CSZ16 v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CSZ16 v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2020] FCCA 772
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Protection Visa – decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority – whether the IAA failed to consider exercising the discretion in s.473DC(3) of the Migration Act – whether it was unreasonable for the IAA not to exercise the discretion in s.473DC(3) of the Migration Act – whether IAA erred in assessment relocation – no jurisdictional error – application dismissed.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.36(2B), 473CC, 473DB, 473DC, 473DD, 473DE, 476

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), reg.4.42

Cases cited:

BJB16 v Minister for Immigration [2018] FCAFC 49
Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v CRY16 [2017] FCAFC 210
Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v DZU16 [2018] FCAFC 32
MZANX v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 307
MZZZA v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 594

Applicant: CSZ16
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Second Respondent: IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY
File Number: MLG 2076 of 2016
Judgment of: Judge C. E. Kirton QC
Hearing date: 16 May 2018
Date of Last Submission: 16 May 2018
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 8 April 2020

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Ms G. Costello
Solicitors for the Applicant: Victoria Legal Aid
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr J. Maloney
The Second Respondent submitting appearance, save as to costs.
Solicitors for the Respondents: DLA Piper

ORDERS

  1. The name of the First Respondent be amended to the “Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs”.

  2. The Applicant’s amended application for judicial review filed on 3 May 2018 be dismissed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT MELBOURNE

MLG 2076 of 2016

CSZ16

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. This is an application for judicial review of a decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA), dated 23 August 2016.

  2. The IAA’s decision affirmed a decision of a delegate of the First Respondent (Minister) not to grant the Applicant a Temporary Protection (Subclass 785) visa (Visa).

  3. The Applicant filed an amended application in this Court with three grounds of review on 3 May 2018, those grounds of review, discussed below, are the subject of this Judgment.

  4. These proceedings are brought pursuant to s.476 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Act). To obtain assistance from this Court, the Applicant must show that the IAA has fallen into jurisdictional error.

  5. The Court had before it a Court Book spanning 388 pages, written submissions from the Applicant dated 2 May 2018 and written submissions from the Minister dated 9 May 2018.

Background

  1. The Applicant in these proceedings is a citizen of Afghanistan[1].

    [1] Court Book (CB) 37.

  2. On 13 July 2015, the Applicant applied for the Visa. The Applicant’s Visa application was accompanied by a Statutory Declaration, dated 25 June 2015[2].

    [2] CB 82.

  3. The Applicant claimed that he…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CSZ16 v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCCA 772
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before Judge C. E. Kirton QC concerning an application by CSZ16 against the Minister for Immigration. The dispute arose from the Delegate's decision on 28 June 2016 to refuse the Applicant's application. While the Delegate acknowledged the unsafe security situation in Logar Province, preventing the Applicant's safe return there, the Delegate concluded that the Applicant could relocate to Kabul without suffering harm for the claimed reasons.

The legal issues before the court involved determining whether the Delegate and subsequently the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA) had adequately considered the Applicant's personal circumstances when assessing the reasonableness of relocation to Kabul. Specifically, the court was required to consider whether the Applicant's lack of familiarity with Kabul, absence of support networks, limited education, and minimal life experience rendered him vulnerable to serious harm and exploitation upon return, particularly given the volatile situation in Afghanistan and the limited resources in Kabul due to a high number of internally displaced persons. The court also had to consider whether the IAA had properly addressed country information regarding the likelihood of attacks on Kabul's Shia population and the safety of other regions in Afghanistan, such as Balkh province and Herat.

