Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
KIEFEL, GAGELER, NETTLE AND GORDON JJ

MILITARY REHABILITATION AND
COMPENSATION COMMISSION  APPELLANT

AND

BENJAMIN JAMES EDWARD MAY  RESPONDENT

Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May

[2016] HCA 19

11 May 2016

S243/2015

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed.

2.Set aside paragraphs 2, 3(a) and 3(b) of the order of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 30 June 2015, and in their place order that the appeal be dismissed.

3.The appellant pay the respondent's costs of the appeal to this Court.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation

P J Hanks QC with P G Woulfe for the appellant (instructed by Moray & Agnew Solicitors)

R G McHugh SC with B K Nolan for the respondent (instructed by Legal Minds)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

Workers compensation – Where employee vaccinated in course of employment and later felt unwell, described as "vertigo" – Where evidence did not establish nature and incidents of any physiological or psychiatric change – Whether employee suffered "injury" within meaning of s 4(1) of Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth).

Words and phrases – "ailment", "disease", "disturbance of the normal physiological state", "injury", "injury (other than a disease)", "physiological change", "psychiatric change", "sudden or identifiable".

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), ss 4(1), 14(1).

  1. FRENCH CJ, KIEFEL, NETTLE AND GORDON JJ.   The respondent, Mr May, served in the Royal Australian Air Force ("the RAAF") before being discharged.  Mr May had become "significantly disabled" by dizziness.  This "cut short what might have been a very promising career as a pilot in the RAAF"[1]. 

    [1]Re May and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2011] AATA 886 at [66].

  2. Mr May applied for compensation under s 14(1) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ("the Act") "in respect of an injury suffered by an employee [where] the injury results in death, incapacity for work, or impairment" (emphasis added). 

  3. The question on this appeal is whether Mr May's dizziness was an "injury" for the purposes of the Act and therefore compensable under s 14 of the Act. The Full Court said it was. For the reasons that follow, that conclusion cannot be supported and the appeal must be allowed.

    Legislative framework

  4. This appeal is concerned with the Act as at 29 November 2002[2], being the date Mr May lodged his claim. 

    [2]All references in these reasons are to the Act as at that date: see the compilation prepared as at 13 September 2002, taking into account amendments up to Act No 144 of 2001.

  5. Section 14 of the Act, entitled "Compensation for injuries", relevantly provided:

    "(1)Subject to this Part, Comcare is liable to pay compensation in accordance with this Act in respect of an injury suffered by an employee if the injury results in death, incapacity for work, or impairment."  (emphasis added)

  6. "[I]njury" was defined in s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] HCA 19
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal from the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia concerning the interpretation of "injury (other than a disease)" under the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (Cth). The dispute arose from a claim for compensation by Mr May, a former RAAF officer, who alleged he suffered adverse reactions, including vertigo, as a result of vaccinations received during his service. The Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission (the appellant) denied his claim, as medical specialists were unable to diagnose a specific condition or establish a causal link between his symptoms and the vaccinations.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether Mr May's reported symptoms constituted an "injury" as defined by the Act, specifically under the limb of "injury (other than a disease)". This required the Court to consider whether the symptoms represented a physiological or psychiatric change that was sudden or identifiable, and whether the absence of a diagnosed pathology meant no injury had occurred. The Court also had to determine the proper construction of the Act in light of its text, context, and purpose.

The High Court allowed the appeal, reasoning that the definition of "injury" in the Act requires a disturbance of the normal physiological or psychiatric state of a person, which must be identifiable and, in the case of an injury other than a disease, be sudden. The Court found that while Mr May experienced symptoms, the extensive medical evidence, including the findings of numerous specialists and the Tribunal's reliance on Dr Loblay's evidence, did not establish a physiological or psychiatric change that was sudden or identifiable. The evidence indicated that Mr May's symptoms were not consistent with a diagnosed pathology or an immunological reaction to the vaccinations, and therefore did not meet the threshold for an "injury" under the Act.

