Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltd v The Ship ‘Comandate' (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltd v The Ship ‘Comandate’ (No 2)
[2006] FCA 1112

ARBITRATION – ELECTION - stay of proceedings – anti-anti-suit injunction – where arbitral proceedings brought in England and in rem proceedings brought in Federal Court of Australia by same party - whether action in rem constituted election to litigate rather than arbitrate – abandonment of right to arbitrate – whether right to arbitrate waived - whether arbitration agreement rendered inoperative

ARBITRATION – definition of agreement in writing under International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) – interpretation of Art II r 2 of the New York Convention – meaning of ‘contained in an exchange of letters or telegrams’- agreement formed by provision of bank guarantee

ARBITRATION - scope of arbitration clause – whether trade practices claim falls within scope of arbitration clause – where arbitration clause governed claims ‘arising out of this contract’

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – stay of proceedings – continuation of anti-anti-suit injunction – continuation of injunction to restrain the defendant from obtaining an injunction in a foreign court which would restrain the continuation of proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia – where defendant threatening to take steps in English High Court of Justice to restrain proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia

ADMIRALTY & MARITIME JURISDICTION – arrest of vessel – in personam claim

WORDS & PHRASES - ‘agreement in writing’ ‘arbitration agreement’ ‘contained in an exchange of letters or telegrams’ ‘dispute arising out of this contract’

Held – that Marine Comandate’s action in rem constituted an election to litigate rather than arbitrate and the arbitration agreement is therefore inoperative; that there was no ‘agreement in writing’ for the purposes of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth); the application for a stay and referral to arbitration be refused; that the trade practices claim by Pan falls outside the scope of the arbitration agreement; that the Federal Court has jurisdiction to hear and determine Pan’s claim; and the interim injunction should continue to restrain the defendant from taking any steps in any court seeking to restrain the continuation of the current proceeding.

The Constitution s 75 s 76 (ii) s 76 (iii) s 51(i)
Admiralty Act 1988 (Cth) s 29 s 31
Commercial Arbitration Act 1984 (NSW) s (53) s (4)(1)
International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) s 7(2) s 7(5)

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)

Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (as adopted on June 10 1958, New York) (‘the New York Convention’)
UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration (as adopted by the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law on 21 June 1985) (‘the Model Law’)

ACD Tridon v Tridon Australia [2002] NSWSC 896 followed
Allergan Pharmaceuticals Inc v Bausch & Lomb Inc (1985) 7 ATPR §40-636 discussed
Allonah Pty Limited v The Ship ‘Amanda N’ (1989) 21 FCR 60 cited
Australian Granites Ltd v Eisenwerk Hensel Bayreuth Dipl-ing Burkhardt GmbH [2001] 1 Qd R 461 cited
Batistatos v Roads and Traffic Authority [2006] HCA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltd v The Ship ‘Comandate' (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 1112
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltd and Comandate Marine engaged in a dispute concerning a charter party for the vessel Comandate. The conflict escalated to a legal battle, primarily centred on the vessel's arrest and the provision of security. The case was brought before the Federal Court of Australia, where the central issues involved the enforcement of maritime liens and the jurisdiction of the court. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Federal Court had jurisdiction to hear Comandate Marine's claims against Pan Australia Shipping, particularly in the context of maritime liens and the enforcement of security for maritime claims.

The court examined the contractual provisions, particularly clause 45(b) of the charter party, which stipulated that any disputes arising from the contract would be arbitrated in London and governed by English law. The court also considered the implications of the arrest of the vessel and the application for security, as well as the procedural steps taken by both parties. After reviewing the communications between the parties, the court found that the charter party's terms were clear and unambiguous, and that the jurisdiction clause was binding on both parties. The court also determined that the arrest of the vessel and the demand for security were strategic moves that did not alter the agreed-upon jurisdiction.

The court concluded that the Federal Court did not have jurisdiction to hear Comandate Marine's claims, as the charter party clearly designated London as the seat of arbitration. Consequently, the court dismissed Comandate Marine's motion with costs, affirming the interim injunction that had been previously granted to Pan Australia Shipping. The decision underscored the importance of contractual clauses in determining jurisdiction and highlighted the enforceability of agreed-upon arbitration terms in maritime disputes.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The further amended notice of motion filed by the defendant be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 27 June 2006 Emmett, Allsop and Siopis JJ set aside Comandate Marine’s writ in rem and ordered the Boomerang I to be released from arrest subject to a short stay. Heydon J, in the High Court of Australia, refused Comandate Marine’s application for a stay of the Full Court’s orders setting aside the writ in rem and refused to order a rearrest of the vessel Boomerang I, but granted expedition of the application for special leave to appeal which Comandate Marine had filed. On 28 June 2006 Mr Wilson swore an affidavit in support of the motion for rearrest in the High Court saying that by way of its in rem proceedings, Comandate Marine had sought security in respect of its claims pursuant to, inter alia, s 19 of the Admiralty Act1988 (Cth) by arresting a sister ship or surrogate ship of the Comandate in respect of which ‘… Pan is the person who would be liable on [Comandate Marine’s] claims in a proceeding commenced as an action in personam’.LOCATION OF WITNESS AND EVIDENCE Pan relies, as an important part of its case, on the reasons for which the Maritime Safety Authority detained the Comandate twice during May 2006 for three and eleven days respectively. The validity of those reasons may in due course have to be established by witnesses including those officers of the Authority who inspected the Comandate or made decisions. I merely recite some of the reasons given by the Authority in documents so as to illustrate issues which will be raised for any hearing. (Of course, in what follows, I am not making any finding as to whether what the Authority said was well founded.) The first detention in Sydney finished on 10 May 2006 and occurred because a number of defects were identified by the Authority. The tank air pipes were not in satisfactory condition. There were problems with the ceiling plates and screws had been corroded, emergency preparedness had not been properly addressed, fire dampers were unable to be closed, the fire line was leaking in a number of places. The Authority required temporary repairs to the air pipes to be made as per condition of class and the conditions of the flag state were required to be met. The second detention was at Fremantle and finished on 9 June 2006. The Authority reported that there had been a crack in the port ship’s hull steel plating, the CO2 piping in the cargo hulls was wasted away in several areas with no CO2 protection afforded to cargo holds. The Master was said to have failed to report the hull damage to the relevant authorities and the procedures for maintenance and inspection of the ship were not functional as was evidenced by numerous hardware deficiencies. There was also reported to be a problem with the watertightness of certain doors and the ability to secure the cargo hold access hatch in a watertight manner. Temporary repairs were carried out under the supervision of the class society and permanent repairs were required to be carried out at the next port, Singapore, as per the condition of release.

