Muhlhan and K & S Freighters Pty Limited (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

Muhlhan and K & S Freighters Pty Limited (Compensation) [2016] AATA 42 (1 February 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers

2013/6760 & 2013/6742

Re

Bruce Muhlhan

APPLICANT

And

K & S Freighters Pty Limited

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

Date 1 February 2016
Place Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

[sgd]........................................................................

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

COMPENSATION – pre-existing physical and psychiatric conditions – persisting symptoms – escalation of symptoms whilst in the employ of the respondent – claimed further injury – failure to reveal past history and workers’ compensation claims – question of wilful and false representation and s24 liability – decision affirmed

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1991

Cases

Comcare v Porter (1996) FCA 562

Comcare v Amira (1996) FCA 1438

Jordan v Australian Postal Corporation (2007) FCA 2028

Martin v Australian Postal Corporation (1999) FCA 655

National Australia Bank v Georgoulas (2013) FCA 1412

Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations v Comcare [2008]

FCA 52

Kennedy and Comcare [2015] AATA 334.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

1 February 2016

  1. Initially there were two claims before the Tribunal, one for permanent impairment relating to Mr Muhlhan’s hernia repairs and continuing groin pain (2013/6742) and the second (2013/6760) a claim for a major depressive disorder (MDD), due to restraining a right inguinal hernia repair. 

  2. The respondent in a primary determination dated 23 October 2013 accepted liability for the psychological condition (T6).  On its own motion the respondent reviewed this decision. It determined that there was no liability to pay compensation under s 24 and s 27 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1991 (the SRC Act) in relation to a major depressive disorder, based on the reports of Associate Professor Brazenor and Associate Professor Mendelson.  The respondent has since raised the argument that s 7(7) of the SRC Act is attracted and that liability should be denied on the basis that Mr Muhlhan made a wilful and false representation that he had not previously suffered from a depressive disorder.

  3. Mr Muhlhan lodged an application with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for review of this decision on 19 December 2013.

  4. Mr Muhlhan was represented by Mr Ternes of counsel, instructed by Maurice Blackburn solicitors. The respondent was represented by Ms Anne McMahon of counsel, instructed by Clarke Legal. The Tribunal was provided with the documents lodged by the respondent in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the T-documents) assigned Exhibit R1.  Both parties tendered further documentation a list of which is appended to this decision.

  5. Mr Muhlhan, Dr Justine Birchall, Dr Epstein and Associate Professor Mendelson gave evidence before the Tribunal.

    BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION

  6. In October 1999, Mr Muhlhan lodged a WorkCover Victoria claim for hernia left groin. The injury giving rise to this condition occurred on 27 September 1999 when Mr Muhlhan lifted a neatly folded 20 kilogram tarpaulin from the ground to his truck.  At the time Mr Muhlhan was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Muhlhan and K & S Freighters Pty Limited (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 42
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Muhlhan and K & S Freighters Pty Limited involves a claim for workers' compensation by Mr Muhlhan, who alleges that he suffered a hernia in his left groin while working for O’Shea and Bennett Sales Pty Ltd in 1999. This injury led to further complications, including chronic pain and psychological issues. Mr Muhlhan later sought compensation for a claimed injury to his right groin while employed by K & S Freighters in 2006. The crux of the dispute is whether Mr Muhlhan made a wilful and false representation regarding his medical history and past workers' compensation claims, which could affect his eligibility for compensation under section 24 of the relevant Act.

The legal issues before the court were primarily concerned with whether Mr Muhlhan's failure to disclose his past medical history and previous workers' compensation claims constituted a wilful and false representation, potentially barring him from compensation under section 24. The court also needed to determine whether there was a significant contribution by his employment with K & S Freighters to his ongoing physical and psychological conditions. The court examined the history of Mr Muhlhan's hernias, the surgeries he underwent, and the persistence of his symptoms to assess the impact of his employment on his condition.

The Tribunal found that Mr Muhlhan's hernias were indeed work-related and were repaired in 2000, with subsequent surgeries to address complications and pain. However, the Tribunal concluded that Mr Muhlhan's failure to disclose his past medical history and previous compensation claims amounted to a wilful and false representation, thus barring him from compensation under section 24 of the Act. The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, upholding the findings that Mr Muhlhan's claim was invalid due to the undisclosed history and the provisions of section 24.

