FFU18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

FFU18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FedCFamC2G 1335

File number(s): MLG 3002 of 2018
Judgment of: JUDGE LUCEV
Date of judgment: 6 December 2024
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Judicial review application – review of decision of Immigration Assessment Authority affirming delegate’s decision to refuse Safe Haven Enterprise visa – citizen of Pakistan – whether failure to consider risk of harm in context of whether reasonable to relocate from Parachinar to Islamabad – whether failure to consider claim that applicant would travel back to Parachinar to collect family – whether material jurisdictional error.  
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 5J, 36, 473CB, 473CC, 473DD, 474, 476
Cases cited:

APE16 v Minister for Home Affairs [2020] FCAFC 93; (2020) 277 FCR 640

Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 184; (2003) 236 FCR 593; (2003) 75 ALD 630

Carrascalao v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCAFC 107; (2017) 252 FCR 352; (2017) 347 ALR 173

CIT17v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 150; (2018) 265 FCR 572

CSO15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 14; (2018) 260 FCR 134; (2018) 353 ALR 666

CSZ16 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCAFC 156

CXO16 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCA 17

DKY22 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FCAFC 24; (2024) 302 FCR 25

DNQ18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCAFC 72; (2020) 275 FCR 517

DQU16 v Minister for Immigration [2021] HCA 10; (2021) 273 CLR 1; (2021) 95 ALJR 352; (2021) 388 ALR 363

Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] HCA 26; (2003) 77 ALJR 1088; (2003) 197 ALR 389; (2003) 73 ALD 321

EVA17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 214; (2018) 262 FCR 304

Htun v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 1802; (2001) 233 FCR 136; (2001) 194 ALR 244

Januzi v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2006] 2 AC 426; [2006] 3 All ER 305

LPDT v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 12; (2024) 98 ALJR 610

Ludgero v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCCA 1060; (2021) 358 FLR 215

Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang [1996] HCA 6; (1996) 185 CLR 259; (1996) 70 ALJR 568; (1996) 136 ALR 481; (1996) 41 ALD 1

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v DZU16 [2018] FCAFC 32; (2018) 253 FCR 526; (2018) 357 ALR 474

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZMTA [2019] HCA 3; (2019) 264 CLR 421; (2019) 163 ALD 38; (2019)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FFU18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FedCFamC2G 1335
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of FFU18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs, FFU18, a citizen of Pakistan, sought judicial review of a decision by the Immigration Assessment Authority to uphold a delegate's decision to refuse his application for a Safe Haven Enterprise (SHE) visa. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Authority erred in concluding that it was reasonable for FFU18 to relocate within Pakistan. FFU18 contended that the Authority failed to consider his claim that even a low risk of harm in Islamabad would render relocation unreasonable. The Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs argued that FFU18 did not clearly claim that a low risk of harm in Islamabad made relocation unreasonable, and even if he did, the Authority had considered this in its decision-making process.

The court found that FFU18's submissions did not clearly articulate that a low risk of harm in Islamabad was sufficient to deem relocation unreasonable. Instead, FFU18's focus was on other practical considerations, such as cost of living, language barriers, and employment prospects. The court held that the Authority's role is to address the specific claims made by the applicant, and in this case, FFU18's materials did not squarely claim that a low risk of harm in Islamabad would make relocation unreasonable. The court further found that even if the Authority had erred, it was an immaterial error that could not have realistically affected the outcome of the decision.

Based on the reasoning provided, the court dismissed FFU18's application for judicial review. The decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority to uphold the delegate's decision to refuse the SHE visa application was affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

