National Australia Bank Ltd v Georgoulas

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

National Australia Bank v Georgoulas [2013] FCA 1412

Citation: National Australia Bank v Georgoulas [2013] FCA 1412

Appeal from: 

Georgoulas and National Australia Bank Limited [2013] AATA 512

Parties: NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LIMITED v MARIA GEORGOULAS
File number: NSD 1683 of 2013
Judge: PERRY J
Date of judgment: 20 December 2013
Catchwords:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – appeal from the Administrative Appeals Tribunal on a question of law – scope of jurisdiction conferred by s 44(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) – whether questions of law raised in notice of appeal – where no questions of law raised, no jurisdiction to entertain – requirement to provide reasons

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – compensation pursuant to Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) for disease – effect of legislative definitions – disease in the context of mental illness – exclusion of compensation entitlement – whether wilful and false misrepresentation made

Legislation: Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), ss 43(2), 44(1), 45
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth), s 5
Federal Court Rules 1979 (Cth), O 53 r 3(2)
Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), r 33.12
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), s 39B
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s 430(1)(c)
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), ss 4, 5, 5A(1), 5B, 7(7), 14(1), 16,
Cases cited: Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue (Northern Territory) (2009) 239 CLR 27
Birdseye v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2003) 38 AAR 55
Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336
Civil Aviation Safety Authority v Central Aviation Pty Ltd (2009) 179 FCR 554
Comcare v Ethridge (2006) 149 FCR 522
Comcare v Mooi (1996) 69 FCR 439
Comcare Australia v Porter (1996) 70 FCR 139
Commissioner of Taxation v Miller (1946) 73 CLR 93
Commissioner of Taxation v Osborne (1990) 26 FCR 63
Commonwealth v Christoffelsz (1988) 18 FCR 415
Hope v Bathurst City Council (1980) 144 CLR 1
Victims Compensation Fund Corp v Brown (2003) 77 ALJR 1797
Date of hearing: 18 October 2013
Date of last submissions: 18 October 2013
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 88
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr B Dooley SC
Solicitor for the Applicant: Clarke Legal
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr L Grey
Solicitor for the Respondent: Carroll & O'Dea Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1683 of 2013

ON APPEAL FROM THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
BETWEEN:

NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LIMITED
Applicant

AND:

MARIA GEORGOULAS
Respondent

JUDGE:

PERRY J

DATE OF ORDER:

20 DECEMBER 2013

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application for leave to amend the notice of appeal to insert the proposed additional question of law (g) is allowed.

2.The application for leave to amend the notice of appeal to insert the proposed additional question of law (h) is refused.

3.The appeal under s 44(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) is dismissed with costs.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read National Australia Bank Ltd v Georgoulas and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 1412
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

National Australia Bank Ltd v Georgoulas was a case in which the Federal Court of Australia considered an appeal from the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) on a question of law. The dispute centred around the scope of jurisdiction conferred by section 44(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) and whether questions of law were raised in the notice of appeal. The case also examined the compensation entitlement under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) for a disease, specifically in the context of mental illness, and whether a wilful and false misrepresentation had been made.

The legal issues before the court included the interpretation of section 44(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), determining the scope of jurisdiction conferred by the section, and whether the AAT had jurisdiction to entertain the appeal in the absence of questions of law being raised. Additionally, the court had to consider the definitions of "disease" and "ailment" under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), and whether the legislative definitions excluded compensation entitlement for Ms Georgoulas' mental illness. The court was also required to decide if Ms Georgoulas had made a wilful and false misrepresentation regarding her medical history.

The court found that there were no questions of law raised in the notice of appeal, and therefore, the AAT had no jurisdiction to entertain the appeal. The court further held that the definition of "disease" in the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) did not exclude compensation entitlement for Ms Georgoulas' mental illness. Finally, the court found that Ms Georgoulas had not made a wilful and false misrepresentation regarding her medical history, as there was no evidence to suggest she had previously suffered from a psychiatric condition which was the same or substantially the same as the chronic adjustment disorder from which she now suffers.

The appeal under section 44(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) was dismissed with costs. The application for leave to amend the notice of appeal to insert the proposed additional question of law (g) was allowed, while the application for leave to amend the notice of appeal to insert the proposed additional question of law (h) was refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for leave to amend the notice of appeal to insert the proposed additional question of law (g) is allowed.

2. The application for leave to amend the notice of appeal to insert the proposed additional question of law (h) is refused.

