Comandate Marine Corp v Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 83 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Comandate Marine Corp v Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltd [2006] FCAFC 192

ADMIRALTY AND MARITIME JURISDICTION – action in rem in Australia commenced by foreign party who had commenced London arbitration against Australian party – no statutory basis for commencing the in rem action – no election or waiver or abandonment of arbitration – nature of action in rem discussed  

INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION – proceedings begun in this Court by Australian party – stay sought by foreign party under International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) – stay granted

International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) ss 3, 7, 16
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 82, 87

ACD Tridon Inc v Tridon Australia Pty Ltd [2002] NSWSC 896 approved
Aichhorn & Co KG v The Ship MV ‘Talabot’ (1974) 132 CLR 449applied

Allergan Pharmaceuticals Inc v Bausch & Lomb Inc (1985) 7 ATPR 40-636 discussed and distinguished

Branir Pty Ltd v Owston Nominees (No 2) Pty Ltd (2001) 117 FCR 424 applied
Caltex Oil (Australia) Pty Ltd v The Dredge ‘Willemstad’ (1976) 136 CLR 529 applied
Codelfa Constructions Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of New South Wales (1982) 149 CLR 337 discussed and distinguished
Craine v Colonial Mutual Fire Insurance Co Ltd (1920) 28 CLR 305 applied

Ethiopian Oilseeds and Pulses Export Corporation v Rio del Mar Foods Inc [1990] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 86 discussed and approved

Ferris v Plaister (1994) 34 NSWLR 474 discussed and approved

Flakt Australia Ltd v Wilkins & Davies Construction Co Ltd [1979] 2 NSWLR 243 referred to

Francis Travel Marketing Pty Ltd v Virgin Atlantic Airways Ltd (1996) 39 NSWLR 160 discussed and approved
Government of Gibraltar v Kenney [1956] 2 QB 410 discussed

Harbour Assurance Co (UK) Ltd v Kansa General International Insurance Co Ltd [1992] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 81 discussed

Harbour Assurance Co (UK) Ltd v Kansa General International Insurance Co Ltd [1993] QB 701 referred to

Heyman v Darwins Ltd [1942] AC 356 referred to
Hi-Fert Pty Ltd v Kiukiang Maritime Carriers Inc (No 5) (1998) 90 FCR 1 discussed and not followed
Immer (No 145) Pty Ltd v Uniting Church in Australia Property Trust (NSW) (1993) 182 CLR 26 applied
Kuo Fen Ching v Dauphin Offshore Engineering & Trading Pte Ltd [1999] 3 SLR 721 referred to
La Donna Pty Ltd v Wolford AG (2005) 194 FLR 26 discussed and distinguished
Perri v Coolangatta Investments Pty Ltd (1982) 149 CLR 537 applied
Recyclers of Australia Pty Ltd v Hettinga Equipment Inc (2000) 100 FCR 420 referred to
Republic of India v India Steamship Co Ltd (No 2) (The ‘Indian Grace’) [1998] AC 878 discussed and disapproved

Samick Lines Co Ltd v Owners of The ‘Antonis P Lemos’ [1985] AC 711 discussed

Sargent v ASL Developments Ltd (1974) 131 CLR 656 applied

SZEEU v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2006) 150 FCR 214 applied

Tanning Research Laboratories Inc v O’Brien (1990) 169 CLR 332 discussed
The ‘August 8’ [1983] 2 AC 450 discussed
The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Comandate Marine Corp v Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCAFC 192
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Comandate Marine Corp v Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltd was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The dispute involved Comandate Marine Corp, which sought to enforce an arbitration clause in a time charter agreement against Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltd. The primary issue was whether Comandate Marine had waived or abandoned its right to arbitrate by commencing in rem proceedings against another vessel owned by Pan, the Boomerang I, without seeking a stay of the proceedings. The case also involved broader issues concerning the scope of the arbitration clause and the application of the International Arbitration Act 1974.

The court was required to decide several legal issues, including whether Comandate Marine had waived its right to arbitrate by initiating in rem proceedings, whether there was a written agreement for the purposes of the International Arbitration Act, the proper scope of the arbitration clause, and the applicability of the International Arbitration Act in light of the arbitration clause. Additionally, the court needed to determine if there were other bases for a stay of the proceedings if the International Arbitration Act was inapplicable, and whether an anti-anti-suit injunction should be granted.

The court held that Comandate Marine had not waived or abandoned its right to arbitrate. The primary judge's conclusions that Comandate Marine had elected not to pursue arbitration and that the arbitration agreement had been abandoned were found to be erroneous. The court also ruled that there was an agreement in writing for the purposes of the International Arbitration Act. The scope of the arbitration clause was deemed to be sufficiently broad to cover all disputes between the parties. The court found that Comandate Marine was entitled to an unconditional stay based on the Model Law and the International Arbitration Act. The court further held that the anti-anti-suit injunction should be dissolved.