All references in these Reasons for Judgment to provisions in the Migration Act refer to the provisions as at the date of the Authority Decision.BACKGROUND AND CLAIMS The factual background to this matter is as follows:(a)FFU18 was born on 30 May 1981 in Pakistan: CB 3;(b)FFU18 arrived in Australia by boat in 2013: CB 19;(c)on 23 May 2016 FFU18 was invited to apply for a SHE Visa: CB 23;(d)on 31 March 2017 FFU18 made an application for a SHE Visa with a statutory declaration in support (“March 2017 Statutory Declaration”): CB 32-83. In the March 2017 Statutory Declaration FFU18 advanced a claim that he could not relocate within Pakistan safely due to sectarian violence: CB 71 at [18]; (e)in summary, FFU18’s claims were as follows:(i)FFU18 is a Shia Muslim, a member of the Turi Tribe, ethnically Pashtun, and from Parachinar in the Kurram Agency in Pakistan;(ii)FFU18’s father is a schoolteacher, an influential man in Parachinar due to ownership of significant land and real estate, a member of the peace committee and of a Shia religious group (“Shia Religious Group”);(iii)FFU18 worked in Karachi from 2001 to 2006 as a security guard. FFU18 returned to Parachinar when it became too risky to live in Karachi. In Parachinar FFU18 worked as a tractor driver delivering water and on the family farm; (iv)FFU18’s father organised for him to go to the United Arab Emirates in March 2009 as it was increasingly risky for FFU18 to continue to live in Parachinar due to the war. FFU18 worked in Abu Dhabi from March 2009 to 2012;(v)when FFU18 returned to Parachinar he again worked delivering water and as a farmer. In December 2012 FFU18’s friend, who was also a water deliverer, was killed by the Taliban. After this, FFU18 was too scared to work; and(vi)if FFU18 returns to Parachinar, he fears being killed by an extremist group because he is Shia and Turi. He believes he will be targeted because of his:(A)religion;(B)membership of the Turi tribe;(C)father’s association with the Shia Religious Group;(D)actual and imputed political opinion opposed to the Taliban;(E)returning from a Western country; and(F)work as a delivery driver which implicated him as being anti-Taliban by assisting Shia people and spying for enemies of the Taliban;(f)on 7 April 2017 the Minister by his department (“Department”) acknowledged receipt of the SHE Visa application: CB 84;(g)on 7 November 2017 the Department requested that FFU18 attend an interview on 21 November 2017 (“Delegate’s Interview”): CB 98;(h)after the Delegate’s Interview FFU18’s agent provided to the Delegate a further statutory declaration signed by FFU18 (“November 2017 Statutory Declaration”): CB 102-103; a letter of support: CB 105; written submissions (“FFU18’s Delegate Submissions”): CB 107-119; photographs: CB 121-125; and police documents: CB 126-127; (i)in the November 2017 Statutory Declaration FFU18 repeated his claim that he could not relocate within Pakistan safely due to sectarian violence: CB 102 at [5], and also made a claim that he could not relocate due to not having a support network to assist him in establishing himself with young family members: CB 103 at [9];(j)FFU18’s Delegate Submissions addressed the reasonableness of FFU18 relocating within Pakistan: CB 107-119. They referred to sectarian violence as a reason why FFU18 ought not be deemed able to relocate within Pakistan: CB 116 at [64]-[66], and included references to Federal Court judgments concerning relocation: CB 117-118 at [72];(k)on 3 April 2018 the Delegate’s Decision was to refuse to grant FFU18 a SHE Visa: CB 133-148. The Delegate relevantly concluded that FFU18 would not face a real risk of suffering significant harm in Islamabad, Karachi, or Lahore: CB 141. The Delegate recorded that it discussed FFU18’s relocation to Islamabad, Karachi, or Lahore with FFU18 at the Delegate’s Interview: CB 138-141. The Delegate also concluded that it would be reasonable for FFU18 to relocate to any of those cities: CB 144-145;(l)on 10 April 2018 the Delegate’s Decision was referred to the Authority: CB 149-151;(m)on 11 April 2018 the Authority acknowledged the referral of the case: CB 150; and(n)on 25 April 2018 FFU18’s appointed agent: CB 161, provided submissions to the Authority: CB 162-166 (“FFU18’s Authority Submission”).AUTHORITY DECISION

