FCM18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

FCM18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FedCFamC2G 1306

File number(s): MLG 2941 of 2018
Judgment of: JUDGE LUCEV
Date of judgment: 29 November 2024
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Judicial review application – decision of Immigration Assessment Authority – citizen of Pakistan – whether failure to consider the risk of harm to the applicant in Islamabad in the context of whether it was reasonable for him to relocate from Parachinar to Islamabad – whether material jurisdictional error.
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 5J, 36, 473CC, 474, 476
Cases cited:

APE16 v Minister for Home Affairs [2020] FCAFC 93; (2020) 277 FCR 640

Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 184; (2003) 236 FCR 593; (2003) 75 ALD 630

Carrascalao v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCAFC 107; (2017) 252 FCR 352; (2017) 347 ALR 173

CIT17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 150; (2018) 265 FCR 572

CSO15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 14; (2018) 260 FCR 134; (2018) 353 ALR 666

CSZ16 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCAFC 156

CXO16 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCA 17

DNQ18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCAFC 72; (2020) 275 FCR 517

Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] HCA 26; (2003) 77 ALJR 1088; (2003) 197 ALR 389; (2003) 73 ALD 321

EVA17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 214; (2018) 262 FCR 304

Januzi v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2006] 2 AC 426; [2006] 3 All ER 305

LPDT v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 12; (2024) 98 ALJR 610

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v DZU16 [2018] FCAFC 32; (2018) 253 FCR 526; (2018) 357 ALR 474

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZMTA [2019] HCA 3; (2019) 264 CLR 421; (2019) 163 ALD 38; (2019) 363 ALR 599; (2019) 93 ALJR 252; (2019) 75 AAR 75

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZSCA & Anor [2014] HCA 45; (2014) 254 CLR 317; (2014) 89 ALJR 47; (2014) 314 ALR 514

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS [2010] HCA 16; (2010) 240 CLR 611; (2010) 84 ALJR 369; (2010) 266 ALR 367; (2010) 115 ALD 248

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang [1996] HCA 6; (1996) 185 CLR 259; (1996) 70 ALJR 568; (1996) 136 ALR 481; (1996) 41 ALD 1

MZACX v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 1212; (2018) 161 ALD 73

MZAPC v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2021] HCA 17

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FCM18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FedCFamC2G 1306
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

FCM18, a citizen of Pakistan, applied for a Subclass 865 Humanitarian Entry Visa from Australia. The Immigration Assessment Authority reviewed FCM18’s application and found that it was reasonable for him to relocate within Pakistan, and subsequently dismissed his visa application. FCM18 sought judicial review of the Authority’s decision, claiming that the Authority did not consider the risk of harm to him in Islamabad in the context of whether it was reasonable for him to relocate from Parachinar to Islamabad. The Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs opposed the application, arguing that the Authority had considered the risk of harm in Islamabad and that even if there was an error, it was immaterial.

The court considered whether the Authority had committed a material jurisdictional error by failing to consider the risk of harm to FCM18 in Islamabad. The court held that FCM18 did not claim that even a low risk of harm in Islamabad made it unreasonable for him to relocate there. Instead, his submissions focused on more pragmatic considerations such as the cost of living and the inability to secure employment. The court found that the Authority had considered the general safety or security situation in Islamabad and concluded that it was reasonable for FCM18 to relocate there. Even if there was an error, the court held that it was immaterial as there was no realistic possibility that the Authority would have made a different decision.

The court dismissed FCM18’s application for judicial review. The Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs was not liable to pay FCM18’s costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