The court's reasoning focused on the Applicant's submissions, which highlighted his vulnerability due to a lack of family ties and support in Kabul, contrasting with his ability to secure work in his home community through such ties. The Applicant's representatives argued that without family support and appropriate accommodation in Kabul, he would be extremely vulnerable to harm and exploitation. The IAA's invitation to comment on country information, including the potential infrequency of attacks on Kabul's Shia population and the relative safety of other provinces, indicated that the IAA was considering these factors. However, the Applicant's response reiterated the unreasonableness and irrelevance of relocation given his personal circumstances and the broader context of limited resources in Kabul.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of CSZ16 v Minister for Immigration involves a decision by a Delegate on 28 June 2016, where the Applicant's application was refused. The Delegate concluded that although the security situation in Logar Province was poor, the Applicant could safely relocate to Kabul and would not suffer harm. This conclusion was based on the Delegate's assessment that the Applicant could reasonably relocate within Afghanistan. Following the referral of the matter to the Independent Review Authority (IAA), the Applicant's representative submitted a document in July 2016, arguing that the Delegate had failed to consider the Applicant's personal circumstances, including the lack of support networks and familiarity with Kabul, which would make the Applicant vulnerable to serious harm and exploitation upon return to Kabul.

The Applicant’s submission highlighted that they had previously obtained work through family ties, which were absent in Kabul, and emphasised the Applicant’s lack of education and limited life experience. The submission also noted that resources in Kabul were extremely limited due to the high number of internally displaced persons living there. In addition to the July 2016 submission, the Applicant provided further information in July 2016 regarding the potential for attacks in Kabul targeting individuals based on their religious identity or ethnicity. On 4 August 2016, the IAA invited the Applicant to comment on various matters, including the safety of relocating to areas other than those where the Applicant claimed harm would occur. In response, the Applicant’s representatives reiterated their previous submissions and argued that it was not reasonable or relevant for the Applicant to relocate.

The case of CSZ16 v Minister for Immigration came before the court following a decision by the Delegate on 28 June 2016, which refused the Applicant's application for protection. The Delegate determined that although the Applicant could not safely return to Logar Province due to the poor security situation, they could safely relocate to Kabul without facing harm. This decision was subsequently referred to the Immigration and Asylum Reviewer (IAA) for further consideration. The Applicant's representatives submitted additional information and arguments in July 2016, asserting that the Delegate failed to consider the Applicant's personal circumstances, including their lack of familiarity with Kabul, absence of support networks, limited education, and vulnerability to serious harm and exploitation. The Applicant further submitted that their ability to obtain work previously was due to family ties which they do not have in Kabul. The IAA invited the Applicant to comment on various country information points and the reasonableness of relocating to areas of Afghanistan other than those claimed. In response, the Applicant's representatives reiterated their earlier submissions and argued that it was not reasonable for the Applicant to relocate.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 28 June 2016, the Delegate refused the Applicant’s application[5] (Delegate’s Decision). While the Delegate found that the poor security situation in Logar Province meant that the Applicant could not safely return there, the Delegate found that the Applicant could relocate to Kabul and he would not suffer harm for any of the reasons he had claimed. [5] CB 247-275. Following the referral of the matter to the IAA, the Applicant’s representative provided a submission for consideration (Applicant’s July 2016 Submission)[6]. Relevantly, that submission made extensive reference to the issue of relocation. The Applicant’s July 2016 Submission stated as follows[7]:[T]he delegate failed to take into consideration the applicant’s personal circumstances when assessing whether it was reasonable to expect him to relocate. Given the volatile situation in Afghanistan, we submit the applicant’s lack of familiarity with Kabul and lack of support networks would make him vulnerable to serious harm and exploitation upon return. The Applicant instructs that he was able to obtain work previously due to family ties he held with his community. He reiterates that he does not have such ties in Kabul, Afghanistan. Further, we note the applicant is not educated and has very limited life experience. […] [W]ithout family support and appropriate accommodation in Kabul, the applicant will be extremely vulnerable to harm. In particular, we note that resources in Kabul are extremely limited given the high number of IDPs forced to live there. […] Given these matters, we submit that the applicant would be vulnerable to exploitation and harm if forced to return to Kabul.[6] CB 287-294.[7] CB 293. On 25 July 2016, the Applicant provided further information to the IAA relating to the capacity for an attack to be undertaken in Kabul that targets people based on their religious identity or ethnicity (Applicant’s Additional July 2016 Submissions)[8]. [8] CB 295-298. On 4 August 2016, the IAA invited the Applicant to comment on a range of matters (IAA Invitation to Comment). Those matters included[9]:a)Commenting on country information which the IAA considered may lead it to conclude that ‘future attacks upon Kabul’s Shia population are likely to be infrequent, and not to such an extent as to pose a real chance or risk of harm to you’. b)Providing ‘Information as to why it would not be reasonable for you to relocate to any other areas of Afghanistan apart from those places you claim you will suffer harm’.c)Commenting on country information about Tajiks in the Balkh province, the relative safety of Mazar-e-Sharif and the dominance of Tajiks in Herat, and the availability of flights from Kabul to Herat and Mazar-e-Sharif.[9] CB 308-309. On 18 August 2016, the Applicant’s representatives responded to the IAA Invitation to Comment. The Applicant’s representatives reiterated their reliance on the previous submissions and information that they had provided and further submitted that it was not relevant or reasonable for the Applicant to relocate[10].[10] CB 311-315.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The primary issue addressed in the case of CSZ16 v Minister for Immigration was whether it was reasonable to expect the Applicant to relocate to Kabul, given his personal circumstances. The Applicant argued that his lack of familiarity with Kabul, absence of support networks, and limited life experience would make him vulnerable to serious harm and exploitation if forced to relocate there. The Applicant emphasized that he had previously obtained work through family ties, which he lacked in Kabul. Additionally, the Applicant highlighted that the resources in Kabul were extremely limited due to the high number of internally displaced persons (IDPs) living there. The Applicant maintained that without family support and appropriate accommodation, he would be extremely vulnerable to harm in Kabul.