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The factual background to this matter is as follows:(a)FFU18 was born on 30 May 1981 in Pakistan: CB 3;(b)FFU18 arrived in Australia by boat in 2013: CB 19;(c)on 23 May 2016 FFU18 was invited to apply for a SHE Visa: CB 23;(d)on 31 March 2017 FFU18 made an application for a SHE Visa with a statutory declaration in support (“March 2017 Statutory Declaration”): CB 32-83. In the March 2017 Statutory Declaration FFU18 advanced a claim that he could not relocate within Pakistan safely due to sectarian violence: CB 71 at [18]; (e)in summary, FFU18’s claims were as follows:(i)FFU18 is a Shia Muslim, a member of the Turi Tribe, ethnically Pashtun, and from Parachinar in the Kurram Agency in Pakistan;(ii)FFU18’s father is a schoolteacher, an influential man in Parachinar due to ownership of significant land and real estate, a member of the peace committee and of a Shia religious group (“Shia Religious Group”);(iii)FFU18 worked in Karachi from 2001 to 2006 as a security guard. FFU18 returned to Parachinar when it became too risky to live in Karachi. In Parachinar FFU18 worked as a tractor driver delivering water and on the family farm; (iv)FFU18’s father organised for him to go to the United Arab Emirates in March 2009 as it was increasingly risky for FFU18 to continue to live in Parachinar due to the war. FFU18 worked in Abu Dhabi from March 2009 to 2012;(v)when FFU18 returned to Parachinar he again worked delivering water and as a farmer. In December 2012 FFU18’s friend, who was also a water deliverer, was killed by the Taliban. After this, FFU18 was too scared to work; and(vi)if FFU18 returns to Parachinar, he fears being killed by an extremist group because he is Shia and Turi. He believes he will be targeted because of his:(A)religion;(B)membership of the Turi tribe;(C)father’s association with the Shia Religious Group;(D)actual and imputed political opinion opposed to the Taliban;(E)returning from a Western country; and(F)work as a delivery driver which implicated him as being anti-Taliban by assisting Shia people and spying for enemies of the Taliban;(f)on 7 April 2017 the Minister by his department (“Department”) acknowledged receipt of the SHE Visa application: CB 84;(g)on 7 November 2017 the Department requested that FFU18 attend an interview on 21 November 2017 (“Delegate’s Interview”): CB 98;(h)after the Delegate’s Interview FFU18’s agent provided to the Delegate a further statutory declaration signed by FFU18 (“November 2017 Statutory Declaration”): CB 102-103; a letter of support: CB 105; written submissions (“FFU18’s Delegate Submissions”): CB 107-119; photographs: CB 121-125; and police documents: CB 126-127; (i)in the November 2017 Statutory Declaration FFU18 repeated his claim that he could not relocate within Pakistan safely due to sectarian violence: CB 102 at [5], and also made a claim that he could not relocate due to not having a support network to assist him in establishing himself with young family members: CB 103 at [9];(j)FFU18’s Delegate Submissions addressed the reasonableness of FFU18 relocating within Pakistan: CB 107-119. They referred to sectarian violence as a reason why FFU18 ought not be deemed able to relocate within Pakistan: CB 116 at [64]-[66], and included references to Federal Court judgments concerning relocation: CB 117-118 at [72];(k)on 3 April 2018 the Delegate’s Decision was to refuse to grant FFU18 a SHE Visa: CB 133-148. The Delegate relevantly concluded that FFU18 would not face a real risk of suffering significant harm in Islamabad, Karachi, or Lahore: CB 141. The Delegate recorded that it discussed FFU18’s relocation to Islamabad, Karachi, or Lahore with FFU18 at the Delegate’s Interview: CB 138-141. The Delegate also concluded that it would be reasonable for FFU18 to relocate to any of those cities: CB 144-145;(l)on 10 April 2018 the Delegate’s Decision was referred to the Authority: CB 149-151;(m)on 11 April 2018 the Authority acknowledged the referral of the case: CB 150; and(n)on 25 April 2018 FFU18’s appointed agent: CB 161, provided submissions to the Authority: CB 162-166 (“FFU18’s Authority Submission”).AUTHORITY DECISION