The appeal was allowed, and the orders of the primary judge were set aside. The court ordered that the proceedings be stayed, subject to the retention of certain security, and that Pan pay the costs of Comandate Marine related to the motion for a stay and the appeal. The court also noted that Comandate Marine would allow the arbitration to determine all issues arising under the Trade Practices Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. Order 5 made by the Court on 13 July 2006 and the order made by the Court on 22 August 2006 be dissolved and set aside, respectively and in lieu of the order made on 22 August 2006:

(a) Subject to the retention of the security provided for the release of Comandate remaining as security for Pan’s claims against Comandate Marine in the arbitration, proceeding NSD 1330 of 2006 be stayed.

(b) Pan pay the costs of Comandate Marine of the motion for a stay of proceedings served on 23 June 2006 and filed 4 July 2006.

3. Pan pay Comandate Marine’s costs of the appeal.

4. The question of the costs of the anti-anti suit injunction and of the balance of the proceedings at first instance be stood over for argument to a date to be fixed.

THE COURT NOTES:

5. The undertaking to the Court of Comandate Marine Corp that it will allow the arbitration to determine all issues between the parties arising under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth).

Background

Background to the litigation

I set out a table of contents of these reasons:- Background to the litigation [12] - [20]- Pan’s Amended statement of claim [21] - [33]- The provisions of the International Arbitration Act1974 (Cth)and Comandate Marine’s notice of motion [34] - [45]- The issues on appeal and my conclusions in summary form [46] - [52]- The first group of issues: waiver, election and abandonment [53] - [132]- The second group of issues: whether there was an agreement in writing for the purposes of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) [133] - [161]- The third group of issues: the scope of the arbitration clause [162] - [187]- The fourth group of issues: the operation of the InternationalArbitration Act 1974 (Cth) in the light of the proper construction of the arbitration clause [188] - [245]- The fifth group of issues: other bases for a stay by reason of thearbitration clause, assuming the inapplicability of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) [246] - [250]- The sixth group of issues: the anti-anti-suit injunction [251] - [253]- The appropriate orders [254] - [256]Background to the litigation An understanding of the orders made by the primary judge and the issues on appeal require an appreciation of the background facts of the dispute. At all relevant times, Pan carried on a coastal liner shipping service from and to Australian ports. It was engaged in the coasting trade as that term is understood in s 7 of the Navigation Act 1912 (Cth). Pan is now in voluntary administration. There was no asserted present relevance of that fact to the disposition of the appeal. The service run by Pan was undertaken initially by one ship, Boomerang I, and was to be undertaken also by a second ship, Comandate, which was known, for a short time, as Boomerang II. For clarity, I will refer to the second ship as Comandate. Boomerang I was demise chartered by Pan from Jaymont Shipping Company Limited, a company wholly unrelated to Comandate Marine. Comandate was time chartered to Pan under terms which included those contained in New York Produce Exchange Form 1993 Revision (NYPE 93). The time charter indicated that it was made for a duration of 24 months with a further 12 months at charterer’s option from 19 April 2006. It will be necessary to examine the assertions of the parties in relation to the formation of the time charter in a little detail. For the moment, it is only necessary to understand the relevant terms of the arbitration clause (which both parties accept formed part of the time charter) being, clause 45(b) of the NYPE 93 (clause 45(a), providing for New York arbitration, had been excised and the final paragraph of clause 45(b) dealing with small claims is not relevant):“(b) LONDONAll disputes arising out of this contract shall be arbitrated at London and, unless the parties agree forthwith on a single Arbitrator, be referred to the final arbitrament of two Arbitrators carrying on business in London who shall be members of the Baltic Mercantile & Shipping Exchange and engaged in Shipping one to be appointed by each of the parties, with the power to such Arbitrators to appoint an Umpire. No award shall be questioned or invalidated on the ground that any of the Arbitrators is not qualified as above, unless objection to his action be taken before the award is made. Any dispute arising hereunder shall be governed by English Law.…”[emphasis added]

