Ziade and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

Ziade and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) [2024] AATA 2586 (16 July 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):2019/7512; 2023/8320      

Re:Alexander Ziade  

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Mr S. Webb, Member  

Date:16 July 2024

Place:Sydney

  1. The decision under review in application 2019/7512 is varied to the extent that Star Track is liable to pay Mr Ziade compensation in respect of the 6 August 2019 ‘injury’ under s 14, s 16 and Division 3, Part II of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 up to and including 6 November 2019.

  2. The parties have not been heard in respect of orders for costs. Unless contrary submissions are made within 14 days, the Tribunal will order Star Track to pay Mr Ziade’s reasonable costs of this application as agreed or taxed.

  3. The decision under review in application 2023/8320 is affirmed.

    ………[SGD]……………………………….

    Mr S. Webb, Member

    CATCHWORDS

    WORKERS COMPENSATION – compensation claims – alleged shoulder injuries – left and right shoulder pathology – delivery driver duties in employment – work incident involving impact on shoulder – nature and conditions of employment – causal thresholds for ‘disease’ and ‘injury (other than a disease)’ – meaning of ‘aggravation’ – unreliable evidence – divergent expert medical opinions – temporary symptoms with use in the course of the employment – no aggravation injury – natural progression of degenerative condition – effusion indicative of acute injury – temporary impairment and incapacity for work – medical treatment – entitlements to compensation during a period – decision varied

    JURISDICTION – scope of reviewable decision – alleged invalidity of primary determination – determination of temporal limit on liability – legislative construction – contemporaneous determination of threshold liability and entitlement under specific heads of compensation – requirement for a claim –  imprecise language – determination not invalid ­– defect in determination curable on reconsideration or review ­– power to make fresh decision – jurisdiction to review reviewable decision – power to decide all matters before previous decision-maker – Tribunal has jurisdiction

    LEGISLATION
    Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 25, 37, 43
    Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 4, 5, 5A, 5B, 6, 7, 14, 16, 19, 52,53, 54, 58, 60, 62, 64, 67, 103, 104

    CASES
    Lees v Comcare [1999] FCA 753
    Fuad v Telstra Corp Ltd [2004] AATA 1182
    Irwin v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2009] FCAFC 33
    Comcare v Lofts [2013] FCA 1197
    Abrahams v Comcare [2006] FCA 1829
    Collector of Customs (New South Wales) v Brian Lawlor Automotive Pty Ltd [1979] FCA 21 Canute v Comcare [2006] HCA 47
    Australian Postal Corporation v Oudyn [2003] FCA 318
    Rosillo v Telstra Corporation Limited [2003] FCA 1628
    Duong v Australian Postal Corporation [2005] FCA 991
    Riddle v Telstra Corporation Limited [2006] FCA 58
    Telstra Corporation Ltd v Hannaford [2006] FCAFC 87
    Prain v Comcare [2017] FCAFC 143
    Woodhouse v Comcare [2021] FCAFC 95
    Comcare v Laidlaw [1999] FCA 40
    Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May [2016] HCA 19
    Bailey v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ziade and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 2586
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned compensation claims brought by Mr Ziade against the Australian Postal Corporation (trading as Star Track). Mr Ziade alleged injuries to his left and right shoulders arising from his employment as a delivery driver. The dispute centred on whether the conditions of his employment caused or aggravated a disease or injury, and the extent of any resulting incapacity for work.

The court was required to determine several legal issues. Firstly, it needed to ascertain the causal thresholds for establishing a 'disease' and an 'injury (other than a disease)' under the relevant legislation. Secondly, the court had to consider the meaning of 'aggravation' in the context of pre-existing conditions. Thirdly, the court was tasked with assessing the weight of divergent expert medical opinions and the reliability of Mr Ziade's evidence. Finally, the court had to determine the validity of a primary determination regarding temporal limits on liability and the Tribunal's jurisdiction to review such decisions.

The court found that Mr Ziade's claim for an injury arising from the nature and conditions of his employment with Star Track was not made out. It reasoned that while there was evidence of temporary symptoms and impairment, these were not indicative of an aggravation of a pre-existing degenerative condition caused by his work. The court distinguished between temporary symptoms experienced during employment and a compensable aggravation or injury. The court also addressed jurisdictional issues, finding that a primary determination, even if imprecise, was not invalid and that the Tribunal had the power to make a fresh decision on all matters before the previous decision-maker.