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Minister Submissions in relation to ground 3 were as follows:(a)in determining whether the Authority committed the error asserted by FFU18, the Court must determine: (i)whether FFU18 claimed that it was not reasonable to relocate to Islamabad even if the claimed risk of harm was low;(ii)if so, whether the Authority considered that claimed risk of harm in concluding that it was reasonable for FFU18 to relocate to Islamabad; and(iii)if not, whether the error was material, in the sense that it could have realistically affected the outcome of the Authority Decision;(b)for the reasons set out below, the Minister contends that: (i)FFU18 did not squarely claim that even a low risk of harm in Islamabad was such that it was unreasonable for him to relocate there;(ii)even if he did, the Authority considered the risk of harm to FFU18 in Islamabad in concluding that it was reasonable for him to relocate there; and(iii)despite the above, even if the Authority erred, the error was immaterial, as it could not have realistically affected the outcome of the Authority Decision. (c)as to whether FFU18 claimed that it was unreasonable for him to relocate to Islamabad because of the risk of harm there it is important for the Court to answer the question at [12(a)(i)] above because a decision-maker is not always required to consider whether a low risk of harm in a location means it is unreasonable for a person to relocate to that place. For that reason, in MZYQU v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCA 1032; (2012) 206 FCR 191; (2012) 133 ALD 276 (“MZYQU”) at [55] per Dodds-Streeton J the Federal Court held that (emphasis added): Consistently with SZATV, factors such as “other and different risks in the propounded place of internal relocation” ... may be relevant, albeit not mandatory, considerations when determining the reasonableness of a proposed relocation.0FTo the extent that MZYQU stands for the proposition that consideration must always be given to the risk of generalised violence when assessing the reasonableness of relocation, the Minister formally submits that it was wrongly decided;(d)the well-settled principle is that the Authority’s role is to address an applicant’s claims: Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] HCA 26; (2003) 77 ALJR 1088; (2003) 197 ALR 389; (2003) 73 ALD 321 (“Dranichnikov”) at [78] per Kirby J. Put another way, the answer to the question of whether it is reasonable for an applicant to relocate “depends upon the framework set by the particular objections raised to relocation”: SZMCD v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and Another [2009] FCAFC 46; (2009) 174 FCR 415 at [124] per Tracey and Foster JJ;(e)FFU18’s submissions and materials to the Delegate and to the Authority on the reasonableness of relocation to Islamabad focused overwhelmingly on more pragmatic considerations, such as the cost of living, FFU18’s lack of education, his limited ability with the Urdu and Punjabi languages, and difficulties he would face in securing employment;(f)out of FFU18’s 2-page November 2017 Statutory Declaration to the Delegate, the 13-page Delegate Submission, and the 5-page Authority Submission, so far as the Minister can discern, the only reference to FFU18’s risk of harm being relevant to the reasonableness of relocation was in the following, entirely non-specific, reference to case law in FFU18’s Delegate Submissions: CB 117-118 at [72] (footnotes omitted, otherwise reproduced unamended): 72.Reasonableness of relocation in sense of practical, was addressed in recent case law;•In MZACX v Minister for Immigration (12 October 2016) at [35], Kenny J considered the principles relating to relocation thus: •In considering the possibility of relocation within a visa applicant’s country of nationality, the first question that arises is whether, objectively, there is no appreciable risk of the occurrence of the feared persecution in another part of that country. If there is an appreciable risk, then the issue of relocation for a particular applicant is concluded. If, however, there is no appreciable risk of the feared persecution at some other place in the country of nationality, the issue of relocation can be further explored. At this point, as indicated earlier, the question is whether the relocation of the visa applicant to that place is “reasonable”, in the sense of “practicable”, having regard to the particular circumstances of the applicant and the impact upon the applicant of relocation to that place. In answering this question, it may be relevant to include different or lower risks of harm faced by the applicant at a suggested place in assessment of the reasonableness of relocation in the particular circumstances of the case. •Her Honour’s reference to the relevance of “lower levels of harm” draws from the judgments of Dodds-Streeton J in MZYQU v Minister for Immigration, especially at [61]-[62], and Davies J in MZZJY v Minister for Immigration at [21]. The principle established in those cases was expressed by Davies J in MZZJY at [21] in this way: The fact that the risk of harm may be remote does not necessarily answer the question whether it is reasonable, having regard to the personal circumstances of the applicant, to expect the applicant to face that risk. The Tribunal was obliged to consider the practical realities for the applicant in determining whether it is reasonable to expect him to relocate. (g)this is the only part of FFU18’s materials that addresses the relevance of a risk of harm to the reasonableness of relocation. FFU18’s submissions at [11] that “The Applicant made an express claim that such a risk formed a reason why it was not reasonable for him to relocate to Islamabad” by the above extracted paragraph, is wrong because no such express claim was raised. The extracted paragraph made no reference whatsoever to FFU18, Islamabad, nor the risk faced by FFU18 therein. It was simply a bland extraction of case law on the reasonableness of relocation; (h)importantly, in the immediately following paragraphs in FFU18’s Delegate Submissions: CB 118, at [73]-[74], FFU18 did not mention any claim about a risk of harm in Islamabad making it not reasonable for him to relocate there. Instead, FFU18 listed “two reasons” why it was “not practical for applicant to relocate to another area of Pakistan”. The first was that he claimed he would be required to return to Parachinar to take his family with him and relocate to another area. The second was that he would be required to go back to Parachinar in order to unblock his ID Card and renew his driving licence. FFU18 then concluded by submitting that it was “neither reasonable nor practical for applicant to relocate to Islamabad or any other major city in Pakistan to establish himself and his family without undue hardship to subsist. We therefore request that reasonableness and practicality of relocation be given significant importance in your decision making”; and(i)the Minister submits that the above extracted paragraph did not amount to a claim squarely being made that even a low risk of harm (such as sectarian violence, now relied upon by FFU18) in Islamabad made it such that it was unreasonable for FFU18 to relocate to there.