No further orders were made beyond the affirmation of the decision under review.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Muhlhan, Dr Justine Birchall, Dr Epstein and Associate Professor Mendelson gave evidence before the Tribunal.BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION In October 1999, Mr Muhlhan lodged a WorkCover Victoria claim for hernia left groin. The injury giving rise to this condition occurred on 27 September 1999 when Mr Muhlhan lifted a neatly folded 20 kilogram tarpaulin from the ground to his truck. At the time Mr Muhlhan was working as a truck driver for O’Shea and Bennett Sales Pty Ltd and had been in their employ for seven months. According to the employer his health during that time was poor (Exhibit R5) and he had taken six days of sick leave in August and September due a bout of the flu associated with a persistent cough. Following the injury of 27 September 1999 Mr Muhlhan did not miss work and did not consult his general practitioner until 30 September 1999. Dr Birchall, his general practitioner, diagnosed bilateral inguinal hernias and referred him to Mr Ken Farrell for a surgical opinion. Mr Farrell saw Mr Muhlhan on 25 October 1999. He noted that the applicant had experienced stressful life incidents for the past one to two years, in terms of his job with Armaguard, his marriage breakdown and a period of unemployment. Mr Farrell diagnosed bilateral inguinal hernias, the left being larger than the right, and recommended that surgery was the appropriate treatment. Prior to approving the surgery, Mr Muhlhan’s then insurer obtained reports from Mr P Battlay, general surgeon, who noted two previous workers’ compensation claims, one in 1980 for severe facial injuries secondary to an explosion and a right shoulder problem suffered while working for Armaguard. Mr Battlay diagnosed bilateral indirect inguinal hernias. He agreed that a surgical approach was indicated. Mr Farrell performed bilateral hernia repairs on 10 January 2000 and found that his original diagnosis was correct in that both hernias were direct inguinal hernias. Both hernias were repaired in the same manner with a prolene mesh patch, stapled into place reinforcing the posterior wall of the inguinal canal. Postoperatively, Mr Muhlhan developed haematomas in both groins. This was an extremely uncommon occurrence and Mr Farrell could only postulate that it was associated with the prophylactic subcutaneous heparin given over the perioperative period. The haematoma in the right groin area was dealt with by needle aspiration of the blood clot but the left side had to be surgically evacuated. This was performed in Mr Farrell’s consulting rooms. Mr Muhlhan continued to complain of pain in both groins for several months after the operation but the wounds healed well and the pain seemed to be settling. In November 2000 he was again seen because of the sudden onset of pain in his left groin. On examination a definite lump was found at the midpoint of the hernia repair scar. This was very tender and Mr Muhlhan pleaded with Mr Farrell to do something about it. The left hernial repair was re-explored on 6 December 2000 and found to be a mass of scar tissue through which the ilioinguinal nerve was passing and was entrapped by a staple. The scar tissue was resected and the staple removed. Mr Muhlhan recovered well from this procedure and returned to work.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Muhlhan has never been referred to a psychiatrist or a clinical psychologist for treatment and the only psychiatric opinions provided to the Tribunal have been for medico-legal purposes. EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNALMr Muhlhan In his evidence, Mr Muhlhan described the episodes wherein he states he injured his right groin when working for K & S Freighters. The event of 14 August 2006 occurred while unloading Coca Cola at Safeway, Broadmeadows. He was required to lift a heavy gate on rollers that prevented the stock from rolling within the truck and on lifting the gate he noticed pain in his right groin. He remained at work but on light duties as he had trouble getting in and out of the truck. Mr Muhlhan said that prior to 2006 he drank very little alcohol but after the injury he increased his intake as it helped him to sleep. After he ceased working he had imbibed more heavily as this helped with the pain. He described his reaction to the operative procedure of July 2007 wherein his right testis was resected and his hernial repair tissue, that is, the mesh was removed and replaced with new mesh sutured in place rather than stapled, as being devastating. He agreed that the possibility of an orchidectomy had been discussed before the operation. He said that while the pain in his groin had been better after the procedure this improvement was short lived. After he ceased work he felt useless and what he described as letdown. Mr Muhlhan stated that it had been his plan to keep working until he could no longer physically cope with work. In response to a question from the Tribunal regarding the distribution of his right groin pain, he stated that it radiated from his right groin to his right knee over the front of his right thigh and that it was sharp and stabbing in nature, although that in the inner thigh was predominately a burning sensation. This description is the same as that given to Mr Brygel in 2003. In order to cope with his pain he said he now spent most of his time lying on a couch. He described himself as being angry, snappy, depressed and unable to control his feelings. Having initially drunk to excess he had ceased in 2008 with the help of Dr Zeeher. Mr Muhlhan stated that his memory was bad and his concentration poor, although he did say that he only remembered the bad things. While his relationship with his daughter remains precarious, he sees her once a week or fortnight and sees the children slightly more often. Mr Muhlhan described his daily activities and lack of any interest in doing most things and his total lack of confidence in terms of sexual relationships which made him feel weak, unmanly and angry. He was unable to recall having any emotional or psychological problems prior to 2007. He claimed that prior to 2007 he led a good life, was happy and contented. Under cross-examination Mr Muhlhan agreed that in 1980 he had suffered a major injury at work resulting in a fractured skull, loss of teeth and facial fractures and had been off work for 12 months. He had received a lump sum permanent impairment payment. Additionally, when he worked at Armaguard as a firearms trainer and also taught company policy and occupational health and safety, he had suffered an injury to his right shoulder and wrist when undergoing a course in restraint. Surgery to the right shoulder had been required and this had been the subject of a WorkCover claim. He had resigned from Armaguard after his marriage had broken up and he drank to excess for some months after the separation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether section 7(7) of the SRC Act applies to Mr Muhlhan's claim and, if not, whether there was a wilful and false representation made by him.
2. Whether Mr Muhlhan's employment with K & S Freighters significantly contributed to his current condition, including the development of his chronic right groin pain and depressive disorder.