The decision under review in application 2019/7512 was varied to the extent that Star Track was liable to pay Mr Ziade compensation for an 'injury' on 6 August 2019 until 6 November 2019. The decision in application 2023/8320 was affirmed. The court indicated it would order Star Track to pay Mr Ziade's reasonable costs of the application unless contrary submissions were made.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

When the applications came on for hearing, issues arose in respect of the Tribunal’s jurisdiction and the validity of the primary determination to accept liability under s 14 of the SRC Act for Mr Ziade’s claimed right shoulder injury during a closed period. I dealt with this in the hearing and gave an oral ruling with supporting reasons. For the avoidance of any doubt, I will provide further explication of the ruling and the reasons for it in this decision.FACTS The following findings are made on the evidence, applying the reasonable satisfaction standard. Mr Ziade was born in 1982. He is an Australian citizen of Lebanese descent. He obtained an MR Heavy Rigid Truck Licence in 2008 and, thereafter, obtained employment as a delivery driver with Toll Fast. From 2010 to 2013 Mr Ziade was employed as a truck driver by TNT before returning to work for Toll Fast, where he continued in employment until June 2014.[1][1] AT5, folio 11. On 25 July 2011, Dr Abdullah Zobair, a general practitioner, referred Mr Ziade to Dr Trantalis, an orthopaedic surgeon, for opinion and management in respect of a painful right elbow. It appears, in or about December 2010, Mr Ziade injured his right elbow and an Xray was taken which Dr Zobair noted “shows ? old fracture olecranon process”.[2] Subsequently, on 16 December 2011, Dr A. Khan, another general practitioner, reported a conservative approach to management was advised.[3] It appears Mr Ziade consulted Dr Khan on 10 November 2011 in respect of “Rt elbow tenderness and pain in lateral epicondylar area, upper thoracic pain, which is limiting his ability to drive specially while turning the steering wheel”.[4] Dr Khan considered Mr Ziade’s “condition is aggravation of his previous injury as well as his old Rt Elbow xrays shows old fracture at Rt olecranon process which may be the cause of his Rt elbow pain as he hit it repeatedly while lifting and moving boxes”.[5][2] Exhibit 3, page 194.[3] Ibid, page 195.[4] Ibid.[5] Ibid. On 24 October 2014, Mr Ziade underwent an Australia Post pre-employment medical examination conducted by Dr Elton Chen (a general practitioner).[6] Mr Ziade completed a questionnaire in which he answered No to the questions:13) Have you ever had an injury or disease at work?15) Do you have any difficulty … reaching above shoulder height? 21) Have you ever had any other illnesses, injuries or fractures?Do you or have you ever experienced the following?32 Back pain or disc problems?35 Shoulder pain, tendonitis or frozen shoulder?[7]Dr Chen indicated Mr Ziade’s shoulders were normal on examination.[8][6] AT5.[7] Ibid, folios 12-13.[8] Ibid, folio 16. On 5 November 2014, Mr Ziade commenced employment with Star Track. On 15 November 2015, Mr Ziade consulted Dr Irfan Malik (a general practitioner). The doctor noted “occasional shoulder pain especially while working overhead”.[9][9] AT6, folio 19. On 15 December 2015, Mr Ziade consulted Dr Mir Ali (a general practitioner). The doctor noted:History:CC: Right shoulder injury and chronic back pain.Run fleet driver, health assessor at work assed today and not fit for work, advice physiotherapy/fitness programme.Recurrent pain in back, no pain at night, bowel and urine regular.…Back: Pain in back and paraspinal area, Forward motion near full.[10][10] Ibid, folio 18.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Ziade’s ‘nature and conditions’ claim is not made out. Mr Ziade did not suffer an ‘injury’ for which Star Track is liable as a result of the nature and conditions of his Star Track employment from 1 July 2016.DECISION The decision under review in application 2019/7512 is varied to the extent that Star Track is liable to pay Mr Ziade compensation in respect of the 6 August 2019 ‘injury’ under s 14, s 16 and Division 3, Part II of the SRC Act until 6 November 2019. The parties have not been heard in respect of orders for costs under s 67(8) of the SRC Act. Unless contrary submissions are made within 14 days, the Tribunal will order Star Track to pay Mr Ziade’s reasonable costs of this application as agreed or taxed. The decision under review in application 2023/8320 is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.