May v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

May v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2014] FCA 406

Citation: May v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2014] FCA 406
Appeal from: May and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2011] AATA 886
Parties: BENJAMIN JAMES EDWARD MAY v MILITARY REHABILITATION AND COMPENSATION COMMISSION
File number(s): NSD 2336 of 2013
Judge(s): BUCHANAN J
Date of judgment: 30 April 2014
Catchwords:

DEFENCE AND WAR – whether applicant suffered a compensable injury or disease within the definition of s 4 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) as a result of vaccinations received in the course of RAAF service – No compensable injury or disease found by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal on the evidence – no error by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal in defining an injury simpliciter – whether reported symptoms represented an injury in the course of employment – appeal dismissed

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – whether grounds of appeal to the Court state a “pure” question of law or mixed questions of law and fact – whether appeal competent – not necessary for determination in the present case

Legislation: Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), ss 44, 44(1)
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), ss 4, 6A, 6A(2)(b), 14
Cases cited: Accident Compensation Commission v McIntosh [1991] 2 VR 253
Birdseye v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2003] FCAFC 232
Brown v Repatriation Commission [2006] FCA 914
Colby Corporation Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2008) 165 FCR 133
Comcare v Etheridge (2006) 149 FCR 522
Comcare v PVYW [2013] HCA 41
Hatzimanolis v ANI Corporation Ltd (1992) 173 CLR 473
Kennedy Cleaning Services Pty Ltd v Petkoska (2000) 200 CLR 286
Mori v Secretary, Department of Social Services [2014] FCA 333
National Australia Bank v Georgoulas [2013] FCA 1412
Peters v Comcare [2013] FCA 1361
Purvis v Dairy Adjustment Authority (No 2) (2006) 150 FCR 48
Rana v Repatriation Commission [2011] FCAFC 124
Soames v Secretary, Department of Social Services [2014] FCA 295
TNT Skypack International (Aust) Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [1988] FCA 119
Zickar v MGH Plastic Industries Pty Ltd (1996) 187 CLR 310
Date of hearing: 3 April 2014
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 78
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr A Anforth
Solicitor for the Appellant: AW Simpson & Co
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr G Johnson SC
Solicitor for the Respondent: DLA Piper

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 2336 of 2013

ON APPEAL FROM THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
BETWEEN:

BENJAMIN JAMES EDWARD MAY
Appellant

AND:

MILITARY REHABILITATION AND COMPENSATION COMMISSION
Respondent

JUDGE:

BUCHANAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

30 APRIL 2014

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed with costs.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 2336 of 2013

ON APPEAL FROM THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read May v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 406
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of May v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission, the applicant, Mr May, sought compensation from the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission (MRCC) for an alleged injury he sustained during his service in the Royal Australian Air Force (RAAF). Mr May claimed that vaccinations administered during his service caused him to suffer from low immunity, fatigue, illnesses, and dizziness. The MRCC denied the claim, and the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) upheld the decision, finding that Mr May had not suffered a compensable injury or disease within the meaning of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth).

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the AAT erred in its determination that Mr May had not suffered a compensable injury or disease as a result of the vaccinations received during his RAAF service. The court had to consider whether the AAT correctly interpreted the definition of "injury" under the SRC Act and whether the AAT's findings were supported by the evidence presented.

The court found that the AAT did not err in its interpretation of the definition of "injury" and that the AAT's findings were supported by the evidence. The court noted that for an injury to be compensable, there must be a sudden or identifiable physiological change, and the injury must arise out of or in the course of employment. The medical evidence presented did not establish a clear causal link between the vaccinations and Mr May's reported symptoms, and the AAT did not accept that the reported symptoms constituted an injury in the course of employment. The court also found that the appeal was not limited to a "pure" question of law, but rather involved mixed questions of law and fact, and as such, the appeal was competent.