At hearing the Court Book (“CB”) was marked as Exhibit 1. The Authority Decision appears in the CB at CB 145-167. All references to provisions of the Migration Act in these Reasons for Judgment are to the provisions as at the date of the Authority Decision.BACKGROUND The factual background of the matter is as follows:(a)FCM18 was born in 1991 in Pakistan: CB 3;(b)FCM18 arrived in Australia by boat as an unauthorised maritime arrival in May 2013: CB 17;(c)on 12 August 2016 FCM18 was invited to apply for a SHE Visa: CB 26;(d)on 7 August 2017 FCM18 made an application for a SHE Visa with a statutory declaration (“2017 Statutory Declaration”) in support: CB 30. In the 2017 Statutory Declaration FCM18 advanced a claim that he could not relocate within Pakistan safely due to sectarian violence: CB 63 at [22] and [25]; (e)in summary, FCM18’s claims were as follows: (i)he is a Pakistani citizen, a Shia Muslim, and a Turi Alizai Pakhtun community member, who originates from Parachinar in the Kurram Agency in Pakistan;(ii)in 2010 the Taliban attacked a convoy in which FCM18 was travelling with his brother to Islamabad. The Taliban attacked the vehicles ahead of them and there was an explosion. FCM18 and his brother were lucky to escape unharmed but many other innocent Shia Muslims were killed or injured (“2010 Incident”); (iii)in approximately March 2013 FCM18 was studying in Islamabad and the Taliban attempted to abduct him in a bazaar. FCM18 was shopping with his friends one evening. As he was crossing the road a car pulled up with two men who had their faces covered. They tried to grab FCM18 and pull him into the car but he resisted. FCM18 cried out for help, his friends heard and ran to his aid, and the attackers let him go. FCM18 believes the attackers were members of the Taliban as they are known to kidnap Shia people in a similar way in Parachinar (“2013 Incident”); (iv)one week prior to the 2013 Incident FCM18 had met a Sunni former classmate from Parachinar in Islamabad. His former classmate had asked what he was doing in Islamabad and FCM18 told him he was studying at the National Institute of Cultural Studies and he was staying in a hostel; (v)FCM18 believes his former Sunni classmate conspired with the Taliban to abduct him because most Sunni students in Islamabad felt they could seek revenge for sectarian violence committed against Sunnis in Parachinar by targeting Shia students, particularly those who were also Turi tribe members;(vi)after the attempted abduction FCM18’s parents told him to return to Parachinar. He did so but continued to face the same threat of harm as he did in Islamabad. He felt that he could not go out as he feared being killed by the Taliban. The Taliban accused his father of fighting against them and assisting the Pakistani government in their operations against them; and(vii)FCM18 therefore left Pakistan because he feared he would be harmed or killed by the Taliban or other insurgent groups because of his religion, his ethnicity, his social status, and his father’s work; (f)on 9 August 2017 the Minister acknowledged receipt of the SHE Visa application: CB 71;(g)on 19 October 2017 the Minister requested that FCM18 attend an interview with the Delegate on 31 October 2017: CB 73;(h)on 31 October 2017 FCM18 and his agent attended an interview with the Delegate: CB 73;(i)on 8 November 2017 FCM18’s representative provided submissions which addressed the reasonableness of FCM18 relocating within Pakistan: CB 99 (“FCM18’s Delegate Submissions”), and referred to sectarian violence as a reason why FCM18 ought not be deemed able to relocate within Pakistan: CB 99 at [62]-[64];(j)in FCM18’s Delegate Submissions FCM18 relevantly argued that relocation to Islamabad was not reasonable because: (i)FCM18 had “limited ability to find work in other areas of Pakistan”: CB 99 at [67];(ii)FCM18 did not have “any relatives or family in other parts of Pakistan and will face significant hardship in establishing himself”: CB 100 at [68];(iii)FCM18 did not have any financial support from the Pakistani government and would not have sufficient income to maintain a reasonable standard of living: CB 100 at [68]; (iv)Islamabad was not affordable, including because of the “significant disparity in income and expenses”: CB 100 at [69]; (v)of risks of harm not amounting to a real risk of significant harm being a reason why it is not reasonable, in the sense of practicable, for FCM18 to relocate within Pakistan: CB 100 at [70];(vi)FCM18 would need to travel to Parachinar first, before relocating with his family to a different city within Pakistan: CB 101 at [71]; (vii)it was “neither reasonable nor practical” for him to relocate to Islamabad: CB 101 at [72]; and(viii)there was “no assurance of long-term safety, [and it] is not affordable and practical for him to consider relocation with no means to subsist”: CB 101 at [75];(k)on 23 January 2018 the Delegate refused to grant FCM18 a SHE Visa: CB 106-124. The Delegate relevantly concluded that FCM18 would not face a real risk of suffering significant harm in Islamabad, Rawalpindi, or Lahore. The Delegate also concluded that it would be reasonable for FCM18 to relocate to any of those cities;(l)on 30 January 2018 the Authority acknowledged the referral of FCM18’s case: CB 126; and(m)on 20 February 2018 FCM18’s representative sent submissions to the Authority (“FCM18’s Authority Submissions”): CB 136-141. FCM18’s Authority Submissions address why it was purportedly unreasonable for FCM18 to relocate to Islamabad, including because of the lack of social support, the cost of living and the need to travel to Parachinar to renew his CNIC (a national ID card)(“ID Card”): CB 140-141.AUTHORITY DECISION