The High Court ordered that the appeal be allowed, setting aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court and substituting an order dismissing Mr May's appeal to that Court. The appellant was ordered to pay Mr May's costs of the appeal to the High Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. Set aside paragraphs 2, 3(a) and 3(b) of the order of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 30 June 2015, and in their place order that the appeal be dismissed.

3. The appellant pay the respondent's costs of the appeal to this Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

This appeal concerns the proper construction of the phrase "injury (other than a disease)" in par (b) of the definition of "injury" in s 4(1) of the Act. That question of construction is determined by reference to the text, context and purpose of the Act[3].[3]Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355 at 381-382 [69]-[71]; [1998] HCA 28; Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue (2009) 239 CLR 27 at 46-47 [47]; [2009] HCA 41.Facts Mr May was born in 1975. On 6 November 1998, he enlisted in the RAAF. At that time, he was healthy and fit. He was discharged on 30 July 2004 at the rank of Officer Cadet. Between 10 November 1998 and 30 March 2000 (inclusive), in the course of his employment with the RAAF, Mr May was required to undergo a series of vaccinations. He said that he suffered a series of adverse reactions to these vaccinations. On 29 November 2002, Mr May applied under s 14 of the Act for compensation in respect of "low immunity, fatigue, illnesses, dizziness – immune system/whole body", which, he maintained, he sustained as a result of the vaccinations he received while he was employed with the RAAF. On 11 March 2003, a delegate of the appellant denied Mr May's claim, noting that specialists who had examined him had been unable to diagnose any specific condition or determine a cause for his symptoms, and the delegate was therefore unable to connect the claimed condition with his RAAF service ("the determination"). In April 2010, following an application by Mr May, the appellant reconsidered but affirmed the determination. Previous decisionsAdministrative Appeals Tribunal ("the Tribunal") In 2010, Mr May applied to the Tribunal for a review of that second decision. The Tribunal received extensive medical evidence about Mr May's medical history. The medical evidence relating to his "vertigo" included reports from a number of experts. Dr Barrie, an ear, nose and throat ("ENT") surgeon, reported that "[p]hysical examination reveals normal tests of balance with no gaze nystagmus"[4]. Dr Halmagyi, a neurophysiologist, "could find no vestibular abnormalities" and no "pathological cause for his minor vestibular symptoms"[5]. Dr Halmagyi noted that he found no validated example of immunisation causing vestibular problems and had personally never seen someone in whom he attributed their vestibular problems to an immunisation.[4]May [2011] AATA 886 at [25].[5]May [2011] AATA 886 at [25]. Dr Tonkin, an ENT specialist, initially found mild imbalance inconsistent both with Mr May's symptoms and with Eustachian tube dysfunction. Further test results were all negative, including a balance test, which was normal[6]. Professor Fagan, a second ENT surgeon, reported he could not "find any evidence of any vestibular or central nervous system abnormality"[7]. Dr Kertesz, a third ENT surgeon, organised tests, the results of which were within normal limits, and noted no diagnosis[8]. Dr Pohl, a fourth ENT surgeon, noted Mr May's history of imbalance and vertigo associated with nausea and then described his examination findings as unremarkable. A subsequent MRA scan proved normal and Dr Pohl concluded that he was "unable to find a cause for [Mr May's] imbalance and dizziness"[9]. Dr Lowy, an occupational physician, reported that Mr May's "constellation of symptoms … is not consistent with substantial pathology within his vestibular system"[10]. Dr Dowe, a fifth ENT surgeon, agreed. Dr Moore, a psychiatrist, concluded that Mr May "does not suffer from a diagnosable psychiatric disorder" and that "no psychiatric disturbance … could better account for his symptoms"[11]. [6]May [2011] AATA 886 at [27].[7]May [2011] AATA 886 at [28].[8]May [2011] AATA 886 at [29].[9]May [2011] AATA 886 at [30].[10]May [2011] AATA 886 at [31].[11]May [2011] AATA 886 at [31].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, KIEFEL, NETTLE AND GORDON JJ GAGELER J