The appeal was dismissed with costs. The court held that the AAT's decision was not flawed, and the findings of fact were supported by the evidence presented. The court did not find any legal errors in the AAT's approach or analysis, and as such, the appeal did not have practical prospects of success. The AAT's determination that Mr May had not suffered a compensable injury or disease as a result of the vaccinations received during his RAAF service was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed with costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The AAT gave the following brief summary as background to its determinations: BACKGROUND2.Mr May was born in 1975 and is aged 36. He enlisted in the Royal Australian Air Force (RAAF) on 6 November 1998 and was discharged on 30 July 2004 at the rank of Officer Cadet. On 29 November 2002, Mr May lodged a claim for rehabilitation and compensation dated 20 November 2002 in respect of “low immunity, fatigue, illnesses, dizziness” which he claimed was caused by vaccinations received in the course of his employment in the RAAF. On 11 March 2003, a MRCC delegate denied Mr May’s claim noting that specialists who had examined Mr May had been unable to diagnose any specific condition or determine a cause for his symptoms, and the delegate was therefore unable to connect the claimed condition with his RAAF service. The AAT correctly identified that the principal issue before it was whether Mr May had suffered an “injury” within the meaning of s 14 of the SRC Act which provides: 14 Compensation for injuries(1)Subject to this Part, Comcare is liable to pay compensation in accordance with this Act in respect of an injury suffered by an employee if the injury results in death, incapacity for work, or impairment. (2)Compensation is not payable in respect of an injury that is intentionally self-inflicted. (3)Compensation is not payable in respect of an injury that is caused by the serious and wilful misconduct of the employee but is not intentionally self-inflicted, unless the injury results in death, or serious and permanent impairment. At the relevant time “injury”, “disease” and “ailment” were defined by s 4 of the SRC Act as follows: injury means: (a)a disease suffered by an employee; or (b)an injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee, being a physical or mental injury arising out of, or in the course of, the employee’s employment; or (c)an aggravation of a physical or mental injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee (whether or not that injury arose out of, or in the course of, the employee’s employment), being an aggravation that arose out of, or in the course of, that employment; but does not include any such disease, injury or aggravation suffered by an employee as a result of reasonable disciplinary action taken against the employee or failure by the employee to obtain a promotion, transfer or benefit in connection with his or her employment. disease means: (a)any ailment suffered by an employee; or (b)the aggravation of any such ailment; being an ailment or an aggravation that was contributed to in a material degree by the employee’s employment by the Commonwealth or a licensed corporation. ailment means any physical or mental ailment, disorder, defect or morbid condition (whether of sudden onset or gradual development). As a result of those provisions, the AAT recorded: 5.Thus, where a person has suffered an injury other than a disease (often referred to as an injury simpliciter), the causal connection of which the Tribunal must be satisfied is that the injury arose out of or in the course of their employment. Where a person has suffered from a disease, the Tribunal must be satisfied that the disease, or any aggravation of the disease, was contributed to in a material degree by the person’s employment. 