Krecu and Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

Krecu and Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2015] AATA 769 (1 October 2015)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number

2013/5114

Re

Jon Krecu

APPLICANT

And

Linfox Australia Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President K Bean

Date 1 October 2015
Place Adelaide

The Tribunal decides that:

(1)    The decision under review is varied so as to provide that:

(a)   from 21 June 2013 to the date of this decision, and as at the date of this decision:

(i)    the compensable injuries to Mr Krecu’s left shoulder and right hip/buttock continue to result in incapacity and require medical treatment;

(ii) the respondent continues to be liable to pay compensation to Mr Krecu in respect of the compensable injuries to his left shoulder and right hip/buttock pursuant to sections 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act);

(b)   the description of Mr Krecu’s compensable injuries is amended so as to include subacromial bursitis and adhesive capsulitis of the left shoulder, labral tear, degenerative changes and iliopsoas bursitis of the right hip, and right meralgia paraesthetica;

(2)   The matter is remitted to the respondent for determination and calculation of the amounts payable to Mr Krecu as a consequence of this Decision; and

(3)   The Tribunal:

(a)    reserves liberty to apply within 14 days in relation to the costs of the proceedings; and

(b) orders that in the absence of any such application, the respondent is to pay the costs of the proceedings incurred by Mr Krecu pursuant to subsection 67(8) of the SRC Act.

............ [Sgd] ........................................

Deputy President K Bean

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – Liability accepted for left shoulder, right hip, and thoracic back injuries – Whether shoulder symptoms properly regarded as a disease or an aggravation of a pre-existing disease – Whether wilful and false representation provision applies – Whether applicant continues to require medical treatment in relation to compensable injuries – Whether applicant continues to be incapacitated for work as a result of compensable injuries – Description of accepted conditions amended – Decision under review varied.

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, ss 5A, 5B, 7(7),16, 19

CASES

Telstra Corporation Ltd v Hannaford (2006) 90 ALD 263

National Australia Bank Ltd v Georgoulas (2013) 217 FCR 382

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President K Bean

1 October 2015

  1. On 18 February 2009, the applicant, Mr Krecu, was working as a road train driver for the respondent. Before leaving Port Augusta on his way to Adelaide, he was securing a load of copper plates on the back of his road train when the head of the spanner he was using cracked, causing him to lose his balance and fall to the ground. As a result of this fall (the accident), Mr Krecu suffered injuries to his left shoulder, buttock and hip region and also to his thoracic spine.

  2. Shortly after the accident, on 20 February 2009, Mr Krecu lodged a claim for workers’ compensation in respect of “left shoulder, right hip, thoracic back”.[1] Liability was subsequently…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Krecu and Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 769
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Krecu and Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation) involved a dispute regarding the ongoing entitlement of Mr. Krecu to compensation for injuries sustained in a workplace accident. The matter was before the Workers Compensation Tribunal of New South Wales, which was tasked with reviewing a decision made by the respondent, Linfox Australia Pty Ltd, regarding the ongoing compensability of Mr. Krecu's injuries. The primary legal issues addressed by the tribunal were whether Mr. Krecu's left shoulder symptoms constituted a disease or an aggravation of a pre-existing condition, whether the provision concerning wilful and false representation applied, and whether Mr. Krecu continued to require medical treatment and was incapacitated for work due to his compensable injuries.

The tribunal found that Mr. Krecu was not suffering from bursitis prior to the accident, based on the opinions of medical experts, particularly Professor Krishnan, who performed surgery on Mr. Krecu's shoulder. The tribunal held that since the bursitis was a result of the accident and not an aggravation of a pre-existing condition, there was no basis for applying the wilful and false representation provision. The tribunal also concluded that Mr. Krecu's injuries to his left shoulder and right hip continued to result in incapacity and required ongoing medical treatment as of 21 June 2013, the date of the decision. Furthermore, the tribunal amended the description of Mr. Krecu's injuries to include specific conditions such as subacromial bursitis and adhesive capsulitis of the left shoulder, among others.

