paragraph) as to its “significant concerns” with the Death Certificates themselves. This was tantamount to a finding, which requires no particular formulary, that the Death Certificates and the claim were “evidently not believable”: s 473DD(b)(ii). In that respect, it is to be recalled that the claim of the cousins’ deaths was necessarily bound up, and fundamentally said to be corroborated by the Death Certificates;(iii)third, having complied with the order of analysis required by AUS17, the Authority said that it was not satisfied that there were exceptional circumstances to “consider this new claim and the death certificates provided”: CB 232-233 at [5]; and(iv)fourth, even if, contrary to the Minister’s submission, the Court concludes that the Authority did not comply with s 473DD, it is clear that it would not change the result. As noted, the Authority made no adverse credibility finding anywhere in its reasons, and the case for the SHE Visa was determined essentially on the weight of the country information, which, on the Authority's review, was overwhelmingly against EBB19's specific claims;(g)there can be no suggestion that any breach was material: see Hossain v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] HCA 34; (2018) 264 CLR 123; (2018) 92 ALJR 780; (2018) 75 AAR 551; (2018) 359 ALR 1 at [25] and [30]-[31] per Kiefel CJ, Gageler and Keane JJ and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZMTA [2019] HCA 3; (2019) 264 CLR 421; (2019) 93 ALJR 252; (2019) 75 AAR 75; (2019) 363 ALR 599; (2019) 163 ALD 38 (“SZMTA”) at [45]-[46] per Bell, Gageler and Keane JJ. Expressed generally, EBB19 could only succeed if the outcome could have been different as a matter of reasonable conjecture: MZAPC at [38] per Kiefel CJ, Gageler, Keane and Gleeson JJ. That standard is undemanding: Nathanson at [33] per Kiefel CJ, Keane and Gleeson JJ. As a matter of reasonable conjecture, the new claim was obviously inherently unbelievable, insofar as it depended for its acceptance (as it did) on the Death Certificates being official. That is, were they capable of being believed? For the reasons given by the Authority, they were not;(h)as such, there is no prospect that the new information would have been accepted by the Authority as “credible” for the purpose of s 473DD, if it had been assessed as EBB19 asserts (in this proceeding) as free from infection; and(i)the Court should reject ground 1.Consideration – ground 1