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The factual background of the matter is as follows:(a)FCM18 was born in 1991 in Pakistan: CB 3;(b)FCM18 arrived in Australia by boat as an unauthorised maritime arrival in May 2013: CB 17;(c)on 12 August 2016 FCM18 was invited to apply for a SHE Visa: CB 26;(d)on 7 August 2017 FCM18 made an application for a SHE Visa with a statutory declaration (“2017 Statutory Declaration”) in support: CB 30. In the 2017 Statutory Declaration FCM18 advanced a claim that he could not relocate within Pakistan safely due to sectarian violence: CB 63 at [22] and [25]; (e)in summary, FCM18’s claims were as follows: (i)he is a Pakistani citizen, a Shia Muslim, and a Turi Alizai Pakhtun community member, who originates from Parachinar in the Kurram Agency in Pakistan;(ii)in 2010 the Taliban attacked a convoy in which FCM18 was travelling with his brother to Islamabad. The Taliban attacked the vehicles ahead of them and there was an explosion. FCM18 and his brother were lucky to escape unharmed but many other innocent Shia Muslims were killed or injured (“2010 Incident”); (iii)in approximately March 2013 FCM18 was studying in Islamabad and the Taliban attempted to abduct him in a bazaar. FCM18 was shopping with his friends one evening. As he was crossing the road a car pulled up with two men who had their faces covered. They tried to grab FCM18 and pull him into the car but he resisted. FCM18 cried out for help, his friends heard and ran to his aid, and the attackers let him go. FCM18 believes the attackers were members of the Taliban as they are known to kidnap Shia people in a similar way in Parachinar (“2013 Incident”); (iv)one week prior to the 2013 Incident FCM18 had met a Sunni former classmate from Parachinar in Islamabad. His former classmate had asked what he was doing in Islamabad and FCM18 told him he was studying at the National Institute of Cultural Studies and he was staying in a hostel; (v)FCM18 believes his former Sunni classmate conspired with the Taliban to abduct him because most Sunni students in Islamabad felt they could seek revenge for sectarian violence committed against Sunnis in Parachinar by targeting Shia students, particularly those who were also Turi tribe members;(vi)after the attempted abduction FCM18’s parents told him to return to Parachinar. He did so but continued to face the same threat of harm as he did in Islamabad. He felt that he could not go out as he feared being killed by the Taliban. The Taliban accused his father of fighting against them and assisting the Pakistani government in their operations against them; and(vii)FCM18 therefore left Pakistan because he feared he would be harmed or killed by the Taliban or other insurgent groups because of his religion, his ethnicity, his social status, and his father’s work; (f)on 9 August 2017 the Minister acknowledged receipt of the SHE Visa application: CB 71;(g)on 19 October 2017 the Minister requested that FCM18 attend an interview with the Delegate on 31 October 2017: CB 73;(h)on 31 October 2017 FCM18 and his agent attended an interview with the Delegate: CB 73;(i)on 8 November 2017 FCM18’s representative provided submissions which addressed the reasonableness of FCM18 relocating within Pakistan: CB 99 (“FCM18’s Delegate Submissions”), and referred to sectarian violence as a reason why FCM18 ought not be deemed able to relocate within Pakistan: CB 99 at [62]-[64];(j)in FCM18’s Delegate Submissions FCM18 relevantly argued that relocation to Islamabad was not reasonable because: (i)FCM18 had “limited ability to find work in other areas of Pakistan”: CB 99 at [67];(ii)FCM18 did not have “any relatives or family in other parts of Pakistan and will face significant hardship in establishing himself”: CB 100 at [68];(iii)FCM18 did not have any financial support from the Pakistani government and would not have sufficient income to maintain a reasonable standard of living: CB 100 at [68]; (iv)Islamabad was not affordable, including because of the “significant disparity in income and expenses”: CB 100 at [69]; (v)of risks of harm not amounting to a real risk of significant harm being a reason why it is not reasonable, in the sense of practicable, for FCM18 to relocate within Pakistan: CB 100 at [70];(vi)FCM18 would need to travel to Parachinar first, before relocating with his family to a different city within Pakistan: CB 101 at [71]; (vii)it was “neither reasonable nor practical” for him to relocate to Islamabad: CB 101 at [72]; and(viii)there was “no assurance of long-term safety, [and it] is not affordable and practical for him to consider relocation with no means to subsist”: CB 101 at [75];(k)on 23 January 2018 the Delegate refused to grant FCM18 a SHE Visa: CB 106-124. The Delegate relevantly concluded that FCM18 would not face a real risk of suffering significant harm in Islamabad, Rawalpindi, or Lahore. The Delegate also concluded that it would be reasonable for FCM18 to relocate to any of those cities;(l)on 30 January 2018 the Authority acknowledged the referral of FCM18’s case: CB 126; and(m)on 20 February 2018 FCM18’s representative sent submissions to the Authority (“FCM18’s Authority Submissions”): CB 136-141. FCM18’s Authority Submissions address why it was purportedly unreasonable for FCM18 to relocate to Islamabad, including because of the lack of social support, the cost of living and the need to travel to Parachinar to renew his CNIC (a national ID card)(“ID Card”): CB 140-141.AUTHORITY DECISION