The tribunal varied the decision under review to reflect these findings, continuing the respondent's liability for compensation and remitting the matter back to the respondent for the calculation of the amounts payable to Mr. Krecu. The tribunal reserved the right to apply for costs within 14 days but ordered that if no such application was made, the respondent would be responsible for the costs incurred by Mr. Krecu under subsection 67(8) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal decides that:

(1) The decision under review is varied so as to provide that:

(a) from 21 June 2013 to the date of this decision, and as at the date of this decision:

(i) the compensable injuries to Mr Krecu’s left shoulder and right hip/buttock continue to result in incapacity and require medical treatment;

(ii) the respondent continues to be liable to pay compensation to Mr Krecu in respect of the compensable injuries to his left shoulder and right hip/buttock pursuant to sections 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act);

(b) the description of Mr Krecu’s compensable injuries is amended so as to include subacromial bursitis and adhesive capsulitis of the left shoulder, labral tear, degenerative changes and iliopsoas bursitis of the right hip, and right meralgia paraesthetica;

(2) The matter is remitted to the respondent for determination and calculation of the amounts payable to Mr Krecu as a consequence of this Decision; and

(3) The Tribunal:

(a) reserves liberty to apply within 14 days in relation to the costs of the proceedings; and

(b) orders that in the absence of any such application, the respondent is to pay the costs of the proceedings incurred by Mr Krecu pursuant to subsection 67(8) of the SRC Act.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I should acknowledge that counsel for Mr Krecu, Mr Rossi, challenged the Tribunal’s jurisdiction to address these issues, given the reviewable decision related only to ss 16 and 19 liability. However, I am satisfied that I am entitled, and indeed obliged, to consider issues potentially bearing upon s 14 liability in this context, for the reasons outlined in Telstra Corporation Ltd v Hannaford.[7][7] Telstra Corporation Ltd v Hannaford (2006) 90 ALD 263.The evidence As alluded to above, as I understand the respondent’s case as it evolved at the hearing, the relevant disease from which the respondent says Mr Krecu was suffering before the fall was bursitis of the left shoulder. The respondent had earlier contended that Mr Krecu was also suffering from degenerative changes in the acromioclavicular joint of his left shoulder. However, in the course of his oral evidence, the respondent’s medical witness, Mr Elsner (an Orthopaedic Surgeon) accepted that no such changes were present prior to the accident as none were observed by Mr Krecu’s treating Orthopaedic Surgeon, Professor Krishnan, when he operated on Mr Krecu in August 2009. Nevertheless, Mr Elsner maintained that, based on the report of an ultrasound done the day after the accident, on 19 February 2009[8], Mr Krecu was suffering from a degree of bursitis prior to the relevant accident. Mr Elsner based this opinion on the fact that in the ultrasound report the bursa was reported as being “thickened” and there was no report of fluid in the bursa. In his evidence, Mr Elsner said that if fluid had been present, this would be indicative of an acute traumatic bursitis. He said the fact that the bursa was thickened and there was apparently no fluid indicated a longstanding condition, rather than one of recent traumatic origin.[8] Exhibit 1, T8/55. However, of the doctors who have expressed an opinion on this issue, Mr Elsner is the only one who holds that view. Dr Stockhoff, Occupational Physician Trainee, examined Mr Krecu on 27 July 2009, prior to his left shoulder surgery. She relevantly reported that he had damaged the bursa in his left shoulder in the fall and was suffering from left shoulder bursitis. She made no mention of any pre-existing bursitis.[9][9] Exhibit 1, T27/83. Dr Awerbuch, Consultant Physician, saw Mr Krecu on 18 November 2009. Although he acknowledged that the ultrasound report of February 2009 showed thickening of the bursa, he nevertheless accepted that the swelling and impingement symptoms reported by Mr Krecu were attributable to the accident. He relevantly reported:By objective criteria Mr Krecu appears to have sustained three injuries in the incident that occurred on 18/2/09. The most troublesome of these was an injury to the left shoulder although in point of fact the ultrasound of the left shoulder on 19/2/09 did not identify evidence of an injury but did show thickening of the subacromial/subdeltoid bursa with bursal catching. Given that Mr Krecu did not report left shoulder pain prior to the incident a reasonable hypothesis would be that the trauma of the incident caused swelling of the bursa with bursal impingement to which he is likely to have been predisposed by virtue of a down sloping acromion (see x-ray of 6/4/09).[10][10] Exhibit 1, T33/97 - 98.