On 11 March 2003, a delegate of the appellant denied Mr May's claim, noting that specialists who had examined him had been unable to diagnose any specific condition or determine a cause for his symptoms, and the delegate was therefore unable to connect the claimed condition with his RAAF service ("the determination"). In April 2010, following an application by Mr May, the appellant reconsidered but affirmed the determination. Previous decisionsAdministrative Appeals Tribunal ("the Tribunal") In 2010, Mr May applied to the Tribunal for a review of that second decision. The Tribunal received extensive medical evidence about Mr May's medical history. The medical evidence relating to his "vertigo" included reports from a number of experts. Dr Barrie, an ear, nose and throat ("ENT") surgeon, reported that "[p]hysical examination reveals normal tests of balance with no gaze nystagmus"[4]. Dr Halmagyi, a neurophysiologist, "could find no vestibular abnormalities" and no "pathological cause for his minor vestibular symptoms"[5]. Dr Halmagyi noted that he found no validated example of immunisation causing vestibular problems and had personally never seen someone in whom he attributed their vestibular problems to an immunisation.[4]May [2011] AATA 886 at [25].[5]May [2011] AATA 886 at [25]. Dr Tonkin, an ENT specialist, initially found mild imbalance inconsistent both with Mr May's symptoms and with Eustachian tube dysfunction. Further test results were all negative, including a balance test, which was normal[6]. Professor Fagan, a second ENT surgeon, reported he could not "find any evidence of any vestibular or central nervous system abnormality"[7]. Dr Kertesz, a third ENT surgeon, organised tests, the results of which were within normal limits, and noted no diagnosis[8]. Dr Pohl, a fourth ENT surgeon, noted Mr May's history of imbalance and vertigo associated with nausea and then described his examination findings as unremarkable. A subsequent MRA scan proved normal and Dr Pohl concluded that he was "unable to find a cause for [Mr May's] imbalance and dizziness"[9]. Dr Lowy, an occupational physician, reported that Mr May's "constellation of symptoms … is not consistent with substantial pathology within his vestibular system"[10]. Dr Dowe, a fifth ENT surgeon, agreed. Dr Moore, a psychiatrist, concluded that Mr May "does not suffer from a diagnosable psychiatric disorder" and that "no psychiatric disturbance … could better account for his symptoms"[11]. [6]May [2011] AATA 886 at [27].[7]May [2011] AATA 886 at [28].[8]May [2011] AATA 886 at [29].[9]May [2011] AATA 886 at [30].[10]May [2011] AATA 886 at [31].[11]May [2011] AATA 886 at [31]. The Tribunal had "particular regard to" the evidence of Dr Loblay, a physician and the Director of the Allergy Unit at the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital, who gave evidence at the hearing and had many years' experience in the investigation and treatment of immune reactions, both to drugs and to vaccines[12]. The Tribunal found his evidence convincing and noted his opinion that it is "very unlikely that Mr May has suffered from an immunologically mediated adverse reaction to the vaccinations he was given"[13]. Dr Loblay also expressed the view that Mr May's symptoms "could be categorized as a 'functional somatic disorder'"[14]. Dr Loblay opined that although Mr May was not malingering, his history was "not characteristic of an immune reaction to vaccinations"[15] and in his case there was "no biological mechanism consistent with a vaccine generating an immune response"[16]. Dr Loblay also opined that it was "not uncommon for a person to have symptoms without there being an explanation for the symptoms and without there being a diagnosable disease" and that Mr May's condition was an "illness", being a subjective description of his symptoms[17]. The absence of damage to the vestibular system meant that Mr May's "vertigo" could not be linked to an immunological reaction. [12]May [2011] AATA 886 at [56].[13]May [2011] AATA 886 at [56].[14]May [2011] AATA 886 at [32].[15]May [2011] AATA 886 at [34].[16]May [2011] AATA 886 at [35].[17]May [2011] AATA 886 at [35].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, KIEFEL, NETTLE AND GORDON JJ, GAGELER J