3. The appeal under s 44(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) is dismissed with costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Ms Georgoulas contended that, while there is evidence she suffered certain symptoms before her claim, she was not required to disclose them given the differences between her previous and current illnesses. As such, she contended that her answers in the claim form were not false, let alone wilfully so. 2.3 The expert evidence before the Tribunal The Tribunal received expert reports from Ms Georgoulas’ treating psychiatrist and psychologist, and from experts retained by her lawyers and the lawyers for the NAB. Ms Georgoulas’ general practitioner was not called although his medical records were relied upon. These showed that Ms Georgoulas visited him on sixteen occasions between August 2007 to January 2008. The Tribunal found that, while various medical certificates were issued over this time and all referred to anxiety and/or stress, the majority related to Ms Georgoulas’ complaints about her back and abdominal pain, and bronchitis. Only three consultations record discussions about stress and/or anxiety as opposed to physical complaints. A psychologist’s medical report dated 18 April 2012 was prepared by Ms Mina Candalepas, Clinical Psychologist for Ms Georgoulas. Ms Candalepas provided eighteen sessions of counselling between 14 April 2011 and 3 April 2012. According to her report, Ms Georgoulas presented with symptoms consistent with a major depressive disorder and panic disorder with agoraphobia. In her report Ms Candalepas notes that “[h]er psychological response is characteristic of a person that has experienced such work-related stressors.” Ms Georgoulas also consulted Dr Alex Pilsky, Consultant General and Forensic Psychiatrist, commencing on 17 February 2010 following a referral in December 2009. According to his report dated 13 April 2012, Ms Georgoulas told Dr Pilsky that she felt anxious “nearly all the time”, and had panic attacks at least on a weekly basis, insomnia and forgetfulness. She reported negative feelings and hopelessness. Dr Pilsky also diagnosed Ms Georgoulas with panic disorder with agoraphobia and major depression, moderate to severe, with melancholic features. The Tribunal noted in particular the opinion expressed by Dr Pilsky in his report that:“Prior to the onset of current problems of 2009, Maria never experienced severe depression or anxiety. She did describe an episode of feeling stressed in 2007, whilst experiencing severe back pain and bronchitis which necessitated sick leave of three months duration. However at the time she did not experience panic attacks nor any depressive symptoms and her mood improved quickly as her symptoms resolved”. Dr Stephen Allnutt, Senior Consultant Forensic Psychiatrist, was also retained by Ms Georgoulas’ lawyers. He examined Ms Georgoulas on 15 August 2011 and produced a report dated 15 August 2011 for the purpose of these proceedings. In his view, Ms Georgoulas had symptoms consistent with a “depressive disorder characterised by a depressed mood…”. Dr Allnutt also noted that in association with her depression, Ms Georgoulas was manifesting panic attacks consistent with a diagnosis of a panic disorder with agoraphobia. He further noted that she had first experienced symptoms of anxiety and depression in about 2007 and that he regarded her present mental condition as an aggravation of a previous psychiatric condition in 2007.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, the NAB referred Ms Georgoulas to Dr Jeffrey Bertucen, Consultant Psychiatrist, for assessment on three occasions in August 2010 and July 2012. Dr Bertucen formed the view that Ms Georgoulas was suffering from chronic adjustment disorder with mixed feelings or features of anxiety, panic and depressed mood. He was further of the view that she had no appreciable psychiatric diagnosis prior to 2009 and that the circumstances associated with her workplace at the NAB were responsible for her subsequent psychological condition. There were, in his opinion, no non-work factors which contributed to her psychological condition.2.4 The Tribunal’s conclusions The Tribunal rejected the contention by the NAB that s 7(7) of the Act was enlivened. Its reasons can be summarised as follows. As to the disease suffered by Ms Georgoulas, the Tribunal found, at [56], that:“The diagnosis of both treating specialists and the medical experts retained by the parties is consistent. The respondent accepted liability for the applicant’s condition which was characterised as ‘chronic adjustment disorder with mixed features of anxiety, panic and depressed mood’. As noted by counsel for the applicant in his submissions, the reports of Dr Allnutt, Dr Pilsky and Ms Candalepas suggest a more serious diagnosis of a major depressive disorder and panic disorder. While anxiety is a symptom of these various disorders, all medical practitioners also refer to panic attacks, agoraphobia and depression as being prominent features of the applicant’s current condition.” While the failure to disclose a symptom does not of itself amount to a representation of an illness or injury, the Tribunal found that the injury or illness referred to in Question 14 must refer to the injury or illness in Question 8 for which Ms Georgoulas claims compensation, namely, “stress and anxiety”. By answering “No” to Question 14, the Tribunal found at [59]-[60] that Ms Georgoulas represented that she did not suffer and had not previously suffered from the illness in respect of which she sought compensation, regardless of how the condition was so described. For the representation to be false, the Tribunal found that it must be satisfied that Ms Georgoulas had previously suffered a pschychiatric condition which was the same or substantially the same as the chronic adjustment disorder from which she now suffers, at [61]. The Tribunal was not so satisfied for the following reasons.