Ofori and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

Ofori and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) [2025] ARTA 2062 (10 October 2025)

ReviewNumber:                  2023/8772, 2023/8773

Applicant/s:  Carol Ofori

Respondent:  Australian Capital Territory

Tribunal Number:                2023/8772, 2023/8773

Tribunal:General Member F Eylward

Place:Canberra

Date:10 October 2025

Application 2023/8772

Decision:The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review made on 5 October 2023 and in substitution decides:

1.    That the Applicant suffered ‘soft tissue injuries to the left hip and thigh. Right knee stiffness’ (the Injury), being an injury arising out of, or in the course of her employment with Canberra Health Services on 5 July 2023.

2.    As at 30 August 2023, the Applicant ceased to suffer the effects of the Injury.

3.    In respect of the Injury, the Respondent is liable pursuant to section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation & Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act) in accordance with this Act.

Application 2023/8773

Decision:The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

..............................[SGD]....................................

General Member F Eylward

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – claim for physical and psychological injuries arising from the same incident – assault in the workplace – personal protection order not granted – no police charges – section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation & Compensation Act 1988 – soft-tissue injury to left hip and thigh, right knee – whether injury or ailment – psychological claim – pre-existing injuries/conditions declined – wilful misrepresentation of no previous injury – whether significantly contributed to by employment – reasonable administrative action – assertions of mismanagement and misconduct by employer in reporting incident unfounded  

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation & Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth)
Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential & Transitional Provisions No 1) Act 2024

Personal Violence Act 2016 (ACT)

CASES

Lees v Comcare [1999] FCA 753

Plumb v Comcare (1992) 39 FCR 236
Liu and Comcare (2004) 79 ALD 119
Rosillo v Telstra Corporation Ltd (2003) 77 ALD 396
Australian Postal Corporation v Oudyn (2003) 73 ALD 659
Simeoni v Comcare [2025] 15 August 2025
Ofori v Comcare [2018] AATA 2113
In the Matter of an Application in the Estate of Thelma June Hanley [2007] ACTSC 70
Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May [2016] HCA 19
Sandland v Canberra Health Services [2023] FWC 3389
Comcare v Sahu-Khan (2007) 156 FCR 536
Comcare v Power (2015) 238 FCR 187
Szabo v Comcare (2012) 58 AAR 152
National Bank Ltd v Georgoulas (2013) 217 FCR 382
K&S Freighters Pty Ltd v McQueen-Thomas [2018] FCA 1518

Philip Jones v Comcare (2023) AATA (23 June 2023)

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Administrative Review Tribunal (Common Procedures) Practice Direction 2024

Administrative Review Tribunal (Expert Evidence) Practice Direction 2024

Statement of Reasons

  1. These proceedings arise from an Application for Review, filed with the (former) Administrative Appeals Tribunal on 20 November 2023 under the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act).[1] The Application seeks review of two separate reviewable decisions made by the claims manager for the Respondent affirming earlier decisions declining liability under section 14 of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ofori and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 2062
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ofori and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) involved a 55-year-old registered nurse, employed part-time by Canberra Health Services, who claimed compensation for physical and psychological injuries resulting from an assault by the mother of a patient, Ms Nola Cook, on 5 July 2023. The dispute centred on whether the injuries were sustained in the course of employment and if the respondent was liable for compensation under section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation & Compensation Act 1988. The primary issues included the diagnosis of physical and psychological symptoms, whether the physical claim constituted an injury or ailment, if the physical injuries resulted in incapacity or impairment, and whether the psychological claim arose from reasonable administrative actions. Furthermore, the court had to determine if the applicant made wilful misrepresentations regarding previous injuries.

The court was tasked with deciding whether the physical injuries to the left hip and thigh, and right knee, constituted a compensable injury under the SRC Act. It also had to ascertain if the psychological symptoms resulted from reasonable administrative actions and whether the applicant had made false representations about previous injuries. Additionally, the court needed to evaluate whether the physical injuries caused a physiological change leading to incapacity or impairment and if the psychological claim was significantly contributed to by employment.

In its reasoning, the court found that the applicant suffered a compensable physical injury to her left thigh and hip, and right knee stiffness, arising from the incident with the wheelie walker. The court set aside the previous decision and held the respondent liable for compensation under section 14 of the SRC Act. However, the court affirmed the decision regarding the psychological claim, noting that the applicant's extensive history of traumatic events did not establish that the psychological symptoms were significantly contributed to by her employment. The court highlighted that it was not within its jurisdiction to make orders regarding the conduct or management of the employer. Consequently, the court concluded that the applicant's physical injuries were compensable, but her psychological claim was not.