6.In Kennedy Cleaning Services Pty Limited v Petkoska (2000) 200 CLR 286, the High Court said that a long line of decisions in Australia had recognised that for there to be ‘an injury’ requires that it be established that there has been “a sudden or identifiable physiological change”: Gleeson CJ and Kirby J at [35]. If an injury, in what was described as the “primary sense of that word”, happens in the course of the person’s employment, “it is ordinarily compensable without proof of a specific causal connection with the worker’s employment”: at [39]. 7.Mr May contends that he suffered an injury simpliciter and not a disease and that there is sufficient evidence to establish a causal link between his condition and the vaccinations he received while in the RAAF. The MRCC contends that whether Mr May’s condition is treated as an injury simpliciter or a disease, there is an insufficient causal link, there being no clear diagnosis for his condition and it having not been established that his symptoms are connected with the vaccinations he received. It therefore denies liability to pay compensation to Mr May under s 14(1) of the SRC Act.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Determination of those issues required consideration of an amount of medical evidence, as well as Mr May’s own evidence. The medical evidence The AAT conducted a survey of the medical evidence which it regarded as material to the issues before it. The vaccinations during Mr May’s RAAF service occurred between 10 November 1998 and 30 March 2000, although he also had earlier vaccinations against Hepatitis A and B. The survey discloses a history of medical difficulties and issues for Mr May. Some occurred in the same period as various vaccinations were given to him, although no relationship between those matters was established, as the AAT assessed the matter. Before his RAAF service, Mr May had suffered from glandular fever and experienced chronic fatigue which appeared to resolve. After the first set of vaccinations which occurred during his RAAF service he was diagnosed with a viral illness. The following year (1999), he was again diagnosed with a viral illness. In 2000 Mr May was found to need gammaglobulin treatment for persistent lymphopenia (low lymphocytes count). It was suggested then that the treatment would be lifelong but in 2001 the treatment was found to be no longer necessary. In the succeeding years Mr May underwent a series of investigatory procedures which produced no clear identification of the cause of his symptoms. I shall refer to some of them in more detail later. One feature of Mr May’s condition, the complaints which he made and his recorded perceptions is that no clinical evidence or psychiatric explanation could be found to support his reported symptoms, although it has not been suggested that he is malingering or has given an account lacking in honesty. One example of the difficulty that has presented for his case concerns his report, over some years, that he feels as though his tongue is swollen, a circumstance which he attributes to a reaction to the vaccinations he was given during his RAAF service. The most recent authoritative medical reports before the AAT were from Dr Robert Loblay, the Director of the Allergy Unit in the Department of Clinical Immunology at the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital in Sydney, who also gave oral evidence to the AAT which it is apparent the AAT accepted. In a report dated 26 October 2010 Dr Loblay said: 12. … ·Despite the lack of obvious swelling on examination, Mr May is convinced that his tongue is pathologically swollen. … In a later, more comprehensive, report dated 1 September 2011 Dr Loblay recorded Mr May’s symptoms (in part) as follows: Mr May’s symptomsMr May described a sensation of swelling of his tongue and soft palate coming on within 30‑60 minutes (possibly less) of his first injection of ADT and Twinrix vaccine in November 1998. There was no associated itch, tingling, burning, gagging, or difficulty with breathing, swallowing or speaking, and there were no systemic symptoms (urticarial, angioedema, bronchospasm, syncope) to suggest a generalized allergic reaction. The sensation of palate swelling subsided over about 2 days, but his tongue has subjectively felt “large and uncomfortable” ever since, despite the lack of any objective swelling. …