The court examined the Delegate’s reasoning in refusing the Applicant’s claim for protection, focusing on the Delegate's finding that the Applicant could safely relocate to Kabul. The Applicant's representatives argued that the Delegate failed to consider the Applicant's personal circumstances, which made relocation unreasonable. The court had to determine whether the Delegate's assessment overlooked significant factors that would make relocation to Kabul a perilous prospect for the Applicant.

In assessing the vulnerability of the Applicant in Kabul, the court had to consider whether the Applicant would be susceptible to serious harm, exploitation, or attacks due to his religious identity or ethnicity, and the limited resources available in Kabul. The Applicant’s representatives submitted that the volatile situation in Afghanistan, coupled with the Applicant’s lack of familiarity with Kabul, lack of support networks, and limited life experience, would place him at a high risk of harm. The court needed to evaluate whether these factors indeed rendered relocation to Kabul unreasonable.

Another significant issue was the accuracy and relevance of the country information presented by the IAA, suggesting that attacks upon Kabul’s Shia population are likely to be infrequent and do not pose a real chance or risk of harm. The Applicant's representatives argued that this information was not relevant to the Applicant's case. The court had to assess the reliability and applicability of the IAA’s country information and determine whether it adequately addressed the Applicant's specific circumstances.

Lastly, the court had to consider whether it was reasonable for the Applicant to relocate to areas other than those where he claimed he would suffer harm. The Applicant argued that it was not reasonable for him to relocate to any other areas apart from those where he claimed he would suffer harm. The IAA had invited the Applicant to comment on country information regarding Tajiks in the Balkh province, the safety of Mazar-e-Sharif, and the availability of flights from Kabul to Herat and Mazar-e-Sharif. The Applicant's representatives reiterated their previous submissions and further argued that it was not relevant or reasonable for the Applicant to relocate. The court needed to evaluate the relevance of this information and the Applicant's arguments against relocating to other areas.

In summary, the court's reasoning in this case revolved around the assessment of the Applicant's personal circumstances, the risks associated with relocating to Kabul, the relevance of country information, and the reasonableness of relocating to areas other than those claimed to be unsafe. The court's analysis included examining whether the Delegate's decision adequately considered the Applicant's unique vulnerabilities, the reliability of the country information presented by the IAA, and whether the Applicant's claims about potential harm in alternative locations were substantiated. The ratio decidendi of this case lies in the necessity to thoroughly assess individual circumstances and vulnerabilities when determining the reasonableness of relocation within a country of origin, ensuring that decisions are made with a comprehensive understanding of the applicant's specific situation and risks.