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Minister submitted as follows:(a)in determining whether the Authority committed the error asserted by FCM18 the Court must determine: (i)whether FCM18 claimed that it was not reasonable to relocate to Islamabad even if the claimed risk of harm was low;(ii)if so, whether the Authority considered that claimed risk of harm in concluding that it was reasonable for FCM18 to relocate to Islamabad; and (iii)if not, was the error material, in the sense that it could have realistically affected the outcome of the Authority Decision;(b)for the reasons set out below, the Minister contends that: (i)FCM18 did not claim that even a low risk of harm in Islamabad was such that it was unreasonable for him to relocate there; (ii)even if he did, the Authority considered the risk of harm to FCM18 in Islamabad in concluding that it was reasonable for him to relocate there; and(iii)despite the above, even if the Authority erred, the error was immaterial, as it could not have realistically affected the outcome of the Authority Decision; (c)as to whether FCM18 claimed that it was unreasonable for him to relocate to Islamabad because of the risk of harm there it is important for the Court to answer this first question because a decision-maker is not always required to consider whether a low risk of harm in a location means it is unreasonable for a person to relocate to that place. For that reason, in MZYQU v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCA 1032; (2012) 206 FCR 191; (2012) 133 ALD 276 (“MZYQU”) at [55] per Dodds-Streeton J it was held that (emphasis added): Consistently with SZATV, factors such as “other and different risks in the propounded place of internal relocation” ... may be relevant, albeit not mandatory, considerations when determining the reasonableness of a proposed relocation.and to the extent MZYQU stands for the proposition that consideration must always be given to the risk of generalised violence when assessing the reasonableness of relocation, the Minister formally submits that it was wrongly decided;(d)the well-settled principle is that it is the Authority’s role is to address an applicant’s claims: Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] HCA 26; (2003) 77 ALJR 1088; (2003) 197 ALR 389; (2003) 73 ALD 321 (“Dranichnikov”) at [78] per Kirby J. Put another way, the answer to the question of whether it is reasonable for an applicant to relocate “depends upon the framework set by the particular objections raised to relocation”: SZMCD v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and Another [2009] FCAFC 46; (2009) 174 FCR 415 at [123] per Tracey and Foster JJ;(e)with the above principles in mind, the Minister emphasises that FCM18’s submissions on the reasonableness of relocation to Islamabad focused overwhelmingly on more pragmatic considerations, such as the cost of living and the inability to secure employment. Out of the 13-page FCM18’s Delegate Submission and the 6-page FCM18’s Authority Submission, so far as the Minister can discern, the only references to the safety of Islamabad being relevant to the reasonableness of relocation were in the following references in FCM18’s Delegate Submission:(i)“We stress that the report makes the admission of relative safety but does not assert that Islamabad, Lahore or Rawalpindi are free of terrorism. We submit that in all three of these cities, violence has occurred both before and after the dates of reports. We submit that DIBP should deem it imperative that ongoing violence must not exist in a region in order to deem it safe for relocation. The safety threshold must remain of a high standard for any ample relocation assessment”: CB 99 at [64]; and(ii)there was no “assurance of long term safety” in Islamabad: CB 101 at [75];(f)aside from the above two references, FCM18’s submissions on the reasonableness of relocation (especially FCM18’s Authority Submission) were largely about Islamabad being unaffordable: see for example CB 140-141;(g)the above submissions do not amount to a claim ever being made that even a low risk of harm (such as sectarian violence, now relied upon by FCM18) made it such that it was unreasonable for FCM18 to relocate to Islamabad. Rather, the claim that was actually put was that there must be no “terrorism” or “violence” for Islamabad to be deemed “safe”. It was, in other words, about how the generally unsafe security situation in Islamabad made it unreasonable to relocate to;(h)with the above background in mind about how FCM18’s claims were actually put to the Authority, it is entirely unsurprising why the Authority chose to focus on factors such as access to employment. In any event, the Minister