Decision

Reasons for decision

RARES J
While the Master and crew are likely to be witnesses as to the vessel’s condition, it will not make much difference where the hearing is so far as convenience to them is concerned. Wherever they are in the world either they will have to come away from whatever vessel they are on at the time or use electronic communication to give evidence at any hearing. The critical aspects of the claims of unseaworthiness and defective condition of the vessel together with the evidence as to the incurring of the damage to the hull are likely to be given by Australian witnesses and members of the ship’s company. Pan had identified from the documents produced on subpoena at this early stage at least 12 different witnesses, 10 from the Authority, who may be required to give evidence. Of course, certain parts of the evidence may become uncontroversial as the case progresses but the impression I have is that leaving aside witnesses who will need to come from Sri Lanka and Singapore, on the material before me the likelihood is that most of the material witnesses other than the ship’s company will be from Australia. There does not appear to be any relevant connection to London other than the requirement in cl 45(b) that the seat of the arbitration be there.CONCLUSION I order that Comandate Marine’s motion be dismissed with costs. It follows that the interim injunction which I granted on 13 July 2006 until further order will continue undisturbed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: RARES J

On 8 April 2006 Mr Athanassiou sent Mr Colaco a pro forma charter that had been used by Comandate Marine and another charterer in respect of the vessel, the Asiatic. That contained a clause, which is central to this matter, cl 45(b). Throughout the negotiations the terms of cl 45(b) did not change. It provided relevantly as follows:‘45 Arbitration… (b) LONDONAll disputes arising out of this contract shall be arbitrated at London …. Any dispute arising hereunder shall be governed by English Law ….’ There was a deal of toing and froing in telexes and emails. The parties adopted a convention of sending telexes and also emails in exactly the same form, as confirmation. The parties are agreed that for the purposes of determining these proceedings an email may be treated as if it were a telex and that both forms of communication amount to a letter or telegram within the meaning of Article II r 2 of the Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (‘the New York Convention’) which is in schedule 1 of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth). On 19 April 2006 Prime sent to Pan care of Mr Colaco a telex and email stating that the owners were glad to confirm their agreement to the charterer’s alterations as provided in the message which was set out thereunder. It continued:‘We therefore are fully fixed subject to Bank Guarantee. Kindly advise urgently within today the Bank’s full style … so that our Bankers can contact them tomorrow.’A request was made to have Pan’s bankers send the bank guarantee to the Royal Bank of Scotland at Piraeus. On 20 April 2006 Prime sent a telex/email to Mr Colaco headed ‘FINAL RECAP’ which commenced:‘Confirm having fixed with all subs in order, “SUBJECT Owners to Receive the BANK GUARANTEE from Chrtr’s/Chrtrs’ Bank’ as follows ….’At the conclusion of a lengthy recitation of the vessel’s details and certain clauses and amendments, Mr Athanassiou wrote:‘Both Parties, are kindly requested to confirm abv recap is in line with negos agreed far.’B. Rgds/DA’I infer that ‘DA’ stands for Mr Athanassiou’s initials. Later on 20 April 2006 Prime sent Mr Colaco an email which noted that the bank guarantee had been received with thanks. The Comandate was delivered to and accepted by Pan on 21 April 2006 at Singapore. Mr Athanassiou said that it was an accepted practice in the ship building industry that responsibility for the preparation of the written charter party rests with the charterer’s broker but that on this occasion cl 8 of the recap provided that Prime would be responsible for the preparation of the written charter. He said that the preparation of the written charter party invariably occurred after the vessel had been delivered to charters.DISPUTE AS TO PAN PROVIDING SECURITY On 10 June 2006, following the arrest of the vessel, Comandate Marine’s London solicitor, Mr O’Neill of Stephenson Harwood, wrote to Pan’s Australian solicitor, Ms Wilmshurst, asking that Pan take steps to provide security for an amount in the region of USD 2.5 million. Mr O’Neill wrote again on 11 June requiring Ms Wilmshurst to take Pan’s instructions on putting up security of USD 4 million and threatened that unless he received confirmation that a first class bank guarantee would be provided for that amount, Comandate Marine would be taking immediate steps to obtain this security ‘by other means. You will know the options open to us as well as we do’. Ms Wilmshurst responded saying that the owner’s claim for security appeared to be strategic and intended as a threat and indicated that she assumed Comandate Marine might apply for a maritime attachment order. Mr O’Neill responded that a claim would be substantiated shortly and indicated that Pan was being given sufficient time to provide security. Mr O’Neill persisted in making demands and threats that whatever steps were necessary would be taken if security were not provided.