The final orders of the court were to set aside the previous decision regarding the physical claim and to affirm the decision on the psychological claim. The court did not determine the nature and amount of compensation payable, leaving it to be decided under other provisions of the SRC Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The primary issues in dispute to consider in order to determine whether the Respondent is liable to pay compensation under section 14 of the SRC Act are as follows: (a)The diagnosis of the physical symptoms and the psychological symptoms;[6](b)Whether the physical claim is characterised as an injury or an ailment;[7](c)If categorised as an injury, whether the physical injuries caused a physiological change resulting in incapacity for work or impairment;[8](d)If categorised as an ailment, whether the claimed conditions were contributed to, to a significant degree, by the Applicant’s employment;[9] (e)If so, whether the psychological claim was the result of reasonable administrative action, taken in a reasonable manner to exclude her from compensation;[10] and(f)Whether the Applicant made wilful or false representations that she had not previously suffered from either of the claimed injuries previously, thereby excluding the claimed conditions from the definition of injury for the purposes of the SRC Act.[11] [6] Section 5A of the SRC Act.[7] Section 5B of the SRC Act.[8] Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May (2016) 257 CLR 468.[9] Sub-section 5B(3) of the SRC Act.[10] Section 5A(2) of the SRC Act.[11] Section 7(7) of the SRC Act.FACTS The Applicant is a 55 year old registered nurse, level 1, at The Canberra Hospital, employed part-time by Canberra Health Services for approximately 10 years, having extensive nursing experience of many years prior to that. At the time of the incident, the Applicant was primarily working in the acute haemodialysis unit in the Renal Department on Ward 8A.[12] [12] T5. The Applicant has an accepted workers compensation claim relating to a previous neck injury requiring adjustments to her duties including reduced hours and ongoing massage and pain medication consumption. A workers compensation claim was also filed by the Applicant in August 2016 for pain in the feet diagnosed as tendonitis, though this was rejected and proceeded to be reviewed by the AAT where the reviewable decision was affirmed.[13][13] Ofori v Comcare (Compensation) [2018] AATA 2113. The Applicant also has a significant history of difficult and traumatic events in her life both before and subsequent to the subject incident, set out in more detail in this decision. During the course of her duties as a registered nurse, the Applicant was providing care for a patient on 5 July 2023, when there was an incident with the mother of another patient on the ward, who was allocated to a different nurse on duty. The Applicant describes in her claim form that she was threatened and assaulted by Ms Nola Cook on 5 July 2023 when Ms Cook initially approached her asking for water for her daughter. The precise accounts of what then occurred start to diverge from there, but in summary, it appears the Applicant responded that she was tending to another patient so could not get the water and to ask another nurse.[14] [14] T4; T10. Both the Applicant and Ms Cook each considered the other spoke rudely in the verbal exchange and each was upset by it.[15]Ms Cook purportedly then said she would be reporting the Applicant to her employer, presumably for what she considered to be the unprofessional and rude behaviour of the Applicant in her tone and refusal to assist her terminally ill daughter. The Applicant perceived this to be a threat and became upset, however proceeded to tend to her allocated patient who had observed the interaction.[15] T4, T6, JHB 1.4, pg 384-394.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant has not been cleared medically fit to return to work since 10 July 2023 due primarily to her psychological symptoms.EVIDENCE The evidence before the Tribunal consisted primarily of the ‘Updated Joint Hearing Bundle’[40] (Exhibit A) containing the T-Documents and Supplementary T-Documents filed by the Respondent pursuant to section 37 of the ART Act, medical evidence and statements, together with relevant summons documents, ACT Magistrates Court Records (Exhibit B), and Riskman Facts Sheets (Exhibit C). The following witnesses gave oral evidence:(g)The Applicant(h)Professor Peter Youssef, rheumatologist, for the Respondent(i)A/Professor Frank Varghese, psychiatrist, for the Respondent[40] Updated Joint Hearing Book filed 21 March 2025. Notably, neither the patient who witnessed the incident, nor Ms Cook, were called to give evidence. Helpfully included within Exhibit A is a statement from the patient to the ACT Police of 13 October 2023, together with comments made by Ms Cook to police as part of their investigation.[41][41] JHB 3.1. The Applicant relied on two lay witness statements of Ms Josie Ares and Dr Zainab Wajih, tendered as part of the Joint Hearing Bundle, but neither was required for cross-examination by the Respondent. No medical experts were called by the Applicant. The parties also provided closing written submissions following the conclusion of the Hearing, with the Respondent’s written submissions purporting to be an extension of its Statement of Facts, Issue & Contentions filed on 19 September 2024.Applicant Further to the information set out above, the Applicant’s evidence is that she was ‘assaulted and threatened within her workplace’ on 5 July 2023 when she was approached by the mother of a patient, Ms Cook, whilst she was tending to another patient, demanding water for her daughter. When she politely declined noting she was assisting another patient at that time, Ms Cook spoke rudely to her and threatened to report her, stating; ‘I’m going to report you’. The Applicant did not respond but gave oral evidence that she was distressed by this threat commenting that ‘I was disrespected. I was threatened, and then I was subject to an unprovoked and witnessed assault’. In her oral evidence, the Applicant was relatively consistent in her description of the incident when she was standing at the hygiene station near the administrative/ward clerk desk, being hit from behind in the left upper thigh area by the top rail of Mrs Cook’s wheelie walker. She reported it to Ms Chen and required Panadol for a headache that developed before finishing her shift. She stated that she had Panadol and nurofen later that evening before bed acknowledging that it would have been for both her pre-existing neck pain and her left thigh and hip pain. Her evidence is that during her rostered days off work, she continued to require Panadol and nurofen due to a sore left thigh and hip and then later physiotherapy and massage before her physical injuries were fully resolved with full mobility 20 weeks after the incident.