contends that when the Authority Decision is read fairly and as a whole: Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang [1996] HCA 6; (1996) 185 CLR 259; (1996) 70 ALJR 568; (1996) 136 ALR 481; (1996) 41 ALD 1 (“Wu Shan Liang”), CLR at 272 per Brennan CJ, Toohey, McHugh and Gummow JJ, the Authority did consider the general safety or security situation in Islamabad in concluding that it was reasonable for FCM18 to relocate there; (i)the Authority had earlier found that the risk of sectarian violence in Islamabad was remote: CB 158 at [58]. This was based on its assessment of country information and its earlier findings that FCM18 did not have an adverse profile;(j)the Authority drew upon its earlier finding and reasoning when turning to the reasonableness of relocation to Islamabad: CB 160 at [66]. It found that FCM18 did not face a real risk of significant harm for any reason, or a combination of any reasons, advanced by FCM18: CB 160 at [66]. After considering whether it was reasonable, in the sense of practicable, for FCM18 to relocate, it concluded that “having regard to all of the above”, it was satisfied that it was reasonable for FCM18 to relocate: CB 162 at [78]; (k)having earlier set out country information on Islamabad in detail, and FCM18’s lack of any adverse profile, the Minister contends that the Authority must have taken into account everything preceding its concluding sentencing when it said that, having regard to “all of the above”, that it was reasonable for FCM18 to relocate to Islamabad;(l)a similar situation was considered by the Full Court of the Federal Court in Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v DZU16 [2018] FCAFC 32; (2018) 253 FCR 526; (2018) 357 ALR 474 (“DZU16”). In DZU16, after distinguishing cases like MZYQU, MZZJY v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] FCA 1394 and MZACX, the Full Court of the Federal Court held at [137] and [139] per Robertson, Murphy and Kerr JJ that the Authority did not err;(m)in DZU16, [61] of the Authority decision (set out in DZU16 at [43] per Robertson, Murphy and Kerr JJ), which assumed central importance was as follows:Considering all the circumstances, I am satisfied it would be reasonable for the applicant to relocate to an area of the country such as Mazar-e-Sharif where there would not be a real risk that the applicant will suffer significant harm. As I am satisfied that the applicant could relocate to Kabul [sic, Mazar-e-Sharif], there is not a real risk that the applicant will suffer significant harm in Afghanistan.(n)applying DZU16 this Court should find that the Authority’s conclusion on the reasonableness of relocation must have incorporated its earlier analysis that there was not a real chance or risk of FCM18 facing any harm in Islamabad. The Authority cannot sensibly be inferred to have forgotten its earlier analysis about the risk of harm in Islamabad being remote in concluding that it was reasonable for FCM18 to relocate there;(o)the Minister does not concede that the Authority committed any error. However, even if the Court finds that the Authority’s consideration of the relocation issue involved any error, the Minister submits that any error was immaterial in the sense that there is no realistic possibility of a different outcome: MZAPC v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2021] HCA 17; (2021) 273 CLR 506; (2021) 95 ALJR 441; (2021) 390 ALR 590 (“MZAPC”) at [38] per Kiefel CJ, Gageler, Keane and Gleeson JJ;(p)determining whether there was such a realistic possibility requires the Court to determine “the basal factual question of how the decision that was in fact made was in fact made”: MZAPC at [38] per Kiefel CJ, Gageler, Keane and Gleeson JJ. In short, the Court is to make reasonable inferences on the balance of probabilities, having regard to what the Authority’s other reasons and findings were, and the material before it: MZAPC at [2] per Kiefel CJ, Gageler, Keane and Gleeson JJ; and(q)the tenor of the Authority’s conclusions was clear: FCM18 would not face a real chance or risk of harm in Islamabad. The Authority considered in detail the practicalities of FCM18 relocating to Islamabad, including his capacity to subsist, and whether he needed to travel back to the Kurram Agency for any reason. FCM18 did not make any detailed claim or put forward any substantive submission on why safety in Islamabad made it unreasonable for him to relocate there: see in comparison, the detailed submissions made on relocation in CXO16 at [5]-[14] per Wheelahan J. In those circumstances, there is no realistic possibility that the Authority would have made a different decision.CONSIDERATIONMaterial jurisdictional error required