Held
1. The court concluded that section 7(7) of the SRC Act does not apply to Mr Muhlhan's claim. The court also found that there was no wilful and false representation made by Mr Muhlhan.
2. The court determined that Mr Muhlhan's employment with K & S Freighters did not significantly contribute to his current condition, which includes his chronic right groin pain and depressive disorder.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the event that the Tribunal determined that s 7(7) was inapplicable or its requirements not met in this matter, Ms McMahon contended that the Tribunal must then look at the injury and determine its exact nature. This would involve consideration of the disabling right groin pain which was first reported in November 2002 and persisted throughout 2003, at which time it was labelled neuralgia prior to Mr Muhlhan’s employment by K & S Freighters. TRIBUNAL DELIBERATIONS Mr Muhlhan’s claim for lump sum payment in relation to permanent impairment and non-economic loss is based on his depressive disorder, be it an adjustment disorder, a major depressive disorder single episode or chronic MDD, as being a sequelae of his physical injury, namely his chronic right groin pain. The parties have identified the issues before the Tribunal correctly as being the application of s 7(7) of the SRC Act, where for purposes connected with his employment, the employee made a wilful and false representation that he did not suffer or had not previously suffered from the disease he is claiming under the SRC Act. Should the Tribunal find that s 7(7) is not applicable the Tribunal would be required to review the entire history of the claim, acknowledging that liability under s 14 was accepted for Mr Muhlhan’s claimed injury to his right groin of 14 August 2006, in order to determine whether there had been a significant contribution by employment to the development of firstly the groin pain and secondly the depressive disorder manifest in late 2007. The Tribunal has elected to deal with these two issues in the reverse order to that delineated by the parties. On the evidence before it, the Tribunal finds it is clear that Mr Muhlhan’s bilateral direct inguinal hernias when diagnosed were attributed to his employment with O’Shea and Bennett as a truck driver some six years before he commenced work with K & S Freighters. In 1999 the hernias were accepted as work related under state legislation and bilateral repair was undertaken in early 2000. Both repairs involved the same surgical technique of reinforcing the posterior wall of the inguinal canal with a prolene mesh. This mesh provides a skeleton for the laying down of fibrous tissue the aim of which is to strengthen the posterior wall of the inguinal canal. The mesh is either sewn into place using a choice of various sutures or stapled. The incidence of chronic groin pain following mesh repair of inguinal herniae is reported in the surgical literature to be approximately 15 per cent and this incidence accompanies prolene mesh repair as well as repair with biological mesh. (Australian New Zealand Journal of Surgery, Volume 85, Issue 12, page 90, Fang, Z et al, Biological mesh v synthetic mesh in open inguinal hernia repair: system review and meta- analysis). Mr Muhlhan has undergone a total of three surgical procedures in his left groin, namely the initial repair, the evacuation of the haematoma in the post-operative phase in 2000 and the removal of a nubbin of fibrous tissue and a staple entrapping the ilio-inguinal nerve which was undertaken on 6 December 2000. Mr Muhlhan has not experienced any further pain or problems with his left groin. In total he has had four procedures on his right groin, the first of these being the original direct inguinal hernia repair again with insertion of a prolene mesh. There is no evidence whatsoever that he has ever had a recurrence of his hernia. All surgery undertaken has been to identify the cause of and hopefully relieve his episodic but ongoing groin pain.