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I do make a peripheral observation that given the extensive argument regarding this same issue in her previous Tribunal matter, one would expect an over cautious approach to completing claim forms thereafter to avoid such an issue arising again. Were it to continue happening it could be said to be a tendency or pattern of behaviour that would certainly suggest a more deliberate intent to misrepresent the truth. DECISION2023/8772 – Physical Claim Based on the reasons set out above, I am satisfied the Applicant suffered from a compensable physical injury to her left thigh and hip with right knee stiffness arising from the altered gait from limping due to the contact made with the wheelie walker in her workplace on 5 July 2023 that resulted in incapacity and the need for medical treatment. Accordingly, I set aside the decision under review dated 5 October 2023 and in substitution, decide the Respondent is liable under section 14 of the SRC Act. I do note that on the medical evidence before the Tribunal, and the Applicant’s own evidence, the soft tissue injury to her left thigh, hip and right knee stiffness resolved within a short period of time of the incident with physiotherapy treatment and certainly as at the date of the Hearing she no longer suffers the effects of these injuries, having fully recovered. In accordance with the decision of Lees v Comcare[74] the nature and amount of any compensation payable is to be determined under other provisions of the SRC Act, and it is not for this Tribunal to determine any future entitlement in advance, pre-judge or bind a future decision maker.[75] [74] [1999] FCA 753.[75] Plumb v Comcare (1992) 39 FCR 236; Liu and Comcare (2004) 79 ALD 119; Rosillo v Telstra Corporation Ltd (2003) 77 ALD 396; Australian Postal Corporation v Oudyn (2003) 73 ALD 659.2023/8773 – Psychological Claim Further, for the reasons already stated, I affirm the decision under review in relation to the psychological claim. While I acknowledge that this decision may cause some distress to the Applicant, I am required to apply the legislation and applicable case law to the facts as presented in evidence. I encourage the Applicant to provide a copy of this decision to her treating General Practitioner and discuss it with him to seek his support.Applicant: Self-RepresentedRespondent: Mr Peter Woulfe instructed by HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Senior Member O’Donovan considered the operation of section 7(7) in the matter of Philip Jones v Comcare[61] and while ultimately, he did not have to determine whether subsection 7(7) applied in that proceeding, he provides useful commentary on the interpretation of the sub-section and if it operates to exclude liability generally, or to deprive an employee only from the benefit of treatment for the injury where similar to a previous injury or condition that has been denied when read with section 6 of the SRC Act. [61] [2023] AATA (30 June 2023).CONSIDERATION From the Applicant’s history gleaned from the various records in Exhibit A, it is clear she has had a difficult and, at times, traumatic life. Quite properly and reasonably she has sought medical treatment and counselling at various points to assist her in coping with these traumatic events (other than the incident) including:(a)Serious physical abuse from her father in the guise of strict discipline; (b)Marital breakdown with psychological violence;(c)Separation anxiety from her child following divorce;(d)The deaths of her father at an early age, and later her mother during the time of her marital breakdown;(e)Caring for a child diagnosed with oppositional defiant disorder;(f)Involvement of Child Youth Protective Services in relation to her son; (g)Violent altercations between her and her son requiring numerous police attendance;(h)An accepted neck injury in the course of work;(i)Litigation relating to the denial of her claim for tendonitis;(j)The death of a friend and losing her son’s uncle to suicide on the same day;(k)Resuscitating a person whilst attending a funeral for her friend, in the presence of her son; (l)Sexual harassment in the workplace and subsequent claimed harassment and victimisation after reporting the colleague;(m)Witnessing a crime at her local shopping centre and having to give a statement, but fearing retribution for doing the right thing; and(n)Encountering and contacting police as a result of a neighbour attending her home terrorising her son; A common thread appears to be feelings of being victimised and persecuted by others. In the simplest terms, the real issue in these matters is whether the Applicant sustained the claimed injuries as a result of her employment with the Respondent. As reiterated during the course of the Hearing, it is not within this Tribunal’s power or jurisdiction to make orders on Ms Cook’s behaviour, or even make orders regarding the conduct or management of the Canberra Health Services or the Respondent in the decision-making process. It is only to determine, afresh, if the Applicant was injured in the course of her employment or not, to the requisite degree, for the purposes of the SRC Act having regard to the definitions under the SRC Act (and any exclusions that may apply) and relevant case law. The issue in dispute before the Tribunal is whether there was a physical and/or psychological injury that arose out of, or during the course of the Applicant’s employment with the Respondent as a registered nurse on 5 July 2023 when the incident occurred.