(a)The Tribunal considered that the words “that disease” in s 7(7) of the Act “includes a condition that is the same or substantially the same as the current condition diagnosed.” They do not mean “the actual condition suffered or diagnosed” as that would be unduly restrictive. Conversely, the Tribunal was of the view that to construe the words “that disease” to mean “a similar condition or, as the respondent contended, a condition with similar or the same symptoms as a current condition, would be contrary to the beneficial nature of the legislation.” (b)The Tribunal rejected the NAB’s submission that Ms Georgoulas had symptoms which were “apparently indistinguishable” from those suffered previously and that that was sufficient to establish that the representation was false within s 7(7) of the Act. On the basis of its analysis of the evidence, the Tribunal found at [64] that:“We are not satisfied that the applicant suffered a psychiatric condition in respect of which anxiety is a key or dominant symptom prior to her employment with the respondent.” (Emphasis in the original)(c)The Tribunal also considered that, even if it had found that there was sufficient evidence to establish that Ms Georgoulas had previously suffered a psychiatric condition in respect of which anxiety was a prominent symptom, the Tribunal was not satisfied that this was the relevant test for the purposes of s 7(7). The critical question identified by the Tribunal was whether any previous or pre-existing condition suffered by Ms Georgoulas was the same or substantially the same as Ms Georgoulas' psychiatric condition, as diagnosed by Dr Bertucen, Dr Allnutt, Dr Pilsky and Ms Candalapas. On this question, the Tribunal found at [71]-[72] that:“Even though we accept that the applicant previously sought treatment for anxiety from her general practitioner and experienced some of the symptoms she later experienced while working at the respondent (ie anxiety, chest pain, palpitations, shortness of breath and sleeplessness), there is no evidence that she previously suffered panic attacks or depression. In our view this is significant. The symptoms suffered by the applicant in 2007 and 2009, however categorised, are clearly distinguishable. They are not the same or substantially the same.The most compelling argument in support of the applicant’s case is the fact that there is no expert evidence to support the respondent’s contention. This is the case even though the respondent’s expert, Dr Bertucen, was briefed with the applicant’s previous medical records and was asked to opine on whether these records and the report of Dr Allnutt changed his opinion. Indeed, Dr Bertucen specifically addressed the issue of whether the applicant had a pre-existing psychiatric condition in his last report and unambiguously stated that the applicant had ‘no substantial psychiatric history prior to 2009’.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In short, it is apparent that, for this appeal to succeed, the NAB must establish that each of the “cascading” or alternative bases for the decision, as counsel for Ms Georgoulas described them, is tainted by an error or errors of law, namely:(a)The representation was not false for the reason that:i.the evidence did not establish that Ms Georgoulas had suffered from any mental condition outside the boundaries of normal mental functioning before 2009; andii.even if there was sufficient evidence to establish that Ms Georgoulas had previously suffered a psychiatric condition in respect of which anxiety was a prominent symptom, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the condition was the same or substantially similar.(b)In any event, even if the Tribunal had found the representation to be false, it was not satisfied that the misrepresentation was wilful.3. CONSIDERATION3.1 The statutory scheme under the Act Section 14(1) of Part II of the Act imposes liability on the Commonwealth or a licensee to pay compensation to injured employees “…in accordance with this Act in respect of an injury suffered by an employee if the injury results in death, incapacity for work, or impairment.” An “employee” is defined in s 5 relevantly to mean a person employed by a licensed corporation, as defined in s 4. It is not in dispute that the NAB is a licensed corporation for the purposes of the Act, or that Ms Georgoulas was an employee of the NAB at the time that the injury which is the subject-matter of her claim occurred. The term “injury” is defined in s 5A(1) to mean:(a) a disease suffered by an employee; or(b)an injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee that is a physical or mental injury arising out of, or in the course of, the employee’s employment; or(c)an aggravation of a physical or mental injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee (whether or not that injury arose out of, or in the course of, the employee’s employment), that is an aggravation that arose out of, or in the course of, that employment;… The term “disease” in turn is defined in s 5B(1) to mean: (a) an ailment suffered by an employee; or(b) an aggravation of such an ailment;that was contributed to, to a significant degree, by the employee’s employment by the Commonwealth or a licensee. “Ailment”, in turn, is defined in s 4 of the Act to mean “any physical or mental ailment, disorder, defect or morbid condition (whether of sudden onset or gradual development”. I note that the requirement that there be a contribution to a significant degree to the suffering or aggravation of the ailment applies only in relation to an injury which is a disease. Otherwise, it is sufficient if the injury arose out of, or in the course of, employment. As such, liability may arise under the Act where, for example, the employee suffered from a particular ailment before commencing work with, relevantly, a licensee but the ailment was subsequently aggravated by the employee’s employment by the licensee, provided that the specific requirements of s 5B are met.