Decision

Reasons for decision

FINN, FINKELSTEIN AND ALLSOP JJ
It will be necessary to refer to other provisions of the International Arbitration Act, the Convention and the Model Law and to the content of those various provisions later in these reasons.The issues on appeal and my conclusions in summary form There were numerous issues argued on the appeal. To assist in the understanding of these reasons I set out the issues in six groups in the order in which they fall for consideration and my views in summary on them. The first group of issues concerns the assertions by Pan that Comandate Marine waived or elected to abandon the London arbitration by its conduct. If Pan is correct in this respect, the later questions as to the extent of the arbitration agreement, the meaning and operation of the International Arbitration Act, and other discretionary considerations do not arise. For the purpose of these issues an arbitration agreement with ample relevant scope can be assumed. My views are that the primary judge erred in his conclusion that there had been waiver and election and that Pan fails on all these arguments. It is therefore necessary to move to the next group of issues. The second group of issues is whether there was an agreement in writing so that there can be an agreement for the purposes of the operation of the International Arbitration Act. My views are that the primary judge erred in concluding that there was no agreement in writing for the purposes of the International Arbitration Act. The third group of issues concerns the proper scope of the arbitration clause here, and, in particular, whether it is wide enough to encompass the Trade Practices Act claims. My views are that the primary judge erred in construing clause 45(b) too narrowly and that the clause is sufficiently wide to cover all the disputes between the parties. The fourth group of issues concerns the operation of the International Arbitration Act. My views are that Comandate Marine is entitled to an unconditional stay based on Article 8 of the Model Law and s 7 of the International Arbitration Act. The fifth group of issues concerns other possible basis for a stay assuming no order under the International Arbitration Act. It is unnecessary to deal with these issues. The sixth group of issues concerns the anti-anti-suit injunction. My view is that the anti-anti-suit injunction should be dissolved.The first group of issues: whether Comandate Marine by its conduct elected to waive or abandon, waived, abandoned, or otherwise lost its right to insist on arbitration The primary judge concluded that Comandate Marine had elected not to pursue its arbitration proceedings by beginning its in rem proceedings against Boomerang I without placing on the writ its intention to seek a stay under s 29 of the Admiralty Act or otherwise indicating on the writ that the proceeding was brought solely for the purpose of obtaining security for the London arbitration. Secondly, he concluded that by the conduct of both parties in electing to litigate in the Court the arbitration agreement had been, in substance, abandoned. So his Honour concluded that the arbitration agreement was either “incapable of being performed” or “inoperative” for the purposes of s 7(5) of the International Arbitration Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FINN, FINKELSTEIN AND ALLSOP JJ

The sixth group of issues concerns the anti-anti-suit injunction. My view is that the anti-anti-suit injunction should be dissolved.The first group of issues: whether Comandate Marine by its conduct elected to waive or abandon, waived, abandoned, or otherwise lost its right to insist on arbitration The primary judge concluded that Comandate Marine had elected not to pursue its arbitration proceedings by beginning its in rem proceedings against Boomerang I without placing on the writ its intention to seek a stay under s 29 of the Admiralty Act or otherwise indicating on the writ that the proceeding was brought solely for the purpose of obtaining security for the London arbitration. Secondly, he concluded that by the conduct of both parties in electing to litigate in the Court the arbitration agreement had been, in substance, abandoned. So his Honour concluded that the arbitration agreement was either “incapable of being performed” or “inoperative” for the purposes of s 7(5) of the International Arbitration Act. Pan sought in argument to bolster these conclusions by putting the matter in two other ways. First, it said that the filing of the in rem writ against Boomerang I was the acceptance by Comandate Marine of Pan’s repudiation of the arbitration agreement; and, secondly, it said that there was an implied contractual abandonment of the arbitration agreement. These ways of putting the matter were formalised in a notice of contention filed after the hearing on 1 November 2006. (It was not submitted by Pan that Comandate Marine’s conduct was itself a repudiation of the arbitration agreement. Though, in fairness, it was said to be an abandonment of the arbitration agreement.) For the reasons that follow, in my view: the primary judge erred in reaching the conclusions that he did, Pan should not be permitted to raise the new ways of putting the matter on appeal and, even if Pan be permitted to do so, on the material before the Court, it should not be concluded that there was an acceptance by Comandate Marine of a repudiation by Pan or that the parties had impliedly agreed to abandon the arbitration. Central to the reasoning of the primary judge was the form of relief in the writ in rem filed on 23 June 2006 and served on the ship, together with the arrest warrant, late on 23 June or in the early hours of 24 June 2006. The writ was, relevantly, in the following terms:“BY THIS WRIT the Plaintiff commences action against the Ship specified below.DATE OF ISSUE: 23 June 2006 PARTICULARS OF PROPERTY: The Ship “Boomerang 1” registered in Cyprus.AMOUNT CLAIMED OR OTHER RELIEF SOUGHT:1.arrest of the ship “Boomerang I”;2.damages;3.interest;4.costs.PARTICULARS OF CLAIM:1. The Plaintiff’s claim is for damages for breach of a time charter entered into between the Plaintiff and Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltd on or about 19 April 2006 in respect of the ship “Comandate”. In breach of the time charter, Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltd has:(a)failed to obtain valid crew visas for the intended trade of the ship “Comandate”;(b)wrongfully terminated the charter in respect of the ship “Comandate”; and (c)failed to make hire payments due under the time charter.The Court’s jurisdiction in respect of this claim arises under sections 10, 17 and 4(3)(d), (f), (o) and (w) of the Admiralty Act.RELEVANT PERSON:Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltdthe demise or bareboat charterer of the vessel “Boomerang 1”…TO THE DEFENDANTIf you wish to defend this claim, you must, within 21 days after this writ is served on you, file an appearance.”