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr May’s challenge to the decision of the AAT is a proceeding in the original jurisdiction of the Court. The right to maintain it is given by s 44 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (“the AAT Act”). Section 44(1) provides: 44 Appeals to Federal Court of Australia from decisions of the TribunalAppeal on question of law(1)A party to a proceeding before the Tribunal may appeal to the Federal Court of Australia, on a question of law, from any decision of the Tribunal in that proceeding. The existence (and appropriate identification) of a question of law has been held to be essential to the jurisdiction of the Court to entertain an appeal under s 44 of the AAT Act (see TNT Skypack International (Aust) Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [1988] FCA 119; Birdseye v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2003] FCAFC 232; Comcare v Etheridge (2006) 149 FCR 522; Purvis v Dairy Adjustment Authority (No 2) (2006) 150 FCR 48; Brown v Repatriation Commission [2006] FCA 914; Colby Corporation Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2008) 165 FCR 133; Rana v Repatriation Commission [2011] FCAFC 124; Peters v Comcare [2013] FCA 1361; National Australia Bank v Georgoulas [2013] FCA 1412; Soames v Secretary, Department of Social Services [2014] FCA 295; and Mori v Secretary, Department of Social Services [2014] FCA 333). In the present case, the respondent’s first argument was that no “pure” question of law had been identified and as the appeal was not “confined” to questions of law it was not competent. I propose to defer any consideration of that issue for the moment. It is, however, important to retain an appropriate focus on legal, rather than factual, issues. The present appeal does not provide an opportunity to canvass the factual findings made by the AAT, or the merits of its decision. It remains necessary to identify a legal defect in its approach or analysis, if the appeal is to have practical prospects of success. Symptoms and suggested injury The AAT gave the following brief summary as background to its determinations: BACKGROUND2.Mr May was born in 1975 and is aged 36. He enlisted in the Royal Australian Air Force (RAAF) on 6 November 1998 and was discharged on 30 July 2004 at the rank of Officer Cadet. On 29 November 2002, Mr May lodged a claim for rehabilitation and compensation dated 20 November 2002 in respect of “low immunity, fatigue, illnesses, dizziness” which he claimed was caused by vaccinations received in the course of his employment in the RAAF. On 11 March 2003, a MRCC delegate denied Mr May’s claim noting that specialists who had examined Mr May had been unable to diagnose any specific condition or determine a cause for his symptoms, and the delegate was therefore unable to connect the claimed condition with his RAAF service. The AAT correctly identified that the principal issue before it was whether Mr May had suffered an “injury” within the meaning of s 14 of the SRC Act which provides: 14 Compensation for injuries(1)Subject to this Part, Comcare is liable to pay compensation in accordance with this Act in respect of an injury suffered by an employee if the injury results in death, incapacity for work, or impairment. (2)Compensation is not payable in respect of an injury that is intentionally self-inflicted. (3)Compensation is not payable in respect of an injury that is caused by the serious and wilful misconduct of the employee but is not intentionally self-inflicted, unless the injury results in death, or serious and permanent impairment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 6A(2)(b) of the SRC Act, at the relevant time, provided: 6AInjury arising out of or in the course of employment—extended operation… (2)If, at any time, whether before, on, or after, 1 December 1988: (a)an employee to whom this section applies received or receives medical treatment paid for by the Commonwealth; and (b)as an unintended consequence of that treatment the person suffered or suffers an injury; the injury to the employee is taken to have arisen out of, or in the course of, the person’s employment, whether or not the person has remained an employee to whom this section applies. Section 6A of the SRC Act applied to Mr May, but it did not give him any greater, or different, claim to compensation on the facts of his case. The AAT decision accepted, as a fundamental premise in Mr May’s case, that the claim he made was based on the proposition that the vaccinations he received caused him a compensable injury. The findings of fact made by the AAT apply as equally to any reliance on s 6A(2)(b) as they do to reliance on s 14. Ground 6 The written submissions argued that an inference arose of a probable connection between the vaccinations and an injury because of a temporal proximity with symptoms described by Mr May and that the AAT could, and should, have accepted that as sufficient to find the claim for compensation established. The AAT took into account Mr May’s argument that an inference arose from the temporal proximity of the symptoms he described with the vaccinations he received. However, as earlier discussed, the AAT did not accept that an injury had occurred, despite the asserted temporal connection. That involved a weighing of the evidence and findings of fact. There was no misunderstanding by the AAT of any relevant legal principle including the appropriate standard of proof. Oral arguments in support of the appeal Before the AAT, Mr May’s case was that it should be accepted, in the absence of another plausible explanation, that his condition was the result of the vaccinations. The difficulty for that case was that the AAT did not, in the end, accept that the vaccinations provided an explanation for his condition which it should accept. The AAT accepted Dr Loblay’s evidence that this suggested explanation, while not impossible, was very unlikely. On the present appeal, Mr May’s case was put more broadly, particularly in oral argument. It was submitted on his behalf that the AAT should have gone beyond the parameters of the case advanced by Mr May and examined for itself the proposition that his reported symptoms were sufficient evidence of an injury regardless of any suggested connection with vaccinations. As I understood the argument , it was that Mr May’s own evidence should have been accepted by the AAT as sufficient evidence of an injury (a sudden or identifiable physiological change) of a physical or mental nature occurring during his employment, regardless of its cause. The argument faces some practical difficulties. Mr May’s case has always been that he suffered an injury as a result of vaccinations. The symptoms which persist are attributed by Mr May to the vaccinations. Those symptoms have not been found to correspond with observable physiological indications consistent with his reports. The vaccinations have been found to be unlikely to result in such symptoms.