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I have accordingly decided to vary the decision under review so as to reflect those conclusions.DECISION The Tribunal decides that:(1)The decision under review is varied so as to provide that:(a) from 21 June 2013 to the date of this decision, and as at the date of this decision:(i)the compensable injuries to Mr Krecu’s left shoulder and right hip/buttock continue to result in incapacity and require medical treatment;(ii)the respondent continues to be liable to pay compensation to Mr Krecu in respect of the compensable injuries to his left shoulder and right hip/buttock pursuant to ss 16 and 19 of the SRC Act;(b) the description of Mr Krecu’s compensable injuries is amended so as to include subacromial bursitis and adhesive capsulitis of the left shoulder, labral tear, degenerative changes and iliopsoas bursitis of the right hip, and right meralgia paraesthetica;(2)The matter is remitted to the respondent for determination and calculation of the amounts payable to Mr Krecu as a consequence of this Decision; and(3) The Tribunal:(a) reserves liberty to apply within 14 days in relation to the costs of the proceedings; and(b) orders that in the absence of any such application, the respondent is to pay the costs of the proceedings incurred by Mr Krecu pursuant to subs 67(8) of the SRC Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In his oral evidence, Mr Krecu’s treating Orthopaedic Surgeon, Professor Krishnan, confirmed that in his view Mr Krecu’s bursitis developed as a result of an acute injury to the bursa on 18 February 2009.ConsiderationWas Mr Krecu suffering from bursitis at the time of the accident? Having regard to the whole of the evidence, and giving appropriate weight to the opinions of Professor Krishnan and Mr Elsner (each of whom gave oral evidence), I am not persuaded that Mr Krecu was suffering from left shoulder bursitis prior to the accident. I note that the only evidence in support of the proposition that he was, is the opinion Mr Elsner gave during his oral evidence. The main basis for that opinion was the absence in the ultrasound report of 19 February 2009 of any mention of fluid in the bursa. However, many of the other doctors had also seen that ultrasound report and none appear to have drawn the same conclusion from it. In particular, Professor Krishnan, who operated on Mr Krecu’s shoulder, remained of the view that his bursitis was of acute and traumatic onset, notwithstanding having seen that ultrasound report. Whilst acknowledging the thickening of Mr Krecu’s bursa reported on in the ultrasound report, Dr Awerbuch also accepted that the swelling of Mr Krecu’s bursa and the impingement symptoms which resulted were attributable to the accident. Admittedly, it was unfortunate that Mr Elsner’s opinion with respect to the pre-existing bursitis was given after Professor Krishnan’s evidence, so there was no opportunity for him to comment on this during the hearing. However, I also note that Mr Elsner conceded during his oral evidence that if Mr Krecu had been suffering from bursitis prior to the fall of 18 February 2009, he would have expected that Mr Krecu would also have been suffering from impingement symptoms. Mr Elsner further conceded that there was no evidence of Mr Krecu suffering from such symptoms prior to the accident, either in the notes produced by his chiropractor[16] or elsewhere in any of the medical records. Mr Elsner also appeared to concede that the absence of any recorded symptoms of bursitis reduced the likelihood that there was any significant bursitis or impingement present prior to the accident.[16] Exhibit 3. I have accordingly concluded that I am not positively satisfied that Mr Krecu was suffering from left shoulder bursitis prior to the accident of 18 February 2009. I prefer the opinion of Professor Krishnan on this issue, which is consistent with most of the other medical evidence.Does subs 7(7) apply? Of course, it follows from that conclusion that Mr Krecu did not suffer from any aggravation of a “disease” in the accident. Further, even if the bursitis he sustained in the accident was to be regarded as a “disease” rather than an “injury”, as the disease was not present prior to the accident, and there is no evidence that Mr Krecu had previously suffered from the same or a substantially similar condition[17], there is no basis for a finding that he failed to disclose a previous history of bursitis. Put simply, as Mr Krecu did not have a previous history of bursitis, or any substantially similar condition, there was nothing for him to disclose. It therefore follows that subs 7(7) has no application to this matter, and no basis has been established for me to make findings inconsistent with the respondent’s initial acceptance of liability for Mr Krecu’s left shoulder injury pursuant to s 14 of the SRC Act.AS AT 21 JUNE 2013, WAS MR KRECU SUFFERING ONGOING INCAPACITY AS A RESULT OF ANY OF HIS COMPENSABLE INJURIES?[17] See National Australia Bank Ltd v Georgoulas (2013) 217 FCR 382 at 388 [29].